Washington State

House of Representatives

Office of Program Research

BILL

ANALYSIS

Local Government & Housing Committee

SSB 6214

This analysis was prepared by non-partisan legislative staff for the use of legislative members in their deliberations. This analysis is not a part of the legislation nor does it constitute a statement of legislative intent.

Brief Description: Restructuring three growth management hearings boards into one board.

Sponsors: Senate Committee on Government Operations & Elections (originally sponsored by Senators Haugen, Morton, Swecker, Shin, McCaslin, Ranker, Rockefeller, Fairley, Pridemore, Kline, Parlette, Jacobsen, Schoesler, Sheldon, McDermott and Fraser; by request of Growth Management Hearings Board).

Brief Summary of Substitute Bill

  • Consolidates the powers, duties, and functions of the three regional Growth Management Hearings Boards into a single Growth Management Hearings Board.

  • Reduces the total number of Growth Management Hearings Board members from nine to seven.

  • Specifies that petitions for review before the consolidated Growth Management Hearings Board must be heard and decided by a regional panel of three board members.

  • Specifies provisions for the adjudicative and operational functioning of the consolidated Growth Management Hearings Board.

  • Makes technical changes.

Hearing Date: 2/22/10

Staff: Ethan Moreno (786-7386).

Background:

The Growth Management Act (GMA) is the comprehensive land use planning framework for county and city governments in Washington. Enacted in 1990 and 1991, the GMA establishes numerous planning requirements for counties and cities obligated by mandate or choice to fully plan under the GMA (planning jurisdictions) and a reduced number of directives for all other counties and cities. Twenty-nine of Washington's 39 counties, and the cities within those counties, are planning jurisdictions.

The GMA establishes three regional Growth Management Hearings Boards (Boards or Regional Boards) with defined geographic jurisdictions: (1) an Eastern Washington Board; (2) a Central Puget Sound Board; and (3) a Western Washington Board. Each Board consists of three gubernatorial appointee members who are qualified by experience or training and who also meet residency requirements. At least one member of each Board must be admitted to practice law in Washington, and at least one member of each Board must have been a city or county elected official. No more than two members of a Board may be from the same political party. Board members serve six-year terms.

Boards have limited jurisdiction and may only hear and determine petitions alleging:

Boards must make findings of fact and prepare a written decision in each decided case. Findings of fact and decisions become effective upon being signed by two or more Board members and upon being filed at the applicable Board office. Final decisions of the Boards may be appealed to the superior court. If all parties agree, the superior court may directly review a petition filed with a Board.

Boards are governed by other statutory requirements for conduct and procedure. For example, a majority of a Board constitutes a quorum for making decisions, adopting rules, and conducting other official business. Additionally, Boards are required to jointly develop and adopt rules of practice and procedure. Boards must also meet jointly at least annually to share information that promotes the goals and purposes of the GMA. Although provisions allowing for the part-time operation of each Board are specified in statute, the three Regional Boards operate on a full-time basis.

In response to budget reductions enacted in Washington's 2009-2011 operating budget, the Boards consolidated their administrative functions and closed their Eastern Washington and Central Puget Sound regional offices in Yakima and Seattle, respectively. The office of the Western Washington Board in Olympia effectively serves as the administrative office of all three Boards. Associated staff reductions also occurred, and one Board member position is vacant.

Summary of Bill:

Consolidation and Member Provisions.

The three regional Growth Management Hearings Boards are abolished and consolidated into a single Growth Management Hearings Board (consolidated board). The consolidated board must consist of seven members qualified by experience or training in land use law or planning. The members must be appointed by the Governor to six-year terms, with six members from three specified regions of the state: two members each from (1) the Central Puget Sound area, (2) Eastern Washington, and (3) Western Washington. A seventh member must be appointed as an at-large member. At least three members of the consolidated board, one from each region, must be admitted to practice law in the state. Additionally, at least three members of the consolidated board, one from each region, must have been a county or city elected official or must have experience in city or county planning. After the expiration of the terms of the Board members who serve prior to the consolidation, no more than four members of the consolidated board may be members of the same major political party. No more than two members at the time of their appointment or during their term may reside in the same county.

The members of the three Regional Boards who serve prior to the consolidation will complete their staggered current terms, with the reduction from nine members to seven occurring through attrition, voluntary resignation, or retirement.

Hearing and Adjudication Practices.

Petitions for review that are filed with the consolidated board must be heard and decided by a regional three-member panel, with membership for the regional panels selected from among full membership of the consolidated board. With some exceptions, a majority of the regional panel members selected to hear and decide a case must reside within the region in which the case arose. Except in cases of emergency, the presiding officer in each case must reside within the region in which the case arose. Also, with some exceptions, each regional panel must:

The regional panels are constituted as follows:

Administrative Matters.

The consolidated board must annually elect one of its members to be the administrative officer. The administrative officer is responsible for the administrative, budget, and personnel matters of the consolidated board. The administrative officer is also responsible for making member case assignments, subject to the consolidated board's rules of procedure, for the purpose of achieving a fair and balanced workload among all members.

The reports, files, records, et cetera of the three regional Growth Management Hearings Boards must be delivered to the consolidated board, the office of which must be in Olympia. Funds, credits, assets, and employees of the Regional Boards are transferred to the consolidated board. Tangible property of the Regional Boards must be made available to the consolidated board. Rules and pending business before the Regional Boards must be continued and acted upon by the consolidated board. The transfer of powers, duties, functions, and personnel of the Regional Boards to the consolidated board does not affect the validity of any act performed before July 1, 2010. All cases decided and all orders previously issued by the Regional Boards remain in full force and effect.

Technical Changes.

Numerous statutory references to multiple Boards are changed to reflect a single consolidated board. Provisions pertaining to the part-time operations of the Regional Boards are deleted.

Appropriation: None.

Fiscal Note: Not requested.

Effective Date: July 1, 2010.