Washington State

House of Representatives

Office of Program Research

BILL

ANALYSIS

State Government & Tribal Relations Committee

HB 2437

This analysis was prepared by non-partisan legislative staff for the use of legislative members in their deliberations. This analysis is not a part of the legislation nor does it constitute a statement of legislative intent.

Brief Description: Concerning voting accessibility and security.

Sponsors: Representatives Kilduff, Leavitt, Gregerson, Santos, Tharinger, Pollet, Wylie and Morgan.

Brief Summary of Bill

  • Permits voters with disabilities, service voters, and overseas voters to return ballots through an electronic portal that has been approved for use by the Office of the Secretary of State (OSOS), instead of by email or fax.

  • Requires the OSOS election review staff to review county election policies, procedures, and practices every two years, instead of five, and to review the county's accessibility for voters with disabilities.

  • Requires county auditors and the County Disability Advisory Committee to survey all voting centers for accessibility for voters with disabilities prior to each general election, and to submit reports of potential barriers to the OSOS.

  • Requires the OSOS to respond to county auditor reports of potential barriers with recommendations and suggestions to alleviate identified issues.

Hearing Date: 1/21/20

Staff: Jason Zolle (786-7124).

Background:

Washington is a vote-by-mail state. County auditors must send each voter a ballot with instructions about how to mark and return the ballot to the auditor either by mail or in a drop box. Voters may also receive a ballot in person at a voting center, which may also be mailed in or deposited in a drop box. Each voting center must have a drop box on site.

Accommodations for Voters with Disabilities.

Voting centers must be located in public buildings or buildings leased by a public entity, and they must be accessible to people with disabilities. However, the Legislature has found that the elimination of polling places during the transition to vote-by-mail may create barriers to voting for voters with disabilities. Accordingly, counties are required to take appropriate steps to mitigate these impacts and permit voters with disabilities to vote independently and privately. The United States (U.S.) Department of Justice has also issued a checklist to help counties comply with disability access requirements under the federal Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA). This checklist includes questions such as:

County auditors must provide notice of the availability of registration and voting aids, assistance to elderly voters and disabled persons, and procedures for voting calculated to reach elderly voters and disabled persons. "Disabled voter" is defined as a registered voter who qualifies for special handicapped parking privileges, is legally blind, or states that he or she is unable to cast a vote due to a disability.

Each county must establish and maintain an advisory committee that includes people with diverse disabilities. The County Disability Advisory Committee (CDAC) must assist election officials in developing a plan to improve the accessibility of elections for voters with disabilities. The plan must be updated annually and should include recommendations for:

Overseas and Service Voters.

The federal Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act (UOCAVA) permits many U.S. service members and U.S. citizens residing outside the country to vote absentee for federal offices. Washington permits such absentee voting for state offices as well. Overseas and service voters must be given a return envelope that enables them to vote postage-free if returned through the U.S. Postal Service, the U.S. Armed Forces Postal Service, or the postal service of a U.S. Foreign Embassy.

Overseas and service voters are also permitted to return their ballots by fax or email. County auditors must provide instructions to these voters on how they may do so.

Review of Election Procedures.

The election review staff of the Office of the Secretary of State (OSOS) are required to conduct a review of each county's election-related policies, procedures, and practices at least once every five years, except:

Under rules adopted by the OSOS, county auditors may request a review and the OSOS must honor that request whenever practical.

As part of its review, the election review staff must issue a report with findings and recommendations regarding the county's policies, procedures, and practices. County auditors or canvassing boards must respond to the review in writing and list the steps that will be taken to correct any problems noted in the report. Within a year of that response, the OSOS must verify that the county has taken steps to correct the problems noted in the report. A county auditor may also appeal the findings or recommendations to the Election Administration and Certification Board. The OSOS has issued a rule for the standards to evaluate appeals.

When the county auditor certifies an election, the auditor must prepare an election reconciliation report that contains information about voter turnout and the number of provisional ballots, replacement ballots, and rejected ballots, along with the reason for the rejection. The report must separately tally the number of overseas and service ballots issued, received, and counted by email or fax. The OSOS must collect the counties' reconciliation reports and prepare a statewide reconciliation report that includes a comparison among counties of the rates of votes received, counted, and rejected that includes ballots transmitted electronically.

Summary of Bill:

Electronic Voting.

Voters with disabilities, service voters, and overseas voters may return ballots through an electronic portal that has been approved for use by the OSOS. To be approved, a portal must include:

Service and overseas voters may no longer return ballots by email or fax. The county election reconciliation reports no longer need to include data about ballots received, counted, or rejected by email or fax.

Review of Election Procedures for Accessibility.

The OSOS election review staff must conduct a review of each county at least once every two years, rather than five, and the exception for low staffing or budget levels is removed. That review must include assessment of the county's policies, procedures, and practices related to accessible voting for voters with disabilities.

Between 90 and 120 days before a November general election, the county auditor must survey all county voting centers and their surrounding environment to assess whether the voting centers are accessible within the meaning of the ADA Checklist for Polling Places. The surrounding environment includes routes between the voting center entrance and nearby public transportation stops. The auditor must actively engage the CDAC when conducting this survey.

If the county auditor, in consultation with the CDAC, determines that there are any potential barriers that could prevent the voting center from being deemed accessible, the auditor must submit a report to the OSOS within 14 days. The OSOS must respond within 14 days with suggestions and recommendations for ways that the county can ensure that the voting centers noted in the report are accessible.

These reports and the facts related to barriers in the report, or the lack of a report or barriers noted in a report, and the OSOS letter and the facts related to barriers in the letter are not admissible in a civil or administrative proceeding when used to establish liability for a violation of state or federal law or to prove knowledge or lack thereof of such a violation. Certain testimony related to the survey and the drafting of these documents is also inadmissible.

Definitions.

"Disabled voter" is changed to "Voters with disabilities" and is defined as registered voters who have a disability as defined in the Washington Law Against Discrimination.

Appropriation: None.

Fiscal Note: Requested on January 14, 2020.

Effective Date: The bill takes effect 90 days after adjournment of the session in which the bill is passed.