PERMANENT RULES
RELATIONS COMMISSION
Effective Date of Rule: April 1, 2008.
Purpose: To streamline, update and codify well established procedures and case precedent for representation, unit clarification, unfair labor practice, impasse resolution, grievance arbitration, and nonassociation cases. Housekeeping amendments also needed to reflect the full integration of employees covered by the Personnel System Reform Act of 2002 into the agency's jurisdiction.
Citation of Existing Rules Affected by this Order: Amending WAC 391-08-010, 391-25-051, 391-25-110, 391-25-140, 391-25-210, 391-25-350, 391-25-370, 391-25-390, 391-25-530, 391-35-020, 391-35-170, 391-35-190, 391-45-290, 391-45-310, 391-95-010, 391-95-030, 391-95-050, 391-95-070, 391-95-130, 391-95-230, and 391-95-250.
Statutory Authority for Adoption: For WAC 391-08-010, 391-25-110, 391-25-140, 391-25-210, 391-25-350, 391-25-370, 391-25-390, and 391-25-530 is RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.58.050, 41.59.110, 41.76.060, 41.80.080; for WAC 391-25-051 is RCW 41.56.060, 41.56.090, 41.58.050; for WAC 391-25-397 is RCW 41.58.050, 41.80.080; for WAC 391-35-020, 391-35-170, and 391-35-190 is RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.58.050, 41.59.110, 41.76.060, 41.80.070; for WAC 391-35-301 is RCW 41.56.060, 41.56.090, 41.58.050; for WAC 391-45-290 and 391-45-310 is RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.58.050, 41.59.110, 41.76.060, 41.80.120; for WAC 391-95-010 is RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.58.050, 41.59.110, 41.76.060, 41.80.100; for WAC 391-95-030, 391-95-050, 391-95-070, 391-95-130, 391-95-220, 391-95-230, and 391-95-205 is RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.58.050, 41.59.110, 41.76.060; and for WAC 391-95-036, 391-95-056, 391-95-076, and 391-95-136 is RCW 41.58.050, 41.80.100.
Adopted under notice filed as WSR 07-21-067 on October 14, 2007.
Changes Other than Editing from Proposed to Adopted Version:
• | Changed to clarify that rule applies to family child care providers under RCW 41.56.028. |
• | Substitutes the terms "employee" to the more accurate term of "provider." |
• | Amended to clarify that briefs may be extended for complex legal or factual issues. |
• | A new subsection is added to permit parties to make oral motions at the end of an administrative hearing to extend briefs. |
WAC 391-35-170, 391-45-290 and 391-95-230:
• | Changed to clarify that briefs may be extended for complex legal or factual issues. |
• | A new subsection is added to permit parties to make oral motions at the end of an administrative hearing to extend briefs. |
• | Clarified to state that interlocutory appeals may not challenge a preliminary ruling issued under WAC 391-45-110 or application of the six-month statute of limitation. |
• | Rule is amended to comport with IAFF Local 216 v. PERC, 128 Wn.2d 375 (1996) which limits this commission's jurisdiction in union security obligation disputes to determining [determine] an employees right to assert nonassociation. |
• | Changed to clarify the procedure that applies to an employee asserting a right of nonassociation under chapter 41.80 RCW. |
• | Changed to clarify that the requirements under the rule are procedural only, and do not negate an employee's union security obligation. |
• | Changed to add the procedural element similar to WAC 391-95-050. |
Number of Sections Adopted in Order to Comply with Federal Statute: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0; Federal Rules or Standards: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0; or Recently Enacted State Statutes: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0.
Number of Sections Adopted at Request of a Nongovernmental Entity: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0.
Number of Sections Adopted on the Agency's Own Initiative: New 7, Amended 20, Repealed 0.
Number of Sections Adopted in Order to Clarify, Streamline, or Reform Agency Procedures: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0.
Number of Sections Adopted Using Negotiated Rule Making: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0; Pilot Rule Making: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0; or Other Alternative Rule Making: New 0, Amended 0, Repealed 0.
Date Adopted: January 15, 2008.
Dario de la Rosa
General Counsel
OTS-1113.1
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 00-14-048, filed 6/30/00,
effective 8/1/00)
WAC 391-08-010
Appearance and practice before
agency -- Who may appear -- Notice of appearance.
(1) No person
may appear in a representative capacity before the agency
other than the following:
(a) Attorneys at law duly qualified and entitled to practice before the supreme court of the state of Washington;
(b) Attorneys at law duly qualified and entitled to practice before the highest court of record of any other state, if the attorneys at law of the state of Washington are permitted to appear in a representative capacity before administrative agencies of such other state, and if not otherwise prohibited by our state law;
(c) A bona fide officer, employee or other authorized
representative of: (i) Any employer subject to the
jurisdiction of the agency, ((or)) (ii) any labor or employee
organization, or (iii) individual.
(2) Except where the information is already listed in the agency's docket records for the particular case, a person appearing in a representative capacity shall file and serve a notice of appearance listing the representative's name, address, telephone number, fax number, and e-mail address.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050. 00-14-048, § 391-08-010, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110 and chapters 28B.52, 41.56, 41.58, 41.59, 49.08 and 53.18 RCW. 90-06-070, § 391-08-010, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90; Order 77-1, § 391-08-010, filed 1/27/77.]
OTS-1114.3
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 03-03-064, filed 1/14/03,
effective 2/14/03)
WAC 391-25-051
Special provision -- Individual providers
((under)) of home care ((quality authority)) under RCW 74.39A.270 and 74.39A.300 -- Family child care providers under
RCW 41.56.208 -- Adult family home providers under RCW 41.56.029.
(1) This rule consolidates special rules
applicable to:
(a) Individual providers under ((chapter 3, Laws of 2002,
Initiative Measure No. 775 (I-775) passed by Washington voters
in November of 2001. I-775 extended)) RCW 74.39A.270 and
74.39A.300, which extend the coverage of chapter 41.56 RCW to
"individual providers" defined as a person, including a
personal aide, who has contracted with the department of
social and health services to provide personal care or respite
care services to functionally disabled persons under the
Medicaid personal care, community options program entry
system, chore services program, or respite care program, or to
provide respite care or residential services and support to
persons with developmental disabilities under chapter 71A.12 RCW, or to provide respite care as defined in RCW 74.13.270.
(((1))) (b) Family child care providers under RCW 41.56.028, which extends coverage of chapter 41.56 RCW to
"child care providers" defined as persons who:
(i) Provide regularly scheduled care for a child or children in the home of the provider or in the home of the child or children for periods of less than twenty-four hours or, if necessary due to the nature of the parent's work, for periods equal to or greater than twenty-four hours;
(ii) Receive child care subsidies; and
(iii) Are either licensed by the state under RCW 74.15.030 or are exempt from licensing under chapter 74.15 RCW.
(c) Adult family home providers under RCW 41.56.029, which extends coverage of chapter 41.56 RCW to "adult family home providers" who are persons defined as a provider as defined in RCW 70.128.010 who receives payments from the Medicaid and state-funded long-term care programs.
(2) The showing of interest requirement in WAC 391-25-110
is modified for the bargaining unit affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270 and 74.39A.300, to require a ten percent showing of
interest for either a petitioner or an intervenor.
(((2))) (3) The posting of notice requirement in WAC 391-25-140 is inapplicable to the bargaining unit affected by
((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270, 74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and
41.56.029.
(((3))) (4) A party wishing to participate as an
intervenor in representation proceedings governed by this rule
must file a motion to intervene no later than ten days
following receipt of the petition for investigation of a
question concerning representation.
(5) The description of bargaining unit requirement of WAC 391-25-190 is limited to a single, statewide unit of:
(a) Individual providers under ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270
and 74.39A.300; or
(b) Family child care providers under RCW 41.56.028; or
(c) Adult family home providers under RCW 41.56.029.
(((4))) (6) The description of bargaining unit
requirement of WAC 391-25-210(2) is limited to a single,
statewide unit of:
(a) Individual providers under ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270
and 74.39A.300; or
(b) Family child care providers under RCW 41.56.028; or
(c) Adult family home providers under RCW 41.56.029.
(((5))) (7) The provisions of WAC 391-25-210(3) relating
to alternative units or mergers of units are inapplicable to
the bargaining unit affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270,
74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and 41.56.029.
(((6))) (8) The posting requirement in WAC 391-25-220(2),
relating to investigation statements, is inapplicable to the
bargaining unit affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270,
74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and 41.56.029.
(((7))) (9) The posting requirement in WAC 391-25-230(2),
relating to election agreements, is inapplicable to the
bargaining unit affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270,
74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and 41.56.029.
(((8))) (10) The cross-check procedures in WAC 391-25-250, 391-25-391, and 391-25-410 are inapplicable to the
bargaining unit affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270,
74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and 41.56.029.
(((9))) (11) The unit determination election procedures
in WAC 391-25-420 are inapplicable to the bargaining unit
affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270, 74.39A.300, 41.56.028,
and 41.56.029.
(((10))) (12) The requirements of WAC 391-25-430,
relating to posting of election notices on the employer's
premises, is inapplicable to the bargaining unit affected by
((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270, 74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and
41.56.029.
(((11))) (13) Any representation election for the
bargaining unit affected by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270,
74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and 41.56.029 shall be conducted by
mail ballot under WAC 391-25-470, with the following
modifications:
(a) Together with the procedures for casting ballots, the
notice supplied to ((individual)) providers may describe the
collective bargaining rights established by ((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270, 74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and 41.56.029 and
agreements reached by a petitioning union and the employer
concerning the election process;
(b) The notice and ballot materials supplied to
((individual)) providers shall be set forth in English ((and
Spanish)) and any other language the agency deems reasonably
necessary to conduct a fair election;
(c) The ballot materials supplied to ((individual))
providers shall include a card return-addressed to the
commission, by which ((individual)) providers eligible voters
can individually request notice and ballot materials in
((Cambodian, Korean, Mandarin, Russian, Tagalog, Ukrainian, or
Vietnamese)) languages other than those received. Upon
receipt of such a request ((from an individual provider))
card, the agency shall promptly supply notice and ballot
materials to the ((individual provider)) eligible voter in the
requested language.
(d) At least ((twenty-four)) twenty-one days shall be
provided between the date on which ballot materials are mailed
to ((individual)) providers and the deadline for return of
cast ballots to the commission.
(e) The executive director shall have discretion to vary tally arrangements and procedures from those customarily used, because of the large size of the bargaining unit involved.
(f) The reference in ((WAC 391-25-470 to)) WAC 391-25-140
through 391-25-470 shall be interpreted in light of subsection
(((2))) (3) of this section.
(((12))) (14) The procedure for on-site elections in WAC 391-25-490 is inapplicable to the bargaining unit affected by
((I-775)) RCW 74.39A.270, 74.39A.300, 41.56.028, and
41.56.029.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.06.340, 41.76.060, 74.39A.240 and [74.39A].270. 03-03-064, § 391-25-051, filed 1/14/03, effective 2/14/03.]
(2) The agency shall not disclose the identities of employees whose authorization cards or letters are furnished to the agency in proceedings under this chapter.
(a) A petitioner or intervenor shall not serve its showing of interest on any other party to the proceeding.
(b) The question of whether a showing of interest requirement for a petition or for intervention has been satisfied is a matter for administrative determination by the agency and may not be litigated at any hearing.
(c) In order to preserve the confidentiality of the showing of interest and the right of employees freely to express their views on the selection of a bargaining representative, the agency shall not honor any attempt to withdraw any authorization submitted for purposes of this section.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.56.070 and 41.59.070. 01-14-009, § 391-25-110, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 98-14-112, § 391-25-110, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 96-07-105, § 391-25-110, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.56.070 and 41.59.070. 90-06-072, § 391-25-110, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-054 (Order 88-02), § 391-25-110, filed 5/31/88. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 81-02-034 (Order 81-01), § 391-25-110, filed 1/6/81.]
(2) Changes of the status quo concerning wages, hours or other terms and conditions of employment of employees in the bargaining unit are prohibited during the period that a petition is pending before the commission under this chapter.
(3) The employer shall not express or otherwise indicate any preference between competing organizations, where two or more employee organizations are seeking to represent its employees.
(4) Where a petition filed under this chapter involves employees who are represented for the purposes of collective bargaining, the employer shall suspend negotiations with the incumbent exclusive bargaining representative on a successor collective bargaining agreement involving employees affected by the petition. The employer and incumbent union may proceed with negotiations covering employees not affected by the petition, and shall resume negotiations on a successor agreement covering the affected employees after the question concerning representation is resolved, if the incumbent exclusive bargaining representative retains its status.
(5) When an order of dismissal issued under WAC 391-25-390 (1)(a) is served upon the parties, the obligations to maintain the status quo under subsection (2) of this section and suspend negotiations with the incumbent exclusive bargaining representative under subsection (4) of this section are lifted.
(a) If a party to the proceeding files a timely notice of appeal of the order of dismissal, then the obligations under subsections (2) and (4) of this section shall be reinstated once the parties to the proceeding are served the notice of appeal. Those obligations shall remain in effect until a final order is issued by the commission under WAC 391-25-670, unless governed by (b) of this subsection.
(b) Where a timely filed notice of appeal reinstates the obligation to maintain the status quo or suspend bargaining, any party to the proceeding may petition the commission to stay either of those obligations where the petitioning party demonstrates a need for a change in terms and conditions of employment due to circumstances that are beyond that party's control, or where the failure to resume bargaining would substantially harm the petitioned-for employees and leave them without an adequate administrative remedy. A petition filed under this subsection shall be accompanied by affidavits and evidence.
(c) Following the receipt of a petition under (b) of this subsection, the due date for any counter-affidavits from other parties is seven days following the date on which that party is served with the petition.
(d) The executive director shall forward all petitions and affidavits to the commission, who shall determine whether to stay the obligations under subsections (2) and (4) of this section at the next regularly scheduled commission meeting.
(e) If the commission uses its authority under (b) of this subsection, any party seeking review of the commission's decision shall seek relief through the courts.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.56.050. 01-14-009, § 391-25-140, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 96-07-105, § 391-25-140, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110 and 41.56.050. 90-06-072, § 391-25-140, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-054 (Order 88-02), § 391-25-140, filed 5/31/88.]
(2) An organization which files a motion for intervention under WAC 391-25-190 shall not be permitted to seek a bargaining unit configuration different than proposed by the original petitioner.
(3) If petitions filed by two or more organizations under this chapter are pending before the agency at the same time and involve any or all of the same employees, the timeliness of the respective petitions and the sufficiency of the respective showings of interest shall be determined separately and the proceedings shall be consolidated for resolution of all issues concerning the description(s) of the bargaining unit(s). A petition filed after the issuance of a notice of election in another proceeding under WAC 391-25-430 or after the commencement of a cross-check in another proceeding under WAC 391-25-410 shall be dismissed as untimely.
(4) A party to proceedings under this chapter shall not be permitted to propose more than one bargaining unit configuration for the same employee or employees, except where a merger of bargaining units is proposed under WAC 391-25-420.
(5) Where a petitioning union seeks severance of a portion of an existing bargaining unit of classified employees at a school district or educational service district, appropriate bargaining units existing on July 25, 2005, may not be divided into more than one appropriate bargaining unit without the agreement of the employer and certified bargaining representative of the unit where severance is sought.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.06.340, 41.76.060, 41.56.070, 41.59.070, and 41.80.080. 03-11-029, § 391-25-210, filed 5/15/03, effective 6/15/03. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.56.070 and 41.59.070. 01-14-009, § 391-25-210, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 98-14-112, § 391-25-210, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 90-06-072, § 391-25-210, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-046 (Order 80-5), § 391-25-210, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(a) The parties shall be responsible for the presentation of their cases.
(b) The hearing officer shall ascertain the respective positions of the parties, to obtain a full and complete factual record upon which the agency may discharge its responsibilities under the applicable statute. The hearing officer has authority, under WAC 10-08-200 (8) and (9), to ask questions, call witnesses, and explore matters not raised or only partially raised by the parties.
(2) Once a hearing has been declared closed, it may be reopened only upon the timely motion of a party upon discovery of new evidence which could not with reasonable diligence have been discovered and produced at the hearing.
(3) The hearing officer may allow or direct the filing of briefs as to any or all of the issues in a case. Arrangements and due dates for briefs shall be established by the hearing officer. Any brief shall be filed with the hearing officer as required by WAC 391-08-120(1), and copies shall be served on all other parties to the proceeding as required by WAC 391-08-120 (3) and (4).
(4) A party filing a brief under this section must limit its total length to twenty-five pages (double-spaced, twelve-point type), unless:
(a) It files and serves a motion for permission to file a longer brief in order to address novel or complex legal and/or factual issues raised by the objections;
(b) The executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer grants such a motion for good cause shown; and
(c) A motion for permission to file a longer brief may be made orally to the hearing officer at the end of the administrative hearing, and the hearing officer has the authority to orally grant such motion at such time.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.030, 34.05.437, 41.56.060, 41.56.070, 41.59.070 and 41.59.080. 01-14-009, § 391-25-350, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 00-14-048, § 391-25-350, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-25-350, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 96-07-105, § 391-25-350, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.56.060, 41.56.070, 41.59.070, 41.59.080 and 53.18.015. 90-06-072, § 391-25-350, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-046 (Order 80-5), § 391-25-350, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(a) A complaint charging unfair labor practices is filed under the provisions of chapter 391-45 WAC; and
(b) It appears that the facts as alleged may constitute an unfair labor practice; and
(c) Such unfair labor practice could improperly affect the outcome of a representation election.
(2) The complainant(s) in the unfair labor practice case
may file and serve, as required by WAC 391-08-120, a written
request to proceed with the executive director. The request
to proceed shall specify the case number of the representation
proceeding, shall request that the representation petition be
processed notwithstanding the pending unfair labor practice
case, and shall waive the right to file objections under WAC 391-25-590 (1)(a) based on conduct alleged in the unfair labor
practice case. Upon the filing of a request to proceed under
this subsection, the executive director ((shall)) may resume
the processing of the representation petition and shall
summarily dismiss any objections filed in conflict with the
request to proceed.
(((3) Where a complaint charging unfair labor practices
is filed after the issuance of a notice of election, the
executive director shall proceed with the determination of the
question concerning representation, subject to the right of
any party to file objections as provided in WAC 391-25-590.))
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050. 01-14-009, § 391-25-370, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 98-14-112, § 391-25-370, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 96-07-105, § 391-25-370, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.56.070 and 41.59.070. 90-06-072, § 391-25-370, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-046 (Order 80-5), § 391-25-370, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(a) The executive director shall determine whether a question concerning representation exists, and shall issue a direction of election, dismiss the petition or make other disposition of the matter.
(b) Unless otherwise provided in a direction of election, the cut-off date for eligibility to vote in an election shall be the date of issuance of the direction of election.
(2) Where the executive director determines that employee eligibility issues exist, the executive director may delegate authority to the hearing officer to decide those issues.
(3) A direction of election and other rulings in the
proceedings up to the issuance of a tally are interim orders,
and may only be appealed to the commission by objections under
WAC 391-25-590 after the election. ((An exception is made for
rulings on whether the employer or employees are subject to
the jurisdiction of the commission, which may be appealed
under WAC 391-25-660.))
(4)(a) A party seeking review by the commission of an interlocutory decision of the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer must file a motion for discretionary review with the commission and a copy with the executive director or his or her designee within seven days after the decision is issued.
(b) Discretionary review of an interlocutory decision issued by the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer will be accepted by the commission only:
(i) If the executive director or his or her designee has committed an obvious error which would render further proceedings useless; or
(ii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer has committed probable error and the decision of the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer substantially alters the status quo or substantially limits the freedom of a party to act; or
(iii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer has so far departed from the accepted and usual course of administrative proceedings as to call for the exercise of revisory jurisdiction by the commission.
(c) A motion for discretionary review under this rule, and any response, should not exceed fifteen pages double spaced, excluding appendices.
(d) Denial of discretionary review of a decision does not affect the right of a party to obtain later review of the executive director's, his or her designee's, or hearing officer's decision or the issues pertaining to that decision.
(5) Unless appealed to the commission under WAC 391-25-660, a decision issued under this section shall be the final order of the agency, with the same force and effect as if issued by the commission.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.56.060, 41.56.070, 41.56.080, 41.59.070, 41.59.080 and 41.59.090. 01-14-009, § 391-25-390, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.56.060, 41.56.070, 41.59.070 and 41.59.080. 98-14-112, § 391-25-390, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 90-06-072, § 391-25-390, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-054 (Order 88-02), § 391-25-390, filed 5/31/88. Statutory Authority: RCW 34.04.022, 41.58.050, 41.56.090, 41.59.110 and 28B.52.080. 85-19-059 (Resolution No. 85-01), § 391-25-390, filed 9/16/85. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-046 (Order 80-5), § 391-25-390, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(a) The employee's name typed or printed legibly, the employee's signature, and the date of the employee's signature;
(b) A statement that the employee designates the named labor organization as the employee's exclusive bargaining representative for purposes of collective bargaining;
(c) A statement that the showing of interest may be used for purposes of a cross-check election under this section;
(d) A statement that the employee understands that the employee's signature on the card may be used to obtain certification of the named labor organization as the exclusive bargaining representative of the employee without a secret ballot election; and
(e) A statement that the employee has the right to ask the agency to revoke the employee's authorization card for purposes of cross-check of records. The agency shall notify the petitioner of the existence and number of any such revocation(s) prior to the commencement of the cross-check, but shall not disclose the identities of the employees involved.
(2) An authorization card that fails to comply with subsection (1) of this section shall be invalid for purposes of initiating a cross-check of records under this section.
(3) A direction of cross-check and other rulings in the proceedings up to the issuance of a tally are interim orders, and may only be appealed to the commission by objections under WAC 391-25-590 after the cross-check. An exception is made for rulings on whether the employer or employees are subject to the jurisdiction of the commission, which may be appealed under WAC 391-25-660.
[]
(2) Unless governed by WAC 391-25-531, representation elections shall be decided by a majority of those voting. Where there are only two choices on the ballot, a tie vote shall result in a certification of no representative.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.56.070 and 41.59.070. 90-06-072, § 391-25-530, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-046 (Order 80-5), § 391-25-530, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
OTS-1115.4
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 01-14-009, filed 6/22/01,
effective 8/1/01)
WAC 391-35-020
Time for filing petition -- Limitations on
results of proceedings.
(a) Disputes concerning positions which have been newly created by an employer.
(b) Disputes concerning the allocation of employees or positions claimed by two or more bargaining units.
(c) Disputes under WAC 391-35-300 concerning a requirement for a professional education certificate.
(d) Disputes under WAC 391-35-310 concerning eligibility for interest arbitration.
(e) Disputes under WAC 391-35-320 concerning status as a confidential employee.
(f) Disputes under WAC 391-35-330 concerning one-person bargaining units.
(2) A unit clarification petition concerning status as a supervisor under WAC 391-35-340, or status as a regular part-time or casual employee under WAC 391-35-350, is subject to the following conditions:
(a) The signing of a collective bargaining agreement will not bar the processing of a petition filed by a party to the agreement, if the petitioner can demonstrate that it put the other party on notice during negotiations that it would contest the inclusion or exclusion of the position or class through a unit clarification proceeding, and it filed the petition prior to signing the current collective bargaining agreement.
(b) Except as provided under subsection (2)(a) of this section, the existence of a valid written and signed collective bargaining agreement will bar the processing of a petition filed by a party to the agreement unless the petitioner can demonstrate, by specific evidence, substantial changed circumstances during the term of the agreement which warrant a modification of the bargaining unit by inclusion or exclusion of a position or class.
(4) Employees or positions may be added to an existing bargaining unit in a unit clarification proceeding:
(a) Where a petition is filed within a reasonable time period after a change of circumstances altering the community of interest of the employees or positions; or
(b) Where the existing bargaining unit is the only appropriate unit for the employees or positions.
(5) Except as provided under subsection (4) of this section, a question concerning representation will exist under chapter 391-25 WAC, and an order clarifying bargaining unit will not be issued under chapter 391-35 WAC:
(a) Where a unit clarification petition is not filed within a reasonable time period after creation of new positions.
(b) Where employees or positions have been excluded from a bargaining unit by agreement of the parties or by a certification, and a unit clarification petition is not filed within a reasonable time period after a change of circumstances.
(c) Where addition of employees or positions to a bargaining unit would create a doubt as to the ongoing majority status of the exclusive bargaining representative.
(6) Where a petitioning union seeks severance of a portion of an existing bargaining unit of classified employees at a school district or educational service district, appropriate bargaining units existing on July 25, 2005, may not be divided into more than one appropriate bargaining unit without the agreement of the employer and certified bargaining representative of the unit where severance is sought.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 34.05.413, 41.56.060 and 41.59.080. 01-14-009, § 391-35-020, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 96-07-105, § 391-35-020, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110 and chapters 28B.52, 41.56, 41.58, 41.59, 49.08 and 53.18 RCW. 90-06-073, § 391-35-020, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-061 (Order 88-03), § 391-35-020, filed 5/31/88.]
(a) The parties shall be responsible for the presentation of their cases.
(b) The hearing officer shall ascertain the respective positions of the parties, to obtain a full and complete factual record upon which the agency may discharge its responsibilities under the applicable statute. The hearing officer has authority, under WAC 10-08-200 (8) and (9), to ask questions, call witnesses, and explore matters not raised or only partially raised by the parties.
(2) Once a hearing has been declared closed, it may be reopened only upon the timely motion of a party upon discovery of new evidence which could not with reasonable diligence have been discovered and produced at the hearing.
(3) The hearing officer may allow or direct the filing of briefs as to any or all of the issues in a case. Arrangements and due dates for briefs shall be established by the hearing officer. Any brief shall be filed with the hearing officer as required by WAC 391-08-120(1), and copies shall be served on all other parties to the proceeding as required by WAC 391-08-120 (3) and (4).
(4) A party filing a brief under this section must limit its total length to twenty-five pages (double-spaced, twelve-point type), unless:
(a) It files and serves a motion for permission to file a longer brief in order to address novel or complex legal and/or factual issues raised by the objections;
(b) The executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer grants such a motion for good cause shown; and
(c) A motion for permission to file a longer brief may be made orally to the hearing officer at the end of the administrative hearing, and the hearing officer has the authority to orally grant such a motion at such time.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 34.05.437, 41.56.060 and 41.59.080. 01-14-009, § 391-35-170, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 00-14-048, § 391-35-170, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-35-170, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 96-07-105, § 391-35-170, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.56.060, 41.59.080 and 53.18.015. 90-06-073, § 391-35-170, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-047 (Order 80-6), § 391-35-170, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(2) Where the executive director determines that employee eligibility issues exist, the executive director may delegate authority to the hearing officer to decide those issues.
(3)(a) A party seeking review by the commission of an interlocutory decision of the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer must file a motion for discretionary review with the commission and a copy with the executive director or his or her designee within seven days after the decision is issued.
(b) Discretionary review of an interlocutory decision issued by the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer will be accepted by the commission only:
(i) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer has committed an obvious error which would render further proceedings useless; or
(ii) If the executive director or his or her designee has committed probable error and the decision of the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer substantially alters the status quo or substantially limits the freedom of a party to act; or
(iii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing officer has so far departed from the accepted and usual course of administrative proceedings as to call for the exercise of revisory jurisdiction by the commission.
(c) A motion for discretionary review under this rule, and any response, should not exceed fifteen pages double-spaced, excluding appendices.
(d) Denial of discretionary review of a decision does not affect the right of a party to obtain later review of the executive director's, his or her designee's, or hearing officer's decision or the issues pertaining to that decision.
(4) Unless appealed to the commission under WAC 391-35-210, a decision issued under this section shall be the final order of the agency, with the same force and effect as if issued by the commission.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.56.060 and 41.59.080. 01-14-009, § 391-35-190, filed 6/22/01, effective 8/1/01; 98-14-112, § 391-35-190, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 90-06-073, § 391-35-190, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 34.04.022, 41.58.050, 41.56.090, 41.59.110 and 28B.52.080. 85-19-059 (Resolution No. 85-01), § 391-35-190, filed 9/16/85. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-047 (Order 80-6), § 391-35-190, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
[]
OTS-1116.3
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 00-14-048, filed 6/30/00,
effective 8/1/00)
WAC 391-45-290
Briefs.
(1) Any party shall be entitled,
upon request made before the close of the hearing, to file a
brief. The examiner may direct the filing of briefs as to any
or all of the issues in a case. Arrangements and due dates
for briefs shall be established by the examiner. Any brief
shall be filed with the examiner as required by WAC 391-08-120(1), and copies shall be served on all other parties
to the proceeding as required by WAC 391-08-120 (3) and (4).
(2) A party filing a brief under this section must limit its total length to twenty-five pages (double-spaced, twelve-point type), unless:
(a) It files and serves a motion for permission to file a longer brief in order to address novel or complex legal and/or factual issues raised by the objections;
(b) The hearing examiner grants such a motion for good cause shown; and
(c) A motion for permission to file a longer brief may be made orally to the hearing examiner at the end of the administrative hearing, and the hearing officer has the authority to orally grant such motion at such time.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 34.05.437, 41.56.160 and 41.59.150. 00-14-048, § 391-45-290, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-45-290, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 96-07-105, § 391-45-290, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 28B.52.073, 41.56.180, 41.59.150 and 53.18.015. 90-06-074, § 391-45-290, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-048 (Order 80-7), § 391-45-290, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(b) Discretionary review of an interlocutory decision issued by the executive director, his or her designee, or a hearing examiner will be accepted by the commission only:
(i) If the executive director, his or her designee, or a hearing examiner has committed an obvious error which would render further proceedings useless; or
(ii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or a hearing examiner has committed probable error and the decision of the interlocutory decision of the hearing examiner substantially alters the status quo or substantially limits the freedom of a party to act; or
(iii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or a hearing examiner has so far departed from the accepted and usual course of administrative proceedings as to call for the exercise of registry jurisdiction by the commission.
(c) The commission will not accept motions for discretionary review of:
(i) The scope of proceedings issued in a preliminary ruling by the executive director or his or her designee or a hearing examiner under WAC 391-45-110; or
(ii) Application of the six-month statute of limitations;
(iii) Any evidentiary ruling by a hearing examiner during the course of an administrative hearing.
(d) A motion for discretionary review under this rule, and any response, should not exceed fifteen pages double-spaced, excluding appendices.
(e) Denial of discretionary review of a decision does not affect the right of a party to obtain later review of the executive director's, his or her designee's, or hearing examiner's decision or the issues pertaining to that decision.
(2) After the close of the hearing and the filing of all briefs, the examiner shall issue a decision containing findings of fact, conclusions of law, and an order. Unless appealed to the commission under WAC 391-45-350, a decision issued under this section shall be the final order of the agency, with the same force and effect as if issued by the commission.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.065, 41.56.160 and 41.59.150. 00-14-048, § 391-45-310, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-45-310, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 28B.52.073, 41.56.180, 41.59.150 and 53.18.015. 90-06-074, § 391-45-310, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-048 (Order 80-7), § 391-45-310, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
OTS-1117.3
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 03-03-064, filed 1/14/03,
effective 2/14/03)
WAC 391-95-010
Notice of union security obligation.
(1)
((Whenever)) With respect to union security obligations
contained within a collective bargaining agreement negotiated
under ((the provisions of)) chapter 28B.52, 41.56, 41.59,
41.76, or 41.80 RCW ((contains a union security provision, the
exclusive bargaining representative shall provide each
affected employee with a copy of the collective bargaining
agreement, and shall specifically advise each employee of his
or her obligations under that agreement, including informing
the employee of the amount owed, the method used to compute
that amount, when such payments are to be made, and the
effects of a failure to pay.
(2) Disputes concerning whether an employee is within the bargaining unit covered by a union security provision shall be resolved through unit clarification proceedings under chapter 391-35 WAC, and shall not be a subject of proceedings under this chapter.
(3) Disputes concerning interpretation or application of a union security provision shall be resolved through grievance arbitration or other procedures for interpretation or application of the collective bargaining agreement, and shall not be a subject of proceedings under this chapter)), this commission's jurisdiction is limited to resolving disputes regarding an employee's right to assert nonassociation.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 41.06.340, 41.76.060, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122, 41.59.100, 41.76.045 and 41.80.100. 03-03-064, § 391-95-010, filed 1/14/03, effective 2/14/03. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-010, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 90-06-075, § 391-95-010, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-058 (Order 88-10), § 391-95-010, filed 5/31/88. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-051 (Order 80-10), § 391-95-010, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
An employee asserting the right of nonassociation under RCW 28B.52.045, 41.56.113, 41.56.122, 41.59.100, or 41.76.045 shall, at the same time, provide the exclusive bargaining representative with the name(s) and address(es) of one or more nonreligious charitable organizations to which the employee is prepared to make alternative payments in lieu of the payments required by the union security provision.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-030, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 90-06-075, § 391-95-030, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-058 (Order 88-10), § 391-95-030, filed 5/31/88. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-051 (Order 80-10), § 391-95-030, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
An employee asserting the right of nonassociation under RCW 41.80.100 may provide the exclusive bargaining representative with his or her choice to receive funds paid under the union security provision, if such a list is published by the exclusive bargaining representative.
[]
(1) For employees who desire to assert the right of nonassociation under RCW 28B.52.045, 41.56.113, 41.56.122, 41.59.100, or 41.76.045, the response of the exclusive bargaining representative shall address:
(((1))) (a) The eligibility of the employee to make
alternative payments; and
(((2))) (b) The acceptance or rejection of the charitable
organization(s) suggested by the employee under WAC 391-95-030.
(2) The requirements of this section are procedural only, and shall not be a basis to void or negate obligations under the union security provisions of a collective bargaining agreement.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-050, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 90-06-075, § 391-95-050, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-051 (Order 80-10), § 391-95-050, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(1) For employees asserting the right of nonassociation under RCW 41.80.100, the response of the exclusive bargaining representative shall address:
(a) The eligibility of the employee to make alternative payments; and either
(b) If designated by the employee under WAC 391-95-036, acceptance or rejection of the program or charitable organization designated by an employee under WAC 391-95-036; or
(2) If the employee fails to designate a program of the exclusive bargaining representative that would be in harmony with the employees' individual conscience under WAC 391-95-036, the employee organization shall provide a list of designated program(s) of the employee organization to receive funds paid under the nonassociation provision to the employee.
(3) Within sixty days after being presented with a list under this subsection, the employee asserting a right of nonassociation shall provide the employee organization with written notice of his or her designation of the purpose or purposes on that list, if any, that are in harmony with his or her individual conscience. If the employee fails to timely designate a program, the labor organization may choose a program from the list, provided that the list clearly informs the employee of this consequence. The employee may subsequently choose a different program.
(4) The requirements of this section are procedural only, and shall not be a basis to void or negate obligations under the union security provisions of a collective bargaining agreement.
[]
(1) Either the employee or the exclusive bargaining representative may file a petition to obtain a ruling from the commission if:
(a) The exclusive bargaining representative disputes the
eligibility of the employee to ((make alternative payments))
assert the right of nonassociation; or
(((2))) (b) The exclusive bargaining representative
disputes the charity or charitable organization which ((is to
receive such)) the employee desires to be the recipient of
alternative payments; or
(((3))) (c) The exclusive bargaining representative fails
to make a timely response under WAC 391-95-050((, either the
employee or the exclusive bargaining representative may obtain
a ruling from the commission)); or
(d) The employee claiming nonassociation fails to name a charity or charitable organization to receive alternative payments.
(2) Disputes concerning whether an employee is within the bargaining unit covered by a union security provision shall not be a subject of proceedings under this chapter.
(3) Disputes concerning interpretation or application of the collective bargaining agreement containing the union security provision shall not be a subject of proceedings under this chapter.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-070, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-95-070, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 90-06-075, § 391-95-070, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-051 (Order 80-10), § 391-95-070, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(a) The exclusive bargaining representative disputes the eligibility of the employee to assert the right of nonassociation; or
(b) The exclusive bargaining representative disputes the program of the employee organization which the employee desires to be the recipient of alternative payments; or
(c) The exclusive bargaining representative fails to make a timely response under WAC 391-95-056; or
(d) The employee claiming nonassociation fails to name a program of the employee organization to receive alternative payments.
(2) Disputes concerning whether an employee is within the bargaining unit covered by a union security provision shall not be a subject of proceedings under this chapter.
(3) Disputes concerning interpretation or application of the collective bargaining agreement containing the union security provision shall not be a subject of proceedings under this chapter.
[]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-130, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 90-06-075, § 391-95-130, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 81-02-034 (Order 81-01), § 391-95-130, filed 1/6/81.]
(1) Upon being served with a copy of a petition filed under WAC 391-95-076 concerning an employee asserting the right of nonassociation under RCW 41.80.100, the employee organization shall preserve the status quo by holding the disputed funds in a separate account, and shall not request the discharge or other action against the affected employee based on the employee's union security obligations, until the proceedings under this chapter are concluded.
(2) While the nonassociation proceedings remain pending before the commission, the employer shall not honor or otherwise act upon any request for discharge or other action against the affected employee based on the employee's union security obligations.
[]
(2) The employee has the burden to make a factual showing, through testimony of witnesses and/or documentary evidence, of the legitimacy of his or her beliefs, as follows:
(a) In cases where the claim of a right of nonassociation is based on the teachings of a church or religious body, the claimant employee shall demonstrate:
(i) His or her bona fide religious objection to union membership; and
(ii) That the objection is based on a bona fide religious teaching of a church or religious body; and
(iii) That the claimant employee is a member of such church or religious body.
(b) In cases where the claim of a right of nonassociation is based on personally held religious beliefs, the claimant employee shall demonstrate:
(i) His or her bona fide religious objection to union membership; and
(ii) That the religious nature of the objection is genuine and in good faith.
(3) Once a hearing has been declared closed, it may be reopened only upon the timely motion of a party upon discovery of new evidence which could not with reasonable diligence have been discovered and produced at the hearing.
(4) Any party shall be entitled, upon request made before the close of the hearing, to file a brief. The examiner may direct the filing of briefs as to any or all of the issues in a case. Arrangements and due dates for briefs shall be established by the examiner. Any brief shall be filed with the examiner as required by WAC 391-08-120(1), and copies shall be served on all other parties to the proceeding as required by WAC 391-08-120 (3) and (4).
(5) A party filing a brief under this section must limit its total length to twenty-five pages (double-spaced, twelve-point type), unless:
(a) It files and serves a motion for permission to file a longer brief in order to address novel or complex legal and/or factual issues raised by the objections;
(b) The executive director, his or her designee, or hearing examiner grants such a motion for good cause shown; and
(c) A motion for permission to file a longer brief may be made orally to the hearing examiner at the end of the administrative hearing, and the hearing officer has the authority to orally grant such motion at such time.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 34.05.437, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-230, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-95-230, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 96-07-105, § 391-95-230, filed 3/20/96, effective 4/20/96. Statutory Authority: RCW 41.58.050, 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 90-06-075, § 391-95-230, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.58.050, 41.56.090 and 41.59.110. 88-12-058 (Order 88-10), § 391-95-230, filed 5/31/88. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-051 (Order 80-10), § 391-95-230, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]
(b) Discretionary review of an interlocutory decision issued by the hearing examiner will be accepted by the commission only:
(i) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing examiner has committed an obvious error which would render further proceedings useless; or
(ii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing examiner has committed probable error and the decision of the interlocutory decision of the hearing examiner substantially alters the status quo or substantially limits the freedom of a party to act; or
(iii) If the executive director, his or her designee, or hearing examiner has so far departed from the accepted and usual course of administrative proceedings as to call for the exercise of revisory jurisdiction by the commission.
(c) The commission will not accept motions for discretionary review of:
(i) The issuance of a preliminary ruling by the executive director, his or her designee, or a hearing examiner under WAC 391-95-150; or
(ii) Any evidentiary ruling by a hearing examiner during the course of an administrative hearing.
(d) A motion for discretionary review under this rule, and any response, should not exceed fifteen pages double-spaced, excluding appendices.
(e) Denial of discretionary review of a decision does not affect the right of a party to obtain later review of the executive director's, his or her designee's, or hearing examiner's decision or the issues pertaining to that decision.
(2) After the close of the hearing and the filing of all briefs, the examiner shall issue a decision containing findings of fact, conclusions of law, and an order. Unless appealed to the commission under WAC 391-95-270, a decision issued under this section shall be the final order of the agency, with the same force and effect as if issued by the commission.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.090, 41.59.110, 41.58.050, 28B.52.045, 41.56.122 and 41.59.100. 00-14-048, § 391-95-250, filed 6/30/00, effective 8/1/00; 98-14-112, § 391-95-250, filed 7/1/98, effective 8/1/98; 90-06-075, § 391-95-250, filed 3/7/90, effective 4/7/90. Statutory Authority: RCW 34.04.022, 41.58.050, 41.56.090, 41.59.110 and 28B.52.080. 85-19-059 (Resolution No. 85-01), § 391-95-250, filed 9/16/85. Statutory Authority: RCW 28B.52.080, 41.56.040, 41.58.050, 41.59.110 and 47.64.040. 80-14-051 (Order 80-10), § 391-95-250, filed 9/30/80, effective 11/1/80.]