PROPOSED RULES
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
(Division of Consumer Services)
Original Notice.
Preproposal statement of inquiry was filed as WSR 09-10-066.
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: Amending the rules (chapter 208-630 WAC) under the Check Cashers and Sellers Act (chapter 31.45 RCW).
Hearing Location(s): John A. Cherberg Senate Building, Senate Hearing Room 1, Capitol Campus, Capitol Way, Olympia, Washington 98504, on November 5, 2009, at 10 a.m. - 12 noon.
Date of Intended Adoption: November 24, 2009.
Submit Written Comments to: Elizabeth Hampton, P.O. Box 41200, Olympia, WA 98504-120 [98504-1200], e-mail elizabeth.hampton@dfi.wa.gov, fax (360) 586-5068, by November 13, 2009.
Assistance for Persons with Disabilities: Contact Elizabeth Hampton by October 30, 2009, TTY (360) 664-8126 or (360) 902-8786.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: To implement chapters 13 and 510, Laws of 2009, and to amend the rules generally for clarity and consistency. The Laws of 2009 are significant amendments and rule amendments are necessary to provide specificity and guidance to the laws' requirements.
Reasons Supporting Proposal: The changes to the law are significant and specific information is necessary to guide the industry in complying with the laws.
Statutory Authority for Adoption: Chapter 43.320 RCW, chapter 510, Laws of 2009.
Statute Being Implemented: Chapter 31.45 RCW.
Rule is not necessitated by federal law, federal or state court decision.
Name of Proponent: Department of financial institutions, governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting: Cindy Fazio, 150 Israel Road, Olympia, WA, (360) 902-8800; Implementation and Enforcement: Deborah Bortner, 150 Israel Road, Olympia, WA, (360) 902-8800.
A small business economic impact statement has been prepared under chapter 19.85 RCW.
Background for Proposed Rules: During the 2009 legislative session, the Washington legislature passed SB 5164 and ESHB 1709. Governor Gregoire signed SB 5164 into law on March 25, 2009, as chapter 13, Laws of 2009, and signed ESHB 1709 into law on May 15, 2009, as chapter 510, Laws of 2009.
The proposed rules impact companies licensed under the act that have a small loan endorsement (licensees). Key changes required by the legislature affecting licensees include:
• | Licensees are required to maintain a log of all communications with borrowers regarding collection communications. |
• | Small loan amounts are limited to $700 or 30% of the borrower's gross monthly income, whichever is lower. |
• | Borrowers are limited to eight loans in any twelve-month period. |
• | Licensees must access a statewide database to determine a borrower's eligibility for a small loan. |
• | Borrowers are entitled to an installment plan on each small loan they are unable to repay. |
• | Licensees must provide a disclosure to borrowers about the availability of an installment plan. |
• | Licensees must provide a notice to applicants highlighting changes to the act. |
ELEMENT 1: A brief description of the reporting, record-keeping, and other compliance requirements of the proposed rules and the kinds of professional services that a small business is likely to need in order to comply with the requirements.
RESPONSE:
Reporting: There are no new reporting requirements for licensees.
Record keeping: Licensees will be subject to the following new record-keeping requirements:
1. Create and maintain a communication log of all licensee initiated collection communications with a borrower, including telephone and written communications;
2. Maintain the income documentation used to determine the borrower's eligibility for a small loan;
3. Include a disclosure to borrowers, on the small loan application form, about the availability of the installment plan; and
4. Provide borrowers with contracts that meet the amended installment plan terms and conditions.
Other compliance requirements: Licensees will be subject to the following other compliance requirements:
1. Licensees must use a database implemented by the department to determine a borrower's eligibility for a small loan;
2. Licensees must use a database implemented by the department to update required information on small loans outstanding or that have not expired;
3. Licensees will incur a database transaction fee of approximately $1.00 for each small loan recorded on the database; and
4. Licensees must provide a notice to applicants and borrowers describing the changes to the act resulting from the Laws of 2009. The department will provide the content of the notice.
Professional services required: The reporting, record-keeping and other compliance requirements of the proposed rules do not necessarily require professional services. These functions can be performed by a licensee. However, many licensees will likely choose to hire additional employees or outside professional services to create and maintain a communications log, maintain income documentation, amend application forms, create installment plan agreements, access the database, or produce the required notice.
ELEMENT 2: An analysis of the costs of compliance for identified industries, including costs of equipment, supplies, and increased administrative costs.
RESPONSE: The department gathered the data needed for analysis using an online survey of licensees. The survey was available to licensees from August 10, to August 31, 2009. To promote licensee participation, on August 10, 2009, the department used its check-casher-seller ListServ to send an email to the seven hundred thirty-six individual ListServ subscribers (consisting of licensees and other interested persons) advising them of the survey. This communication resulted in a total of eighty-two survey responses; however, after eliminating incomplete and duplicate entries, the department found that just thirty-one of the responses were acceptable. These thirty-one responses came from the department's population of one hundred twenty-six licensees, for a 25% response rate. Only six of these thirty-one respondents have more than fifty employees. All other respondents are "small businesses" under RCW 19.85.020. The small businesses that participated in the survey had from one to forty-eight employees.
Each survey participant was asked to estimate the cost of the proposed rules on the business. The tables shown below, Appendices A and B, summarize the results of the survey from small businesses with fifty or fewer employees and businesses with more than fifty employees respectively, with each response assigned a number rather than the respondent's name.
Analysis of survey results for licensees with fifty or fewer employees: The highest cost elements of the proposed rules for this group are the income documentation and database utilization provisions. Respondents indicated that a majority of the income documentation costs were associated with labor, while the costs associated with using the database were evenly split between labor and other administrative costs. Among the other elements of the proposed rules, labor represented the highest cost component by a significant margin in all cases except the requirement to provide a brochure to borrowers where the cost of supplies slightly exceeds labor costs.
There is a wide range of cost estimates among the respondents. The department believes this is due to the varied business models, delivery channels, and uses of technology among licensees.
Analysis of survey results for licensees with more than fifty employees: The highest cost element of the proposed rules for this group is by far the income documentation requirement. Accessing the database, using installment plan contracts, and keeping and maintaining the communication log are other elements identified as higher cost. Respondents indicated that a majority of the income documentation, database use, and installment plan contract costs were associated with other administrative costs; while labor was the highest cost associated with maintaining a communication log.
ELEMENT 3: Whether compliance with the proposed rules will cause businesses to lose sales or revenue.
RESPONSE: The proposed rules do not restrict a licensee's ability to provide services. However, the act was amended to limit borrowers to eight small loans in any twelve-month period. This amendment will likely cause licensees to lose sales and revenue. The proposed rule requiring licensees to provide borrowers with a notice explaining the amendments to the act may increase the borrower's awareness of the installment plan provision and could result in more borrowers exercising that right. However, the department does not believe that enhanced disclosure of this provision of the law will have a measurable effect on a licensee's volume of business or revenue.
ELEMENT 4: A comparison of compliance costs for the small and large business segments of the affected industries, and whether the impact on small business is disproportionate.
RESPONSE: It appears that the cost of compliance for a small business runs from a low of $1,669 per employee to a high cost of $60,938 per employee with an average of $12,197 per employee. For businesses with over fifty employees, the cost of compliance runs from a low of $63 per employee to a high cost of $4,178 per employee with an average of $1,293 per employee. Therefore, it does appear that the proposed rules will have a disproportionate impact on small businesses.
ELEMENT 5: Steps taken by the agency under RCW 19.85.030(2) to reduce costs of the proposed rules on small businesses, or reasonable justification for not doing so, addressing the specified mitigation steps.
RESPONSE: The department's analysis of these new licensee requirements, listed in the response to Element 1 above, found that several of the requirements addressed are either entirely or partially attributable to legislative changes to the act rather than the proposed rules. The department has fully considered and pursued methods to reduce the costs on small businesses in accordance with RCW 19.85.030 (3)(a) through (f). The following table summarizes each new requirement, the department's findings related to the requirement's source, and the steps taken by the department to mitigate the costs to small businesses.
New Requirement | Source of Requirement | Department Mitigation Efforts |
Licensees must create and maintain a communication log of all licensee initiated collection communications with a borrower, including telephone and written communications. | This is a requirement of the act, SB 5164, section 1(4). | The department amended an earlier version of the proposed rules to limit the required elements of the communication log to only those items required by the act. |
Licensees must maintain the income documentation used to determine the borrower's eligibility for a small loan. | Partially attributable to proposed rules. | The department has expanded the acceptable forms of income verification from earlier versions of the proposed rule and reduced the frequency that licensees must obtain income verification from once every thirty days to every ninety days. In addition, most licensees already collect income documentation as part of their routine processes; therefore, any additional cost would be negligible. |
Licensees must include a disclosure to borrowers, on the small loan application form, about the availability of the installment plan. | This is a requirement of the act, SB 1709, section 5(1). | The department is unable to mitigate the impact of this statutory change. |
Licensees must provide borrowers with contracts that meet the amended installment plan terms and conditions. | This is a requirement of the act, SB 1709, section 4(1). | The department is unable to mitigate the impact of this statutory change. |
Licensees must use a database implemented by the department to determine a borrower's eligibility for a small loan. | This is a requirement of the act, SB 1709, section 6(1). | The department is unable to mitigate the impact of this statutory change. |
Licensees must use a database implemented by the department to update required information on small loans. | This is a requirement of the act, SB 1709, section 6(4). | The department is unable to mitigate the impact of this statutory change. |
Licensees will incur a database transaction fee of approximately $1.00 for each small loan recorded on the database. | Partially attributable to proposed rules. | This cost is tied to a licensee's volume of business and therefore should be comparable for all licensees regardless of business size. In addition, the nature of this charge is self-mitigating, since a licensee must make a small loan, and thus will charge the borrower a loan fee of up to $95, in order to incur the $1 database transaction fee. |
Licensees must provide a notice, using content provided by the department, to each small loan applicant outlining the changes to the act resulting from the Laws of 2009. | Attributable to proposed rules. | The department requires licensees to provide the notice to borrowers only during 2010. |
RESPONSE: The department involved industry representatives and consumer advocates to assist in developing the proposed rules. The department met with each group individually and jointly during rule drafting. All rule drafts were available on the department's web site. The department has received numerous comments on the amendments to the act and the proposed rules. The department will continue to solicit comments until November 13, 2009.
ELEMENT 7: A list of the industry(ies) affected by the proposed rules.
RESPONSE: The industry affected by the proposed rule is check cashers, check sellers, and small loan ("payday loan") lenders licensed under the act. Check cashers and sellers must obtain a license before engaging in business. Small loan lenders must first obtain a check casher and seller's license and then obtain an endorsement that permits them to make small loans. Not all companies provide all three services.
ELEMENT 8: An estimate of the number of jobs that will be created or lost as the result of compliance with the proposed rules.
RESPONSE: Based upon the survey responses, licensees with fifty or fewer employees estimate that an average of one job would be lost as a result of the proposed rules, and none indicated that any jobs would be created. Licensees with more than fifty employees estimated that an average of ten jobs would be lost, and an average of one job would be created.
Responses from the fifty or fewer employee licensee group ranged from zero to eight lost jobs. Just one respondent with more than fifty employees reported that any jobs would be lost; however, this respondent indicated that all fifty-six of its employees would lose their jobs. The two respondents that indicated jobs would be created reported that two and four jobs would be created as a result of the proposed rules.
A copy of the statement may be obtained by contacting Elizabeth Hampton, P.O. Box 41200, Olympia, WA 98504-120 [98504-1200], phone (360) 902-8793, fax (360) 586-5068, e-mail elizabeth.hampton@dfi.wa.gov.
A cost-benefit analysis is not required under RCW 34.05.328. Not applicable to the proposed rules.
September 22, 2009
Deborah Bortner, Director
Division of Consumer Services
OTS-2510.5
REGULATION OF CHECK CASHERS AND SELLERS(( -- REGULATION OF)) AND
SMALL LOANS (PAYDAY LENDERS)
"Act" means chapter 31.45 RCW.
"Affiliate" means any person who directly or indirectly through one or more intermediaries, controls, or is controlled by, or is in common control with another person.
"Agent" for purposes of RCW 31.45.079 means a person who, pursuant to the terms of a written agreement and for compensation, performs small loan agent services on behalf of an exempt entity.
"Annual percentage rate" or "APR" means the cost of credit expressed as a yearly rate, determined in accordance with the federal Truth in Lending Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1601 et seq.), and Regulation Z (12 C.F.R. Part 226 et seq.), as amended.
The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) has developed an APR calculator (APRWIN) that licensees may download and use without charge. APRWIN is available on the OCC's web site at http://www.occ.treas.gov/aprwin.htm.
"Board director" means a director of a corporation or a person occupying a similar status and performing a similar function with respect to an organization, whether incorporated or unincorporated.
"Check" means the same as defined in RCW 62A.3-104(f) and, for purposes of conducting the business of making small loans, includes other electronic forms of payment, including stored value cards, internet transfers, and automated clearing house transactions.
"Check casher" means an individual, partnership, unincorporated association, or corporation that, for compensation, engages, in whole or in part, in the business of cashing checks, drafts, money orders, or other commercial paper serving the same purpose.
"Check seller" means an individual, partnership, unincorporated association, or corporation that, for compensation, engages, in whole or in part, in the business of selling checks, drafts, money orders, or other commercial paper serving the same purpose.
"Close of business" for the purposes of RCW 31.45.86 and these regulations means the actual time a licensee closes for business at the location from which a small loan was originated or 11:59 p.m. Pacific Time, whichever is earlier.
"Default" means the borrower's failure to repay the small loan in compliance with the terms contained in the small loan agreement or note or failure to pay any installment plan payment within ten days after the date upon which the installment was scheduled to be paid.
"Department" means the department of financial institutions.
"Exempt entity" means a person described in RCW 31.45.020 that is engaged in the business of making small loans.
"Installment plan" is a contract between a licensee and borrower that provides that the loaned amount will be repaid in substantially equal installments scheduled on or after a borrower's pay dates and no less than fourteen days apart.
"Investigation" means an examination undertaken for the purpose of detecting violations of chapter 31.45 RCW or these rules or obtaining information lawfully required under chapter 31.45 RCW or these rules.
"License" means a license issued by the director to engage in the business of check cashing or check selling under the provision of chapter 31.45 RCW.
"Loaned amount" means the outstanding principal balance and any fees authorized under RCW 31.45.073 that have not been paid by the borrower.
"Monetary instrument" means a check, draft, money order or other commercial paper serving the same purpose.
"Paid" means that moment in time when the licensee deposits the borrower's check or accepts cash for the full amount owed on a valid small loan. If the borrower's check is dishonored and returned unpaid by the borrower's bank, the loan is not paid.
"Payday advance lender" or "payday lender" means a licensee under this chapter who has obtained a small loan endorsement under RCW 31.45.073.
"Payday advance loan," "payday loan" or "deferred deposit loan" means the same as a small loan.
"Postdated check" means a check delivered prior to its date, generally payable at sight or on presentation on or after the day of its date. "Postdated check" does not include any promise or order made or submitted electronically by a borrower to a licensee.
"RCW" means the Revised Code of Washington.
"Small loan" or "loan" means a loan of up to the maximum amount and for a period of time up to the maximum term specified in RCW 31.45.073.
"Small loan agent services" means all or substantially all of the following services:
(1) Marketing and advertising small loans;
(2) Taking small loan applications;
(3) Assisting customers in completing small loan documentation;
(4) Providing required disclosures;
(5) Disbursing small loan proceeds;
(6) Collecting small loans;
(7) Retaining documents and records; and
(8) Making reports.
"State" means the state of Washington.
"Unsafe or unsound financial practice" means any action,
or lack of action, the likely consequences of which, if
continued, would ((impair)) materially impair the net worth of
a licensee or create an abnormal risk of loss to its
customers.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 07-23-094, § 208-630-110, filed 11/20/07, effective 12/21/07. Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-110, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(2) In order to make payday loans (small loans), a
business must first obtain a license as a check casher or
seller ((must first)) and then obtain a small loan
endorsement to ((its)) that license ((to make small loans in
accordance with chapter 31.45 RCW and this chapter)).
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-120, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-180, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-190, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-230, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(1) Time deposit. ((An assignment)) A certificate of
deposit assigned in favor of the director ((of a certificate
of deposit)). The certificate of deposit must be issued by a
financial institution in the state and whose deposits or
shares are insured by an agency of the government of the
United States. The deposit must be in an amount equal to or
greater than the required surety bond. The depositor is
entitled to receive all interest and dividends on the
certificate of deposit.
(2) Demonstration of sufficient net worth. ((A licensee
or applicant for a small loan endorsement may)) You must
demonstrate net worth ((in excess)) of at least three times
the amount of the required bond. ((The licensee shall)) You
must notify the director within ten business days of any date
upon which ((its)) your net worth decreases below the required
amount. ((A licensee that)) If you fail((s)) to maintain the
required level of net worth and continue((s)) to operate under
a small loan endorsement ((will be required to)), you must
immediately obtain a surety bond and maintain it for five
years after the date of noncompliance. During this five-year
period, the director will not accept a demonstration of net
worth in lieu of a surety bond.
(3) Reports required. ((A licensee that)) If you
maintain((s)) net worth in lieu of a surety bond ((shall)),
you must submit ((annually)) to the director an annual audited
financial statement and ((within forty-five days after the
close of each quarter)) a supplementary year-to-date financial
statement within forty-five days after the close of each
quarter, both prepared in accordance with generally accepted
accounting principles. The financial statements must include
at a minimum a statement of assets and liabilities and a
profit and loss statement. The director may continue to
require other documents, agreements or information necessary
to properly evaluate and ensure that ((the licensee remains in
compliance)) you comply with this section.
(4) Bad debts and judgments. ((A licensee that)) If you
maintain((s)) net worth in lieu of a surety bond ((may)) you
are not required to consider bad debts and certain judgments
as assets. The director may approve exceptions in writing. ((The licensee)) You must charge off ((its)) your books any
debt upon which any payment is six months or more past due. ((The licensee)) You may not count as an asset any unpaid
judgment more than two years old ((which has not been paid)). Time consumed by an appeal from a judgment is not counted in
the two-year limit.
(5) Noncompliance. ((A licensee that does)) If you do
not comply with this section you must obtain and file with the
director a surety bond in the required amount in WAC
((208-630-030)) 208-630-240 and 208-630-250 by the date
specified by the director.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-260, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-360, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
ANNUAL ASSESSMENTS (((PAYDAY LENDING)
NEW SECTION
WAC 208-630-461
What is the maximum amount that all
licensees may lend to a borrower at any one time?
The
outstanding principals of all small loans made by all
licensees to a single borrower at any one time may not exceed
seven hundred dollars or thirty percent of the gross monthly
income of the borrower, whichever is lower.
[]
(2) A copy of the borrower's receipt documenting payment of government benefits; or
(3) Other documentation as approved by the director, including, but not limited to, bank statements that show regular direct deposits from an identified source, check cashing history, employer's verbal confirmation of the borrower's employment status and current gross income.
For repeat borrowers, you must verify the borrower's gross monthly income at least every one hundred twenty days.
[]
[]
(a) Driver's license issued in the United States, Canada, or Mexico;
(b) Any state's state identification card;
(c) Matricula consular;
(d) Tribal identification;
(e) Passport;
(f) Military identification; or
(g) Other forms of identification that provide a reliable means of verifying the borrower's identity.
(2) For loans made over the internet. Reserved.
(3) You must keep a copy of the identification you accepted as proof of the borrower's identity in the loan file.
[]
(2) If the principal exceeds five hundred dollars, you may charge interest or fees not to exceed in the aggregate ten percent of the portion of the principal in excess of five hundred dollars.
(3) If you make more than one loan to a single borrower, and the aggregated principal of all loans made to that borrower exceeds five hundred dollars at any one time, you may charge interest or fees not to exceed in the aggregate ten percent on the portion of the aggregated principal of all loans at any one time that is in excess of five hundred dollars.
[]
(2) The last due date of the loan may not be set more than forty-five days from the origination date on the loan unless the term of the loan is extended by agreement between you and the borrower at no additional cost to the borrower.
(3) Each due date must be scheduled on a date that the business is open to the public.
(4) For purposes of this section, "pay date" includes the date the borrower receives any direct deposit or other electronic transfer of funds into their bank account.
[]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 07-23-094, § 208-630-505, filed 11/20/07, effective 12/21/07.]
[]
(2) If you extend a small loan's due date, the borrower's right to request an installment plan on that loan follows the extended date.
(3) If you extend a small loan's due date, you must update the data base with that new date as soon as practicable.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-510, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(1) The plan must be in writing;
(2) If the small loan is four hundred dollars or less the
term must be for a period of at least ((sixty)) ninety days
((unless a shorter period is agreed to by both the borrower
and the licensee));
(3) If the small loan is over four hundred dollars the term must be for a period of at least one hundred eighty days; and
(4) The borrower may pay off the total amount due at any time without additional penalty, fee, or charge for prepayment.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-520, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(1) Provide for at least three payments;
(2) Be equal to the total amount of the ((payment))
installment plan balance divided by the number of payments
((())subject to reasonable rounding(())); and
(((2))) (3) Be due at substantially equivalent intervals
on or after the borrower's pay dates but at least fourteen
days apart. ((For example, a sixty-day, three hundred fifty
dollar payment plan entered into on May 1 providing for
payments of one hundred twenty dollars on May 20, one hundred
twenty dollars on June 11, and one hundred ten dollars on June
29, complies with this rule.))
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-530, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[]
[]
[]
[]
(1) The date, time, and brief description of all telephone communications; and
(2) The date and brief description of all written communications. The log may be in written or electronic form, and must indicate the borrower's name.
The log must be maintained in a manner that will allow the examiner to review all collection communications covered under RCW 31.45.082 made during a period of time.
[]
[]
[]
(1) If you have made multiple loans to a single borrower, you may not hold checks that total more than the lower of:
(a) Seven hundred dollars plus the allowable fees; or
(b) Thirty percent of the borrower's gross monthly income plus allowable fees.
(2) For purposes of this section, to "hold a check" does not include a check that has been deposited in your bank and subsequently returned unpaid by the borrower's bank.
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
(1) Prevent the practice of refinancing a small loan with another small loan;
(2) Prevent multiple licensees from making simultaneous small loans to an individual borrower so that the loans' total principal balance is the lesser of seven hundred dollars or thirty percent of the borrower's gross monthly income;
(3) Prevent licensees from making more than eight loans to any one borrower in any twelve-month period;
(4) Prevent a licensee from making a loan to a borrower who already has an outstanding small loan principal balance of the lesser of seven hundred dollars or thirty percent of their gross monthly income;
(5) Prevent licensees from making a loan to a borrower who is in default on a small loan or is in an installment plan; and
(6) Ensure that licensees set the small loan due date no earlier than the borrower's next pay date that is more than seven days from the origination date.
[]
(2) Do I have to buy any equipment, hardware, or software to use the data base system? You must have a computer with access to the internet and Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 or higher. Dial-up capacity of at least 56 kps is sufficient. DSL or broadband access will provide faster access and response.
(3) How and when may I access the data base system?
(a) The data base system is the means by which real-time access to the data is made available to you through your internet connection.
(b) The data base system will be accessible twenty-four hours a day every day of the year, except for routine scheduled system maintenance and upgrades performed by the data base vendor.
(4) What must I do to maintain confidentiality of the borrower's information provided to the data base? In order to maintain the confidentiality and security of the borrower's information, you must not transmit information to the data base system using publicly accessible computers, computers that are not under the licensee's control, unsecured wireless connections, or other connections that are not secure. Maintaining a secure connection includes, but is not limited to, installing and regularly updating antivirus and antispyware software and a firewall.
(5) How do I use the data base system to determine a borrower's eligibility for a small loan? You must:
(a) Access the data base system using the assigned user identification and password provided by the security administrator of your company;
(b) Enter the borrower's Social Security number, individual tax identification number (ITIN), or alien identification number, and the borrower's gross monthly income into the system.
(6) What information will the data base system give me when an eligibility search is conducted? The data base system will state a borrower's eligibility or ineligibility for a small loan and will give a reason for the eligibility determination. If the borrower is eligible for a small loan, the data base system will provide the dollar amount the borrower is eligible to receive.
(7) What must I do once the initial search determines that the borrower is eligible for a small loan?
(a) If you receive an initial indication from the data base vendor that the borrower is eligible for a small loan, you must then submit all of the required borrower information necessary to register the transaction in the data base, as prescribed by the date base vendor.
(b) When the required information has been submitted to the data base, the data base system will confirm the initial borrower search. If the borrower's eligibility is confirmed, the small loan transaction will be recorded as open and assigned a transaction authorization number evidencing that the transaction has been authorized by the data base system. You must place the transaction authorization number on the small loan agreement.
(8) What must I do if the borrower is determined to be ineligible for a small loan? If the borrower is deemed ineligible you will be provided with a printable message with a reason for the determination. The message will also include the name, address, and toll-free support number of the data base vendor. You must provide a copy of the printable message to the borrower.
(9) If I make a mistake entering data and must void the transaction, what do I do? Follow the data base vendor's instructions to administratively void the transaction.
(10) If the data base system is inaccessible via the internet, how do I access the data base?
(a) You will be given at least twenty-four hours notice for scheduled maintenance or system upgrades. The notice will be by electronic mail to the designated security administrator, or by a broadcast message on the data base vendor's web site.
(b) In the event the data base system is unavailable, you must adhere to the following procedures:
(i) Confirm that the data base system remains unavailable by attempting to access the data base system with every borrower seeking a new small loan transaction. You need not comply with this procedure if you have been notified via electronic mail by the data base vendor of an expected period of time necessary to correct whatever problem is causing the data base system to remain unavailable;
(ii) Contact the data base vendor's toll-free help desk or voice response system to obtain a temporary transaction authorization number directly from the data base vendor; and
(iii) Enter the remaining transactional data into the data base system within twenty-four hours of obtaining the temporary transaction authorization number from the data base vendor.
(c) In the event that either the department of financial institutions or the data base vendor notifies you that the data base system is unavailable and that all alternative methods for registering a transaction and receiving a transaction authorization number are also unavailable:
(i) You are authorized to conduct transactions during the specific period of unavailability, after receiving written authorization, via electronic mail or facsimile from either the department of financial institutions or the data base vendor with the department of financial institutions' consent.
(ii) Copies of the written authorization for any transactions conducted during an unavailability period must be attached to the small loan agreement for those transactions. One copy of the authorization must be provided to the borrower and another copy must be kept as an audit record.
(d) Transactions created during a period of authorized unavailability must be registered with the data base within twenty-four hours of notification that the data base system is available; provided, however, that if the data base system is unavailable for more than twenty-four hours, then the period for registration shall be extended by twenty-four hours for each additional twenty-four-hour period of unavailability.
(e) Once the transaction has been registered with the data base, the transaction number assigned to that transaction must be placed on the licensee's record copy of the small loan agreement signed by the borrower for that transaction. If the borrower requests that transaction number at any time, the licensee must provide it to the borrower.
(11) Once a loan is made, how can it be canceled or rescinded as authorized under RCW 31.45.086? A borrower may rescind a small loan agreement before the close of business on the next day of business after the date of the transaction without incurring a transaction fee. If a borrower elects to cancel a small loan agreement you must close the transaction on the data base as soon as practicable after the borrower rescinds the small loan transaction. A loan that has been rescinded does not count toward the eight loan limit; nor will you incur a one dollar transaction fee on that loan.
(12) When must I update information on the data base system?
(a) When a borrower's small loan is paid, you must update open transactions on the data base system as soon as practicable to ensure that all identifying information regarding both the borrower and the transaction are accurate, including any comments on the transaction which you deem relevant. You must input the date and time a transaction closes, as well as the payment method, unless you previously entered the payment method.
(b) When a loan is in default, you must mark the loan in the data base as in default as soon as practicable after the default.
(13) How much will each data base transaction cost me? The data base vendor's transaction fee is one dollar per loan registered. The data base vendor will assess this fee for each transaction that has been registered on the data base.
(14) What happens if I do not pay the data base fees to the data base vendor? The data base vendor will lock you out of the data base system.
(15) What happens if I do not receive training and become certified in using the data base? If you or another designated person in the company do not receive training and certification to use the data base, you will not be given an access number for the data base.
[]
(2) ((A licensee)) You must deliver to the borrower at
the time ((the licensee)) you make((s)) the small loan a
disclosure of the right to rescind the loan and the right to
convert the loan to ((a payment)) an installment plan. See
WAC 208-630-570.
(3) ((A licensee who complies with the federal Truth in
Lending Act and Regulation Z, 12 C.F.R. Part 226, will be
deemed in compliance with this act.)) You must include a
statement on the front page of the application for a small
loan that is in at least twelve point type and is
substantially similar to the following: "At the time you
repay this loan, you should have sufficient funds to meet your
other financial obligations. If you cannot pay other bills
because you are paying off this debt, you should enter the
installment plan offered in connection with this loan."
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 07-23-094, § 208-630-560, filed 11/20/07, effective 12/21/07. Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-560, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
Your right to rescind (cancel) this loan. You have the right to rescind this loan by returning the amount of the loan in cash, or returning the check given to you by us to our office by the close of business on our next business day following the date of this loan. We may not charge you for canceling the loan and we will return to you any postdated check or electronic equivalent you have given to us.
Your right to ((a payment)) an installment plan when you
are unable to pay your small loan when it is due.
If ((this is your fourth (or greater) successive loan,
and if you are not in default)) you will be or are unable to
pay your loan when it is due, you may convert your loan to ((a
payment)) an installment plan with us by notifying us on or
before the loan's due date. (("Successive loans" means loans
made to you by us with no more than three business days
between the repayment in full of one loan and the beginning
date of the next loan.
A payment)) If your loan amount is four hundred dollars or less, you may enter into an installment plan that allows you to pay off your loan in substantially equal payments over ninety days. If your loan amount is more than four hundred dollars, you may enter into an installment plan that allows you to pay off your loan in substantially equal payments over one hundred eighty days.
An installment plan will allow you((, by paying a one
time fee equal to the finance charge on your loan,)) to pay
all that you owe ((in at least three payments over a period of
at least sixty days.
Your right to rescind (cancel) this loan. You have the right to rescind (cancel) this loan by returning the amount of the loan in cash, or returning the check given to you by us to our office by the close of business on our next business day following the date of this loan. We may not charge you for canceling the loan and we will return to you any postdated check or electronic equivalent you have given to us)) without having to pay any additional fees, interest charges or other charge for converting your small loan into an installment plan.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-570, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(a) A ((conspicuous)) notice substantially in the form
set forth in WAC 208-630-570; and
(b) A ((conspicuous)) notice of how consumers may contact
the department, substantially in the following form: "If you
have questions about your rights and responsibilities when
taking out a payday loan, contact the Department of Financial
Institutions at 1-800-RINGDFI (1-877-746-4334), or
360-902-8700, or 150 Israel Road S.W., Tumwater, Washington,
98501."
(2) ((Licensees that)) If you make small loans using the
internet you must post the notices required by subsections (1)
and (2) of this section in a conspicuous location on ((their))
your web sites.
(3) ((Licensees)) You may download a copy of the notice
required by subsection (1)(b) of this section from the
department's web site or by contacting the department
directly.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 07-23-094, § 208-630-580, filed 11/20/07, effective 12/21/07. Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-580, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-590, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[]
REQUIREMENTS FOR ALL LICENSEES (1) A ((licensee must maintain a)) record of transactions
conducted. ((Such a)) The record may be limited to the
following provided a sufficient audit trail is available
through records obtainable from ((the licensee's)) your bank
of account:
(a) Amount of the checks cashed;
(b) Amount of fees charged for cashing the check;
(c) Amount of cash deducted from the transaction for the sales of other services or products;
(d) Amount of each check or monetary instrument sold;
(e) Amount of fee charged for the monetary instrument;
(f) Amount of small loan proceeds disbursed;
(g) Fees charged for small loans;
(h) Amount of payments on small loans received;
(i) Origination date of each small loan;
(j) Termination date of each small loan;
(k) ((Payment)) Installment plan payment due dates;
(l) ((The)) Application information as required ((to be
maintained for applications in the)) by rule;
(m) Records of cash payments made on small loans. The
record must include the date of the payment, the borrower's
name, the amount of cash received, the identity of the
employee who received the cash, and whether the payment was
applied to a loan or ((payment)) installment plan;
(n) Copies of receipts required under WAC 208-630-505.
(2) ((Licensees)) You must maintain a cash reconciliation
summarizing each day's activity and reconciling cash on hand
at the opening of business to cash on hand at the close of
business. Such reconciliation must separately reflect cash
received from the sale of checks, redemption of returned
items, bank cash withdrawals, cash disbursed in cashing of
checks, cash disbursed in making small loans, cash received in
payment of small loans and bank cash deposits.
(3) You must keep records of the disbursement of loan
proceeds and the receipts of all payments on the balance of
small loans. The receipt must ((be kept and must)) indicate
the date of the transaction, the borrower's name, amount of
receipt, and whether the disbursement or payment is on a loan
or ((payment)) installment plan.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 07-23-094, § 208-630-610, filed 11/20/07, effective 12/21/07. Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-610, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(2) Records required to be maintained may be in paper form or on any electronic, magnetic, optical or other storage media, or any combination thereof, so long as the licensee maintains the necessary technology to permit access to the records by the department for the period required by law.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-670, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(2) If the borrower notifies you that he or she will be late with a payment or is unable to repay the loan when it is due and an installment plan is initiated, you must return or destroy any postdated check or ACH authorization the borrower has given you prior to entering into the installment plan.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-700, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(2) You are legally responsible for the acts of your employees under RCW 31.45.070(2) when those acts are within the scope of their employment.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-740, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(a) Directly or indirectly employ any scheme, device, or artifice to defraud or mislead any borrower, to defraud or mislead any lender, or to defraud or mislead any person;
(b) Directly or indirectly engage in any unfair or deceptive practice toward any person;
(c) Directly or indirectly obtain property by fraud or misrepresentation;
(d) Make a small loan to any person physically located in Washington through use of the internet, facsimile, telephone, kiosk, or other means without first obtaining a small loan endorsement;
(e) Directly or indirectly refer a borrower, or encourage
a borrower, to use the services of more than one payday
lending business that results in an amount outstanding that
exceeds the loan limit in RCW 31.45.073; ((and))
(f) Directly or indirectly structure a loan transaction in order to exceed the loan limit in RCW 31.45.073;
(g) Directly or indirectly pressure a borrower to not enter into an installment plan;
(h) Directly or indirectly pressure a borrower to borrow more money than they state they want; provided, it is not a violation of this subsection for a licensee to inform a borrower as to his or her maximum loan amount or that he or she is subject to a limit of eight loans per twelve-months period;
(i) Cash a postdated check before the date written on the check except as permitted by RCW 31.45.070(2);
(j) Make a loan without processing it through the data base system except as specifically allowed in law or rule;
(k) Refuse to provide an installment plan to a borrower who is eligible for one; and
(l) Engage in any device or subterfuge to evade the requirements of the act.
(2) In addition to any other penalties, any transaction
in violation of ((this section)) subsection (1)(d) of this
section is uncollectible and unenforceable.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 07-23-094, § 208-630-8201, filed 11/20/07, effective 12/21/07.]
REPORTING REQUIREMENTS(1) Annual financial statements. The financial statements must include at least a balance sheet and a statement of income prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. If you have established a fiscal year different from the calendar year, the financial statements are due not later than one hundred five days after the close of the fiscal year.
(2) Annual assessment report (AAR). ((Each licensee))
You must submit an AAR ((of its)) on your Washington
activities, in a form prescribed by the director. The AAR
must contain the following:
(a) The total dollar volume of checks cashed during the period, if applicable; and
(b) The total dollar volume of checks sold during the period, if applicable; and
(c) The total dollar volume of small loans made during the period, if applicable; and
(d) The annual assessment fee calculation. See WAC 208-630-400.
(3) Consolidated annual report (CAR). ((Each licensee))
You must submit a CAR ((of its)) on your Washington
activities, in a form prescribed by the director. The CAR
must contain at least the following:
(a) For all licensees, the CAR must contain:
(i) The total number of employees and annual payroll during the period;
(ii) The total number and dollar volume of transactions during the period;
(iii) The total dollar amount of fees collected during the period;
(iv) The total number and dollar amount of undeposited checks taken or held in connection with check cashing and small loan endorsement business at the end of the period;
(v) The total number and dollar amount of returned (NSF) checks taken or held in connection with check cashing and small loan business at the end of the period, and the total dollar amount of fees collected for returned (NSF) checks during the period;
(vi) The total number and dollar amount of charge-offs (losses), net of any recoveries, for the period; and
(vii) The total dollar amount of net income before and after taxes earned under authority of this chapter.
(viii) Such other relevant information as the director may require, in a form prescribed by the director.
(b) For all licensees with a small loan endorsement, the CAR must contain:
(i) The total dollar volume of small loans made during
the period, including payment plans made prior to December 31,
2009, and installment plans ((loans)) made after January 1,
2010;
(ii) The total number of loans made for the period;
(iii) The total number of borrowers for the period;
(iv) The number of borrowers whose accounts were referred to collection agencies;
(v) The number of loans rescinded during the period;
(vi) The number of borrowers ((entering)) who entered
into a payment plan for 2009 or installment plans after
January 1, 2010, and the dollar amount of loans financed;
(vii) The number of borrowers who defaulted;
(viii) The number of loans made to borrowers to be paid through an ACH (automated clearing house) or other electronic transaction;
(((viii))) (ix) The number of loans made to borrowers
through other than a physical visit to the licensee's location
(e.g., internet, telephone, etc.); and
(((ix))) (x) The number of active military borrowers
during the period.
(c) For all licensees with small loan endorsements and total loan volume of at least ten million dollars in principal for the reporting period, the CAR must contain the following:
(i) The number of loans per borrower for the period;
(ii) The number of loans per military borrower during the period; and
(iii) The number of loans with terms in each of the following categories for the period:
(A) One to seven days;
(B) Eight to fourteen days;
(C) Fifteen to twenty-one days;
(D) Twenty-two to thirty-one days; and
(E) Thirty-two or more days.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 08-16-092, § 208-630-830, filed 8/5/08, effective 9/5/08. Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-830, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 43.320.040. 08-16-092, § 208-630-8301, filed 8/5/08, effective 9/5/08.]
(a) Your company filing for bankruptcy or reorganization;
(b) Your company receiving notification of a license revocation procedure against it in any state;
(c) You, or a director, officer, partner, member or controlling person of the company being convicted of a crime;
(d) You, or a director, officer, partner, member or controlling person of the company receiving notification of the filing of criminal charges or a criminal indictment or information, in any way related to check cashing, check selling or small loan activities.
(2) You must notify the director in writing at least fifteen days prior to a change of control. In the case of a corporation, control is defined as a change of ownership by a person or group acting in concert to acquire fifty percent of the stock, or the ability of a person or group acting in concert to elect a majority of the board directors or otherwise effect a change in policy of the corporation. The director may require such information as deemed necessary to determine whether a new application is required. In the case of entities other than corporations, change in control means any change in controlling persons of the organization, either active or passive. Change of control investigation fees are billed to the persons or group at the rate billed for applications.
[]
(a) The date you will cease small loan activity;
(b) A list of all open and pending transactions;
(c) Your contact address and e-mail address; and
(d) Your plan for the orderly closure of open loans on the data base system.
(2) For purposes of this section, the term "ceasing operations" means that you have closed the offices to the public or have removed public access to the web site, if such access is the sole means of communication with customers. This provision does not apply if you have given customers a reasonable alternative for communications and payments.
[]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-880, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-890, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-910, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
(2) A licensee is prohibited from allowing the ((bank
of)) financial institution holding the trust account to charge
back checks or drafts deposited to the trust account and
subsequently dishonored against ((said)) the trust account.
(3) A licensee((,)) whose license has expired or been
suspended((,)) or terminated((, or not renewed, shall)) must
not make withdrawals from the trust account without the
director's consent, until a closing report has been received
according to these rules.
[Statutory Authority: RCW 31.04.165, 43.320.040, 31.45.030, 31.45.050, 31.45.200. 05-22-009, § 208-630-950, filed 10/21/05, effective 11/21/05.]
The following sections of the Washington Administrative Code are repealed:
WAC 208-630-430 | When may a licensee expect a fee increase? |
WAC 208-630-440 | How will a licensee know about fee increases? |
WAC 208-630-460 | When must a licensee inform the director of significant changes in business? |
WAC 208-630-540 | Must a licensee comply with the federal Truth in Lending Act when entering into a payment plan? |
WAC 208-630-550 | May the licensee and the borrower enter into a payment plan prior to the fourth consecutive loan? |
WAC 208-630-750 | What fees may licensees charge to collect a delinquent small loan? |
WAC 208-630-770 | May a licensee allow a borrower to refinance or "rollover" a small loan with another small loan? |
WAC 208-630-780 | May a licensee use a name or place of business other than that named on the license or small loan endorsement? |
WAC 208-630-790 | What is the limit on the amount of checks a licensee may hold from one borrower? |
WAC 208-630-800 | May a licensee holding a borrower's check for a period longer than the statutory limit of forty-five days charge additional fees? |
WAC 208-630-810 | May a licensee charge additional fees to cash monetary instruments issued as part of a small loan? |
WAC 208-630-820 | May a licensee charge any fees if a borrower decides to convert their loan to a payment plan? |