WSR 23-21-050
EXPEDITED RULES
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
[Filed October 10, 2023, 3:26 p.m.]
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: WAC 458-16-130 Change in taxable status of real property and 458-16-165 Conditions under which nonprofit organizations, associations, or corporations may obtain a property tax exemption.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: The department is amending WAC 458-16-130 to incorporate 2023 legislation, HB 1303. Section 2 of this bill explains how the assessor lists and values publicly owned property that loses its exempt status. WAC 458-16-165 is being amended to incorporate 2023 legislation, HB 1265. Section 2 of this bill explains certain provisions regarding a property tax exemption for housing for persons with developmental disabilities.
Reasons Supporting Proposal: Updating these rules will provide clarity to taxpayers regarding administrative provisions for certain property tax exemptions.
Statutory Authority for Adoption: RCW 84.08.010, 84.08.070, and 84.36.865.
Statute Being Implemented: RCW 84.36.805 and 84.40.370.
Rule is not necessitated by federal law, federal or state court decision.
Name of Proponent: Department of revenue, governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting: Leslie Mullin, 6400 Linderson Way S.W., Tumwater, WA, 360-534-1589; Implementation and Enforcement: John Ryser, 6400 Linderson Way S.W., Tumwater, WA, 360-534-1605.
This notice meets the following criteria to use the expedited adoption process for these rules:
Adopts or incorporates by reference without material change federal statutes or regulations, Washington state statutes, rules of other Washington state agencies, shoreline master programs other than those programs governing shorelines of statewide significance, or, as referenced by Washington state law, national consensus codes that generally establish industry standards, if the material adopted or incorporated regulates the same subject matter and conduct as the adopting or incorporating rule.
Explanation of the Reason the Agency Believes the Expedited Rule-Making Process is Appropriate: The expedited rule-making process is applicable to these rule updates because the department is incorporating changes resulting from 2023 legislation.
NOTICE
THIS RULE IS BEING PROPOSED UNDER AN EXPEDITED RULE-MAKING PROCESS THAT WILL ELIMINATE THE NEED FOR THE AGENCY TO HOLD PUBLIC HEARINGS, PREPARE A SMALL BUSINESS ECONOMIC IMPACT STATEMENT, OR PROVIDE RESPONSES TO THE CRITERIA FOR A SIGNIFICANT LEGISLATIVE RULE. IF YOU OBJECT TO THIS USE OF THE EXPEDITED RULE-MAKING PROCESS, YOU MUST EXPRESS YOUR OBJECTIONS IN WRITING AND THEY MUST BE SENT TO Leslie Mullin, Department of Revenue, P.O. Box 47467, Olympia, WA 98504-7467, phone 360-534-1589. fax 360-534-1606, email LeslieMu@dor.wa.gov, AND RECEIVED BY December 18, 2023.
October 10, 2023
Atif Aziz
Rules Coordinator
OTS-5012.1
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 02-02-009, filed 12/20/01, effective 1/20/02)
WAC 458-16-130Change in taxable status of real property.
(1) Introduction. This rule explains what occurs when taxable property becomes exempt and when exempt property becomes taxable. It also describes how property will be treated when exempt use is pending.
(2) Definitions. For purposes of this rule, the following definitions apply:
(a) "Back taxes" means the property taxes that would have been paid but for the existence of the property tax exemption during the three years immediately preceding the cancellation or removal of the exemption or during the life of the exemption, whichever is less, plus interest at the same rate and ((computed))calculated in the same way as delinquent property taxes((, see)). RCW 84.36.810. However, "back taxes" are calculated differently when an exemption is ((cancelled))canceled or removed from property owned by a not-for-profit foundation established for the exclusive support of an institution of higher education under RCW 84.36.050(2) or a nature conservancy under RCW 84.36.260. See RCW 84.36.810 (1)(b) and WAC 458-16-150 Cessation of useTaxes collectible for prior years, regarding not-for-profit foundations and RCW 84.36.262 and WAC 458-16-290 Nature conservancy lands, regarding nature conservancies for a more detailed explanation of the back taxes imposed on these entities.
(b) "Cessation of use" means that an owner or user of exempt real property has ceased to use the property for an exempt purpose. The term also refers to property that has lost its exempt status because it was sold, transferred, loaned, or rented to an owner or user that is not entitled to a property tax exemption under chapter 84.36 RCW.
(c) "Department" means the state department of revenue.
(d) "Real property" means real property, as defined in RCW 84.04.090, owned or used by a nongovernmental nonprofit organization, association, or corporation, a foreign national government, cemetery, soil and water conservation district, and public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW.
(e) "Rollback" means the back taxes and interest imposed in accordance with RCW 84.36.810 because the exempt property lost its exempt status and is now taxable for property tax purposes. However, when an exemption granted to a nature conservancy under RCW 84.36.260 is ((cancelled))canceled or removed different rollback procedures are applied. See RCW 84.36.262 and WAC 458-16-290.
(3) Acquiring tax exempt status.An application must be filed with the department within ((sixty))60 days of acquiring real property that may qualify for exemption or converting real property to a use that may qualify for exemption, any nongovernmental nonprofit organization, association, or corporation, foreign national government, cemetery, or public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW that wants to obtain a property tax exemption for this property ((must file an application with the department)). The applicant may file an application for either a new or continued exemption from property tax under chapter 84.36 RCW. All applications must comply with the requirements set forth in WAC 458-16-110 Initial application and renewal declaration.
(a) If an application for a new exemption is approved, the property will be exempt for taxes payable during the following calendar year. For example, a nonprofit hospital acquires a new building on February 10, ((2001))2022, converts it to an exempt use by April 1, ((2001))2022, and applies for a property tax exemption on April 14, ((2001))2022. If the application is approved, the property tax exemption will be effective for taxes payable in ((2002))2023.
(b) When exempt property is acquired by an entity that is eligible for a property tax exemption under chapter 84.36 RCW, the exempt status of the property will continue ((as long as))if the purchaser makes an application to continue the property tax exemption within ((sixty))60 days of the date of acquisition and the application is subsequently approved by the department. For example, if a nonprofit home for the aging acquires exempt property from a nursing home, the exempt status of the property will not change ((as long as))if the home for the aging makes application to the department within ((sixty))60 days of acquiring the nursing home and the application for exemption is later approved by the department.
(4) Exempt to taxable status(( - Pro rata share of taxes for current tax year)). Real property may lose its exempt status for ((a number of))several reasons; when this occurs, the property tax exemption will be ((cancelled))canceled or removed. ((Once))When the exemption is ((cancelled))canceled or removed, the property becomes subject to the following year's taxes. Except for publicly owned property that was exempt under RCW 84.36.010, the property will be assessed and taxed at its true and fair value as of the date of the cessation of use or the change of ownership occurred, as provided in RCW 84.40.350 through 84.40.390. Additionally, the treasurer of the county in which the property is located ((shall))will collect a pro rata portion of the taxes allocable to the remaining portion of the current tax year after the date the exemption is ((cancelled))canceled or removed. If only a portion of the property no longer qualifies for a tax exemption, the exempt status for only that portion of the property ((shall))will be ((cancelled))canceled and that portion of the property will be subjected to assessment and taxation during the current tax year.
For publicly owned property that was exempt under RCW 84.36.010, and loses its exempt status and becomes taxable, the assessor must value and list the property as of the January 1st assessment date for the year of the status change in accordance with RCW 84.40.175.
(a) Real property changes from exempt to taxable status ((whenever))when the property is:
(i) Transferred as a result of a sale, exchange, gift, or contract from tax exempt to taxable ownership;
(ii) Transferred as a result of a sale, exchange, gift, or contract from tax exempt ownership to ((another))a nonprofit organization, association, or corporation that fails to apply for or has been denied a property tax exemption;
(iii) Converted to a taxable use; or
(iv) Loses its exempt status for some other reason.
(b) Except for publicly owned property exempt under RCW 84.36.010, the rollback provisions of RCW 84.36.810 apply when the status of real property changes from exempt to taxable. See WAC 458-16-150 for specific information. However, the rollback provisions of RCW 84.36.262 apply when the property was exempt under RCW 84.36.260 for the conservation of ecological systems, natural resources, or open space. When property changes from exempt to taxable status, the taxes owing will be prorated as of:
(i) The date the instrument of sale, exchange, gift, or contract is executed; or
(ii) The date on which the property is converted to a taxable use.
(c) Example 1. For five years, nonprofit "A" operated a day care center and received a property tax exemption for this property. Nonprofit "A" transfers this property to nonprofit "B," a nonprofit hospital, that continues to receive a property tax exemption for this property. Two years after acquiring the property nonprofit "B" ceases to use the exempt property for an exempt purpose. One hundred days after the exempt activity ceased, nonprofit "B" sells the exempt property to XYZ Printing Company, a profit seeking business. The property became taxable and the provisions of RCW 84.34.810 will be applied as of the date "B" ceased to use the property for an exempt purpose.
(d) Example 2. A nonprofit shelter for low-income persons owned and occupied a building for which it received a property tax exemption. The shelter ceased to use the property on January 1, ((2001))2022, and had no intent to reoccupy the property. ((But it hoped to rent the property))The shelter advertised the property so it could rent it to another nonprofit organization for a tax exempt purpose ((and actively advertised and looked for such a tenant. On June 1, 2001,)). The nonprofit shelter((, which had been unable to find a suitable tax exempt tenant for the property,))was unable to find another nonprofit organization to rent the property for a tax exempt purpose, so on June 1, 2022, it signed a lease agreement with a for-profit business enterprise((,)) which intended to ((use and)) occupy the property effective ((June 1, 2001))July 1, 2022. The rollback provisions of RCW 84.36.810 must be applied as of January 1, ((2001))2022.
(5) Change of ownership or use - Exempt use pending. If the ownership of exempt property changes or the use of exempt property ceases but the owner of the property begins to use it for an exempt purpose within ((one hundred twenty))120 days of the date the ownership changed or the previous exempt use ceased, the property will continue to be exempt from property tax. However, if an agreement establishing an alternate exempt use is not signed or an alternate exempt use is not found within ((one hundred twenty))120 days, the property becomes taxable and is noted as such on the assessment roll as of the date the ownership changed or the exempt use ceased. Additionally, if appropriate, the rollback provisions of RCW 84.36.810 will be applied or RCW 84.36.262 if the exempt property was exempt as a nature conservancy. A pro rata share of taxes allocable for the remaining portion of the year in which the cessation of use or change in ownership occurred will be collected.
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 22-24-097, filed 12/6/22, effective 1/6/23)
WAC 458-16-165Conditions under which nonprofit organizations, associations, or corporations may obtain a property tax exemption.
(1) Introduction. This rule describes the conditions in RCW 84.36.805 and 84.36.840 that most nonprofit organizations, associations, and corporations must satisfy in order to receive a property tax exemption under chapter 84.36 RCW.
(2) Definitions. For purposes of this rule, the following definitions apply:
(a) "Department" means the department of revenue.
(b) "Inadvertent use" or "inadvertently used" means the use of the property in a manner inconsistent with the purpose for which the exemption is granted through carelessness, lack of attention, lack of knowledge, mistake, surprise, or neglect.
(c) "Maintenance and operation expenses" means items of expense allowed under generally accepted accounting principles to maintain and operate the loaned or rented portion of the exempt property.
(d) "Revenue" means income received from the loan or rental of exempt property when the income exceeds the amount of maintenance and operation expenses attributable to the portion of the property loaned or rented.
(e) "Personal service contract" means a contract between a nonprofit organization, association, or corporation and an independent contractor under which the independent contractor provides a service on the organization's, association's, or corporation's tax exempt property. (See example in subsection (5)(c) of this rule.)
(3) Examples. This rule includes examples that identify a set of facts and then state a conclusion. These examples should only be used as a general guide. The department will evaluate each case on its particular facts and circumstances.
(4) Applicability of this rule. This rule does not apply to exemptions granted to:
(a) Public burying grounds or cemeteries under RCW 84.36.020;
(b) Churches, parsonages, convents, and church grounds under RCW 84.36.020;
(c) Administrative offices of nonprofit recognized religious organizations under RCW 84.36.032;
(d) Nonprofit homeownership development entities under RCW 84.36.049;
(e) Water distribution property owned by a nonprofit corporation or cooperative association under RCW 84.36.250;
(f) Nonprofit fair associations under RCW 84.36.480(2); or
(g) Multipurpose senior citizen centers under RCW 84.36.670.
(5) Exclusive use. Exempt property must be exclusively used for the actual operation of the activity for which the nonprofit organization, association, corporation, hospital established under chapter 36.62 RCW, or public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW, received the property tax exemption unless the authorizing statute states otherwise. The property exempted from taxation must not exceed an area reasonably necessary to facilitate the exempt purpose.
(a) Loan or rental of exempt property. ((As a general rule))For information on loans and rentals of property exempt under RCW 84.36.030, see RCW 84.36.031. For other exempt property, generally, the loan or rental of exempt property does not make it taxable if:
(i) The rents or donations received for the use of the property are reasonable and do not exceed the maintenance and operation expenses attributable to the portion of the property loaned or rented; ((and))
(ii) Except for the exemptions under RCW 84.36.030(4), 84.36.037, 84.36.050, and 84.36.060 (1)(a) and (b), the property would be exempt from tax if owned by the organization to which it is loaned or rented; and
(iii) The loan and rental provisions described in this subsection (5)(a) do not apply to real and personal property owned or leased by a nonprofit organization, corporation, or association to provide housing for eligible persons with developmental disabilities, as described under RCW 84.36.042.
(b) Fund-raising events. The use of exempt property for fund-raising events conducted by an exempt organization, association, corporation, hospital established under chapter 36.62 RCW, or public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW, does not jeopardize the exemption if the fund-raising events are consistent with the purposes for which the exemption was granted. The term "fund-raising" means any revenue-raising event limited to less than five days in length that disburses 51 percent or more of the profits realized from the event to the exempt nonprofit entity conducting the fund-raising event.
(i) Example 1. A nonprofit social service agency holds an art auction in the auditorium of its tax exempt facility to raise funds. The event must be less than five days in length and 51 percent of the profits must be disbursed to the social service agency because the fund-raising event is being held on exempt property.
(ii) Example 2. A nonprofit school has a magazine subscription drive to raise funds and the subscriptions are being sold door-to-door by students. There are no limitations on this fund-raising event because the subscription drive is not being held on exempt property.
(c) Personal service contract - Exempt programs. Programs provided under a personal service contract will not jeopardize the exemption if the following conditions are met:
(i) The program is compatible and consistent with the purposes of the exempt organization, association, or corporation;
(ii) The exempt organization, association, or corporation maintains separate financial records as to all receipts and expenses related to the program; and
(iii) A summary of all receipts and expenses of the program are provided to the department upon request.
(iv) Example 3. A nonprofit school may decide to contract with a provider to offer aerobic classes to promote general health and fitness. All brochures and bulletins advertising these classes must show that the school is sponsoring the classes. Under the terms of the contract between the nonprofit school and the aerobics instructor, an independent contractor, the instructor must provide the classes for a predetermined fee. All fees collected from the participants of the classes must be received by the school; the school, in turn, will absorb all costs related to the classes.
(d) Personal service contract - Nonexempt programs. Programs provided under a personal service contract (i) that require the contractor to reimburse the nonprofit organization for program expenses, or (ii) in which the instructor is paid a fee based on the number of people who attend the program will be viewed as a rental agreement and will subject the property to property tax.
(e) Inadvertent use. An inadvertent use of the property in a manner inconsistent with the purpose for which the exemption was granted does not subject the property to tax if the inadvertent use is not part of a pattern of use. A "pattern of use" is presumed when an inadvertent use is repeated in the same assessment year or in two or more successive assessment years.
(6) No discrimination allowed. The exempt property and the services offered must be available to all persons regardless of race, color, national origin, or ancestry.
(7) Compliance with licensing or certification requirements. A nonprofit entity, hospital established under chapter 36.62 RCW, or public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW seeking or receiving a property tax exemption must comply with all applicable licensing and certification requirements imposed by law or regulation.
(8) Property sold subject to an option to repurchase. Property sold to a nonprofit entity, hospital established under chapter 36.62 RCW, or public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW with an option to be repurchased by the seller cannot qualify for an exemption. This prohibition does not apply to:
(a) Limited equity cooperatives as defined in RCW 84.36.675; or
(b) Property sold to a nonprofit entity, as defined in RCW 84.36.560, by:
(i) A nonprofit as defined in RCW 84.36.800 that is exempt from income tax under section 501(c) of the federal Internal Revenue Code;
(ii) A governmental entity established under RCW 35.21.660, 35.21.670, or 35.21.730;
(iii) A housing authority created under RCW 35.82.030;
(iv) A housing authority meeting the definition of RCW 35.82.210 (2)(a); or
(v) A housing authority established under RCW 35.82.300.
(9) Duty to produce financial records. To determine whether a nonprofit entity is entitled to receive a property tax exemption under the provisions of chapter 84.36 RCW and before the exemption is renewed each year, the entity claiming exemption must submit a signed statement made under oath, with the department. This sworn statement must include a declaration that the income, receipts, and donations of the entity seeking the exemption have been used to pay the actual expenses incurred to maintain and operate the exempt facility or for its capital expenditures and to no other purpose. It must also include a statement listing the receipts and disbursements of the organization, association, or corporation. This statement must be made on a form prescribed and furnished by the department.
(a) The provisions of this subsection do not apply to an entity either applying for or receiving an exemption under RCW 84.36.020, 84.36.030, or 84.36.049.
(b) This signed statement must be submitted on or before March 31st each year by any entity currently receiving a tax exemption. If this statement is not received on or before March 31st, the department will remove the tax exemption from the property. However, the department will allow a reasonable extension of time for filing if the exempt entity has submitted a written request for an extension on or before the required filing date and for good cause.
(10) Caretaker's residence. If a nonprofit entity, hospital established under chapter 36.62 RCW, or public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW exempt from property tax under chapter 84.36 RCW employs a caretaker to provide either security or maintenance services and the caretaker's residence is located on exempt property, the residence may qualify for exemption if the following conditions are met:
(a) The caretaker's duties include regular surveillance, patrolling the exempt property, and routine maintenance services;
(b) The nonprofit entity, hospital established under chapter 36.62 RCW, or the public hospital district established under chapter 70.44 RCW demonstrates the need for a caretaker at the facility;
(c) The size of the residence is reasonable and appropriate in light of the caretaker's duties and the size of the exempt property; and
(d) The caretaker receives the use of the residence as part of his or her compensation and does not pay rent. Reimbursement of utility expenses created by the caretaker's presence is not considered rent.
(11) Nonexempt uses of property. The use of property exempt under this chapter, other than as specifically authorized by this chapter, nullifies the exemption otherwise available for the property for the assessment year. However, the exemption is not nullified by the use of the property by any individual, group, or entity, where such use is not otherwise authorized by this chapter, for not more than 50 days in each calendar year, and the property is not used for pecuniary gain or to promote business activities for more than 15 of the 50 days in each calendar year. The 50 and 15-day limitations do not include days for setup and takedown activities that take place immediately preceding or following a meeting or other event. If these requirements are not met, the exemption is removed for the affected portion of the property for that assessment year.
(12) Farmers markets. The 50 and 15-day limitations in subsection (11) of this rule do not apply to exempt property under RCW 84.36.037 if the property is used for activities related to a qualifying farmers market, for up to 53 days each calendar year, and all income received from the rental or use of the exempt property is used for capital improvements to the exempt property, maintenance and operation of the exempt property, or exempt purposes. For purposes of this rule, "farmers market" has the same meaning as "qualifying farmers market" as defined in RCW 66.24.170.
(13) Segregation of nonqualifying property. Any portion of exempt property not meeting the qualifications of this rule will lose its exempt status. Nonqualifying property must be segregated from property used for exempt purposes. For example, if a portion of a building owned by a nonprofit hospital is rented to a sandwich shop, this portion of the hospital must be segregated from the remainder of the building that is being used for exempt hospital purposes. The portion of the building rented to the sandwich shop is subject to property tax.