WSR 24-14-057
PROPOSED RULES
DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY
[Order 23-01—Filed June 27, 2024, 9:31 a.m.]
Original Notice.
Preproposal statement of inquiry was filed as WSR 23-14-026.
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: Chapter 173-441 WAC, Reporting of emissions of greenhouse gases rule; and chapter 173-446 WAC, Climate Commitment Act program rule, electricity markets rule making.
For more information on this rule making, please visit https://ecology.wa.gov/regulations-permits/laws-rules-rulemaking/rulemaking/wac-173-441-446.
Hearing Location(s): On August 6, 2024, at 1:00 p.m. Hearing via webinar. Join online and see instructions https://waecy-wa-gov.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZAkdeCrqTgiH9WgLsdLU9TAdqV-5Z5bcddJ. Presentation and question and answer session followed by the hearing. This is an online meeting that you can attend from any computer using internet access; and
On August 8, 2024, at 9:00 a.m. Hearing via webinar. Join online and see instructions https://waecy-wa-gov.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZIsduypqzgiEtPFx2hAdGWb5y0eUSL6Pcv-]. Presentation and question and answer session followed by the hearing. This is an online meeting that you can attend from any computer using internet access.
Date of Intended Adoption: December 3, 2024.
Submit Written Comments to: Gopika Patwa, Department of Ecology, Climate Pollution Reduction Program, P.O. Box 47600, Olympia, WA 98504-7600; or Department of Ecology, Climate Pollution Reduction Program, 300 Desmond Drive S.E., Lacey, WA 98503, email gopika.patwa@ecy.wa.gov, https://aq.ecology.commentinput.com?id=ijhB5kQRH, beginning June 27, 2024, 12:00 a.m., by August 20, 2024, 11:59 p.m.
Assistance for Persons with Disabilities: Contact ecology ADA coordinator, phone 360-407-6831, speech disability may call TTY at 877-833-6341, impaired hearing may call Washington relay service at 711, email ecyADAcoordinator@ecy.wa.gov, by August 2, 2024.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: In 2021, the Washington legislature passed the Climate Commitment Act (CCA), which established a cap-and-invest program to help Washington meet statutory greenhouse gas (GHG) emission limits.
To align with the requirements of the CCA, this rule making is proposing amendments to chapter 173-441 WAC, Reporting of emissions of greenhouse gases; and chapter 173-446 WAC, Climate Commitment Act program rule.
The purpose of these updates is to help determine which electricity importers from centralized electricity markets should be covered under the cap-and-invest program. This rule does not modify the eligibility criteria for inclusion under the cap-and-invest program. The rule establishes a framework that identifies the resources supplying the relevant electricity into centralized electricity markets based on the market mechanisms that operators of these markets put in place. The resulting compliance obligation is assigned in the CCA program rule (chapter 173-446 WAC), with the processes and procedures for identifying resources contained with the reporting of emissions of GHG rule (chapter 173-441 WAC). Supporting changes to the reporting rule will also ensure that appropriate data are available.
The proposal applies to existing and future centralized electricity markets including the Energy Imbalance Market, the Extended Day Ahead Market, and the Markets+ initiative underway by the Southwest Power Pool. The proposal also addresses other issues related to the reporting of GHG emissions for entities importing electricity to Washington.
Specifically, this rule making proposes to provide:
A framework for addressing imports of electricity from specified resources through centralized electricity markets.
A process for identifying the electricity importer for imported electricity from centralized electricity markets.
Methods for assigning GHG emissions to imports of electricity from centralized electricity markets.
Equitable treatment across and between bilateral and centralized electricity markets.
Nonsubstantive administrative and process-related changes for clarity and to harmonize the rule with recent statutory changes.
Reasons Supporting Proposal: This rule making is required by RCW 70A.65.080 (1)(c). The rule making is necessary to ensure that specified sources of electricity imported into the state from centralized electricity markets can be identified and counted as covered emissions in the cap-and-invest program. Currently, there is a lack of clear methodologies and procedures to assign the compliance obligations on the importing entity. Additionally, this rule making will allow centralized electricity market operators to put in place the necessary data infrastructure to track importing entities and report that information to the department of ecology (ecology).
Statutory Authority for Adoption: RCW 70A.65.080 (1)(c).
Statute Being Implemented: Greenhouse gas emissionsCap and invest program, program coverage, RCW 70A.65.080 (1)(c); Greenhouse Gas emissionsCap and invest program, adoption of rules, RCW 70A.65.220; Washington Clean Air Act, Classification of air contaminant sourcesRegistrationFeeRegistration program definedAdoption of rules requiring persons to report emissions of greenhouse gases, RCW 70A.15.2200(5).
Rule is not necessitated by federal law, federal or state court decision.
Name of Proponent: Department of ecology, governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting: Gopika Patwa, Lacey, 360-338-2419; Implementation and Enforcement: Lindsey Kennelly, Lacey, 360-584-7426.
A school district fiscal impact statement is not required under RCW 28A.305.135.
A cost-benefit analysis is required under RCW 34.05.328. A preliminary cost-benefit analysis may be obtained by contacting Gopika Patwa, Department of Ecology, Climate Pollution Reduction Program, P.O. Box 47600, Olympia, WA 98504-7600, phone 360-338-2419, speech disability may call TTY at 877-833-6341, impaired hearing may call Washington relay service at 711, email gopika.patwa@ecy.wa.gov.
This rule proposal, or portions of the proposal, is exempt from requirements of the Regulatory Fairness Act because the proposal:
Is exempt under RCW 19.85.025(3) as the rules only correct typographical errors, make address or name changes, or clarify language of a rule without changing its effect; and rule content is explicitly and specifically dictated by statute.
Scope of exemption for rule proposal:
Is partially exempt:
Explanation of partial exemptions: Ecology baselines are typically complex, consisting of multiple requirements fully or partially specified by existing rules, statutes, or federal laws. Where the proposed rule differs from this baseline of existing requirements, it is typically subject to (i.e., not exempt from) analysis required under the Regulatory Fairness Act (RFA; chapter 19.85 RCW) based on meeting criteria referenced in RCW 19.85.025(3) as defined by the Administrative Procedure Act in RCW 34.05.310. The small business economic impact statement below includes a summary of the baseline for this rule making, and whether or how the proposed rule differs from the baseline.
The proposed rule does impose more-than-minor costs on businesses.
Small Business Economic Impact Statement (SBEIS)
This SBEIS presents the:
Compliance requirements of the proposed rule.
Results of the analysis of relative compliance cost burden.
Consideration of lost sales or revenue.
Cost-mitigating action taken by ecology, if required.
Small business and local government consultation.
Industries likely impacted by the proposed rule.
Expected net impact on jobs statewide.
A small business is defined by RFA as having 50 or fewer employees. Estimated costs are determined as compared to the existing regulatory environment; the regulations in the absence of the rule. The SBEIS only considers costs to "businesses in an industry" in Washington state. This means that impacts, for this analysis, are not evaluated for government agencies.
The existing regulatory environment is called the "baseline" in this analysis. It includes only existing laws and rules at federal and state levels.
This information is excerpted from ecology's complete set of regulatory analyses for this rule making. For complete discussion of the likely costs, benefits, minimum compliance burden, and relative burden on small businesses, see the associated Preliminary Regulatory Analyses document (PRA; ecology publication no. 24-14-052, June 2024). We have retained the section numbering, table numbers, and chapter references from the PRA for easier cross-referencing.
COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS OF THE PROPOSED RULE, INCLUDING PROFESSIONAL SERVICES: The baseline for our analyses generally consists of existing laws and rules. This is what allows us to make a consistent comparison between the state of the world with and without the proposed rule amendments.
For this rule making, the baseline includes:
The CCA law, chapter 70A.65 RCW (Greenhouse gas emissionsCap and invest program).
Section 2200 of the Washington Clean Air Act, RCW 70A.15.2200 (Classification of air contaminant sourcesRegistrationFeeRegistration program definedAdoption of rules requiring persons to report emissions of greenhouse gases).
The existing GHG reporting rule, chapter 173-441 WAC (Reporting of emissions of greenhouse gases).
The existing CCA rule, chapter 173-446 WAC (Climate Commitment Act program rule).
E2SSB 6058, section 11, chapter 352, Laws of 2024 (Carbon market linkageCaliforniaQuébec carbon market).
Chapter 19.405 RCW (Washington Clean Energy Transformation Act; CETA).
California Air Resources Board (CARB) Regulation for the Mandatory Reporting of Greenhouse Gas Emissions (Title 17 California Code of Regulations (CCR), Div. 3, Ch. 1, Subchapter 10, Article 2).
CARB California Cap on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Market-Based Compliance Mechanisms (Title 17 CCR, Div. 3, Ch. 1, Subchapter 10, Article 5).
The Federal Power Act (16 U.S.C. Ch. 12).
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) regulation and approval of market tariffs.
2.3 Proposed rule amendments:
The proposed rule amendments would:
Amend reporting requirements in the GHG reporting rule (chapter 173-441 WAC):
oAmending the definition of "electric power entity" (EPE).
oChanging annual report submission requirements.
oAdding, removing, or changing definitions specific to EPE reporting requirements.
oExpanding data requirements and calculation methods from the EIM to all centralized electricity markets (CEMs).
oSpecifying how EPEs must report imported CEM electricity.
oSpecifying GHG emissions equations and applicability.
oExpanding documentation requirements.
oAmending requirements for registration of import or export sources.
oMaking changes without material impacts:
Clarify language and update terminology.
Remove obsolete requirements and language.
Amend the CCA rule (chapter 173-446 WAC):
oAdding definitions consistent with the GHG reporting rule.
oAmending covered emissions to reflect electricity imported from CEMs.
2.3.1 Amending the definition of EPE (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would expand the definition of EPE to include entities that transact electric power in Washington. This proposed amendment would extend reporting requirements to electricity importers and exporters, retail providers, and asset controlling suppliers that transact electric power in the state. This would result in reporting costs for entities that transact power in Washington but are not suppliers, and benefits of comprehensive GHG emissions data collection related to electricity transactions in the state if that data is not being collected under the baseline.
Definitions do not, in and of themselves, have impact beyond how the defined terms are used in the rule. Where definitions inform the coverage, scope, or type(s) of impacts under the proposed rule amendments, associated costs and benefits associated with those sections of the rule below include the relevant baseline and proposed definitions.
2.3.2 Changing annual report submission requirements (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would require each EPE to submit a single annual report by June 1 of each year.
This proposed amendment would reduce reporting costs for EPEs by not requiring a preliminary report by March 31 of each year. Ecology believes that a single annual report is sufficient to provide necessary GHG emissions reporting data to meet program needs. This would also be consistent with similar requirements for EPE reporting in other jurisdictions.
2.3.3 Adding, removing, or changing definitions specific to EPE reporting requirements (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would add, remove, or change various definitions specific to EPEs:
The proposed amendments would add definitions of:
o"Centralized electricity market" (CEM)
o"Deemed market importer"
o"Market operator"
o"Market participant"
o"Markets+"
o"Surplus electricity"
The proposed amendments would remove definitions of:
o"First jurisdictional deliverer" (FJD).
o"Generation providing entity" (GPE).
The proposed amendments would amend definitions of:
o"Direct delivery of electricity"
o"Electricity importer"
o"Electricity transaction"
o"Exported electricity"
o"Imported electricity"
o"Power contract"
o"Specified source"
Definitions do not, in and of themselves, have impact beyond how the defined terms are used in the rule. Where definitions inform the coverage, scope, or type(s) of impacts under the proposed rule amendments, associated costs and benefits associated with those sections of the rule below include the relevant baseline and proposed definitions.
2.3.4 Expanding data requirements and calculation methods from the EIM to all CEMs (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would replace the EIM with CEMs.
This proposed rule amendment would result in expansion of the types of CEMs the GHG reporting rule applies to. This would, in turn, contribute to costs associated with reporting emissions from electricity from these markets, as well as benefits of supporting centralized market functions, efficiencies, and use in Washington.
2.3.5 Specifying how EPEs must report imported CEM electricity (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would:
Require reporting entities to report electricity from CEMs:
oFor the EIM, for 2023-2026, retail providers receiving electricity facilitated through the EIM are the electricity importers. If the market operator identifies deemed market importers that offer energy attributed to Washington before 2026, those are the deemed market importers beginning in the following year.
oEach deemed market importer must separately report electricity assigned, designated, deemed, or attributed to Washington by an originating CEM.
oEach deemed market importer must annually calculate, report, and verify GHG emissions for the electricity they offered that was designated, deemed, or attributed to Washington.
Add a requirement that for electricity dispatched by a CEM, EPEs must report specified electricity sales attributed to market participants outside Washington or exported from the market to entities outside Washington, for unspecified and specified sources disaggregated by the recipient.
Add a requirement that retail providers must report net purchases from CEMs based on annual total purchases from each separate market.
In the baseline specification that reporting includes retail sales from the EIM, replace the EIM with each CEM.
In the application and maintenance requirements for asset-controlling suppliers, replace first jurisdictional deliverers with deemed market importers.
This proposed rule amendment would contribute to overall reporting costs, as well as costs associated with designation of importers and attribution of electricity. It would also contribute to benefits of:
Accurate identification of electricity imports from centralized markets and who is importing that power.
Participation and development of CEMs.
Data collection supporting the state's statutory goals related to GHG emissions tracking, planning, and reductions.
Based specifically on proposed rule language related to regulatory timing and transition, Washington energy imbalance market (EIM) importers would not be considered deemed market importers for reporting years 2023-2026. Since only deemed market importers would be required to report emissions associated with specified power CEM imports, this means these reporting costs and benefits would not occur until the 2027 reporting year. Similarly, these costs and benefits would not occur for imports from future CEMs such as extended day ahead market (EDAM) and Markets+ until they launch operations (currently expected in May 2026 and in 2027, respectively). We therefore assume reporting costs and benefits would not occur until reporting year 2027.
2.3.6 Expanding documentation requirements (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would add documentation requirements for any other reports provided by the market operator to the EPE documenting electricity attributed to Washington for which that EPE is the deemed market importer.
This proposed rule amendment would result in minor costs of retaining additional documents, as well as benefits of maintaining verifiable records underlying GHG emissions reporting.
2.3.7 Specifying GHG emissions equations and applicability (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would remove reference to WAC 173-444-040(4), and replace it with a numerically equivalent equation in which emissions are the product of the number of MWh, an unspecified emissions factor, and a transmission loss multiplier. The unspecified emissions factor would be 0.428 MT CO2e/MWh, and the transmission loss multiplier would be 1.02. The simplified equation would therefore be MWh multiplied by 0.437, equivalent to the baseline equation.
The proposed rule would also specify that the equation for specified electricity emissions also applies to specified electricity deemed, designated, assigned, or attributed by a CEM.
We do not expect this proposed rule amendment to result in costs or benefits, beyond clarity in which equation must be used facilitating compliance. This is because the newly proposed equation is numerically equivalent to the baseline equation in chapter 173-444 WAC.
2.3.8 Amending requirements for registration of import or export sources (chapter 173-441 WAC): Under the proposed rule amendments, deemed market importers would be included in the types of specified facilities or units required to register their anticipated specified sources, by a registration deadline of February 1st of each year.
The amendments would also add required information to be provided for registration, and specify that EPEs must be able to demonstrate that the market operator designated, assigned, deemed, or attributed the energy from those sources to Washington.
Finally, the amended rule would require EPEs to provide settlement records or other documentation requested by ecology by May 1st of each year.
These proposed rule amendments are likely to result in additional or expanded reporting costs. They would also contribute to benefits of:
oAccurate identification of electricity imports from centralized markets and who is importing that power.
oParticipation and development of CEMs.
oData collection supporting the state's statutory goals related to GHG emissions tracking, planning, and reductions.
2.3.9 Making changes without material impacts (chapter 173-441 WAC): The proposed rule amendments would clarify that point of receipt and point of delivery reports must use an e-tag code only where applicable. They would also delete the requirement to report when unspecified power came from the EIM.
These proposed amendments are not likely to result in costs or benefits as compared to the baseline, beyond clarity. Since e-tag codes are not applicable to all power transactions, the clarification that they must be used only when applicable would reduce confusion for covered entities. Under the collective proposed rule amendments, the requirement to report unspecified power from the EIM would become obsolete, and so its removal would not have material impact given the other proposed amendments would collect necessary information about specified imports from CEMs.
2.3.10 Adding definitions consistent with the GHG reporting rule (chapter 173-446 WAC): This proposed rule amendment would add definitions to the CCA rule, to make it consistent with proposed amendments to the GHG reporting rule. It would define the following by explicit reference to the reporting rule:
CEM.
Deemed market importer.
These proposed amendments would facilitate consistency between terms in the CCA rule and GHG reporting rule. Definitions do not, in and of themselves, have impact beyond how the defined terms are used in the rule. Where definitions inform the coverage, scope, or type(s) of impacts under the proposed rule amendments, costs and benefits associated with those sections of the rule below include the relevant baseline and proposed definitions.
2.3.11 Amending covered emissions to reflect electricity imported from CEMs (chapter 173-446 WAC): Compliance obligations: The baseline CCA rule defines emissions that are covered under the cap-and-invest program, beginning with reported emissions under the GHG reporting rule, and modifying those reported emissions to only those that are not exempt and are covered by the program. This includes allotment provisions to avoid double-counting emissions or counting emissions the rule does not apply to.
As part of those provisions, the CCA rule specifically states that it, "provides details on allotment for covered emissions that are potentially attributable to multiple parties and provides direction for allotment when such emissions may be reported by multiple facilities, suppliers, or first jurisdictional deliverers of electricity." It also notes that it only describes the process for determining which covered or opt-in entity is responsible for a given metric ton of covered emissions after exemptions are accounted for, and does not expand the definition of covered emissions itself.
The subsection relevant to this rule making defines the allotment of covered emissions for first jurisdictional deliverers of imported electricity:
Emissions from imported electricity are covered for the first jurisdictional deliverer that is importing electricity.
If the importer is a federal power marketing administration that is not voluntarily complying with the cap-and-invest program, the importer is the next purchaser-seller on the e-tag. Otherwise, the utility receiving the electricity is the importer.
If the importer is a federal power marketing administrations that is voluntarily participating in the cap-and-invest program, then the utilities buying from it may provide (by agreement) that the federal power marketing administration is assuming the compliance obligation for emissions from the imported electricity.
For the first compliance period (2023-2026), the importer for electricity from the EIM is the purchaser in Washington that receives it. If the first jurisdictional deliverer generates and has a compliance obligation for the electricity that is transferred through the EIM, and that electricity is then delivered into Washington, there is no second compliance obligation for it.
The baseline CCA rule also specifies that ecology may adjust covered emissions based on new reported information, new assigned emissions levels, or to compensate for changes in methodology.
Allocation of no-cost allowances: In section 230, the baseline CCA rule also defines how no-cost allowances are distributed to electric utilities under the cap-and-invest program. Allowances are a form of compliance instrument that can be used to satisfy compliance obligations for GHG emissions. Utilities subject to the Washington Clean Energy Transformation Act (CETA; chapter 19.405 RCW) are eligible to receive no-cost allowances to use for compliance, monetize by consigning them to the allowance market, or bank for future use. By allocating no-cost allowances to electric utilities, the CCA program helps them mitigate the impacts of the following on retail electricity prices and ratepayers:
Utility compliance obligations.
Increased wholesale electricity prices passed on to utilities by generators, marketers, or importers that have compliance obligations.
Allocations are based on the "cost burden effect." This effect is calculated by multiplying the electricity load from each type of source by the emissions factor for that source, and then adding up those emissions across all types of sources.
The CCA rule states that initial allocations will be adjusted as necessary to account for the difference between applicable reported emissions for prior years and the number of no-cost allowances allocated. Allocations may also be adjusted based on updated forecasts.
Proposed: The proposed rule amendments include the following changes to the baseline covered emissions discussed above, to allocate covered emissions (and resulting compliance obligations) for electricity imported from CEMs:
Importers are identified using the GHG reporting rule.
If the importer is a federal power marketing administration, it may voluntarily comply for either all sales into Washington or for attributions to Washington in a CEM for which it is a deemed market importer. In this case, the federal power marketing administration takes on the associated compliance obligation.
Requirements related to EIM power during the first compliance period are deleted.
The compliance obligation is only determined once for electricity from an electric generating facility in Washington that is sold into a CEM, and is then assigned, designated, deemed, or attributed back into Washington by that market.
These proposed amendments, in combination with proposed amendments to the GHG reporting rule, would establish compliance obligations for emissions associated with specified sources of electricity imported through CEMs. Ecology would assign these obligations to those entities identified as CEM importers, distributing compliance obligations in line with actual importing behavior of each EPE. This would result in compliance costs for those entities facing new compliance obligations associated with CEM imports.
Since new information also influences the cost burden effect that ecology uses to allocate no-cost allowances to electric utilities, we also expect these proposed amendments to result in additional allocation of no-cost allowances to match the aggregate increase in compliance obligations. Additional no-cost allowances would be a benefit to those receiving them, as they can choose to:
Use (retire) the allowances to meet compliance obligations.
Consign the allowances to the allowance market, to receive money for them based on the market's settlement price. This allows utilities to offset compliance costs incurred by importers further up their electricity supply chain.
Bank the allowances for future use, including potential retirement or consignment in future years.
Whereas we expect these costs and benefits to be the same in the aggregate over time, it is possible for there to be transitional periods during which they are not. This is because of current uncertainty about the process that will be used to update forecasts and adjust no-cost allowance allocations. Depending on how no-cost allowance adjustments are made and how they occur over time as new information becomes available, there may be periods during which there are differences between the numbers of new compliance obligations and new no-cost allowances. Each of these circumstances has its own net costs and benefits, depending on whether new demand for allowances (from compliance obligations) is less than or greater than new supply (from no-cost allowance allocations).
Based specifically on proposed rule language related to regulatory timing and transition, EIM importers would not be considered deemed market importers for reporting years 2023-2026. Since only deemed market importers would be required to report emissions associated with specified power CEM imports, this means the above costs and benefits associated with new compliance obligations and new no-cost allowance allocations would not occur until the 2027 reporting year. Similarly, these costs and benefits would not occur for imports from future CEMs such as EDAM and Markets+ until after they launch operations (currently expected in May 2026 and in 2027, respectively). We therefore assume these costs and benefits would not occur until reporting year 2027.
COSTS OF COMPLIANCE: EQUIPMENT, SUPPLIES, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES:Compliance with the proposed rule, compared to the baseline, is not likely to impose additional costs of equipment, supplies, or professional services.
COSTS OF COMPLIANCE: LABOR, ADMINISTRATIVE, AND OTHER: 3.2.1.2 Electricity importer compliance: To estimate the costs electricity importers would face under the proposed rule, as compared to the baseline, we considered the number of current and potential future importers. We then applied a range of estimated costs to different types of importers, based on whether they currently report EIM imports, currently report emissions (as they emit more than the reporting threshold of 10,000 MT CO2e), or don't currently report (emit below the threshold).
Total estimated annual costs ranged from $14,124 to $26,786, depending on the number of CEM energy importers reporting in a given year, and whether it is their first year of reporting imports from CEMs. When considering flows of costs over time, ecology calculates the present value of costs. A present value discounts future dollar values into current dollars, accounting for both inflation and the opportunity cost of having funds later instead of now. We estimated the 20-year present value cost of additional reporting effort as approximately $368,000 over 20 years. This is equivalent to an average annual present value cost of $17,527 over the next 20 years.
3.2.2 Costs: New obligations and allocations: To estimate costs associated with new compliance obligations established and assigned under the proposed rule amendments, we considered current imports, potential growth trajectories over time, and potential allowance price profiles.
Multiplying allowance prices by the range of estimated GHG emissions associated with electricity imports from CEMs, we estimated total annual costs (aggregated across all CEM importers) of between $7 million and $119 million. Total costs increase as a larger proportion of GHG emissions is assumed to come from CEM imports, and fall as the decrease in total GHG emissions outweighs CEM import growth.
When considering flows of costs over time, ecology calculates the present value of costs. A present value discounts future dollar values into current dollars, accounting for both inflation and the opportunity cost of having funds later instead of now. We estimated the 20-year present value cost of new compliance obligations as between $497 million and $1.2 billion over 20 years, with the first year of costs occurring in 2027.
COST-SAVINGS:4.2.2 Benefits: New obligations and allocations CEM import data and associated GHG emissions identified under the proposed rule amendments would impact compliance obligations under the CCA program (see Section 3.2.2) but would also impact the allocation of no-cost allowances to CETA-covered retail utilities. These allocations are intended to mitigate the costs of CCA compliance obligations, whether their costs are incurred directly (by utilities) or indirectly and passed on in wholesale prices (by a generator or marketer that sells to a utility).
New data gathered under the proposed rule amendments would influence the cost burden effect that ecology uses to allocate no-cost allowances. As a result, we expect the proposed amendments to result in additional allocation of no-cost allowances to match the aggregate increase in compliance obligations. Additional no-cost allowances would be a benefit to those receiving them, as they can choose to:
Use (retire) the allowances to meet compliance obligations.
Consign the allowances to the allowance market, to receive payment for them based on the market's settlement price. This allows utilities to offset compliance costs incurred by importers further up their electricity supply chain.
Bank the allowances for future use, including potential retirement or consignment in future years.
4.2.2.1 Value of additional no-cost allowances: Corresponding to our assumptions and estimated new compliance obligations in Section 3.2.2, we estimated annual increases in the allocation of no-cost allowances based on the cost burden effect equation (see Section 2.3.11 for detailed discussion of no-cost allowance allocation). Conceptually, these values are equal, and compliance obligations are offset by no-cost allowance allocations in the aggregate - this way, GHG emissions are accounted for in the CCA program while mitigating potential impacts to electricity ratepayers.
Multiplying allowance prices by the range of estimated new no-cost allowances allocated under the proposed rule, we estimated the total value of this benefit as between $7 million and $119 million in a given year over the next 20 years.
When considering flows of benefits over time, ecology calculates the present value of benefits. A present value discounts future dollar values into current dollars, accounting for both inflation and the opportunity cost of having funds later instead of now. We estimated the 20-year present value benefit of new no-cost allowance allocations as between $497 million and $1.2 billion over 20 years.
4.2.3 Benefits: Centralized electricity market function: It is not clear to what degree or how efficiently CEMs would be able to operate in Washington under the baseline. This is because of complex and uncertain factors such as baseline CCA law's requirements for covered emissions (including those from imported electricity, though ecology is tasked with adopting a rule that specifies the process for their inclusion), the lack of a specified mechanism to identify deemed market importers, and potential difficulties EPEs that participate in CEMs could have in demonstrating compliance with the law. This could create enforcement challenges and undermine the effectiveness of regulatory oversight and ecology's ability ensure the state meets statutory GHG emissions reduction goals.
Market operators may also:
Incur higher transaction costs under the baseline, due to a need for additional risk management measures. These costs could then be passed on to consumers through higher electricity prices, without mitigation such as no-cost allowance allocations to utilities.
Encounter difficulties ensuring fair competition or preventing electricity market manipulation, due to a lack of clear guidance. This could reduce CEM efficiency and raise costs.
Be reluctant to invest in infrastructure upgrades or new technologies, which could create gaps in market coverage. Where coverage is possible, it could still be inefficient, and carry risks of grid instability, congestion, or failure due to lacking infrastructure.
As a result, the proposed specifications of CEM importer identification and compliance obligation responsibility support EPEs and consumers receiving the benefits of CEMs operating in Washington. These include:
Cost-efficiency and cost-savings. For example, CEM participants were estimated to receive various benefits of cost savings:
oDuring the 4th quarter of 2023, EIM participants attained nearly $400 million in cost-savings.
o2022 modeling of benefits of the EDAM estimated that the West could save over $500 million per year in operating costs and similar annual savings from avoiding additional capacity investments. Separate 2023 modeling estimated cost savings for five specific participants of nearly $500 million annually.
Improved availability and integration of renewable resources, and feasibility of efficiently meeting statutory GHG reduction goals.
Improved grid reliability and matching of generating resources and demand.
Reduced renewable resource curtailment when supply exceeds local demand.
Improved allocation of emissions-generating resources that are more efficient.
COMPARISON OF COMPLIANCE COST FOR SMALL VERSUS LARGE BUSINESSES:We calculated the estimated per-business costs to comply with the proposed rule amendments, based on the costs estimated in Chapter 3 of the Preliminary Regulator Analyses. In this section, we estimate compliance costs per employee.
The average affected small business likely to be covered by the proposed rule amendments employs about 12 people. The largest 10 percent of affected businesses employ an average of 900 people. Many of the entities potentially impacted by the proposed rule are also governments, and are excluded from this analysis. Based on cost estimates in Chapter 3, we estimated compliance costs per employee. As discussed in Chapters 3 and 4, there is uncertainty about how costs and cost-savings will be distributed. In some cases, the businesses that incur costs will also receive cost-savings (e.g., a utility participating in a CEM), but in other cases they may be separate businesses. To capture various possibilities, we estimated the following average compliance costs per business in the first year the proposed rule amendments are likely to result in costs.
Table 1. Costs per business
Cost Estimate Type
Cost
Cost-Savings
Net Cost
Low estimate
$321,929
($320,955)
$974
High estimate
$926,079
($925,105)
$974
Then, based on costs per business and business size (small or large), we calculated costs per employee, as summarized in the tables below.
Table 2. Costs per employee, net costs
Business size
Cost per employee
Small
$42
Largest
$1
Table 3. Cost per employee, gross costs
Business size
Low cost per employee
High cost per employee
Small
$13,779
$39,638
Largest
$358
$1,029
Table 4. Cost per employee, cost-savings
Business size
Low benefit per employee
High benefit per employee
Small
($13,737)
($39,596)
Largest
($357)
($1,028)
We conclude that the proposed rule amendments are likely to have disproportionate impacts on small businesses, with regard to compliance costs, but may disproportionately benefit small businesses that receive a benefit of cost-savings. As we cannot confidently identify cases in which businesses will see only costs, only cost-savings, or both, ecology has conservatively included elements in the proposed rule amendments to mitigate this disproportion as far as is legal and feasible.
MITIGATION OF DISPROPORTIONATE IMPACT:The RFA (RCW 19.85.030(2)) states that:
"Based upon the extent of disproportionate impact on small business identified in the statement prepared under RCW 19.85.040, the agency shall, where legal and feasible in meeting the stated objectives of the statutes upon which the rule is based, reduce the costs imposed by the rule on small businesses. The agency must consider, without limitation, each of the following methods of reducing the impact of the proposed rule on small businesses:
(a) Reducing, modifying, or eliminating substantive regulatory requirements;
(b) Simplifying, reducing, or eliminating recordkeeping and reporting requirements;
(c) Reducing the frequency of inspections;
(d) Delaying compliance timetables;
(e) Reducing or modifying fine schedules for noncompliance; or
(f) Any other mitigation techniques including those suggested by small businesses or small business advocates."
We considered all of the above options, the goals and objectives of the authorizing statutes (see Chapter 6), and the scope of this rule making. We limited compliance cost-reduction methods to those that:
Are legal and feasible.
Meet the goals and objectives of the authorizing statute.
Are within the scope of this rule making.
Substantive regulatory requirements: The authorizing statutes do not allow ecology to reduce, modify, or eliminate substantive regulatory requirements for any covered entities under the reporting rule or CCA rule. The areas of the rule reflecting these statutory requirements are captured in the scope of the rules, and include program coverage, compliance timetables or support of consistency with potentially linked jurisdictions, and penalties. Ecology does not have discretion in these substantive regulatory requirements.
The baseline rule and proposed amendments also allow for a federal power marketing administration to take on compliance obligations in place of small entities that purchase imported electricity from them.
Recordkeeping and reporting requirements: Recordkeeping and reporting requirements in the baseline rule and in the proposed rule amendments rely largely on maintaining consistency with other programs, using known operations data and information, and using standardized common calculations. Ecology developed the proposed amendments to reporting requirements to provide information necessary for the data's use in the CCA program, and at the same time to be feasible for importers and CEM processes, based on interested party input.
Inspections: This rule making does not address inspections, and inspections are not required under the baseline rules.
Compliance timetables: Compliance deadlines are specified in the authorizing statutes. Ecology cannot use its discretion to change these deadlines. We note also that the proposed amendments would remove some of the phased-in compliance timelines that were included in the baseline rules when they were first adopted but are no longer necessary. As part of the 2022 rule making amending the reporting rule, ecology received information that EPEs (many of which are small) desired later deadlines for the new program. While the statute specifies the reporting deadline, the rule amendments adopted at that time allowed EPEs to submit a provisional report by that deadline, followed by a final report two months later as proposed by interested parties. After gaining experience with the reporting program, reporters are more likely to be able to meet the statutory deadline, and may save costs of developing and submitting separate preliminary reports.
Penalties and noncompliance: The statute specifies many elements related to noncompliance, and could not be changed.
Other reductions of burden: Ecology also considered multiple alternative requirements during development of the proposed rule. These were found to either impose more burden on covered parties, or to not meet the goals and objectives of the authorizing statutes. See Chapter 6 for discussion of these alternatives.
SMALL BUSINESS AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT CONSULTATION: We involved small businesses and local governments in its development of the proposed rule amendments, using the following methods. Recipients and attendees include members of the public, local governments, small businesses, and business associations.
Emails sent to meet requirements one day prior to meetings as a reminder.
Rule development meeting reminders via GovDelivery to all rule-making subscribers.
Informational session #1 - July 25, 2023.
Informational session #2 - August 2, 2023.
Draft language input review meeting #1 - August 12, 2023.
Draft language input review meeting #2 - August 16, 2023.
Listening session - August 18, 2023.
Individual meetings (by request) with:
oBPA - August 31, 2023.
oWestern Power Trading Forum - September 6, 2023.
oPublic Generating Pool - September 11, 2023.
Informational meeting with CAISO - September 12, 2023.
Informational meeting with Southwest Power Pool - September 28, 2023.
First informal comment period - July 25 to August 25, 2023.
Second informal comment period - October 5 to October 30, 2023.
Third informal comment period - November 8 to November 27, 2023.
Draft language input review meeting #3 - January 24, 2024.
Individual meetings (by request) with:
oCARB - March 25, 2024.
oCARB & CAISO - April 10, 2024.
CARB - May 3, 2024, Attendees variously included local and state government:
City of Issaquah.
City of Shoreline.
City of Tacoma.
Office of the attorney general.
Puget Sound Clean Air Agency.
Spokane Regional Clean Air Agency.
Washington department of commerce.
Washington department of health.
Washington public ports association.
Washington department of transportation.
Washington parks and recreation commission.
Washington state parks and recreation commission.
Washington utilities and transportation commission.
NAICS CODES OF INDUSTRIES IMPACTED BY THE PROPOSED RULE:The proposed rule amendments likely impact the following industries, with associated NAICS codes. NAICS definitions and industry hierarchies are discussed at https://www.census.gov/naics/.
221122 Electric power distribution
221118 Other electric power generation
CONSIDERATION OF LOST SALES OR REVENUE, IMPACT ON JOBS:Businesses that would incur costs could experience reduced sales or revenues if the proposed rule amendments significantly affect the prices of the goods they sell. The degree to which this could happen is strongly related to each business's production and pricing model (whether additional lump-sum costs would significantly affect marginal costs), as well as the specific attributes of the markets in which they sell goods, including the degree of influence each firm has on market prices, as well as the relative responsiveness of market demand to price changes. Finally, overall shifts in economic activity in the state, including competition within markets and attributes of the labor market simultaneously adjust in response to changes in compliance costs.
Similarly, employment within directly impacted industries, other industries in Washington, the labor market within and outside of the state, and in the state as a whole will also adjust in response to a change in costs.
We used the REMI E3+ model for Washington state to estimate the impact of the proposed rule amendments on directly affected markets, accounting for dynamic adjustments throughout the economy. The model accounts for variables including but not limited to:
Inter-industry impacts.
Price changes, including wages.
Interstate and international trade.
Population or labor market changes.
Dynamic adjustment of all economic variables over time.
Because the REMI model aggregates homogeneous sectors, all estimated costs and cost-savings under the proposed rule amendments would occur within the same industry grouping: Electric power generation, transmission, and distribution. This means the costs of new compliance obligations and the benefits of new no-cost allowance allocations net out to zero impact. This leaves estimated reporting costs as the net inputs into the model.
Estimated additional reporting costs under the proposed rule amendments are relatively small compared to the electricity sector and state economy as a whole. As a result, the model simulations did not identify any impacts to statewide employment or output. They also did not identify any impacts to employment or output at the industry grouping level.
While we did not identify any employment or output impacts of the proposed rule as a whole, there may be distributional impacts within the electricity sector in Washington. As discussed in Chapters 3 and 4, there is considerable uncertainty about how costs and cost-savings (benefits) would be distributed across electricity importers participating in CEMs and electric utilities. Traditionally, competitive businesses with higher net operating costs would face downward pressure on output and their use of labor.
Electricity importers may also face different incentives and limitations (e.g., obligations to meet demand, government or nonprofit structures, limited local competition or geographic monopolies, regulations governing electricity rates, or variable timing of available generating resources). Where ability to respond with changes to employment or output (positive or negative) are limited, impacts may instead manifest as changes to planned infrastructure investments or timing.
A copy of the statement may be obtained by contacting TTY at 877-833-6341, Washington relay service at 711. To request ADA accommodation for disabilities, or printed materials in a format for the visually impaired, call ecology at 360-407-7668 or visit https://ecology.wa.gov/accessibility.
June 27, 2024
Heather R. Bartlett
Deputy Director
OTS-5373.2
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 22-05-050, filed 2/9/22, effective 3/12/22)
WAC 173-441-020Definitions.
The definitions in this section apply throughout this chapter unless the context clearly requires otherwise.
(1) Definitions specific to this chapter:
(a) "40 C.F.R. Part 98" or "40 C.F.R. § 98" means the United States Environmental Protection Agency's Mandatory Greenhouse Gas Reporting regulation including any applicable subparts. All references are adopted by reference as if it was copied into this rule. References mentioned in this rule are adopted as they exist on February 9, 2022, or the adoption date in WAC 173-400-025(1), whichever is later.
(b) "Asset controlling supplier" or "ACS" means any entity that owns or operates interconnected electricity generating facilities or serves as an exclusive marketer for these facilities even though it does not own them, and has been designated by the department and received a department-published emissions factor for the wholesale electricity procured from its system. Electricity from an asset controlling supplier is considered a specified source of electricity.
(c) "Biomass" means nonfossilized and biodegradable organic material originating from plants, animals, or microorganisms, including products, by-products, residues and waste from agriculture, forestry, and related industries as well as the nonfossilized and biodegradable organic fractions of industrial and municipal wastes, including gases and liquids recovered from the decomposition of nonfossilized and biodegradable organic material.
(d) "Carbon dioxide equivalent" or "CO2e" means a metric measure used to compare the emissions from various greenhouse gases based upon their global warming potential.
(e) "Director" means the director of the department of ecology.
(f) "Ecology" means the Washington state department of ecology.
(g) "Electric power entity" includes any of the following that supply or transact electric power in Washington: (i) Electricity importers and exporters; (ii) retail providers, including multijurisdictional retail providers; and (iii) the asset controlling suppliers. See WAC 173-441-124 for more detail.
(h) "Facility" unless otherwise specified in WAC 173-441-122, 173-441-124, or any subpart of 40 C.F.R. Part 98 as adopted in WAC 173-441-120, means any physical property, plant, building, structure, source, or stationary equipment located on one or more contiguous or adjacent properties in actual physical contact or separated solely by a public roadway or other public right of way and under common ownership or common control, that emits or may emit any greenhouse gas. Operators of military installations may classify such installations as more than a single facility based on distinct and independent functional groupings within contiguous military properties.
(i) "Fuel products" means petroleum products, biomass-derived fuels, coal-based liquid fuels, natural gas, biogas, and liquid petroleum gas as established in 40 C.F.R. Part 98 Subparts LL through NN. Renewable or biogenic versions of fuel products listed in Tables MM-1 or NN-1 of 40 C.F.R. Part 98 are also considered fuel products. Assume complete combustion or oxidation of fuel products when calculating GHG emissions.
(j) "Fuel supplier" means any of the following suppliers of fuel products: (See WAC 173-441-122 for more detail.)
(i) A supplier of fossil fuel other than natural gas, including:
(A) A supplier of petroleum products;
(B) A supplier of liquid petroleum gas;
(C) A supplier of coal-based liquid fuels.
(ii) A supplier of biomass-derived fuels;
(iii) A supplier of natural gas, including:
(A) Operators of interstate and intrastate pipelines;
(B) Suppliers of liquefied or compressed natural gas;
(C) Natural gas liquid fractionators;
(D) Local distribution companies.
(k) "Greenhouse gas," "greenhouse gases," "GHG," and "GHGs" includes carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons, and sulfur hexafluoride. Beginning on January 1, 2012, "greenhouse gas" also includes any other gas or gases designated by ecology by rule in Table A-1 in WAC 173-441-040.
(l) "Operator" means any individual or organization who operates or supervises a facility, supplier, or electric power entity. The operator of an electric power entity may be the electric power entity itself.
(m) "Owner" means any individual or organization who has legal or equitable title to, has a leasehold interest in, or control of a facility, supplier, or electric power entity, except an individual or organization whose legal or equitable title to or leasehold interest in the facility, supplier, or electric power entity arises solely because the person is a limited partner in a partnership that has legal or equitable title to, has a leasehold interest in, or control of the facility, supplier, or electric power entity shall not be considered an "owner" of the facility, supplier, or electric power entity.
(n) "Person" includes the owner or operator of:
(i) A facility;
(ii) A supplier; or
(iii) An electric power entity.
(o) "Product data" means data related to a facility's production that is part of the annual GHG report.
(p) "Reporter" means any of the following subject to this chapter:
(i) A facility;
(ii) A supplier; or
(iii) An electric power entity.
(q) "Supplier" means any person who is a:
(i) Fuel supplier that produces, imports, or delivers, or any combination of producing, importing, or delivering, fuel products in Washington; and
(ii) Supplier of carbon dioxide that produces, imports, or delivers a quantity of carbon dioxide in Washington that, if released, would result in emissions in Washington.
(2) Definitions specific to the Climate Commitment Act program.
For those terms not listed in subsection (1) of this section, WAC 173-441-122(2), or 173-441-124(2), the definitions from chapter 70A.65 RCW, as described in chapters 173-446 and 173-446A WAC apply in this chapter in order of precedence.
(3) Definitions from 40 C.F.R. Part 98. For those terms not listed in subsection (1) or (2) of this section, WAC 173-441-122(2), or 173-441-124(2), the definitions found in 40 C.F.R. § 98.6 or a subpart as adopted in this chapter, apply in this chapter as modified in WAC 173-441-120(2).
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 22-05-050, filed 2/9/22, effective 3/12/22)
WAC 173-441-050General monitoring, reporting, recordkeeping and verification requirements.
Persons subject to the requirements of this chapter must submit GHG reports to ecology, as specified in this section. Every metric ton of CO2e emitted by a reporter required to report under this chapter and covered under any applicable source category listed in WAC 173-441-120, 173-441-122, or 173-441-124 must be included in the report.
(1) General. Follow the procedures for emission calculation, monitoring, quality assurance, missing data, recordkeeping, and reporting that are specified in each relevant section of this chapter.
(2) Schedule. The annual GHG report must be submitted as follows:
(a) Report submission due date:
(i) A person required to report or voluntarily reporting GHG emissions under WAC 173-441-030 must submit the report required under this chapter to ecology no later than March 31st of each calendar year for GHG emissions in the previous calendar year. Electric power entities reporting under WAC 173-441-124 must submit a report ((based on best available information by March 31st. Electric power entities reporting under WAC 173-441-124 must submit a final revised report)) by June 1st of each calendar year for GHG emissions in the previous calendar year ((consistent with deadlines for electric power entities in external GHG emissions trading programs)).
(ii) Unless otherwise stated, if the final day of any time period falls on a weekend or a state holiday, the time period shall be extended to the next business day.
(b) Reporting requirements begin:
(i) For an existing reporter that began operation before January 1, 2012, report emissions for calendar year 2012 and each subsequent calendar year.
(ii) For a new reporter that begins operation on or after January 1, 2012, and becomes subject to the rule in the year that it becomes operational, report emissions beginning with the first operating month and ending on December 31st of that year. Each subsequent annual report must cover emissions for the calendar year, beginning on January 1st and ending on December 31st.
(iii) For any reporter that becomes subject to this rule because of a physical or operational change that is made after January 1, 2012, report emissions for the first calendar year in which the change occurs.
(A) Reporters begin reporting with the first month of the change and ending on December 31st of that year. For a reporter that becomes subject to this rule solely because of an increase in hours of operation or level of production, the first month of the change is the month in which the increased hours of operation or level of production, if maintained for the remainder of the year, would cause the reporter to exceed the applicable threshold.
(B) Suppliers and electric power entities begin reporting January 1st and ending on December 31st the year of the change.
(C) For all reporters, each subsequent annual report must cover emissions for the calendar year, beginning on January 1st and ending on December 31st.
(3) Content of the annual report. Each annual GHG report must contain the following information. All reported information is subject to verification by ecology as described in subsection (5) of this section.
(a) Reporter name, reporter ID number, and physical street address of the reporter, including the city, state, and zip code. If the facility does not have a physical street address, then the facility must provide the latitude and longitude representing the geographic centroid or center point of facility operations in decimal degree format. This must be provided in a comma-delimited "latitude, longitude" coordinate pair reported in decimal degrees to at least four digits to the right of the decimal point.
(b) Year and months covered by the report.
(c) Date of submittal.
(d) For facilities, report annual emissions of each GHG (as defined in WAC 173-441-020) and each fluorinated heat transfer fluid, as follows:
(i) Annual emissions (including biogenic CO2) aggregated for all GHGs from all applicable source categories in WAC 173-441-120 and expressed in metric tons of CO2e calculated using Equation A-1 of WAC 173-441-030 (1)(b)(iii).
(ii) Annual emissions of biogenic CO2 aggregated for all applicable source categories in WAC 173-441-120, expressed in metric tons.
(iii) Annual emissions from each applicable source category in WAC 173-441-120, expressed in metric tons of each applicable GHG listed in (d)(iii)(A) through (F) of this subsection.
(A) Biogenic CO2.
(B) CO2 (including biogenic CO2).
(C) CH4.
(D) N2O.
(E) Each fluorinated GHG.
(F) For electronics manufacturing each fluorinated heat transfer fluid that is not also a fluorinated GHG as specified under WAC 173-441-040.
(iv) Emissions and other data for individual units, processes, activities, and operations as specified in the "data reporting requirements" section of each applicable source category referenced in WAC 173-441-120.
(v) Indicate (yes or no) whether reported emissions include emissions from a cogeneration unit located at the facility.
(vi) When applying (d)(i) of this subsection to fluorinated GHGs and fluorinated heat transfer fluids, calculate and report CO2e for only those fluorinated GHGs and fluorinated heat transfer fluids listed in WAC 173-441-040.
(vii) For reporting year 2014 and thereafter, you must enter into verification software specified by the director the data specified in the verification software records provision in each applicable recordkeeping section. For each data element entered into the verification software, if the software produces a warning message for the data value and you elect not to revise the data value, you may provide an explanation in the verification software of why the data value is not being revised. Whenever the use of verification software is required or voluntarily used, the file generated by the verification software must be submitted with the facility's annual GHG report.
(e) For suppliers and electric power entities, report annual emissions of each GHG (as defined in WAC 173-441-020) as follows:
(i) Annual emissions (including biogenic CO2) aggregated for all GHGs from all applicable source categories in WAC 173-441-122 and 173-441-124 and expressed in metric tons of CO2e calculated using Equation A-1 of WAC 173-441-030 (1)(b)(iii).
(ii) Annual emissions of biogenic CO2 aggregated for all applicable source categories in WAC 173-441-122 and 173-441-124, expressed in metric tons.
(iii) Annual emissions from each applicable source category in WAC 173-441-122 and 173-441-124, expressed in metric tons of each applicable GHG listed in subsection (3)(d)(iii)(A) through (E) of this section.
(A) Biogenic CO2.
(B) CO2 (including biogenic CO2).
(C) CH4.
(D) N2O.
(E) Each fluorinated GHG.
(iv) Emissions and other data for individual units, processes, activities, and operations as specified in the "data reporting requirements" section of each applicable source category referenced in WAC 173-441-122 and 173-441-124.
(f) A written explanation, as required under subsection (4) of this section, if you change emission or product data calculation methodologies during the reporting period or since the previous reporting period.
(g) Each data element for which a missing data procedure was used according to the procedures of an applicable subpart referenced in WAC 173-441-120, 173-441-122, or 173-441-124 and the total number of hours in the year that a missing data procedure was used for each data element.
(h) A signed and dated certification statement provided by the designated representative of the owner or operator, according to the requirements of WAC 173-441-060 (5)(a).
(i) NAICS code(s) that apply to the reporter. NAICS codes are subject to approval by ecology.
(i) Primary NAICS code. Report the NAICS code that most accurately describes the reporter's primary product/activity/service. The primary product/activity/service is the principal source of revenue for the reporter. A reporter that has two distinct products/activities/services providing comparable revenue may report a second primary NAICS code.
(ii) Additional NAICS code(s). Report all additional NAICS codes that describe all product(s)/activity(s)/service(s) at the reporter that are not related to the principal source of revenue.
(j) Legal name(s) and physical address(es) of the highest-level United States parent company(s) of the owners (or operators) of the reporter and the percentage of ownership interest for each listed parent company as of December 31st of the year for which data are being reported according to the following instructions.
(i) If the reporter is entirely owned by a single United States company that is not owned by another company, provide that company's legal name and physical address as the United States parent company and report 100 percent ownership.
(ii) If the reporter is entirely owned by a single United States company that is, itself, owned by another company (e.g., it is a division or subsidiary of a higher-level company), provide the legal name and physical address of the highest-level company in the ownership hierarchy as the United States parent company and report 100 percent ownership.
(iii) If the reporter is owned by more than one United States company (e.g., company A owns 40 percent, company B owns 35 percent, and company C owns 25 percent), provide the legal names and physical addresses of all the highest-level companies with an ownership interest as the United States parent companies and report the percent ownership of each company.
(iv) If the reporter is owned by a joint venture or a cooperative, the joint venture or cooperative is its own United States parent company. Provide the legal name and physical address of the joint venture or cooperative as the United States parent company, and report 100 percent ownership by the joint venture or cooperative.
(v) If the reporter is entirely owned by a foreign company, provide the legal name and physical address of the foreign company's highest-level company based in the United States as the United States parent company, and report 100 percent ownership.
(vi) If the reporter is partially owned by a foreign company and partially owned by one or more United States companies, provide the legal name and physical address of the foreign company's highest-level company based in the United States, along with the legal names and physical addresses of the other United States parent companies, and report the percent ownership of each of these companies.
(vii) If the reporter is a federally owned facility, report "U.S. Government" and do not report physical address or percent ownership.
(k) An indication of whether the facility includes one or more plant sites that have been assigned a "plant code" by either the Department of Energy's Energy Information Administration or by the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Clean Air Markets Division.
(l) Facilities must report electricity information including:
(i) Total annual electricity purchased in megawatt hours (MWh), itemized by the supplying utility or, if not obtained from a utility, from the supplying electric power entity for each different source of electricity. Total annual purchases must be reported separately for each supplying utility or electric power entity.
(ii) Self-generated electricity should be itemized separately if a facility includes an electricity generating unit as follows:
(A) Total facility nameplate generating capacity in megawatts (MW).
(B) Generated electricity in MWh provided or sold to each retail provider, electricity marketer, or other reportable end-user that is not a part of the facility, itemized by end-user.
(C) Generated electricity for on-site industrial applications not related to electricity generation in MWh.
(m) Report fuel use or supplied as follows:
(i) Facilities, report each fuel combusted separately by type, quantity, and units of measurement.
(ii) Fuel suppliers, report:
(A) Each fuel supplied separately by type, quantity, and units of measurement; and
(B) Separately report the quantity of each fuel type by purpose if the fuel supplier reports that the fuel is used for one of the purposes described in WAC 173-441-122 (5)(d)(xi).
(n) Facilities, report total annual facility product data, units of production, and specific product based on their first primary NAICS code.
(i) Facilities with a primary NAICS code listed in Table 050-1 of this section must report total annual facility product data as described in Table 050-1. Facilities may additionally report total annual facility product data as described in Table 050-1 for any reported secondary NAICS code. Use six digit NAICS codes when available, otherwise use the shorter NAICS codes listed below substituting the values in the full reported six digit NAICS code for "X".
Table 050-1: Total Annual Facility Product Data Requirements by Primary NAICS Code.
Primary NAICS Code and
Sector Definition
Activity
Production Metric
112112: Cattle Feedlots
Cattle feedlots
Cattle head days
211130: Natural Gas Extraction
Natural gas extraction
Million standard cubic feet of natural gas extracted
212399: All Other Nonmetallic Mineral Mining
Freshwater diatomite filter aids manufacturing
Metric tons of mineral product produced
2211XX: Electric Power Generation, Transmission and Distribution
Electric power generation, transmission and distribution
Net megawatt hours
221210: Natural Gas Distribution
Natural gas distribution
Million standard cubic feet of natural gas distributed
221330: Steam and Air-conditioning Supply
Steam supply
Kilograms steam produced
311213: Malt Manufacturing
Malt manufacturing
Metric tons of malt produced
3114XX: Fruit and Vegetable Preserving and Specialty Food Manufacturing
Fruit and vegetable preserving and specialty food manufacturing
Metric tons of food product produced
3115XX: Dairy Product Manufacturing
Dairy product manufacturing
Metric tons of dairy product produced
311611: Animal (except poultry) Slaughtering
Animal (except poultry) slaughtering
Metric tons of meat product processed
311613: Rendering and Meat By-product Processing
Rendering and meat by-product processing
Metric tons of meat by-product processed
311919: Other Snack Food Manufacturing
Other snack food manufacturing
Metric tons of snack food produced
311920: Coffee and Tea Manufacturing
Coffee and tea manufacturing
Metric tons of coffee and tea produced
321XXX: Wood Product Manufacturing
Wood product manufacturing
Air dried (10 percent moisture) metric tons of wood product produced
3221XX: Pulp, Paper, and Paperboard Mills
Pulp, paper, and paperboard mills
Air dried (10 percent moisture) metric tons of produced:
• Pulp product; or
• Paper; or
• Paperboard
322299: All Other Converted Paper Product Manufacturing
All other converted paper product manufacturing
Air dried (10 percent moisture) metric tons of converted paper product produced
324110: Petroleum Refineries
Petroleum refineries
Report all of the following:
• Facility level Subpart MM report as reported under 40 C.F.R. Part 98;
• Barrels of crude oil and intermediate products received from off-site that are processed at the facility; and
• Beginning with the first emissions year after a refinery's first turnaround after 2022, the refinery must also submit complexity weighted barrel (CWB) as described in CARB MRR section 95113(l)(3) as adopted by 7/1/2021. CWB supporting data must also be submitted to Ecology as described in CARB MRR section 95113(l)(3).
324121: Asphalt Paving Mixture and Block Manufacturing
Asphalt paving mixture and block manufacturing
Metric tons of asphalt paving mixture and block produced
3251XX: Basic Chemical Manufacturing
Basic chemical manufacturing
Metric tons of chemical produced
325311: Nitrogenous Fertilizer Manufacturing
Nitric acid production
Metric tons of nitric acid produced
32721X: Glass and Glass Product Manufacturing
Glass and glass product manufacturing
Metric tons of glass produced
327310: Cement Manufacturing
Cement manufacturing
Metric tons of adjusted clinker and mineral additives produced
327390: Other Concrete Product Manufacturing
Other concrete product manufacturing
Metric tons of concrete product produced
327410: Lime Manufacturing
Lime manufacturing
Metric tons of lime produced
327420: Gypsum Product Manufacturing
Gypsum product manufacturing
Metric tons of gypsum product produced
331110: Iron and Steel Mills and Ferroalloy Manufacturing
Steel production using an electric arc furnace (EAF)
Metric tons of steel produced
33131X: Alumina and Aluminum Production and Processing
Alumina and aluminum production and processing
Metric tons of aluminum produced
331410: Nonferrous Metal (except aluminum) Smelting and Refining
Granular polysilicon production
Metric tons of granular polysilicon produced
332111: Iron and Steel Forging
Iron forging
Metric tons of iron produced
334413: Semiconductor and Related Device Manufacturing
Semiconductor and related device manufacturing
Square meters of mask layer produced
335991: Carbon and Graphite Product Manufacturing
Carbon and graphite product manufacturing
Metric tons of carbon and graphite product produced
3364XX: Aerospace Product and Parts Manufacturing
Aerospace product and parts manufacturing
• Metric tons of aircraft product and parts produced; or
• Square meters of external surface area of aircraft
486210: Pipeline Transportation of Natural Gas
Pipeline transportation of natural gas
Million standard cubic feet of natural gas transported
488119: Other Airport Operations
Other airport operations
Passenger kilometers serviced
562111: Solid Waste Collection
Solid waste collection
Metric tons of total solid waste collected
562212: Solid Waste Landfill
Solid waste landfill
Metric tons of total waste entered into landfill
562213: Solid Waste Combustors and Incinerators
Solid waste combustors and incinerators
Net megawatt hours
611310: Colleges, Universities, and Professional Schools
Colleges, universities, and professional schools
Students serviced
928110: National Security
Military bases
Troops stationed
(ii) Facilities without a primary NAICS code listed in Table 050-1 of this section must contact ecology no later than 45 calendar days prior to the emissions report deadline established in subsection (2) of this section and report total annual facility product data as instructed by the department. If ecology does not identify product data for a facility, a facility must use the energy-based calculation method described in Equation 050-1 of this section. Report product data and inputs to the equation. Product data calculated using the energy-based method shall use the following equation:
Product data
=
Sconsumed + Fconsumed - esold
(Eq. 050-1)
Where:
 
"SConsumed" is the annual amount of steam consumed, measured in MMBtu, at the facility for any process, including heating or cooling applications. This value shall exclude any steam used to produce electricity. This value shall exclude steam produced from an on-site cogeneration unit;
 
"FConsumed" is the annual amount of energy produced due to fuel combustion at the facility, measured in MMBtu. This value shall be calculated based on measured higher heating values or the default higher heating value of the applicable fuel in Table C-1 of 40 C.F.R. Part 98. This value shall include any energy from fuel combusted in an on-site electricity generation or cogeneration unit. This value shall exclude energy to generate the steam accounted for in the "SConsumed" term;
 
"eSold" is the annual amount of electricity sold or provided for off-site use, measured in MWh and converted to MMBtu using the reporting year U.S. Energy Information Administration conversion factor;
(iii) Facilities with a change in operation that alters either their primary NAICS code, units of production, or product data measurement method must contact ecology no later than 45 calendar days prior to the emissions report deadline established in subsection (2) of this section and report total annual facility product data as instructed by the department. If ecology does not identify product data for a facility, a facility must use the energy-based calculation method described in Equation 050-1 of this section. Report product data and inputs to the equation.
(iv) For a primary NAICS code in Table 050-1 that has multiple production metrics, a facility that wishes to change their reported production metric must contact ecology no later than 45 calendar days prior to the emissions report deadline established in subsection (2) of this section and report total annual facility production data as instructed by the department.
(o) Reporters that cease operation, other than routine maintenance or seasonal shutdowns, for more than 90 calendar days must provide the following information:
(i) The anticipated type of cessation: Closure or curtailment;
(ii) Date cessation began;
(iii) Date cessation ended (if applicable); and
(iv) Reason for cessation and/or resumption of operation.
(p) If there is an increase or decrease of more than five percent in emissions of greenhouse gases in relation to the previous year, the reporter must provide a brief narrative description of what caused the increase or decrease in emissions.
(4) Emission calculations. In preparing the GHG report, you must use the calculation methodologies specified in the relevant sections of this chapter. For each source category, you must use the same calculation methodology as previous reports. This includes throughout a reporting period, and between reporting years. An owner or operator intending to change methodologies must provide a written explanation at least 60 calendar days before the report submission due date in subsection (2)(a) of this section of why a change in methodology was required. Ecology has 45 calendar days to approve or reject the change in method. The reporter must continue to use existing methods until the change is approved by ecology.
(5) Verification. To verify the completeness and accuracy of reported GHG emissions, ecology may review the certification statements described in subsection (3)(h) of this section and any other credible evidence, in conjunction with a comprehensive review of the GHG reports and periodic audits of selected reporting facilities. Nothing in this section prohibits ecology from using additional information to verify the completeness and accuracy of the reports. Reporters must cooperate with ecology's efforts to verify GHG reports.
(6) Recordkeeping. A person that is required to report GHGs under this chapter must keep records as specified in this subsection. Retain all required records for at least 10 years from the date of submission of the annual GHG report for the reporting year in which the record was generated. Upon request by ecology, the person must submit the records required under this section within 15 business days of receipt of the notification, unless a different schedule is agreed to by ecology. Records may be retained off-site if the records are readily available for expeditious inspection and review. For records that are electronically generated or maintained, the equipment or software necessary to read the records must be made available, or, if requested by ecology, electronic records must be converted to paper documents. You must retain the following records, in addition to those records prescribed in each applicable section of this chapter:
(a) A list of all units, operations, processes, and activities for which GHG emissions were calculated.
(b) The data used to calculate the GHG emissions for each unit, operation, process, and activity, categorized by fuel or material type. These data include, but are not limited to, the following information:
(i) The GHG emissions calculations and methods used.
(ii) Analytical results for the development of site-specific emissions factors.
(iii) The results of all required analyses for high heat value, carbon content, and other required fuel or feedstock parameters.
(iv) Any facility operating data or process information used for the GHG emission calculations.
(c) The annual GHG reports.
(d) Missing data computations. For each missing data event, also retain a record of the cause of the event and the corrective actions taken to restore malfunctioning monitoring equipment.
(e) Owners or operators required to report under WAC 173-441-030 must keep a written GHG monitoring plan (monitoring plan, plan).
(i) At a minimum, the GHG monitoring plan must include the following elements:
(A) Identification of positions of responsibility (i.e., job titles) for collection of the emissions data.
(B) Explanation of the processes and methods used to collect the necessary data for the GHG calculations.
(C) Description of the procedures and methods that are used for quality assurance, maintenance, and repair of all continuous monitoring systems, flow meters, and other instrumentation used to provide data for the GHGs reported under this chapter.
(D) Facilities must reference to one or more simplified block diagrams that provide a clear visual representation of the relative locations and positions of measurement devices and sampling locations, as applicable, required for calculating covered emissions and covered product data (e.g., temperature, total pressure, HHV, fuel consumption). The diagram(s) must include fuel sources, combustion units, and production processes, as applicable.
(ii) The GHG monitoring plan may rely on references to existing corporate documents (e.g., standard operating procedures, quality assurance programs under appendix F to 40 C.F.R. Part 60 or appendix B to 40 C.F.R. Part 75, and other documents) provided that the elements required by (e)(i) of this subsection are easily recognizable.
(iii) The owner or operator must revise the GHG monitoring plan as needed to reflect changes in production processes, monitoring instrumentation, and quality assurance procedures; or to improve procedures for the maintenance and repair of monitoring systems to reduce the frequency of monitoring equipment downtime.
(iv) Upon request by ecology, the owner or operator must make all information that is collected in conformance with the GHG monitoring plan available for review during an audit within 15 business days of receipt of the notification, unless a different schedule is agreed to by ecology. Electronic storage of the information in the plan is permissible, provided that the information can be made available in hard copy upon request during an audit.
(f) The results of all required certification and quality assurance tests of continuous monitoring systems, fuel flow meters, and other instrumentation used to provide data for the GHGs reported under this chapter.
(g) Maintenance records for all continuous monitoring systems, flow meters, and other instrumentation used to provide data for the GHGs reported under this chapter.
(h) Suppliers and electric power entities must retain any other data specified in WAC 173-441-122 and 173-441-124.
(7) Annual GHG report revisions.
(a) A person must submit a revised annual GHG report within 45 calendar days of discovering that an annual GHG report that the person previously submitted contains one or more substantive errors. The revised report must correct all substantive errors.
(b) Ecology may notify the person in writing that an annual GHG report previously submitted by the person contains one or more substantive errors. Such notification will identify each such substantive error. The person must, within 45 calendar days of receipt of the notification, either resubmit the report that, for each identified substantive error, corrects the identified substantive error (in accordance with the applicable requirements of this chapter) or provide information demonstrating that the previously submitted report does not contain the identified substantive error or that the identified error is not a substantive error.
(c) A substantive error is an error that impacts the quantity of GHG emissions reported, product data reported, or otherwise prevents the reported data from being validated or verified.
(d) Notwithstanding (a) and (b) of this subsection, upon request by a person, ecology may provide reasonable extensions of the 45-day period for submission of the revised report or information under (a) and (b) of this subsection. If ecology receives a request for extension of the 45-day period, by email, at least five business days prior to the expiration of the 45 calendar day period, and ecology does not respond to the request by the end of such period, the extension request is deemed to be automatically granted for 15 more calendar days. During the automatic 15-day extension, ecology will determine what extension, if any, beyond the automatic extension is reasonable and will provide any such additional extension.
(e) The owner or operator must retain documentation for 10 years to support any revision made to an annual GHG report.
(8) Calibration and accuracy requirements. The owner or operator of a facility that is subject to the requirements of this chapter must meet the applicable flow meter calibration and accuracy requirements of this subsection. The accuracy specifications in this subsection do not apply where either the use of company records (as defined in WAC 173-441-020(3)) or the use of "best available information" is specified in an applicable subsection of this chapter to quantify fuel usage and/or other parameters. Further, the provisions of this subsection do not apply to stationary fuel combustion units that use the methodologies in 40 C.F.R. Part 75 to calculate CO2 mass emissions. Measurement devices used for financial transactions between two or more independent parties meet the calibration and accuracy requirements of this chapter.
(a) Except as otherwise provided in (d) through (f) of this subsection, flow meters that measure liquid and gaseous fuel feed rates, process stream flow rates, product data measuring devices, or feedstock flow rates and provide data for the GHG emissions calculations or product data, must be calibrated prior to January 1, 2012, for emissions data or January 1, 2023, for product data, using the procedures specified in this subsection when such calibration is specified in a relevant section of this chapter. Each of these flow meters must meet the applicable accuracy specification in (b) or (c) of this subsection. All other measurement devices (e.g., weighing devices) that are required by a relevant subsection of this chapter, and that are used to provide data for the GHG emissions calculations or product data, must also be calibrated prior to January 1, 2012, for emissions data or January 1, 2023, for product data; however, the accuracy specifications in (b) and (c) of this subsection do not apply to these devices. Rather, each of these measurement devices must be calibrated to meet the accuracy requirement specified for the device in the applicable subsection of this chapter, or, in the absence of such accuracy requirement, the device must be calibrated to an accuracy within the appropriate error range for the specific measurement technology, based on an applicable operating standard including, but not limited to, manufacturer's specifications and industry standards. The procedures and methods used to quality-assure the data from each measurement device must be documented in the written monitoring plan, pursuant to subsection (6)(e)(i)(C) of this section.
(i) All flow meters and other measurement devices that are subject to the provisions of this subsection must be calibrated according to one of the following: You may use the manufacturer's recommended procedures; an appropriate industry consensus standard method; or a method specified in a relevant section of this chapter. The calibration method(s) used must be documented in the monitoring plan required under subsection (6)(e) of this section.
(ii) For reporters that become subject to this chapter after January 1, 2012, all flow meters and other measurement devices (if any) that are required by the relevant subsection(s) of this chapter to provide data for the GHG emissions calculations or product data must be installed no later than the date on which data collection is required to begin using the measurement device, and the initial calibration(s) required by this subsection (if any) must be performed no later than that date.
(iii) Except as otherwise provided in (d) through (f) of this subsection, subsequent recalibrations of the flow meters and other measurement devices subject to the requirements of this subsection must be performed at one of the following frequencies:
(A) You may use the frequency specified in each applicable subsection of this chapter.
(B) You may use the frequency recommended by the manufacturer or by an industry consensus standard practice, if no recalibration frequency is specified in an applicable subsection.
(b) Perform all flow meter calibration at measurement points that are representative of the normal operating range of the meter. Except for the orifice, nozzle, and venturi flow meters described in (c) of this subsection, calculate the calibration error at each measurement point using Equation A-2 of this subsection. The terms "R" and "A" in Equation A-2 must be expressed in consistent units of measure (e.g., gallons/minute, ft3/min). The calibration error at each measurement point must not exceed 5.0 percent of the reference value.
Where:
 
CE
=
Calibration error
(%)
 
R
=
Reference value
 
 
A
=
Flow meter response to the reference value
(c) For orifice, nozzle, and venturi flow meters, the initial quality assurance consists of in situ calibration of the differential pressure (delta-P), total pressure, and temperature transmitters.
(i) Calibrate each transmitter at a zero point and at least one upscale point. Fixed reference points, such as the freezing point of water, may be used for temperature transmitter calibrations. Calculate the calibration error of each transmitter at each measurement point, using Equation A-3 of this subsection. The terms "R," "A," and "FS" in Equation A-3 of this subsection must be in consistent units of measure (e.g., milliamperes, inches of water, psi, degrees). For each transmitter, the CE value at each measurement point must not exceed 2.0 percent of full-scale. Alternatively, the results are acceptable if the sum of the calculated CE values for the three transmitters at each calibration level (i.e., at the zero level and at each upscale level) does not exceed 6.0 percent.
Where:
 
CE
=
Calibration error
(%)
 
R
=
Reference value
 
 
A
=
Transmitter response to the reference value
 
FS
=
Full-scale value of the transmitter
(ii) In cases where there are only two transmitters (i.e., differential pressure and either temperature or total pressure) in the immediate vicinity of the flow meter's primary element (e.g., the orifice plate), or when there is only a differential pressure transmitter in close proximity to the primary element, calibration of these existing transmitters to a CE of 2.0 percent or less at each measurement point is still required, in accordance with (c)(i) of this subsection; alternatively, when two transmitters are calibrated, the results are acceptable if the sum of the CE values for the two transmitters at each calibration level does not exceed 4.0 percent. However, note that installation and calibration of an additional transmitter (or transmitters) at the flow monitor location to measure temperature or total pressure or both is not required in these cases. Instead, you may use assumed values for temperature and/or total pressure, based on measurements of these parameters at a remote location (or locations), provided that the following conditions are met:
(A) You must demonstrate that measurements at the remote location(s) can, when appropriate correction factors are applied, reliably and accurately represent the actual temperature or total pressure at the flow meter under all expected ambient conditions.
(B) You must make all temperature and/or total pressure measurements in the demonstration described in (c)(ii)(A) of this subsection with calibrated gauges, sensors, transmitters, or other appropriate measurement devices. At a minimum, calibrate each of these devices to an accuracy within the appropriate error range for the specific measurement technology, according to one of the following: You may calibrate using a manufacturer's specification or an industry consensus standard.
(C) You must document the methods used for the demonstration described in (c)(ii)(A) of this subsection in the written GHG monitoring plan under subsection (6)(e)(i)(C) of this section. You must also include the data from the demonstration, the mathematical correlation(s) between the remote readings and actual flow meter conditions derived from the data, and any supporting engineering calculations in the GHG monitoring plan. You must maintain all of this information in a format suitable for auditing and inspection.
(D) You must use the mathematical correlation(s) derived from the demonstration described in (c)(ii)(A) of this subsection to convert the remote temperature or the total pressure readings, or both, to the actual temperature or total pressure at the flow meter, or both, on a daily basis. You must then use the actual temperature and total pressure values to correct the measured flow rates to standard conditions.
(E) You must periodically check the correlation(s) between the remote and actual readings (at least once a year), and make any necessary adjustments to the mathematical relationship(s).
(d) Fuel billing meters are exempted from the calibration requirements of this section and from the GHG monitoring plan and recordkeeping provisions of subsection (6)(e)(i)(C) and (g) of this section, provided that the fuel supplier and any unit combusting the fuel do not have any common owners and are not owned by subsidiaries or affiliates of the same company. Meters used exclusively to measure the flow rates of fuels that are used for unit startup are also exempted from the calibration requirements of this section.
(e) For a flow meter that has been previously calibrated in accordance with (a) of this subsection, an additional calibration is not required by the date specified in (a) of this subsection if, as of that date, the previous calibration is still active (i.e., the device is not yet due for recalibration because the time interval between successive calibrations has not elapsed). In this case, the deadline for the successive calibrations of the flow meter must be set according to one of the following: You may use either the manufacturer's recommended calibration schedule or you may use the industry consensus calibration schedule.
(f) For units and processes that operate continuously with infrequent outages, it may not be possible to meet the deadline established in (a) of this subsection for the initial calibration of a flow meter or other measurement device without disrupting normal process operation. In such cases, the owner or operator may postpone the initial calibration until the next scheduled maintenance outage. The best available information from company records may be used in the interim. The subsequent required recalibrations of the flow meters may be similarly postponed. Such postponements must be documented in the monitoring plan that is required under subsection (6)(e) of this section.
(g) If the results of an initial calibration or a recalibration fail to meet the required accuracy specification, data from the flow meter must be considered invalid, beginning with the hour of the failed calibration and continuing until a successful calibration is completed. You must follow the missing data provisions provided in the relevant missing data sections during the period of data invalidation.
(h) Missing data substitution procedures. Persons must comply with 40 C.F.R. Part 98 when substituting for missing data. Substitute missing data used for product data or other data required under this section that is not included in your 40 C.F.R. Part 98 report by using the best available estimate of the parameter, based on all available data.
(9) Measurement device installation. 40 C.F.R. § 98.3(j) and 40 C.F.R. § 98.3(d) are adopted by reference as modified in WAC 173-441-120(2).
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 22-05-050, filed 2/9/22, effective 3/12/22)
WAC 173-441-124Calculation methods for electric power entities.
This section establishes the scope of reportable energy and GHG emissions under this chapter and GHG emissions calculation methods for electric power entities. Owners and operators of electric power entities must follow the requirements of this section to determine if they are required to report under WAC 173-441-030(3). Owners and operators of electric power entities that are subject to this chapter must follow the requirements of this section when calculating emissions. If a conflict exists between a provision in WAC 173-441-010 through 173-441-110 and 173-441-140 through 173-441-170 and any applicable provision of this section, the requirements of those sections must take precedence.
(1) General requirements. An owner or operator of an electric power entity subject to the requirements of this chapter must report GHG emissions, including GHG emissions from biomass, from all applicable categories listed in (a) of this subsection using the methods and procedures in this section.
(a) Electric power entity categories:
(i) Electricity importers and exporters, as defined in this section;
(ii) Retail providers, including multijurisdictional retail providers, as defined in this section;
(iii) Asset controlling suppliers;
(iv) Electric generating facilities in Washington state must report using the methods specified in WAC 173-441-120.
(b) The calculation methods for voluntary reporting in WAC 173-441-120(3) apply, except calculation methods in WAC 173-441-120 (3)(b) take precedence over the methods from WAC 173-441-120 (3)(a).
(c) Alternative calculation methods approved by petition. An owner or operator may petition ecology to use calculation methods other than those specified in this section to calculate its electric power entities GHG emissions. Such alternative calculation methods must be approved by ecology prior to reporting and must meet the requirements of WAC 173-441-140.
(2) Definitions specific to electric power entities. The definitions in this subsection apply throughout this section unless the context clearly requires otherwise.
(a) "Centralized electricity market" means an electricity market organized and operated by a market operator and approved by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to provide wholesale electricity to market participants through a system of bidding and generation resource offers that are used to determine the dispatch of electricity from market participants. Examples of existing and proposed centralized electricity markets include the Energy Imbalance Market and Extended Day Ahead Market operated by the California Independent System Operator, and the Markets+ market operated by the Southwest Power Pool.
(b) "Deemed market importer" means a market participant that successfully offers electricity from a resource into a centralized electricity market and is assigned, designated, deemed, or attributed to be serving Washington electric load by the methodologies, processes, or decision algorithms that are put in place by the market operator of that centralized electricity market and approved by the department of ecology. For the Energy Imbalance Market, the deemed market importer is the participating resource scheduling coordinator.
(c) "Direct delivery of electricity" means electricity that meets any of the following criteria: The facility has a first point of interconnection at a Washington scheduling point or within a ((power system))balancing authority area located entirely in Washington; The electricity is scheduled for delivery from the specified source to a Washington scheduling point or a ((power system))balancing authority area located entirely in Washington via a continuous physical transmission path from interconnection of the facility in the balancing authority in which the facility is located to the Washington scheduling point or ((power system))balancing authority area located entirely in Washington; or there is an agreement to dynamically transfer electricity from the facility to a Washington scheduling point or ((power system))balancing authority area located entirely in Washington; or the facility has a first point of interconnection within a centralized electricity market and electricity from that facility is attributed to Washington by the centralized electricity market.
(d) "Electricity exporter" means electric power entities that deliver exported electricity. The entity that exports electricity is identified on the e-tag as the purchasing-selling entity (PSE) on the last segment of the tag's physical path, with the point of receipt located inside Washington state and the point of delivery located outside Washington state. For electricity that is exported from a designated scheduling point in the balancing authority area of a federal power marketing administration, the exporter is the purchasing-selling entity at the first point of the physical path of the e-tag that is not the generation source.
(((b)))(e) "Electricity generating facility" means a facility that generates electricity and includes one or more generating units at the same location.
(((c)))(f) "Electricity importer" means:
(i) For electricity that is scheduled with an e-tag to a final point of delivery into a balancing authority area located entirely within Washington state, the electricity importer is identified on the e-tag as the purchasing-selling entity on the last segment of the tag's physical path with the point of receipt located outside Washington state and the point of delivery located inside Washington state;
(ii) For facilities physically located outside Washington state with the first point of interconnection to a balancing authority area located entirely within Washington state when the electricity is not scheduled on an e-tag, the electricity importer is the facility operator or owner;
(iii) For imported electricity ((imported))assigned, designated, deemed, or attributed to Washington through a centralized electricity market, the electricity importer is the ((retail provider, marketer, or asset controlling supplier that conducts an electricity transaction through the EIM that results in EIM power being delivered to final point of delivery in Washington state))deemed market importer;
(iv) For electricity from facilities allocated to serve retail electricity customers of a multijurisdictional electric company, the electricity importer is the multijurisdictional electric company;
(v) If the importer identified under (c)(i) of this subsection is a federal power marketing administration over which Washington state does not have jurisdiction, and the federal power marketing administration has not voluntarily elected to comply with this chapter, then the electricity importer is the next purchasing-selling entity in the physical path on the e-tag, or if no additional purchasing-selling entity over which Washington state has jurisdiction, then the electricity importer is the electric utility that operates the Washington state transmission or distribution system, or the generation balancing authority;
(vi) For electricity that is imported into the state by a federal power marketing administration and sold to a public body or cooperative customer or direct service industrial customer located in Washington state pursuant to section 5 (b) or (d) of the Pacific Northwest Electric Power Planning and Conservation Act of 1980, P.L. 96-501, the electricity importer is the federal marketing administration;
(vii) If the importer identified under (c)(vi) of this subsection has not voluntarily elected to comply with this chapter, then the electricity importer is the public body or cooperative customer or direct service industrial customer;
(viii) For electricity that is imported into the state to a designated scheduling point inside the balancing authority area of a federal power marketing administration, the importer is the purchasing-selling entity on the e-tag at the last point on the physical path that is not the sink;
(ix) If the importer identified under (c)(vii) of this subsection is a federal power marketing administration that has not elected to voluntarily comply with this chapter, then the importer is the retail provider with which the scheduling point is associated; or
(x) For electricity from facilities allocated to a consumer-owned utility inside Washington state from a multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility, the electricity importer is the consumer-owned utility inside Washington state.
(((d) "First jurisdictional deliverer" means the owner or operator of an electric generating facility in Washington state or an electricity importer.
(e) "Generation providing entity" or "GPE" means a facility or generating unit operator, full or partial owner, party to a contract for a fixed percentage of net generation from the facility or generating unit, party to a tolling agreement with the owner, or exclusive marketer for the facility or generating unit recognized by ecology.
(f) "Retail provider" means any of the following:
(i) An electric utility as defined in RCW 19.405.020(14);
(ii) Multijurisdictional retail providers;
(iii) Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utilities.
(g) "Imported electricity" means electricity generated outside Washington state with a final point of delivery within the state.
(i) "Imported electricity" includes electricity from an organized market, such as the energy imbalance market.
(ii) "Imported electricity" includes imports from linked jurisdictions, but such imports shall be construed as having no emissions.
(iii) Electricity from a system that is marketed by a federal power marketing administration shall be construed as "imported electricity," not electricity generated in Washington state.
(iv) "Imported electricity" does not include electricity imports of unspecified electricity that are netted by exports of unspecified electricity to any jurisdiction not covered by a linked program by the same entity within the same hour.
(v) For a multijurisdictional electric company, "imported electricity" means electricity, other than from in-state facilities, that contributes to a common system power pool. Where a multijurisdictional electric company has a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission, the allocation of specific facilities to Washington state's retail load will be in accordance with that methodology.
(vi) For a multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility, "imported electricity" includes electricity from facilities that contribute to a common system power pool that are allocated to a consumer-owned utility inside Washington state pursuant to a methodology approved by the governing board of the consumer-owned utility.
(h) "Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility" means an electric generation and transmission cooperative owned by a collection of consumer-owned utilities in multiple states or a consumer-owned utility that provides electricity to member owners in Washington state and in one or more other states in a contiguous service territory or from a common power system.
(i) "Multijurisdictional electric company" means an investor-owned utility that provides electricity to customers in Washington state and in one or more other states in a contiguous service territory or from a common power system.
(j) "Multijurisdictional retail provider" means a:
(i) Multijurisdictional electric company; or
(ii) Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility.
(k)))(g) "Electricity transaction" means the purchase, sale, import, export, or exchange of electric power. An electricity transaction also includes the successful offer of energy from a resource located in Washington to a centralized electricity market or from a resource located outside Washington that is attributed to Washington by the centralized electricity market, and the purchase of energy by a Washington utility from a centralized electricity market.
(h) "Energy Imbalance Market" or "EIM" means the Western Energy Imbalance Market operated by the California Independent System Operator.
(i) "E-tag" means an energy tag representing transactions on the North American bulk electricity market scheduled to flow between or across balancing authority areas and to and from locations listed in an affiliated registry, as represented in a manner and form created by the North American Electric Reliability Corporation and as maintained by the North American Energy Standards Board or a successor organization.
(((l) "Point of delivery" means a point on the electricity transmission or distribution system where a deliverer makes electricity available to a receiver, or available to serve load. This point may be an interconnection with another system or a substation where the transmission provider's transmission and distribution systems are connected to another system, or a distribution substation where electricity is imported into the state over a multijurisdictional retail provider's distribution system.
(m) "Specified source of electricity" or "specified source" means a facility, unit, or asset controlling supplier that is permitted to be claimed as the source of electricity delivered. The reporting entity must have either full or partial ownership in the facility or a written power contract to procure electricity generated by that facility or unit or from an asset controlling supplier at the time of entry into the transaction to procure electricity.
(n) "Unspecified source of electricity" or "unspecified source" means a source of electricity that is not a specified source at the time of entry into the transaction to procure electricity.
(o) "Electricity exporter" means electric power entities that deliver exported electricity. The entity that exports electricity is identified on the e-tag as the purchasing-selling entity (PSE) on the last segment of the tag's physical path, with the point of receipt located inside Washington state and the point of delivery located outside Washington state. For electricity that is exported from a designated scheduling point in the balancing authority area of a federal power marketing administration, the exporter is the purchasing-selling entity at the first point of the physical path of the e-tag that is not the generation source.
(p) "Electricity transaction" means the purchase, sale, import, export or exchange of electric power.
(q) "Energy imbalance market" or "EIM" means the western energy imbalance market operated by the California independent system operator.
(r)))(j) "Exported electricity" means electricity generated inside Washington state and delivered to serve load located outside Washington state. This includes electricity delivered from a first point of receipt inside Washington state, to the first point of delivery outside Washington state, with a final point of delivery outside Washington state. Exported electricity delivered across balancing authority areas ((is))may be documented on e-tags with the first point of receipt located inside Washington state and the final point of delivery located outside Washington state. Exported electricity does not include electricity generated inside Washington state then transmitted outside of Washington state, but with a final point of delivery inside Washington state. Exported electricity does not include electricity generated inside Washington state that is allocated to serve Washington state retail customers of a multijurisdictional retail provider, consistent with a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission and the utility regulatory commission of at least one additional state in which the multijurisdictional retail provider provides retail electric service.
(((s)))(k) "Extended day ahead market" means the extended day ahead market operated by the California Independent System Operator.
(l) "Final point of delivery" means the sink specified on the e-tag, where defined points have been established through the affiliated registry. When e-tags are not used to document electricity deliveries, as may be the case within a balancing authority, the final point of delivery is the location of the load. Exported electricity is disaggregated by the final point of delivery ((on the e-tag)).
(((t)))(m) "First point of delivery in Washington" means the first defined point on the transmission system located inside Washington state at which imported electricity may be measured, consistent with defined points that have been established through the affiliated registry.
(((u)))(n) "First point of receipt" means the generation source specified on the e-tag, where defined points have been established through the affiliated registry. When e-tags are not used to document electricity deliveries, as may be the case within a balancing authority, the first point of receipt is the location of the individual generating facility or unit, or group of generating facilities or units.
(((v)))(o) "Generation providing entity" or "GPE" means a facility or generating unit operator, full or partial owner, party to a contract for a fixed percentage of net generation from the facility or generating unit, party to a tolling agreement with the owner, or exclusive marketer for the facility or generating unit recognized by ecology.
(p) "Grid" or "electric power grid" means a system of synchronized power providers and consumers connected by transmission and distribution lines and operated by one or more control centers.
(((w)))(q) "Imported electricity" means electricity generated outside Washington state with a final point of delivery within the state.
(i) "Imported electricity" includes electricity transferred into or attributed to Washington by a centralized electricity market but does not include electricity imported into Washington by a market operator to obtain or provide emergency assistance under applicable emergency preparedness and operations reliability standards of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation or Western Electricity Coordinating Council.
(ii) "Imported electricity" includes imports from linked jurisdictions, but such imports shall be construed as having no emissions.
(iii) Electricity from a system that is marketed by a federal power marketing administration shall be construed as "imported electricity," not electricity generated in Washington state.
(iv) "Imported electricity" does not include electricity imports of unspecified electricity that are netted by exports of unspecified electricity to any jurisdiction not covered by a linked program by the same entity within the same hour.
(v) For a multijurisdictional electric company, "imported electricity" means electricity, other than from in-state facilities, that contributes to a common system power pool. Where a multijurisdictional electric company has a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission, the allocation of specific facilities to Washington state's retail load will be in accordance with that methodology.
(vi) For a multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility, "imported electricity" includes electricity from facilities that contribute to a common system power pool that are allocated to a consumer-owned utility inside Washington state pursuant to a methodology approved by the governing board of the consumer-owned utility.
(r) "Last point of delivery in Washington" means the last defined point on the transmission system located inside Washington state at which exported electricity may be measured, consistent with defined points that have been established through the North American Energy Standards Board Electric Industry Registry.
(((x)))(s) "Marketer" means a purchasing-selling entity that delivers electricity and is not a retail provider.
(((y)))(t) "Market operator" means the legal entity that operates and maintains a centralized electricity market.
(u) "Market participant" means an electric power entity that has an agreement with a centralized electricity market operator and participates in that centralized electricity market in accordance with the rules and procedures of that market, as well as with an approved tariff that governs the operations of the centralized electricity market.
(v) "Markets plus" or "Markets+" means the Markets+ centralized day ahead electricity market designed by the Southwest Power Pool.
(w) "Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility" means an electric generation and transmission cooperative owned by a collection of consumer-owned utilities in multiple states or a consumer-owned utility that provides electricity to member owners in Washington state and in one or more other states in a contiguous service territory or from a common power system.
(x) "Multijurisdictional electric company" means an investor-owned utility that provides electricity to customers in Washington state and in one or more other states in a contiguous service territory or from a common power system.
(y) "Multijurisdictional retail provider" means a:
(i) Multijurisdictional electric company; or
(ii) Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility.
(z) "Point of delivery" means a point on the electricity transmission or distribution system where a deliverer makes electricity available to a receiver, or available to serve load. This point may be an interconnection with another system or a substation where the transmission provider's transmission and distribution systems are connected to another system, or a distribution substation where electricity is imported into the state over a multijurisdictional retail provider's distribution system.
(aa) "Point of receipt" or "POR" means the point on an electricity transmission or distribution system where an electricity receiver receives electricity from a deliverer. This point can be an interconnection with another system or a substation where the transmission provider's transmission and distribution systems are connected to another system.
(((z)))(bb) "Power" means electricity, except where the context makes clear that another meaning is intended.
(((aa)))(cc) "Power contract" or "written power contract," as used for the purposes of documenting specified versus unspecified sources of imported and exported electricity, means a written document, including associated verbal or electronic records if included as part of the written power contract, arranging for the sale or procurement of electricity. Power contracts may be, but are not limited to, power purchase agreements, enabling agreements, electricity transactions, and tariff provisions, without regard to duration, or written agreements to import or export on behalf of another entity, as long as that other entity also reports to ecology the same imported or exported electricity. A power contract for a specified source is a contract that is contingent upon delivery of power from a particular facility, unit, or asset-controlling supplier's system that is designated at the time the transaction is executed.
(((bb)))(dd) "Purchasing-selling entity" or "PSE" means the entity that is identified on an e-tag for each physical path segment.
(((cc)))(ee) "Retail end use customer" or "retail end user" means a residential, commercial, agricultural, or industrial electric customer who buys electricity to be consumed as a final product and not for resale.
(((dd)))(ff) "Retail provider" means any of the following:
(i) An electric utility as defined in RCW 19.405.020(14);
(ii) Multijurisdictional retail providers;
(iii) Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utilities.
(gg) "Retail sales" means electricity sold to retail end users.
(((ee)))(hh) "Specified source of electricity" or "specified source" means a facility, unit, or asset controlling supplier that is permitted to be claimed as the source of electricity delivered. The reporting entity must have either full or partial ownership in the facility or a written power contract to procure electricity generated by that facility or unit or from an asset controlling supplier at the time of entry into the transaction to procure electricity. For electricity from a resource dispatched by a centralized electricity market, the reporting entity must indicate in the offer of the electricity to the market that the electricity is available to serve load in Washington. Electricity reported as specified source must be contracted to a Washington retail provider or must be surplus electricity, as determined by methodologies approved by ecology.
(ii) "Sink" or "sink to load" or "load sink" means the sink identified on the physical path of e-tags, where defined points have been established through the affiliated registry. Exported electricity is disaggregated by the sink on the e-tag, also referred to as the final point of delivery on the e-tag.
(((ff)))(jj) "Source of generation" or "generation source" means the generation source identified on the physical path of e-tags, where defined points have been established through the affiliated registry. Imported electricity and wheels are disaggregated by the source on the e-tag, also referred to as the first point of receipt.
(((gg)))(kk) "Surplus electricity" means an amount of electricity generated by a resource in excess of the resource's existing obligations to provide electricity to purchasing entities.
(ll) "Tolling agreement" means an agreement whereby a party rents a power plant from the owner. The rent is generally in the form of a fixed monthly payment plus a charge for every megawatt generated, generally referred to as a variable payment.
(mm) "Unspecified source of electricity" or "unspecified source" means a source of electricity that is not a specified source at the time of entry into the transaction to sell or procure the electricity.
(3) Data requirements and calculation methods. The electric power entity who is required to report under WAC 173-441-030(3) of this chapter must comply with the following requirements.
(a) General requirements and content for GHG emissions data reports for electricity importers and exporters.
(i) Greenhouse gas emissions. The electric power entity must report GHG emissions separately for each category of delivered electricity required, in metric tons of CO2 equivalent (MT of CO2e), with biogenic CO2 reported separately, according to the calculation methods in this section.
(ii) Delivered electricity. The electric power entity must report imported and exported electricity in MWh disaggregated by first point of receipt (POR) or final point of delivery, as applicable, and must also separately report imported and exported electricity from unspecified sources ((and the energy imbalance market)), from centralized electricity markets, and from each specified source. Where applicable, first points of receipt and final points of delivery (POD) must be reported using the standardized code used in e-tags, as well as the full name of the POR/POD.
(iii) Imported electricity from unspecified sources. When reporting imported electricity delivered from unspecified sources, the electric power entity must report for each first point of receipt the following information:
(A) Whether the first point of receipt is located in a linked jurisdiction published on the ecology website;
(B) The amount of electricity from unspecified sources as measured at the first point of delivery in Washington state;
(C) The amount of electricity imports of unspecified electricity that are netted by exports of unspecified electricity to any jurisdiction not covered by a linked program by the same entity within the same hour.
(D) The net amount of imported unspecified electricity after taking into account the requirements in (a)(iii)(C) of this subsection.
(E) GHG emissions, including those associated with transmission losses, as required in this section.
(((F) When the unspecified power was obtained from the energy imbalance market.))
(iv) Delivered electricity from specified facilities or units. The electric power entity must report all direct delivery of electricity as from a specified source for facilities or units in which they are a generation providing entity (GPE) or have a written power contract to procure electricity. An electric power entity must report imported electricity as from a specified source when the electricity power entity is a GPE of that facility. When reporting imported electricity from specified facilities or units, the electric power entity must disaggregate electricity deliveries and associated GHG emissions by facility or unit and by first point of receipt, as applicable. The reporting entity must also report total GHG emissions and MWh from specified sources and the sum of emissions from specified sources explicitly listed as not covered in chapter 70A.65 RCW, as described in chapter 173-446 WAC. Seller Warranty: The sale or resale of specified source electricity is permitted among entities on the e-tag market path insofar as each sale or resale is for specified source electricity in which sellers have purchased and sold specified source electricity, such that each seller warrants the sale of specified source electricity from the source through the market path. Claims of specified sources of imported electricity, must include the following information:
(A) Measured at busbar. The amount of imported electricity from specified facilities or units as measured at the busbar; and
(B) Not measured at busbar. If the amount of imported electricity deliveries from specified facilities or units as measured at the busbar is not provided, report the amount of imported electricity as measured at the first point of delivery in Washington state, including estimated transmission losses as required in this section and the reason why measurement at the busbar is not known.
(v) Imported electricity from ((the energy imbalance))a centralized electricity market. ((The reporting entity must separately report power obtained from the energy imbalance market.))
(A) For the Energy Imbalance Market only, and for emissions reporting years 2023 through 2026 only, the retail provider located or operating in Washington that receives a delivery of electricity facilitated through the Energy Imbalance Market as defined in (c)(iv) of this subsection is the electricity importer for that electricity for the purposes of this section. In the event that the market operator is able to identify deemed market importers that successfully offer energy that is attributed to Washington before 2026, those identified entities are the deemed market importers beginning in the following calendar year.
(B) Each deemed market importer must separately report all electricity assigned, designated, deemed, or attributed to Washington by an originating centralized electricity market, in a manner designated by ecology.
(C) Each deemed market importer must calculate, report, and cause to be verified on an annual basis the greenhouse gas emissions associated with the electricity which the entity offered that has been designated, deemed, or attributed to Washington.
(vi) Imported electricity supplied by asset-controlling suppliers. The reporting entity must separately report imported electricity supplied by asset-controlling suppliers recognized by ecology. The reporting entity must:
(A) Report the asset-controlling supplier standardized purchasing-selling entity (PSE) acronym or code, full name, and the ecology identification number;
(B) Report asset-controlling supplier power that was not acquired as specified power, as unspecified power;
(C) Report delivered electricity from asset-controlling suppliers as measured at the first point of delivery in Washington state; and
(D) Report GHG emissions calculated pursuant to this section, including transmission losses.
(E) To claim power from an asset-controlling supplier, the asset-controlling supplier must be identified in one of the following means:
(I) On the physical path of the e-tag as the PSE at the first point of receipt, or in the case of asset-controlling suppliers that are exclusive marketers, as the PSE immediately following the associated generation owner; or
(II) If there is no e-tag associated with the imported electricity, on a long-term contract that identifies the ACS as the relevant provider of that electricity.
(vii) Exported electricity. The electric power entity must report exported electricity in MWh and associated GHG emissions in MT of CO2e for unspecified sources disaggregated by each final point of delivery outside Washington state, and for each specified source disaggregated by each final point of delivery outside Washington state((, as well as)). For electricity dispatched by a centralized electricity market, the electric power entity must report any specified electricity sales attributed to market participants outside Washington or exported from the market to an entity outside Washington in MWh and associated GHG emissions in MT of CO2e for unspecified sources and for each specified source disaggregated by recipient, to the extent this information is available from the centralized electricity market operator. The electric power entity must also report the following information:
(A) Exported electricity as measured at the last point of delivery located in Washington state, if known. If unknown, report as measured at the final point of delivery outside Washington state.
(B) Do not report estimated transmission losses.
(C) Report whether the final point of delivery is located in a linked jurisdiction published on the ecology website.
(D) Report GHG emissions calculated pursuant to this section.
(viii) Exchange agreements. The electric power entity must report delivered electricity under power exchange agreements consistent with imported and exported electricity requirements of this section. Electricity delivered into Washington state under exchange agreements must be reported as imported electricity and electricity delivered out of Washington state under exchange agreements must be reported as exported electricity.
(ix) Verification documentation. The electric power entity must retain for purposes of verification documentation of e-tags, written power contracts, settlements data, and any other reports provided by the market operator to the electric power entity regarding electricity attributed to Washington for which that entity is the deemed market importer, and all other information required to confirm reported electricity procurements and deliveries pursuant to the recordkeeping requirements of WAC 173-441-050.
(x) Electricity generating units and cogeneration units in Washington state. Electric power entities that also operate electricity generating units or cogeneration units located inside Washington state that meet the applicability requirements of WAC 173-441-030(1) must report GHG emissions to ecology under WAC 173-441-120.
(xi) Electricity generating units and cogeneration units outside Washington state. Operators and owners of electricity generating units and cogeneration units located outside Washington state who elect to report to ecology under WAC 173-441-030(5) must fully comply with the reporting and verification requirements of this chapter.
(b) Calculating GHG emissions.
(i) Calculating GHG emissions from unspecified sources. For electricity from unspecified sources, the electric power entity must calculate the annual CO2 equivalent mass emissions using the ((method established in WAC 173-444-040(4) and based on the amount of net imported electricity reported consistent with (a)(iii)(D) of this subsection.))following equation:
CO2e
=
MWh × TL × EFunsp
(Eq. 124-1)
Where:
 
CO2e
=
Annual CO2 equivalent mass emissions from the unspecified electricity deliveries at each point of receipt identified (MT of CO2e).
 
MWh
=
Megawatt-hours of unspecified electricity deliveries at each point of receipt identified.
 
EFunsp
=
Default emission factor for unspecified electricity imports.
 
EFunsp
=
0.428 MT of CO₂e/MWh.
 
TL
=
Transmission loss correction factor.
 
TL
=
TL = 1.02 to account for transmission losses between the busbar and measurement at the first point of receipt in Washington.
(ii) Calculating GHG emissions from specified facilities or units. For electricity from specified facilities or units, including electricity that is deemed, designated, assigned, or attributed by a centralized electricity market, the electric power entity must calculate emissions using the following equation:
CO2e
=
MWh × TL × EFsp
(Eq. ((124-1))124-2)
Where:
 
CO2e
=
Annual CO2 equivalent mass emissions from the specified electricity deliveries from each facility or unit claimed (MT of CO2e).
 
MWh
=
Megawatt-hours of specified electricity deliveries from each facility or unit claimed.
 
EFsp
=
Facility-specific or unit-specific emission factor published on the ecology website and calculated using total emissions and transactions data as described below. The emission factor is based on data from the year prior to the reporting year.
 
TL
=
Transmission loss correction factor.
 
TL
=
1.02 to account for transmission losses associated with generation outside of a Washington state balancing authority, including electricity from a centralized electricity market that does not account for losses in attribution of energy to Washington.
 
TL
=
1.0 if the reporting entity provides documentation that demonstrates to the satisfaction of a verifier and ecology that transmission losses have been accounted for, or are compensated by using electricity sourced from within Washington state, or for electricity from a centralized electricity market that accounts for a two percent transmission loss factor in the attribution of energy to Washington.
(A) Ecology shall calculate facility-specific or unit-specific emission factors and publish them on the ecology website using the following equation:
EFsp
=
Esp/EG
(Eq. ((124-2))124-3)
Where:
 
Esp
=
CO2e emissions for a specified facility or unit for the report year (MT of CO2e).
 
EG
=
Net generation from a specified facility or unit for the report year shall be based on data reported to the Energy Information Administration (EIA).
(B) To register a specified unit(s) source of power, the reporting entity must provide to ecology unit level GHG emissions consistent with the data source requirements of this section and net generation data as reported to the EIA, along with contracts for delivery of power from the specified unit(s) to the reporting entity, and proof of direct delivery of the power by the reporting entity as an import to Washington state.
(I) For specified facilities or units whose operators are subject to this chapter or whose owners or operators voluntarily report under this chapter, Esp shall be equal to the sum of CO2e emissions reported pursuant to this section.
(II) For specified facilities or units whose operators are not subject to reporting under this chapter or whose owners or operators do not voluntarily report under this chapter, but are subject to the U.S. EPA GHG Mandatory Reporting Regulation, Esp shall be based on GHG emissions reported to U.S. EPA pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Part 98. For GHG emissions reported to U.S. EPA pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Part 98, if it is not possible to isolate the emissions that are directly related to electricity production, ecology may calculate Esp based on EIA data. Emissions from combustion of biomass-derived fuels will be based on EIA data until such time the emissions are reported to U.S. EPA.
(III) For specified facilities or units whose operators are not subject to reporting under this chapter or whose owners or operators do not voluntarily report under this chapter, nor are subject to the U.S. EPA GHG Mandatory Reporting Regulation, Esp is calculated using heat of combustion data reported to the Energy Information Administration (EIA) as shown below.
Esp
=
0.001 × Σ(Q x EF)
(Eq. ((124-3))124-4)
Where:
 
0.001
=
Conversion factor kg to MT
 
Q
=
Heat of combustion for each specified fuel type from the specified facility or unit for the report year (MMBtu). For cogeneration, Q is the quantity of fuel allocated to electricity generation consistent with EIA reporting. For geothermal electricity, Q is the steam data reported to EIA (MMBtu).
 
EF
=
CO2e emission factor for the specified fuel type as required by this chapter (kg CO2e/MMBtu). For geothermal electricity, EF is the estimated CO2 emission factor published by EIA.
(IV) Facilities or units will be assigned an emission factor by the ecology based on the type of fuel combusted or the technology used when a U.S. EPA GHG Report or EIA fuel consumption report is not available, including new facilities and facilities located outside the U.S.
(V) Meter data requirement. For verification purposes, electric power entities shall retain meter generation data to document that the power claimed by the reporting entity was generated by the facility or unit at the time the power was directly delivered.
(VI) A lesser of analysis is applicable to imports from specified sources for which ecology has calculated an emission factor of zero, and for imports from Washington renewable portfolio standard (RPS) eligible resources, excluding the following: Dynamically tagged power deliveries; nuclear power; asset controlling supplier power; and imports from hydroelectric facilities for which an entity's share of metered output on an hourly basis is not established by power contract. A lesser of analysis is required pursuant to the following equation:
Sum of Lesser of MWh
=
ΣHMsp min (MGsp*Ssp, TGsp)
(Eq. ((124-4))124-5)
Where:
 
ΣHMsp
=
Sum of the Hourly Minimum of MGsp and TGsp (MWh).
 
MGsp
=
Metered facility or unit net generation (MWh).
 
Ssp
=
Entity's share of metered output, if applicable.
 
TGsp
=
Tagged or transmitted energy at the transmission or subtransmission level imported to Washington (MWh).
(iii) Calculating GHG emissions of imported electricity supplied by asset-controlling suppliers. Based on annual reports submitted to ecology pursuant to WAC 173-441-070(3), ecology will calculate and publish on the ecology website the system emission factor for all asset-controlling suppliers recognized by the ecology. The reporting entity must calculate emissions for electricity supplied using the following equation:
CO2e
=
MWh × TL × EFacs
(Eq. ((124-5))124-6)
Where:
 
CO2
=
Annual CO2 equivalent mass emissions from the specified electricity deliveries from ecology-recognized asset-controlling suppliers (MT of CO2e).
 
MWh
=
Megawatt-hours of specified electricity deliveries.
 
EFACS
=
Asset-Controlling Supplier system emission factor published on the ecology website (MT CO2e/MWh). Ecology will assign the system emission factors for all asset-controlling suppliers based on a previously verified GHG report submitted to ecology pursuant to WAC 173-441-070(3). The supplier-specific system emission factor is calculated annually by ecology. The calculation is derived from data contained in annual reports submitted that have received a positive or qualified positive verification statement. The emission factor is based on data from two years prior to the reporting year.
 
TL
=
Transmission loss correction factor.
 
TL
=
1.02 when deliveries are not reported as measured at a first point of receipt located within the balancing authority area of the asset-controlling supplier.
 
TL
=
1.0 when deliveries are reported as measured at a first point of receipt located within the balancing authority area of the asset-controlling supplier.
Ecology must calculate the system emission factor for asset-controlling suppliers using the following equations:
EFACS
=
Sum of System Emissions MT of CO2e/Sum of System MWh
(Eq. ((124-6))124-7)
Sum of System Emissions,
MT of CO2e
=
ΣEasp + Σ(PEsp * EFsp) + Σ(PEunsp * EFunsp) - Σ(SEsp * EFsp)
(Eq. ((124-7))124-8)
Sum of System MWh
=
ΣEGasp + ΣPEsp + ΣPEunsp - ΣSEsp
(Eq. ((124-8))124-9)
Where:
 
ΣEasp
=
Emissions from owned facilities. Sum of CO2e emissions from each specified facility/unit in the asset-controlling supplier's fleet (MT of CO2e).
 
ΣEGasp
=
Net generation from owned facilities. Sum of net generation for each specified facility/unit in the asset-controlling supplier's fleet for the data year as reported to ecology under this chapter (MWh).
 
PEsp
=
Electricity purchased from specified sources. Amount of electricity purchased wholesale and taken from specified sources by the asset-controlling supplier for the data year as reported to ecology under this chapter (MWh).
 
PEunsp
=
Electricity purchased from unspecified sources. Amount of electricity purchased wholesale from unspecified sources by the asset-controlling supplier for the data year as reported to ecology under this chapter (MWh).
 
SEsp
=
Electricity sold from specified sources. Amount of wholesale electricity sold from specified sources by the asset-controlling supplier for the data year as reported to ecology under this chapter (MWh).
 
EFsp
=
CO2e emission factor as defined for each specified facility or unit calculated consistent with (b)(ii) of this subsection (MT CO2e/MWh).
 
EFunsp
=
Default emission factor for unspecified sources calculated consistent with (b)(i) of this subsection (MT CO2e/MWh).
(iv) Calculating GHG emissions of imported electricity for multijurisdictional retail providers. Multijurisdictional retail providers must include emissions and megawatt-hours in the terms below from facilities or units that contribute to a common system power pool. Multijurisdictional retail providers do not include emissions or megawatt-hours in the terms below from facilities or units allocated to serve retail loads in designated states pursuant to a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission and the utility regulatory commission of at least one additional state in which the multijurisdictional retail provider provides retail electric service. For multijurisdictional consumer-owned utilities, the cost allocation methodology must be approved by its governing board. Multijurisdictional retail providers must calculate emissions that have a compliance obligation using the following equation:
CO2e
=
(MWhR x TLR - MWhWSP-WA - EGWA) x EFMJRP-notWA + MWhSP-notWA x TLWSP x EFunsp - CO2e linked
(Eq. ((124-9))124-10)
Where:
 
CO2e
=
Annual CO2e mass emissions of imported electricity (MT of CO2e).
 
MWhR
=
Total electricity procured by multijurisdictional retail provider to serve its retail customers in Washington, reported as retail sales for Washington state service territory, MWh.
 
MWhWSP-WA
=
Wholesale electricity procured in Washington state by multijurisdictional retail provider to serve its retail customers in Washington state, as determined by the first point of receipt on a e-tag and pursuant to a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission (UTC) and the utility regulatory commission of at least one additional state in which the multijurisdictional retail provider provides retail electric service, MWh. For multijurisdictional consumer-owned utilities, the cost allocation methodology must be approved by its governing board.
 
MWhWSP-not WA
=
Wholesale electricity imported into Washington state by multijurisdictional retail provider with a final point of delivery in Washington state and not used to serve its Washington state retail customers, MWh.
 
EFMJRP-not WA
=
Multijurisdictional retail provider system emission factor for out-of-state generation calculated by ecology and consistent with a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission and the utility regulatory commission of at least one additional state in which the multijurisdictional retail provider provides retail electric service. For multijurisdictional consumer-owned utilities, the cost allocation methodology must be approved by its governing board.
 
EFunsp
=
Default emission factor for unspecified sources calculated consistent with this section (MT CO2e/MWh).
 
EGWA
=
Net generation measured at the busbar of facilities and units located in Washington state that are allocated to serve its retail customers in Washington state pursuant to a cost allocation methodology approved by the Washington state utilities and transportation commission and the utility regulatory commission of at least one additional state in which the multijurisdictional retail provider provides retail electric service, MWh. For multijurisdictional consumer-owned utilities, the cost allocation methodology must be approved by its governing board.
 
TL
=
Transmission loss correction factor.
 
TL WSP
=
1.02 for transmission losses applied to wholesale power.
 
TL R
=
Estimate of transmission losses from busbar to end user reported by multijurisdictional retail provider.
 
CO2e linked
=
Annual CO2e mass emissions recognized by ecology pursuant to linkage under chapter 70A.65 RCW, as described in chapter 173-446 WAC (MT of CO2e).
(c) Additional requirements for retail providers, excluding multijurisdictional retail providers. Retail providers must include the following information in the GHG emissions data report for each report year, in addition to the information identified in (a)(i), (ii), and (vii) of this subsection.
(i) Retail providers must report Washington state retail sales. A retail provider who is required only to report retail sales may choose not to apply the verification requirements specified in WAC 173-441-085, if the retail provider deems the emissions data report nonconfidential.
(ii) Retail providers may elect to report the subset of retail sales attributed to the electrification of shipping ports, truck stops, and motor vehicles if metering is available to separately track these sales from other retail sales.
(((d)))(iii) Retail providers that report as electricity importers or exporters also must separately report electricity imported from specified and unspecified sources by other electric power entities to serve their load, designating the electricity importer. In addition, all imported electricity transactions documented by e-tags where the retail provider is the PSE at the sink must be reported.
(((e)))(iv) Retail providers must report net purchases of electricity from centralized electricity markets, based on annual totals of electricity purchased in MWh from each separate centralized electricity market.
(d) Additional requirements for multijurisdictional retail providers. Multijurisdictional retail providers that provide electricity into Washington state at the distribution level must include the following information in the GHG emissions data report for each report year, in addition to the information identified elsewhere in this section.
(i) A report of the electricity transactions and GHG emissions associated with the common power system or contiguous service territory that includes consumers in Washington state. This includes the requirements in this section as applicable for each generating facility or unit in the multijurisdictional retail provider's fleet;
(ii) The multijurisdictional retail provider must include in its emissions data report wholesale power purchased and taken (MWh) from specified and unspecified sources and wholesale power sold from specified sources according to the specifications in this section, and as required for ecology to calculate a supplier-specific emission factor;
(iii) Total retail sales (MWh) by the multijurisdictional retail provider in the contiguous service territory or power system that includes consumers in Washington state;
(iv) Retail sales (MWh) to Washington state customers served in Washington state's portion of the service territory;
(v) Retail sales derived from ((the energy imbalance))each centralized electricity market;
(vi) GHG emissions associated with the imported electricity, including both Washington state retail sales and wholesale power imported into Washington state from the retail provider's system, according to the specifications in this section;
(vii) Multijurisdictional retail providers that serve Washington state load must claim as specified power all power purchased or taken from facilities or units in which they have operational control or an ownership share or written power contract;
(viii) Multijurisdictional retail providers that serve Washington state load may elect to exclude information listed in this section when registering claims to specified power from facilities located outside Washington state and participating in the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's PURPA Qualifying Facility program.
(((f)))(e) Additional requirements for asset-controlling suppliers. Owners or operators of electricity generating facilities or exclusive marketers for certain generating facilities may apply for an asset-controlling supplier designation from ecology. Approved asset-controlling suppliers may request that ecology calculate or adopt a supplier-specific emission factor pursuant to this section. To apply for asset-controlling supplier designation, the applicant must:
(i) Meet the requirements in this chapter, including reporting pursuant as applicable for each generating facility or unit in the supplier's fleet;
(ii) Include in its emissions data report wholesale power purchased and taken (MWh) from specified and unspecified sources and wholesale power sold from specified sources according to the specifications in this section, and as required for ecology to calculate a supplier-specific emission factor;
(iii) Retain for verification purposes documentation that the power sold by the supplier originated from the supplier's fleet of facilities and either that the fleet is under the supplier's operational control or that the supplier serves as the fleet's exclusive marketer;
(iv) Provide the supplier-specific ecology identification number to electric power entities who purchase electricity from the supplier's system.
(v) To apply for and maintain asset-controlling supplier status, the entity shall submit as part of its emissions data report the following information, annually:
(A) General business information, including entity name and contact information;
(B) List of officer names and titles;
(C) Data requirements as prescribed by ecology;
(D) A list and description of electricity generating facilities for which the reporting entity is a ((first jurisdiction deliverer))deemed market importer; and
(E) An attestation, in writing and signed by an authorized officer of the applicant, as follows:
(I) "I certify under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Washington that I am duly authorized by (name of entity) to sign this attestation on behalf of (name of entity), that (name of entity) meets the definition of an asset-controlling supplier as specified in this section and that the information submitted herein is true, accurate, and complete."
(II) Asset-controlling suppliers must annually adhere to all reporting and verification requirements of this chapter, or be removed from asset-controlling supplier designation. Asset-controlling suppliers will also lose their designation if they receive an adverse verification statement, but may reapply in the following year for redesignation.
(((g)))(f) Requirements for claims of specified sources of electricity. Each reporting entity claiming specified facilities or units for imported or exported electricity, including deemed market importers, must register its anticipated specified sources with ecology as part of their greenhouse gas report to obtain associated emission factors calculated by ecology for use in the emissions data report required to be submitted by the report submission due date in WAC 173-441-050 (2)(a). If an operator fails to register a specified source by ((the registration due date in WAC 173-441-060(4)))February 1st for sources used the previous year, the operator must use the emission factor provided by ecology for a specified facility or unit in the emissions data report required to be submitted by the report submission due date in WAC 173-441-050 (2)(a). Each reporting entity claiming specified facilities or units for imported or exported electricity must also meet requirements in the emissions data report.
(i) Registration information for specified sources. The following information is required:
(A) The facility names and, for specification to the unit level, the facility and unit names.
(B) For sources with a previously assigned ecology identification number, the ecology facility or unit identification number or supplier number published on ecology's website. For newly specified sources, ecology will assign a unique identification number.
(C) If applicable, the facility and unit identification numbers as used for reporting to the U.S. EPA Acid Rain Program, U.S. EPA pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Part 98, U.S. Energy Information Administration, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's PURPA Qualifying Facility program, as applicable.
(D) The physical address of each facility, including jurisdiction.
(E) Provide names of facility owner and operator.
(F) The percent ownership share and whether the facility or unit is under the electricity importer's operational control.
(G) Total facility or unit gross and net nameplate capacity when the electricity importer is a GPE.
(H) Total facility or unit gross and net generation when the electricity importer is a GPE.
(I) Start date of commercial operation and, when applicable, date of repowering.
(J) GPEs claiming additional capacity at an existing facility must include the implementation date, the expected increase in net generation (MWh), and a description of the actions taken to increase capacity.
(K) Designate whether the facility or unit is a newly specified source, a continuing specified source, or was a specified source in the previous report year that will not be specified in the current report year.
(L) Provide the primary technology or fuel type as listed below:
(I) Variable renewable resources by type, defined for purposes of this chapter as pure solar, pure wind, and run-of-river hydroelectricity;
(II) Hybrid facilities such as solar thermal;
(III) Hydroelectric facilities ≤ 30 MW, not run-of-river;
(IV) Hydroelectric facilities ≥ 30 MW;
(V) Geothermal binary cycle plant or closed loop system;
(VI) Geothermal steam plant or open loop system;
(VII) Units combusting biomass-derived fuel, by primary fuel type;
(VIII) Nuclear facilities;
(IX) Cogeneration by primary fuel type;
(X) Fossil sources by primary fuel type;
(XI) Co-fired fuels;
(XII) Municipal solid waste combustion;
(XIII) Other.
(ii) Additional information for specified sources. For each claim to a specified source of electricity, the electricity importer must indicate whether one or more of the following descriptions applies:
(A) Deliveries from new facilities. Specified source of electricity is first registered pursuant to this section and delivered by an electricity importer within 12 months of the start date of commercial operation and the electricity importer making a claim in the current data year is either a GPE or purchaser of electricity under a written power contract;
(B) Deliveries from existing facilities with additional capacity. Specified source of electricity is first registered pursuant to this section and delivered by a GPE within 12 months of the start date of an increase in the facility's generating capacity due to increased efficiencies or other capacity increasing actions.
(iii) Additional information for deemed market importers for claims of specified sources of electricity. To receive a positive verification statement upon verification for claims of specified imports from a centralized electricity market the electric power entity must be able to demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction that the market operator designated, assigned, deemed, or otherwise attributed energy from those resources to Washington. Proof of such attribution may be demonstrated upon request by settlement records or other information such as that provided by the market operator to the market participant showing that energy offered by the deemed market importer was attributed to Washington. This provision of records and other information must be submitted to ecology in a manner designated by ecology by May 1st for electricity transactions involving centralized electricity markets in the previous calendar year.
(4) Recordkeeping. GHG inventory program for electric power entities that import or export electricity. In lieu of a GHG monitoring plan, electric power entities that import or export electricity must prepare GHG inventory program documentation that is maintained and available for verifier review and ecology audit pursuant to the recordkeeping requirements of this section. The following information is required:
(a) Information to allow the verification team to develop a general understanding of entity boundaries, operations, and electricity transactions;
(b) Reference to management policies or practices applicable to reporting pursuant to this section;
(c) List of key personnel involved in compiling data and preparing the emissions data report;
(d) Training practices for personnel involved in reporting delivered electricity and responsible for data report certification, including documented training procedures;
(e) Query of e-tag source data to determine the quantity of electricity (MWh) imported, exported, and wheeled for transactions in which they are the purchasing-selling entity on the last physical path segment that crosses the border of Washington state, access to review the raw e-tag data, a tabulated summary, and query description;
(f) Reference to other independent or internal data management systems and records, including written power contracts and associated verbal or electronic records, full or partial ownership, invoices, reports and statements from market operators, and settlements data used to document whether reported transactions are specified or unspecified and whether the requirements for adjustments to covered emissions of chapter 70A.65 RCW, as described in chapter 173-446 WAC are met;
(g) Description of steps taken and calculations made to aggregate data into reporting categories required pursuant to this section;
(h) Records of preventive and corrective actions taken to address verifier and ecology findings of past nonconformances and material misstatements;
(i) Log of emissions data report modifications made after initial certification; and
(j) A written description of an internal audit program that includes emissions data report review and documents ongoing efforts to improve the GHG inventory program.
OTS-5374.1
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 22-20-056, filed 9/29/22, effective 10/30/22)
WAC 173-446-020Definitions.
The definitions in this section apply throughout this chapter unless the context clearly requires otherwise. For those terms not listed in this section, the definitions found in chapters 173-441 and 173-446A WAC apply in this chapter.
"Additional" means, in the context of the offset provisions of this rule, greenhouse gas emission reductions or removals that exceed any greenhouse gas reduction or removals otherwise required by law, regulation or legally binding mandate, and that exceed any greenhouse gas reductions or removals that would otherwise occur in a business-as-usual scenario.
"Adverse offset verification statement" means an offset verification statement rendered by a verification body attesting that the verification body cannot say with reasonable assurance that the submitted offset project data report is free of an offset material misstatement, or that it cannot attest that the offset project data report conforms to the requirements of this chapter or applicable compliance offset protocol.
"Affiliated registered entities" means registered entities in a direct or indirect corporate association.
"Aggregation" means, in the context of offsets, a grouping of offset projects carried out according to the same compliance offset protocol and under the responsibility of the same offset project developer or operator.
"Allowance" means an authorization to emit up to one metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent.
"Allowance price containment reserve" means an account maintained by ecology with allowances available for sale through separate reserve auctions at predefined prices to assist in containing compliance costs for covered and opt-in entities in the event of unanticipated high costs for compliance instruments.
"Annual allowance budget" means the total number of GHG allowances allocated for auction and distribution for one calendar year by ecology.
"Asset controlling supplier" or "ACS" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Auction" means the process of selling GHG allowances by offering them up for bid, taking bids, and then distributing the allowances to winning bidders.
"Auction floor price" means a price for allowances below which bids at auction are not eligible to be accepted.
"Auction purchase limit" means the limit on the number of allowances one registered entity or a group of affiliated registered entities may purchase from the share of allowances sold at an auction.
"Auction settlement price" means the price announced by ecology at the conclusion of each auction that all successful bidders pay for each allowance.
"Authorized project designee" means an entity authorized by an offset project operator to act on behalf of the offset project operator. The authorized project designee must be a primary account representative or alternate account representative on the offset project operator's holding account.
"Balancing authority" means the responsible party that integrates resource plans ahead of time, maintains load-interchange generation balance within a balancing authority area, and supports interconnection frequency in real time.
"Balancing authority area" means the collection of generation, transmission, and load within the metered boundaries of a balancing authority. A balancing authority maintains load-resource balance within this area.
"Banking" means the holding of compliance instruments from one compliance period for the purpose of sale or use for compliance in a future compliance period.
"Best available technology" or "BAT" means a technology or technologies that will achieve the greatest reduction in GHG emissions, taking into account the fuels, processes, and equipment used by facilities to produce goods of comparable type, quantity, and quality. Best available technology must be technically feasible, commercially available, economically viable, not create excessive environmental impacts, and be compliant with all applicable laws while not changing the characteristics of the good being manufactured.
"Biomass" means nonfossilized and biodegradable organic material originating from plants, animals, and microorganisms, including products, by-products, residues, and waste from agriculture, forestry, and related industries as well as the nonfossilized and biodegradable organic fractions of municipal wastewater and industrial waste, including gases and liquids recovered from the decomposition of nonfossilized and biodegradable organic material.
"Biomass-derived fuels," "biomass fuels," or "biofuels" means fuels derived from biomass that have at least 40 percent lower GHG emissions based on a full life-cycle analysis when compared to petroleum fuels for which biofuels are capable as serving as a substitute.
"Bundled transaction" means the retail sale of two or more products, except real property or services to real property, where:
(a) The products are otherwise distinct and identifiable; and
(b) The products are sold for one nonitemized price.
A bundled transaction does not include the sale of any products in which the sale price varies or is negotiable, based on the selection by the purchaser of the products included in the transaction.
"Business-as-usual scenario" means, in the context of offsets, the set of conditions reasonably expected to occur within the offset project boundary in the absence of the financial incentives provided by offset credits, taking into account all current laws and regulations, as well as current economic and technological trends.
"Cap and invest consultant or advisor" means an individual or party that meets the criteria in WAC 173-446-056.
"Carbon dioxide equivalents" or "CO2e" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Carbon dioxide removal" or "greenhouse gas removal" means deliberate human activities removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and durably storing it in geological, terrestrial, or ocean reservoirs, or in products. "Carbon dioxide removal" includes existing and potential anthropogenic enhancement of biological or geochemical sinks and including, but not limited to, carbon mineralization and direct air capture and storage.
"Centralized electricity market" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Closed electricity importer" means an electricity importer that has elected to permanently stop providing or importing electric power into Washington.
"Closed facility" means a facility at which the current owner or operator has elected to permanently stop production and will no longer be an emissions source.
"Closed supplier" means a supplier that has elected to permanently stop supplying any of the materials that trigger coverage as a supplier under chapter 70A.65 RCW and this chapter.
"Compliance instrument" means an allowance or offset credit issued by ecology or by an external GHG emissions trading program to which Washington has linked its cap and invest program. One compliance instrument is equal to one metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent.
"Compliance obligation" means the requirement to submit to ecology the number of compliance instruments equivalent to a covered or opt-in entity's covered emissions during the compliance period.
"Compliance offset protocol" means an offset protocol adopted by ecology.
"Compliance period" means the four-year period for which the compliance obligation is calculated for covered entities.
"Conservative" means, in the context of offsets, utilizing project baseline assumptions, emission factors, and methodologies that are more likely than not to understate net GHG reductions or GHG removal enhancements for an offset project to address uncertainties affecting the calculation or measurement of GHG reductions or GHG removal enhancements.
"Cost burden" means the impact on rates or charges to customers of electric utilities in Washington for the incremental cost of electricity service to serve load due to the compliance cost for GHG emissions caused by the program. Cost burden includes administrative costs from the utility's participation in the program.
"Covered emissions" means the emissions described in WAC 173-446-040 for which a covered entity has a compliance obligation under this chapter.
"Covered entity" means a person that is designated by ecology as subject to this chapter as specified in WAC 173-446-030 or 173-446-060. Each facility, supplier, or first jurisdictional deliverer serving as an electricity importer is a separate covered entity.
"Crediting baseline" refers to the reduction of absolute GHG emissions below the business-as-usual scenario after the imposition of greenhouse gas emission reduction requirements or incentives.
"Crediting period" means the predetermined period of time for which an offset project will remain eligible to be issued ecology offset credits or registry offset credits for verified GHG emission reductions or GHG removal enhancements.
"Curtailed electric power entity" means an electric power entity at which the owner or operator has temporarily suspended operations but for which the owner or operator maintains any necessary permits and retains the option to resume business if conditions become amenable.
"Curtailed facility" means a facility at which the owner or operator has temporarily suspended production but for which the owner or operator maintains operating permits and retains the option to resume production if conditions become amenable.
"Curtailed supplier" means a supplier at which the owner or operator has temporarily suspended operations but for which the owner or operator maintains any necessary permits and retains the option to resume business if conditions become amenable.
"Deemed market importer" has the same meaning as in WAC 173-441-124.
"Direct corporate association" means a group of parties that meet the requirements in WAC 173-446-105 to be a direct corporate association.
"Direct environmental benefits in the state" means, in the context of offsets, environmental benefits accomplished through the reduction or avoidance of emissions of any air pollutant in the state or the reduction or avoidance of the release of any pollutant that could have an adverse impact on land or waters of the state.
"Direct GHG emission reduction" means a reduction of GHG emissions from applicable GHG emission sources, GHG sinks, or GHG reservoirs that are under control of an offset project operator or authorized project designee.
"Direct GHG removal enhancement" means a GHG removal enhancement from applicable GHG emission sources, GHG sinks, or GHG reservoirs under control of the offset project operator or authorized project designee.
"Ecology" means the Washington state department of ecology or its agents, including the auction administrator and the financial services administrator retained by ecology pursuant to RCW 70A.65.100(3).
"Electric power entity" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Electricity importer" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Emissions containment reserve allowance" means a conditional allowance that is withheld from sale at an auction by ecology or its agent to secure additional emissions reductions in the event prices fall below the emissions containment reserve trigger price, or any other allowance placed into the emissions containment reserve.
"Emissions containment reserve trigger price" means the price below which allowances will be withheld from sale at an auction by ecology, as determined by ecology by rule unless ecology has suspended the emissions containment reserve trigger price.
"Emissions threshold" means the GHG emission level at or above which a person has a compliance obligation under this chapter.
"Emissions year" means the calendar year in which GHG emissions occur.
"Environmental benefits" means activities that:
(a) Prevent or reduce existing environmental harms or associated risks that contribute significantly to cumulative environmental health impacts;
(b) Prevent or mitigate impacts to overburdened communities or vulnerable populations from, or support community response to, the impacts of environmental harm; or
(c) Meet a community need formally identified to a covered agency by an overburdened community or vulnerable population that is consistent with the intent of chapter 70A.02 RCW.
"Environmental harm" means the individual or cumulative environmental health impacts and risks to communities caused by historic, current, or projected:
(a) Exposure to pollution, conventional or toxic pollutants, environmental hazards, or other contamination in the air, water, and land;
(b) Adverse environmental effects, including exposure to contamination, hazardous substances, or pollution that increase the risk of adverse environmental health outcomes or create vulnerabilities to the impacts of climate change;
(c) Loss or impairment of ecosystem functions or traditional food resources or loss of access to gather cultural resources or harvest traditional foods; or
(d) Health and economic impacts from climate change.
"Environmental impacts" means environmental benefits or environmental harms, or the combination of environmental benefits and harms, resulting or expected to result from a proposed action.
"Environmental justice council" means the council established in RCW 70A.02.110.
"External GHG emissions trading program" or "external GHG ETS" means a government program, other than Washington's program created in this chapter, that restricts GHG emissions from sources outside of Washington and that allows emissions trading.
"Facility" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Federal power marketing administration" means any of the four federal power marketing administrations that operate electric systems and sell the electrical output of federally owned and operated hydroelectric dams in the United States.
"First jurisdictional deliverer" means the owner or operator of an electric generating facility in Washington state or an electricity importer.
"Forest buffer account" means a holding account for ecology offset credits issued to forest offset projects. It is used as a general insurance mechanism against unintentional reversals, for all forest offset projects listed under a compliance offset protocol.
"Forest owner" means the owner of any interest in the real property on which a forest offset project is located, excluding government agency or other third-party beneficiaries of conservation easements. Generally, a forest owner is the owner in fee of the real property on which a forest offset project is located. In some cases, one party may be the owner in fee while another party may have an interest in the trees or the timber on the property, in which case all parties with interest in the real property are collectively considered the forest owners; however, a single forest owner must be identified as the offset project operator.
"General market participant" means a registered entity that is not identified as a covered entity or an opt-in entity that is registered in the program registry and intends to purchase, hold, sell, or voluntarily retire compliance instruments.
"Greenhouse gas" or "GHG" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Greenhouse gas emission reduction" or "GHG emission reduction" or "greenhouse gas reduction" or "GHG reduction" means a calculated decrease in GHG emissions relative to a project baseline over a specified period of time.
"Greenhouse gas emissions source" or "GHG emissions source" means, in the context of offsets, any type of emitting activity that releases greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.
"Greenhouse gas removal enhancement" or "GHG removal enhancement" means a calculated increase in GHG removals relative to a project baseline.
"Greenhouse gas reservoir" or "GHG reservoir" means a physical unit or component of the biosphere, geosphere, or hydrosphere with the capability to store, accumulate, or release a GHG removed from the atmosphere by a GHG sink or a GHG captured from a GHG emission source.
"Greenhouse gas sink" or "GHG sink" means a physical unit or process that removes a GHG from the atmosphere.
"Holding limit" means the maximum number of allowances that may be held for use or trade by a registered entity at any one time.
"Imported electricity" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Indirect corporate association" means a group of parties that meet the requirements in WAC 173-446-105 to be an indirect corporate association.
"Initial crediting period" means the crediting period that begins with the first day of the first reporting period which receives a positive offset or qualified positive offset verification statement and has that offset verification statement approved by ecology.
"Intentional reversal" means any reversal, except as provided below, which is caused by a forest owner's negligence, gross negligence, or willful intent, including harvesting, development, and harm to the area within the offset project boundary, or caused by approved growth models overestimating carbon stocks. A reversal caused by an intentional back burn set by, or at the request of, a local, state, or federal fire protection agency for the purpose of protecting forestlands from an advancing wildfire that began on another property through no negligence, gross negligence, or willful misconduct of the forest owner is not considered an intentional reversal but, rather, an unintentional reversal. Receiving adverse offset verification statements on two consecutive offset verifications after the end of the final crediting period will be considered an intentional reversal.
"Lead offset verifier" means a party that has met all the requirements in WAC 173-441-085(7) and who may act as the lead verifier of an offset verification team providing offset verification services or as a lead verifier providing an independent review of offset verification services rendered.
"Lead offset verifier independent reviewer" or "independent offset reviewer" means a lead offset verifier within a verification body who has not participated in conducting offset verification services for an offset project developer or authorized project designee for the current offset project data report and who provides an independent review of offset verification services rendered for an offset project developer or authorized project designee as required in WAC 173-446-530. The independent reviewer is not required to also meet the requirements for a sector specific or offset project specific verifier.
"Leakage" means a reduction in emissions of GHGs within the state that is offset by a directly attributable increase in GHG emissions outside the state and outside the geography of another jurisdiction with a linkage agreement with Washington.
"Limits" means the GHG emissions reductions required by RCW 70A.45.020.
"Linkage" means a bilateral or multilateral decision under a linkage agreement between GHG market programs to accept compliance instruments issued by a participating jurisdiction to meet the obligations of regulated entities in a partner jurisdiction and to otherwise coordinate activities to facilitate operation of a joint market.
"Linkage agreement" means a nonbinding agreement that connects two or more GHG market programs and articulates a mutual understanding of how the participating jurisdictions will work together to facilitate a connected GHG market.
"Linked jurisdiction" means a jurisdiction with which Washington has entered into a linkage agreement.
"Market position" means the combination of the current and/or expected holdings of compliance instruments by a registered entity and the current and/or expected covered emissions of that registered entity.
"Market sensitive information" means information related to registered entities, or their participation in the cap and invest program that is not otherwise publicly available, and for which ecology determines that the public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the public interest served by maintaining the confidentiality of such information, on the basis that its disclosure would be reasonably expected to have an effect on the price or value of allowances or offset credits and/or enable a registered entity to engage in market manipulation such as bidder collusion, market cornering, or extortion of other market participant. "Market sensitive information" does not include data reported under chapter 173-441 WAC, except to the extent that the disclosure of such data for a particular emission year at any time prior to November 15th of the following calendar year would enable a registered entity to engage in market manipulation. "Market sensitive information" also does not include anonymized information about the contents of registered entities' holding accounts that is publicly displayed pursuant to RCW 70A.65.090 (7)(b), except to the extent that the disclosure of such information that is less than 45 days old would enable a registered entity to engage in market manipulation.
"Multijurisdictional consumer-owned utility" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Multijurisdictional electric company" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"NERC e-tag" or "e-tag" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Offset credit" means a tradable compliance instrument that represents an emissions reduction or emissions removal of one metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent.
"Offset material misstatement" means a discrepancy, omission, misreporting, or aggregation of the three, identified in the course of offset verification services that leads an offset verification team to conclude that an offset project data report contains errors resulting in an overstatement of the reported total GHG emission reductions or GHG removal enhancements by greater than five percent. Discrepancies, omissions, or misreporting, or an aggregation of the three, that result in an understatement of total reported GHG emission reductions or GHG removal enhancements in the offset project data report is not an offset material misstatement.
"Offset project" means a project that reduces or removes GHG that are not covered emissions under this chapter.
"Offset project boundary" is defined by and includes all GHG emission sources, GHG sinks, and GHG reservoirs that are affected by an offset project and under control of the offset project operator or authorized project designee. GHG emissions sources, GHG sinks or GHG reservoirs not under control of the offset project operator or authorized project designee are not included in the offset project boundary.
"Offset project data report" means the report prepared by an offset project operator or authorized project designee each reporting period that provides the information, documentation, and attestations required by this chapter or a compliance offset protocol. An unattested report is not a valid offset project data report, and therefore cannot be used to satisfy any deadlines regarding submittal of an offset project data report.
"Offset project listing" or "listing" means the information, documentation, and attestations required by this chapter or a compliance offset protocol that an offset project operator or authorized project designee has submitted to ecology or an offset project registry, and that has been reviewed for completeness by ecology and/or the offset project registry and publicly listed by ecology or the offset project registry for an initial or renewed crediting period. An offset project listing must include the attestations required by this chapter in order to be considered complete by ecology or the offset project registry.
"Offset project operator" means the party(ies) with legal authority to implement the offset project. Only a primary account representative or alternate account representative may sign listing documents, an offset project data report, a request for issuance, or attestations on behalf of the offset project operator.
"Offset project registry" means a party that meets the requirements of this chapter and is approved by ecology that lists offset projects, collects offset project data reports, facilitates verification of offset project data reports, and issues registry offset credits for offset projects being implemented using a compliance offset protocol.
"Offset protocols" means a set of procedures and standards to quantify GHG reductions or GHG removals achieved by an offset project.
"Offset verification" means a systematic, independent, and documented process for evaluation of an offset project operator's or authorized project designee's offset project data report against ecology compliance offset protocols and this chapter for calculating and reporting project baseline emissions, project emissions, GHG reductions, and GHG removal enhancements.
"Offset verification body" means a firm accredited or recognized by ecology, which is able to render an offset verification statement and provide offset verification services for offset project operators or authorized project designees subject to providing an offset project data report under this chapter.
"Offset verification services" means services provided during offset verification, including reviewing an offset project operator's or authorized project designee's offset project data report, verifying its accuracy according to the standards specified in WAC 173-446-535 and the applicable compliance offset protocol, assessing the offset project operator's or authorized project designee's compliance with this chapter and applicable compliance offset protocol, and submitting an offset verification statement to ecology or an offset project registry.
"Offset verification statement" means the final statement rendered by a verification body attesting whether an offset project operator's or authorized project designee's offset project data report is free of an offset material misstatement, and whether the offset project data report conforms to the requirements of this chapter and applicable compliance offset protocol, and containing the attestations required pursuant to this chapter.
"Offset verification team" means all parties working for a verification body, including all subcontractors, to provide offset verification services for an offset project operator or authorized project designee.
"Opt-in entity" means a party responsible for greenhouse gas emissions that is not a covered entity but voluntarily participates in the program as authorized under RCW 70A.65.090(3).
"Overburdened community" means a geographic area where vulnerable populations face combined, multiple environmental harms and health impacts or risks due to exposure to environmental pollutants or contaminants through multiple pathways, which may result in significant disparate adverse health outcomes or effects.
"Overburdened community" includes, but is not limited to:
(a) Highly impacted communities as defined in RCW 19.405.020;
(b) Communities located in census tracts that are fully or partially on "Indian country" as defined in 18 U.S.C. Sec. 1151; and
(c) Populations, including Native Americans or immigrant populations, who may be exposed to environmental contaminants and pollutants outside of the geographic area in which they reside based on the populations' use of traditional or cultural foods and practices, such as the use of resources, access to which is protected under treaty rights in ceded areas, when those exposures in conjunction with other exposures may result in disproportionately greater risks, including risks of certain cancers or other adverse health effects and outcomes.
(d) Overburdened communities identified by ecology shall include the same communities as those identified by ecology through its process for identifying overburdened communities under RCW 70A.02.010.
"Party" means an individual, person, firm, association, organization, partnership, business trust, corporation, limited liability company, company, or government agency.
"Permanent" means, in the context of offsets, either that GHG reductions and GHG removal enhancements are not reversible, or when GHG reductions and GHG removal enhancements may be reversible, that mechanisms are in place to replace any reversed GHG emission reductions and GHG removal enhancements to ensure that all credited reductions endure for at least the length of time specified in the associated offset protocol.
"Person" includes: An owner or operator of a facility; a supplier; or an electric power entity.
"Point of delivery" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Positive offset verification statement" means an offset verification statement rendered by a verification body attesting that the verification body can say with reasonable assurance that the submitted offset project data report is free of an offset material misstatement and that the offset project data report conforms to the requirements of this chapter and applicable compliance offset protocol.
"Price ceiling unit" means a unit issued at a fixed price by ecology for the purpose of limiting price increases and funding further investments in GHG reductions.
"Program" means the GHG emissions cap and invest program created by chapter 70A.65 RCW and implemented pursuant to this chapter.
"Program registry" means the data system in which covered entities, opt-in entities, and general market participants are registered and in which compliance instruments are recorded and tracked.
"Project baseline" means, in the context of a specific offset project, a conservative estimate of business-as-usual GHG emission reductions or GHG removal enhancements for the offset project's GHG emission sources, GHG sinks, or GHG reservoirs within the offset project boundary.
"Qualified positive offset verification statement" means an offset verification statement rendered by a verification body attesting that the verification body can say with reasonable assurance that the submitted offset project data report is free of an offset material misstatement, but the offset project data report may include one or more nonconformance(s) with this chapter and applicable compliance offset protocol which do not result in an offset material misstatement. Nonconformance, in this context, does not include disregarding the explicit requirements of this chapter or applicable compliance offset protocol and substituting alternative requirements not approved by ecology.
"Registered entity" means a covered entity, opt-in entity, or general market participant that has completed the process for registration in the program registry.
"Registration applicant" means a covered entity, opt-in entity, or general market participant that is applying to register in the program registry.
"Registry offset credit" means a credit issued by an offset project registry for a GHG reduction or GHG removal enhancement of one metric ton of CO2e.
"Reporter" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Reporting period" means, in the context of offsets, the period of time for which an offset project operator or authorized project designee quantifies and reports GHG reductions or GHG removal enhancements covered in an offset project data report. An offset project's reporting period is established in the project listing documentation, but may be modified pursuant to WAC 173-446-525(11).
"Retail electric load" has the same meaning as specified in RCW 19.405.020.
"Retire" means to permanently remove a compliance instrument such that the compliance instrument may never be sold, traded, used for compliance, or otherwise used again.
"Retirement account" means the account to which ecology transfers compliance instruments that have been surrendered for compliance.
"Sector" means an area of the economy in which a grouping of sources of greenhouse gas emissions share the same or related activity, product, or service.
"Sequestration" means the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and storage of carbon in GHG sinks or GHG reservoirs through physical or biological processes.
"Specified source of electricity" or "specified source" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Supplier" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Tier 1 price" means the lower of the two prices set by ecology for allowances auctioned from the allowance price containment reserve.
"Tier 2 price" means the higher of the two prices set by ecology for allowances auctioned from the allowance price containment reserve.
"Total program baseline" means the total of covered greenhouse gas emissions from covered entities as established in WAC 173-446-200.
"Tribal lands" has the same meaning as defined in RCW 70A.02.010.
"Unintentional reversal" means any reversal, including wildfires or disease, that is not the result of the forest owner's negligence, gross negligence, or willful intent.
"Unspecified source of electricity" or "unspecified source" has the same meaning as in chapter 173-441 WAC.
"Vintage year" means the annual allowance allocation budget year to which an individual Washington GHG allowance is assigned.
"Voluntary renewable reserve account" or "voluntary renewable electricity reserve account" means a holding account maintained by ecology from which allowances may be retired for voluntary renewable electricity generation, which is directly delivered to the state and has not and will not be sold or used to meet any other mandatory requirements in the state or any other jurisdiction, on behalf of voluntary renewable energy purchasers or end users.
AMENDATORY SECTION(Amending WSR 22-20-056, filed 9/29/22, effective 10/30/22)
WAC 173-446-040Covered emissions.
(1) Reported emissions. Covered emissions are GHG emissions reported under chapter 173-441 WAC except as modified in subsections (2) through (4) of this section. Covered emissions:
(a) Are calculated on a calendar year basis using chapter 173-441 WAC;
(b) Include emissions of all GHGs identified in WAC 173-441-040;
(c) Are expressed in units of CO2e as calculated using chapter 173-441 WAC; and
(d) Must be based on any assigned emissions level under WAC 173-441-086.
(2) Exemptions.
(a) Covered emissions do not include the following emissions reported under chapter 173-441 WAC:
(i) Carbon dioxide emissions from the combustion of biomass, renewable fuels of biogenic origin, or biofuels from any facility, supplier, or first jurisdictional deliverer. Emissions of other GHGs related to the combustion of biomass or biofuels are not exempt.
(ii) GHG emissions from the following facilities:
(A) A coal-fired electric generation facility exempted from additional GHG limitations, requirements, or performance standards under RCW 80.80.110; or
(B) Facilities with North American industry classification system code 92811 (national security).
(C) Municipal solid waste landfills that are subject to, and in compliance with, chapter 70A.540 RCW.
(iii) Sequestered carbon dioxide when it can be demonstrated to ecology's satisfaction that it qualifies as permanent sequestration, as defined in WAC 173-407-110, either through long-term geologic sequestration or by conversion into long-lived mineral form.
(b) The following supplier emissions are not covered emissions if the supplier can demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction as specified under WAC 173-441-122 (5)(d)(xi) that the emissions originate from:
(i) The combustion of the following fuels, if demonstrated to ecology's satisfaction that they are used for aviation purposes:
(A) Kerosene-type jet fuel; and
(B) Aviation gasoline.
(ii) Watercraft fuels supplied in Washington that are not combusted inside Washington or in waters under the jurisdiction of Washington:
(A) The following fuels may be assumed to be watercraft fuels combusted outside of waters under the jurisdiction of Washington:
(I) Residual fuel oil No. 5 (navy special); and
(II) Residual fuel oil No. 6 (a.k.a. bunker C).
(B) For all other fuels, including distillate No. 2 and distillate fuel oil No. 4, to qualify for this exemption, suppliers must demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction both that the fuels are used in watercraft and that they are combusted outside of waters under the jurisdiction of Washington.
(iii) Motor vehicle fuel or special fuel used exclusively for agricultural purposes by a farm fuel user as described in WAC 173-441-122 (5)(d)(xi)(C).
(iv) Fuels used for transporting agricultural products on public highways if it meets the requirements in RCW 82.08.865 as described in WAC 173-441-122 (5)(d)(xi)(C). This exemption is in effect for emissions years 2023 through 2027 and is not available for emissions after 2027.
(v) Products listed in Table MM-1 of 40 C.F.R. Part 98 Subpart MM as adopted in chapter 173-441 WAC when the supplier can demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction that the product is not combusted or oxidized. All products listed in Table MM-1, except asphalt and road oil, are by default assumed to be combusted or oxidized unless demonstrated otherwise.
(3) Allotment of covered emissions to avoid double counting or including emissions that occur outside the program. The facility, supplier, or first jurisdictional deliverer that reports GHG emissions under chapter 173-441 WAC holds the compliance obligation for the covered emissions it reports unless otherwise provided in this subsection. This subsection provides details on allotment for covered emissions that are potentially attributable to multiple parties and provides direction for allotment when such emissions may be reported by multiple facilities, suppliers, or first jurisdictional deliverers of electricity. This subsection only describes the process for determining which covered or opt-in entity is responsible for a given metric ton of covered emissions after the application of exemptions described in subsection (2) of this section, and does not expand the definition of covered emissions.
(a) Allotment of covered emissions for facilities.
(i) The following GHG emissions are covered emissions for facilities:
(A) Emissions from the on-site combustion of natural gas, natural gas liquids, liquefied petroleum gas, compressed natural gas, or liquefied natural gas;
(B) Emissions from the on-site combustion of residual fuel oil No. 5 (navy special), and residual fuel oil No. 6 (a.k.a. bunker C);
(C) Emissions from the on-site combustion of a fuel product where the fuel product was generated or modified on-site and not purchased in its combusted form from a supplier. These fuel products may include, but are not limited to: Refinery gas, still gas, fuel gas, landfill gas, and biogas;
(D) Carbon dioxide collected and supplied off-site that the facility owner or operator cannot demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction is part of the covered emissions of another covered or opt-in entity under this chapter.
(E) Emissions from an electric generating facility in Washington serving as a first jurisdictional deliverer derived from any of the means in (a)(i)(A) through (D) of this subsection except as exempted in subsection (2) of this section; and
(F) All other reported emissions under WAC 173-441-120 are covered emissions for the facility unless otherwise specified in subsection (2) of this section or (a)(ii) of this subsection.
(ii) The following GHG emissions are not covered emissions for facilities:
(A) Emissions from the on-site combustion of any fuel product as described in WAC 173-441-122(5) except those described in (a)(i)(A), (B) or (C) of this subsection;
(B) Carbon dioxide collected and supplied off-site that the facility owner or operator can demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction is part of the covered emissions of another covered or opt-in entity under this chapter.
(b) Allotment of covered emissions for suppliers of natural gas.
(i) The following GHG emissions are covered emissions for suppliers of natural gas:
(A) Emissions from the on-site combustion of natural gas, natural gas liquids, liquefied petroleum gas, compressed natural gas, or liquefied natural gas supplied to any facility or supplier of natural gas that is not a covered or opt-in entity under this chapter.
(B) All other reported emissions under WAC 173-441-122(4) are covered emissions for the supplier unless otherwise specified in subsection (2) of this section or (b)(ii) of this subsection.
(ii) The following GHG emissions are not covered emissions for suppliers of natural gas:
(A) Emissions from the on-site combustion of natural gas, natural gas liquids, liquefied petroleum gas, compressed natural gas, or liquefied natural gas supplied to any facility, supplier of natural gas, or other party that is a covered or opt-in entity under this chapter.
(B) Emissions that would result from the combustion of fuel products that are produced or imported with a documented final point of delivery outside of Washington and combusted outside of Washington.
(c) Allotment of covered emissions for suppliers of fossil fuels other than natural gas.
(i) The following GHG emissions are covered emissions for suppliers of fossil fuels other than natural gas:
(A) Emissions from the combustion of any fuel product, except those described in (a)(i)(B) or (C) of this subsection; or
(B) All other reported emissions under WAC 173-441-122(5) are covered emissions for the supplier of fossil fuel other than natural gas unless otherwise specified in subsection (2) of this section or (c)(ii) of this subsection.
(ii) The following GHG emissions are not covered emissions for suppliers of fossil fuels other than natural gas:
(A) Emissions from the combustion of fuel products described in (a)(i)(B) or (C) of this subsection;
(B) Emissions from products listed in Table MM-1 of 40 C.F.R. Part 98 Subpart MM as adopted in chapter 173-441 WAC when the supplier is also a refiner and can demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction that the product is used as a noncrude feedstock at a refinery in Washington under their operational control. These noncovered emissions must meet the standards described in Subpart MM, and are calculated using provisions described in Sec. 98.393(b) and subtracted as described in Sec. 98.393(d), which is limited to modifications due to noncrude feedstocks. Emissions occurring at the refinery due to processing the noncrude feedstock are part of the facility's covered emissions. Processed or unprocessed products associated with the previously excluded noncrude feedstocks leaving the refinery are no longer excluded and part of the supplier's covered emissions. Emissions covered under this provision are not also eligible for adjustments due to the product previously being delivered by a position holder or refiner out of an upstream WA terminal or refinery rack prior to delivery out of a second terminal rack.
(C) Emissions that would result from the combustion of fuel products that are produced or imported with a documented final point of delivery outside of Washington and combusted outside of Washington; or
(D) Emissions that are part of the covered emissions of another covered or opt-in entity under this chapter.
(d) Allotment of covered emissions for suppliers of carbon dioxide.
(i) The following GHG emissions are covered emissions for suppliers of carbon dioxide:
(A) Carbon dioxide emissions that the supplier cannot demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction are part of the covered emissions of another covered or opt-in entity under this chapter; or
(B) All other reported emissions under WAC 173-441-122(3) are covered emissions for the supplier of carbon dioxide unless otherwise specified in subsection (2) of this section or (d)(ii) of this subsection.
(ii) The following GHG emissions are not covered emissions for suppliers of carbon dioxide: Carbon dioxide emissions when the supplier can demonstrate to ecology's satisfaction that they are part of the covered emissions of another covered or opt-in entity under this chapter are not covered emissions for the supplier of carbon dioxide.
(e) Allotment of covered emissions for first jurisdictional deliverers of imported electricity.
(i) GHG emissions associated with imported electricity are covered emissions for the first jurisdictional deliverer serving as the electricity importer for that electricity. The electricity importer is identified through the definition and procedures in chapter 173-441 WAC.
(ii) If the electricity importer is a federal power marketing administration over which the state of Washington does not have jurisdiction, and the federal power marketing administration has not voluntarily elected to comply with the program, then the party deemed to be the electricity importer is the next purchasing-selling entity in the physical path on the NERC e-tag, or if there is no additional purchasing-selling entity over which the state of Washington has jurisdiction, then a utility that purchases electricity for use in the state of Washington from that federal power marketing administration or the generation balancing authority. Such a utility or generation balancing authority is a covered entity under this program and has the compliance obligation for the GHG emissions associated with that electricity.
(iii) If the electricity importer is a federal power marketing administration over which the state of Washington does not have jurisdiction, ((and)) the federal power marketing administration ((has))may voluntarily ((elected))elect to comply with the program((, then any utility that purchases electricity for use in the state of Washington from that federal power marketing administration may provide by agreement for the assumption of the compliance obligation by the federal power marketing administration. The department of ecology must be notified of such an agreement at least 12 months prior to the compliance period for which the agreement is applicable or, for the first compliance period, 12 months prior to the first calendar year to which the agreement is applicable))in accordance with the requirements of section 11, chapter 352, Laws of 2024, either for all sales into Washington, or for resources attributed into Washington in a centralized electricity market for which the federal power marketing administration is the deemed market importer. Upon the election taking effect ((of the agreement, the covered emissions for the utility are the responsibility of)), the federal power marketing administration ((as long as the agreement is in effect))will assume the compliance obligation for covered emissions consistent with its election. If no ((agreement is in place for a utility that purchases electricity from))such election has been made by that federal power marketing administration, then the requirements of subsection (e)(ii) of this section apply to the GHG emissions associated with that electricity.
(iv) For ((the first compliance period the electricity importer for electricity derived from the energy imbalance market is the energy imbalance market purchasing entity located or operating in Washington that receives the delivery of electricity transacted through the energy imbalance market. For electricity transferred through the energy imbalance market that is))electricity generated by ((a first jurisdictional deliverer with a compliance obligation under this chapter, there is no))an electric generating facility in Washington where the owner or operator of that facility successfully offers electricity into a centralized electricity market and is assigned, designated, deemed, or attributed to be serving Washington electric load by the methodologies, processes, or decision algorithms put in place by the market operator of that centralized electricity market, the compliance obligation for ((that same electricity if it is delivered to an energy imbalance market purchasing entity in Washington))the GHG emissions associated with that electricity is determined once, based on the emissions reported for that electricity under WAC 173-441-120.
(4) Adjustments to covered emissions. Ecology may adjust the covered emissions for any emissions year for a facility, supplier, or first jurisdictional deliverer based on new reported information, a new assigned emissions level under WAC 173-441-086, or to compensate for a change in methodology as described in WAC 173-441-050(4).