_______________________________________________

 

                       ENGROSSED SUBSTITUTE HOUSE BILL 2409

                  _______________________________________________

 

State of Washington              52nd Legislature             1992 Regular Session

 

By House Committee on Commerce & Labor (originally sponsored by Representatives Franklin, Heavey, Winsley, R. King, Jones, Orr, Jacobsen, Prentice, G. Cole, Day and Valle)

 

Read first time 02/03/92.  Changing requirements for public works contracts bid awards.


     AN ACT Relating to public works contracts; and amending RCW 35.22.620, 35.23.352, 36.32.250, 39.04.015, 39.04.155, 56.08.070, and 57.08.050.

 

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON:

 

     Sec. 1.  RCW 35.22.620 and 1989 c 431 s 59 are each amended to read as follows:

     (1) As used in this section, the term "public works" means as defined in RCW 39.04.010.

     (2) A first class city may have public works performed by contract pursuant to public notice and call for competitive bids.  As limited by subsection (3) of this section, a first class city may have public works performed by city employees in any annual or biennial budget period equal to a dollar value not exceeding ten percent of the public works construction budget, including any amount in a supplemental public works construction budget, over the budget period.  The amount of public works that a first class city has a county perform for it under RCW 35.77.020 shall be included within this ten percent limitation.

     If a first class city has public works performed by public employees in any budget period that are in excess of this ten percent limitation, the amount in excess of the permitted amount shall be reduced from the otherwise permitted amount of public works that may be performed by public employees for that city in its next budget period.  Twenty percent of the motor vehicle fuel tax distributions to that city shall be withheld if two years after the year in which the excess amount of work occurred, the city has failed to so reduce the amount of public works that it has performed by public employees.  The amount so withheld shall be distributed to the city when it has demonstrated in its reports to the state auditor that the amount of public works it has performed by public employees has been so reduced.

     Whenever a first class city has had public works performed in any budget period up to the maximum permitted amount for that budget period, all remaining public works within that budget period shall be done by contract pursuant to public notice and call for competitive bids.

     The state auditor shall report to the state treasurer any first class city that exceeds this amount and the extent to which the city has or has not reduced the amount of public works it has performed by public employees in subsequent years.

     (3) In addition to the percentage limitation provided in subsection (2) of this section, a first class city with a population in excess of one hundred fifty thousand shall not have public employees perform a public works project in excess of fifty thousand dollars if more than a single craft or trade is involved with the public works project, or a public works project in excess of twenty-five thousand dollars if only a single craft or trade is involved with the public works project or the public works project is street signalization or street lighting.  In addition to the percentage limitation provided in subsection (2) of this section, a first class city with a population of one hundred fifty thousand or less shall not have public employees perform a public works project in excess of thirty-five thousand dollars if more than one craft or trade is involved with the public works project, or a public works project in excess of twenty thousand dollars if only a single craft or trade is involved with the public works project or the public works project is street signalization or street lighting.  A public works project means a complete project.  The restrictions in this subsection do not permit the division of the project into units of work or classes of work to avoid the restriction on work that may be performed by day labor on a single project.

     (4) In addition to the accounting and record-keeping requirements contained in RCW 39.04.070, every first class city annually shall prepare a report for the state auditor indicating the total public works construction budget and supplemental public works construction budget for that year, the total construction costs of public works performed by public employees for that year, and the amount of public works that is performed by public employees above or below ten percent of the total construction budget.  However, if a city budgets on a biennial basis, this annual report shall indicate the amount of public works that is performed by public employees within the current biennial period that is above or below ten percent of the total biennial construction budget.

     After September 1, 1987, each first class city with a population of one hundred fifty thousand or less shall use the form required by RCW 43.09.205 to account and record costs of public works in excess of five thousand dollars that are not let by contract.

     (5) The cost of a separate public works project shall be the costs of materials, supplies, equipment, and labor on the construction of that project.  The value of the public works budget shall be the value of all the separate public works projects within the budget.

     (6) When any emergency shall require the immediate execution of such public work, upon the finding of the existence of such emergency by the authority having power to direct such public work to be done and duly entered of record, publication of description and estimate may be made within seven days after the commencement of the work.  Within two weeks of the finding that such an emergency existed, the city council shall adopt a resolution certifying the existence of this emergency situation.

     (7) In lieu of the procedures of subsections (2) and (6) of this section, a first class city may use a small works roster and award contracts under this subsection for contracts of one hundred thousand dollars or less.

     (a) The city may maintain a small works roster comprised of all contractors who have requested to be on the roster and are, where required by law, properly licensed or registered to perform such work in this state.

     (b) Whenever work is done by contract, the estimated cost of which is one hundred thousand dollars or less, and the city uses the small works roster, the city shall invite proposals from all appropriate contractors on the small works roster:  PROVIDED, That not less than five separate appropriate contractors, if available, shall be invited to submit bids on any one contract:  PROVIDED FURTHER, That whenever possible, the city shall invite at least one proposal from a minority or woman contractor who shall otherwise qualify under this section.  Once a bidder on the small works roster has been offered an opportunity to bid, that bidder shall not be offered another opportunity until all other appropriate contractors on the small works roster have been afforded an opportunity to submit a bid.  Invitations shall include an estimate of the scope and nature of the work to be performed, and materials and equipment to be furnished.

     (c) When awarding such a contract for work, the estimated cost of which is one hundred thousand dollars or less, the city shall award the contract to the contractor submitting the lowest responsible bid.  In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the city shall give consideration to:

     (i) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications; and

     (ii) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.

     (8) The allocation of public works projects to be performed by city employees shall not be subject to a collective bargaining agreement.

     (9) This section does not apply to performance-based contracts, as defined in RCW 39.35A.020(3), that are negotiated under chapter 39.35A RCW.

     (10) Nothing in this section shall prohibit any first class city from allowing for preferential purchase of products made from recycled materials or products that may be recycled or reused.

 

     Sec. 2.  RCW 35.23.352 and 1989 c 431 s 56 are each amended to read as follows:

     (1) Any second or third class city or any town may construct any public works, as defined in RCW 39.04.010, by contract or day labor without calling for bids therefor whenever the estimated cost of the work or improvement, including cost of materials, supplies and equipment will not exceed the sum of thirty thousand dollars if more than one craft or trade is involved with the public works, or twenty thousand dollars if a single craft or trade is involved with the public works or the public works project is street signalization or street lighting.  A public works project means a complete project.  The restrictions in this subsection do not permit the division of the project into units of work or classes of work to avoid the restriction on work that may be performed by day labor on a single project.

     Whenever the cost of the public work or improvement, including materials, supplies and equipment, will exceed these figures, the same shall be done by contract.  All such contracts shall be let at public bidding upon posting notice calling for sealed bids upon the work.  The notice thereof shall be posted in a public place in the city or town and by publication in the official newspaper, or a newspaper of general circulation most likely to bring responsive bids, once each week for two consecutive weeks before the date fixed for opening the bids.  The notice shall generally state the nature of the work to be done that plans and specifications therefor shall then be on file in the city or town hall for public inspections, and require that bids be sealed and filed with the council or commission within the time specified therein.  Each bid shall be accompanied by a bid proposal deposit in the form of a cashier's check, postal money order, or surety bond to the council or commission for a sum of not less than five percent of the amount of the bid, and no bid shall be considered unless accompanied by such bid proposal deposit.  The council or commission of the city or town shall let the contract to the lowest responsible bidder or shall have power by resolution to reject any or all bids and to make further calls for bids in the same manner as the original call.  In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the city shall give consideration to:

     (a) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications;

     (b) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.

     When the contract is let then all bid proposal deposits shall be returned to the bidders except that of the successful bidder which shall be retained until a contract is entered into and a bond to perform the work furnished, with surety satisfactory to the council or commission, in the full amount of the contract price.  If the bidder fails to enter into the contract in accordance with his bid and furnish a bond within ten days from the date at which he is notified that he is the successful bidder, the check or postal money order and the amount thereof shall be forfeited to the council or commission or the council or commission shall recover the amount of the surety bond.

     If no bid is received on the first call the council or commission may readvertise and make a second call, or may enter into a contract without any further call or may purchase the supplies, material or equipment and perform the work or improvement by day labor.

     (2) The allocation of public works projects to be performed by city or town employees shall not be subject to a collective bargaining agreement.

     (3) In lieu of the procedures of subsection (1) of this section, a second or third class city or a town may use a small works roster and award contracts under this subsection for contracts of one hundred thousand dollars or less.

     (a) The city or town may maintain a small works roster comprised of all contractors who have requested to be on the roster and are, where required by law, properly licensed or registered to perform such work in this state.

     (b) Whenever work is done by contract, the estimated cost of which is one hundred thousand dollars or less, and the city uses the small works roster, the city or town shall invite proposals from all appropriate contractors on the small works roster:  PROVIDED, That whenever possible, the city or town shall invite at least one proposal from a minority or woman contractor who shall otherwise qualify under this section.  The invitation shall include an estimate of the scope and nature of the work to be performed, and materials and equipment to be furnished.

     (c) When awarding such a contract for work, the estimated cost of which is one hundred thousand dollars or less, the city or town shall award the contract to the contractor submitting the lowest responsible bid.

     (4) After September 1, 1987, each second class city, third class city, and town shall use the form required by RCW 43.09.205 to account and record costs of public works in excess of five thousand dollars that are not let by contract.

     (5) The cost of a separate public works project shall be the costs of the materials, equipment, supplies, and labor on that construction project.

     (6) Any purchase of supplies, material, equipment or services other than professional services, except for public work or improvement, where the cost thereof exceeds seven thousand five hundred dollars shall be made upon call for bids:  PROVIDED, That the limitations herein shall not apply to any purchases of materials at auctions conducted by the government of the United States, any agency thereof or by the state of Washington or a political subdivision thereof.

     (7) Bids shall be called annually and at a time and in the manner prescribed by ordinance for the publication in a newspaper published or of general circulation in the city or town of all notices or newspaper publications required by law.  The contract shall be awarded to the lowest responsible bidder.

     (8) For advertisement and competitive bidding to be dispensed with as to purchases between seven thousand five hundred and fifteen thousand dollars, the city legislative authority must authorize by resolution a procedure for securing telephone and/or written quotations from enough vendors to assure establishment of a competitive price and for awarding the contracts for purchase of materials, equipment, or services to the lowest responsible bidder.  Immediately after the award is made, the bid quotations obtained shall be recorded and open to public inspection and shall be available by telephone inquiry.

     (9) These requirements for purchasing may be waived by resolution of the city or town council which declared that the purchase is clearly and legitimately limited to a single source or supply within the near vicinity, or the materials, supplies, equipment, or services are subject to special market conditions, and recites why this situation exists.  Such actions are subject to RCW 39.30.020.

     (10) This section does not apply to performance-based contracts, as defined in RCW 39.35A.020(3), that are negotiated under chapter 39.35A RCW.

     (11) Nothing in this section shall prohibit any second or third class city or any town from allowing for preferential purchase of products made from recycled materials or products that may be recycled or reused.

 

     Sec. 3.  RCW 36.32.250 and 1991 c 363 s 58 are each amended to read as follows:

     No contract for public works may be entered into by the county legislative authority or by any elected or appointed officer of the county until after bids have been submitted to the county upon specifications therefor.  Such specifications shall be in writing and shall be filed with the clerk of the county legislative authority for public inspection.  An advertisement shall be published in the county official newspaper stating the time and place where bids will be opened, the time after which bids will not be received, the character of the work to be done, the materials and equipment to be furnished, and that specifications therefor may be seen at the office of the clerk of the county legislative authority.  An advertisement shall also be published in a legal newspaper of general circulation in or as near as possible to that part of the county in which such work is to be done.  If the county official newspaper is a newspaper of general circulation covering at least forty percent of the residences in that part of the county in which such public works are to be done, then the publication of an advertisement of the applicable specifications in the county official newspaper shall be sufficient.  Such advertisements shall be published at least once at least ten days prior to the last date upon which bids will be received.  The bids shall be in writing, shall be filed with the clerk, shall be opened and read in public at the time and place named therefor in the advertisements, and after being opened, shall be filed for public inspection.  No bid may be considered for public work unless it is accompanied by a bid deposit in the form of a surety bond, postal money order, cash, cashier's check, or certified check in an amount equal to five percent of the amount of the bid proposed.  The contract for the public work shall be awarded to the lowest responsible bidder.  In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the county shall give consideration to:

     (1) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications; and

     (2) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.

     Any or all bids may be rejected for good cause.  The county legislative authority shall require from the successful bidder for such public work a contractor's bond in the amount and with the conditions imposed by law.  If the bidder to whom the contract is awarded fails to enter into the contract and furnish the contractor's bond as required within ten days after notice of the award, exclusive of the day of notice, the amount of the bid deposit shall be forfeited to the county and the contract awarded to the next lowest and best bidder.  The bid deposit of all unsuccessful bidders shall be returned after the contract is awarded and the required contractor's bond given by the successful bidder is accepted by the county legislative authority.  In the letting of any contract involving less than ten thousand dollars, advertisement and competitive bidding may be dispensed with on order of the county legislative authority.  Immediately after the award is made, the bid quotations obtained shall be recorded and open to public inspection and shall be available by telephone inquiry.

     For advertisement and competitive bidding to be dispensed with as to public works projects with an estimated value of one hundred thousand dollars or less, a county must use a small works roster process as provided in RCW 39.04.155.

     This section does not apply to performance-based contracts, as defined in RCW 39.35A.020(3), that are negotiated under chapter 39.35A RCW.

 

     Sec. 4.  RCW 39.04.015 and 1989 c 59 s 1 are each amended to read as follows:

     Notwithstanding the provisions of RCW 39.04.010, a state contracting authority is authorized to negotiate an adjustment to a bid price, based upon agreed changes to the contract plans and specifications, with a low responsive and responsible bidder under the following conditions:

     (1) All bids for a state public works project involving buildings and any associated building utilities and appendants exceed the available funds, as certified by the appropriate fiscal officer;

     (2) The ((apparent low responsive)) bid does not exceed the available funds by:  (a) Five percent on projects valued under one million dollars; (b) the greater of fifty thousand dollars or two and one-half percent for projects valued between one million dollars and five million dollars; or (c) the greater of one hundred twenty-five thousand dollars or one percent for projects valued over five million dollars; ((and))

     (3) The negotiated adjustment will bring the bid price within the amount of available funds((.)); and

     (4) In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the state contracting authority shall give consideration to:

     (a) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications; and

     (b) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.

 

     Sec. 5.  RCW 39.04.155 and 1991 c 363 s 109 are each amended to read as follows:

     (1) This section provides a uniform process to award contracts for public works projects by those counties that are authorized to use a small works roster in lieu of the requirements for formal sealed bidding.  The state statutes governing counties shall establish the maximum dollar thresholds of the contracts that can be awarded under this process, and may include other matters concerning the small works roster process, for the county.

     (2) Counties may create a single general small works roster, or may create a small works roster for different categories of anticipated work.  The small works roster or rosters shall consist of all responsible contractors who have requested to be on the list, and where required by law are properly licensed or registered to perform such work in this state.  At least once a year, the county shall publish in a newspaper of general circulation within the jurisdiction a notice of the existence of the roster or rosters and solicit the names of contractors for such roster or rosters.

     The governing body of the county shall establish a procedure for securing telephone or written quotations from the contractors on the general small works roster, or a specific small works roster for the appropriate category of work, to assure that a competitive price is established and to award contracts to the lowest responsible bidder((, as defined in RCW 43.19.1911)).  In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the county shall give consideration to:

     (a) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications; and

     (b) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.

     Such invitations for quotations shall include an estimate of the scope and nature of the work to be performed as well as materials and equipment to be furnished.  Whenever possible at least five contractors shall be invited to submit bids.  Once a contractor has been afforded an opportunity to submit a proposal, that contractor shall not be offered another opportunity until all other appropriate contractors on the small works roster have been afforded an opportunity to submit a proposal on a contract.

     A contract awarded from a small works roster under this section need not be advertised.

     Immediately after an award is made, the bid quotations obtained shall be recorded, open to public inspection, and available by telephone inquiry.

 

     Sec. 6.  RCW 56.08.070 and 1989 c 105 s 1 are each amended to read as follows:

     (1) All materials purchased and work ordered, the estimated cost of which is in excess of five thousand dollars shall be let by contract.  All contract projects, the estimated cost of which is less than fifty thousand dollars, may be awarded to a contractor on the small works roster.  The small works roster shall be comprised of all responsible contractors who have requested to be on the list.  The board of sewer commissioners may set up uniform procedures to prequalify contractors for inclusion on the small works roster.  The board of sewer commissioners shall authorize by resolution a procedure for securing telephone and/or written quotations from the contractors on the small works roster to assure establishment of a competitive price and for awarding contracts to the lowest responsible bidder.  Such procedure shall require that a good faith effort be made to request quotations from all contractors on the small works roster.  Immediately after an award is made, the bid quotations obtained shall be recorded, open to public inspection, and available by telephone inquiry.  The small works roster shall be revised once a year.  All contract projects equal to or in excess of fifty thousand dollars shall be let by competitive bidding.  Before awarding any competitive contract the board of sewer commissioners shall cause a notice to be published in a newspaper in general circulation where the district is located at least once, ten days before the letting of such contract, inviting sealed proposals for such work, plans and specifications which must at the time of publication of such notice be on file in the office of the board of sewer commissioners subject to public inspection.  Such notice shall state generally the work to be done and shall call for proposals for doing the same to be sealed and filed with the board of sewer commissioners on or before the day and hour named therein.

     (2) Each bid shall be accompanied by a bid proposal deposit in the form of a certified check, cashier's check, postal money order, or surety bond payable to the order of the county treasurer for a sum not less than five percent of the amount of the bid and no bid shall be considered unless accompanied by such bid proposal deposit.  At the time and place named such bids shall be publicly opened and read and the board of sewer commissioners shall proceed to canvass the bids and may let such contract to the lowest responsible bidder upon plans and specifications:  PROVIDED, That no contract shall be let in excess of the cost of said materials or work, or if in the opinion of the board of sewer commissioners all bids are unsatisfactory they may reject all of them and readvertise and in such case all checks, cash or bid bonds shall be returned to the bidders.  If such contract be let, then all checks, cash or bid bonds shall be returned to the bidders, except that of the successful bidder, which shall be retained until a contract shall be entered into for the purchase of such materials or doing such work, and a bond to perform such work furnished with sureties satisfactory to the board of sewer commissioners in the full amount of the contract price between the bidder and the commission in accordance with bid.  If said bidder fails to enter into said contract in accordance with said bid and furnish such bond within ten days from the date at which he is notified that he is the successful bidder, the said check, cash or bid bonds and the amount thereof shall be forfeited to the sewer district.

     (3) In the event of an emergency when the public interest or property of the sewer district would suffer material injury or damage by delay, upon resolution of the board of sewer commissioners, or proclamation of an official designated by the board to act for the board during such emergencies, declaring the existence of such emergency and reciting the facts constituting the same, the board, or the official acting for the board, may waive the requirements of this chapter with reference to any purchase or contract.  In addition, these requirements may be waived for purchases which are clearly and legitimately limited to a single source of supply and purchases involving special facilities, services, or market conditions, in which instances the purchase price may be best established by direct negotiation.

     (4) In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the board of sewer commissioners shall give consideration to:

     (a) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications; and

     (b) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.

 

     Sec. 7.  RCW 57.08.050 and 1989 c 105 s 2 are each amended to read as follows:

     (1) The board of water commissioners shall have authority to create and fill such positions and fix salaries and bonds thereof as it may by resolution provide.

     (2) All materials purchased and work ordered, the estimated cost of which is in excess of five thousand dollars shall be let by contract.  All contract projects, the estimated cost of which is less than fifty thousand dollars, may be awarded to a contractor on the small works roster.  The small works roster shall be comprised of all responsible contractors who have requested to be on the list.  The board of water commissioners may set up uniform procedures to prequalify contractors for inclusion on the small works roster.  The board of water commissioners shall authorize by resolution a procedure for securing telephone and/or written quotations from the contractors on the small works roster to assure establishment of a competitive price and for awarding contracts to the lowest responsible bidder.  Such procedure shall require that a good faith effort be made to request quotations from all contractors on the small works roster.  Immediately after an award is made, the bid quotations obtained shall be recorded, open to public inspection, and available by telephone inquiry.  The small works roster shall be revised once a year.  All contract projects equal to or in excess of fifty thousand dollars shall be let by competitive bidding.  Before awarding any such contract the board of water commissioners shall cause a notice to be published in a newspaper in general circulation where the district is located at least once ten days before the letting of such contract, inviting sealed proposals for such work, plans and specifications which must at the time of publication of such notice be on file in the office of the board of water commissioners subject to public inspection.  Such notice shall state generally the work to be done and shall call for proposals for doing the same to be sealed and filed with the board of water commissioners on or before the day and hour named therein.

     (3) Each bid shall be accompanied by a certified or cashier's check or postal money order payable to the order of the county treasurer for a sum not less than five percent of the amount of the bid, or accompanied by a bid bond in an amount not less than five percent of the bid with a corporate surety licensed to do business in the state, conditioned that the bidder will pay the district as liquidated damages the amount specified in the bond, unless he enters into a contract in accordance with his bid, and no bid shall be considered unless accompanied by such check, cash or bid bond.  At the time and place named such bids shall be publicly opened and read and the board of water commissioners shall proceed to canvass the bids and may let such contract to the lowest responsible bidder upon plans and specifications on file or to the best bidder submitting his own plans and specifications:  PROVIDED, That no contract shall be let in excess of the cost of said materials or work, or if in the opinion of the board of water commissioners all bids are unsatisfactory they may reject all of them and readvertise and in such case all checks, cash or bid bonds shall be returned to the bidders.  If such contract be let, then all checks, cash or bid bonds shall be returned to the bidders, except that of the successful bidder, which shall be retained until a contract shall be entered into for the purchase of such materials or doing such work, and a bond to perform such work furnished with sureties satisfactory to the board of water commissioners in the full amount of the contract price between the bidder and the commission in accordance with the bid.  If said bidder fails to enter into said contract in accordance with said bid and furnish such bond within ten days from the date at which he is notified that he is the successful bidder, the said check, cash or bid bonds and the amount thereof shall be forfeited to the water district:  PROVIDED, That if the bidder fails to enter into a contract in accordance with his bid, and the board of water commissioners deems it necessary to take legal action to collect on any bid bond required herein, then the water district shall be entitled to collect from said bidder any legal expenses, including reasonable attorneys' fees occasioned thereby.

     (4) In the event of an emergency when the public interest or property of the water district would suffer material injury or damage by delay, upon resolution of the board of water commissioners, or proclamation of an official designated by the board to act for the board during such emergencies, declaring the existence of such emergency and reciting the facts constituting the same, the board, or official acting for the board, may waive the requirements of this chapter with reference to any purchase or contract.  In addition, these requirements may be waived for purchases which are clearly and legitimately limited to a single source of supply and purchases involving special facilities, services, or market conditions, in which instances the purchase price may be best established by direct negotiation.

     (5) In determining the lowest responsible bidder, in addition to price, the board of water commissioners shall give consideration to:

     (a) The ability of the contractor to complete the contract within the prescribed schedule outlined in the contract specifications; and

     (b) The compliance of the contractor with federal, state, and local laws pertaining to the contract.