S-1650.2          _______________________________________________

 

                            SUBSTITUTE SENATE BILL 5452

                  _______________________________________________

 

State of Washington              52nd Legislature             1991 Regular Session

 

By Senate Committee on Children & Family Services (originally sponsored by Senators Roach and Stratton; by request of Dept. of Social & Health Services).

 

Read first time March 6, 1991.Revising provisions for public assistance.


     AN ACT Relating to clarification of existing public assistance statutes; amending RCW 74.04.005, 74.04.055, 74.04.500, and 74.04.515; adding a new chapter to Title 74 RCW; and repealing RCW 74.04.390, 74.04.400, 74.04.410, 74.04.420, 74.04.430, 74.04.440, 74.04.450, 74.04.460, 74.04.470, 74.04.473, 74.04.477, 74.04.505, 74.22.010, 74.22.020, 74.22.030, 74.22.040, 74.22.050, 74.22.060, 74.22.070, 74.22.080, 74.22.090, 74.22.100, 74.22.110, 74.22.120, 74.23.005, 74.23.010, 74.23.020, 74.23.030, 74.23.040, 74.23.050, 74.23.060, 74.23.070, 74.23.080, 74.23.090, 74.23.100, 74.23.110, 74.23.120, and 74.23.900.

 

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON:

 

     Sec. 1.  RCW 74.04.005 and 1990 c 285 s 2 are each amended to read as follows:

     For the purposes of this title, unless the context indicates otherwise, the following definitions shall apply:

     (1) "Public assistance" or "assistance"--Public aid to persons in need thereof for any cause, including services, medical care, assistance grants, disbursing orders, work relief, general assistance and federal-aid assistance.

     (2) "Department"--The department of social and health services.

     (3) "County or local office"--The administrative office for one or more counties or designated service areas.

     (4) "Director" or "secretary" means the secretary of social and health services.

     (5) "Federal-aid assistance"--The specific categories of assistance for which provision is made in any federal law existing or hereafter passed by which payments are made from the federal government to the state in aid or in respect to payment by the state for public assistance rendered to any category of needy persons for which provision for federal funds or aid may from time to time be made, or a federally administered needs-based program.

     (6) (a) "General assistance"--Aid to persons in need who:

     (i) Are not eligible to receive federal-aid assistance, other than food stamps and medical assistance; however, an individual who refuses or fails to cooperate in obtaining federal-aid assistance, without good cause, is not eligible for general assistance;

     (ii) Are either:

     (A) Pregnant:  PROVIDED, That need is based on the current income and resource requirements of the federal aid to families with dependent children program:  PROVIDED FURTHER, That during any period in which an aid for dependent children employable program is not in operation, only those pregnant women who are categorically eligible for medicaid are eligible for general assistance; or

     (B) Incapacitated from gainful employment by reason of bodily or mental infirmity that will likely continue for a minimum of sixty days as determined by the department.  Persons who are unemployable due to alcohol or drug addiction are not eligible for general assistance.  Persons receiving general assistance on July 26, 1987, or becoming eligible for such assistance thereafter, due to an alcohol or drug-related incapacity, shall be referred to appropriate assessment, treatment, shelter, or supplemental security income referral services as authorized under chapter 74.50 RCW.  Referrals shall be made at the time of application or at the time of eligibility review.  Alcoholic and drug addicted clients who are receiving general assistance on July 26, 1987, may remain on general assistance if they otherwise retain their eligibility until they are assessed for services under chapter 74.50 RCW.  This subsection (6)(a)(ii)(B) shall not be construed to prohibit the department from granting general assistance benefits to alcoholics and drug addicts who are incapacitated due to other physical or mental conditions that meet the eligibility criteria for the general assistance program;

     (iii) Are citizens or aliens lawfully admitted for permanent residence or otherwise residing in the United States under color of law; and

     (iv) Have furnished the department their social security account number.  If the social security account number cannot be furnished because it has not been issued or is not known, an application for a number shall be made prior to authorization of assistance, and the social security number shall be provided to the department upon receipt.

     (b) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (6)(a)(i), (ii), and (c) of this section, general assistance shall be provided to the following recipients of federal-aid assistance:

     (i) Recipients of supplemental security income whose need, as defined in this section, is not met by such supplemental security income grant because of separation from a spouse; or

     (ii) To the extent authorized by the legislature in the biennial appropriations act, to recipients of aid to families with dependent children whose needs are not being met because of a temporary reduction in monthly income below the entitled benefit payment level caused by loss or reduction of wages or unemployment compensation benefits or some other unforeseen circumstances.  The amount of general assistance authorized shall not exceed the difference between the entitled benefit payment level and the amount of income actually received.

     (c) General assistance shall be provided only to persons who are not members of assistance units receiving federal aid assistance, except as provided in subsection (6)(a)(ii)(A) and (b) of this section, and will accept available services which can reasonably be expected to enable the person to work or reduce the need for assistance unless there is good cause to refuse.  Failure to accept such services shall result in termination until the person agrees to cooperate in accepting such services and subject to the following maximum periods of ineligibility after reapplication:

     (i) First failure:  One week;

     (ii) Second failure within six months:  One month;

     (iii) Third and subsequent failure within one year:  Two months.

     (d) The department shall adopt by rule medical criteria for general assistance eligibility to ensure that eligibility decisions are consistent with statutory requirements and are based on clear, objective medical information.

     (e) The process implementing the medical criteria shall involve consideration of opinions of the treating or consulting physicians or health care professionals regarding incapacity, and any eligibility decision which rejects uncontroverted medical opinion must set forth clear and convincing reasons for doing so.

     (f) Recipients of general assistance based upon a finding of incapacity from gainful employment who remain otherwise eligible shall not have their benefits terminated absent a clear showing of material improvement in their medical or mental condition or specific error in the prior determination that found the recipient eligible by reason of incapacitation. Recipients of general assistance based upon pregnancy who relinquish their child for adoption, remain otherwise eligible, and ((who)) are not eligible to receive benefits under the federal aid to families with dependent children program shall not have their benefits terminated until the end of the month in which the period of six weeks following the birth of the recipient's child falls.  Recipients of the federal aid to families with dependent children program who lose their eligibility solely because of the birth and relinquishment of the qualifying child may receive general assistance through the end of the month in which the period of six weeks following the birth of the child falls.

     (7) "Applicant"--Any person who has made a request, or on behalf of whom a request has been made, to any county or local office for assistance.

     (8) "Recipient"--Any person receiving assistance and in addition those dependents whose needs are included in the recipient's assistance.

     (9) "Standards of assistance"--The level of income required by an applicant or recipient to maintain a level of living specified by the department.

     (10) "Resource"--Any asset, tangible or intangible, owned by or available to the applicant at the time of application, which can be applied toward meeting the applicant's need, either directly or by conversion into money or its equivalent:  PROVIDED, That an applicant may retain the following described resources and not be ineligible for public assistance because of such resources.

     (a) A home, which is defined as real property owned and used by an applicant or recipient as a place of residence, together with a reasonable amount of property surrounding and contiguous thereto, which is used by and useful to the applicant.  Whenever a recipient shall cease to use such property for residential purposes, either for himself or his dependents, the property shall be considered as a resource which can be made available to meet need, and if the recipient or his dependents absent themselves from the home for a period of ninety consecutive days such absence, unless due to hospitalization or health reasons or a natural disaster, shall raise a rebuttable presumption of abandonment:  PROVIDED, That if in the opinion of three physicians the recipient will be unable to return to the home during his lifetime, and the home is not occupied by a spouse or dependent children or disabled sons or daughters, such property shall be considered as a resource which can be made available to meet need.

     (b) Household furnishings and personal effects and other personal property having great sentimental value to the applicant or recipient, as limited by the department consistent with limitations on resources and exemptions for federal aid assistance.

     (c) A motor vehicle, other than a motor home, used and useful having an equity value not to exceed one thousand five hundred dollars.

     (d) All other resources, including any excess of values exempted, not to exceed one thousand dollars or other limit as set by the department, to be consistent with limitations on resources and exemptions necessary for federal aid assistance.

     (e) Applicants for or recipients of general assistance may retain the following described resources in addition to exemption for a motor vehicle or home and not be ineligible for public assistance because of such resources:

     (i) Household furnishings, personal effects, and other personal property having great sentimental value to the applicant or recipient;

     (ii) Term and burial insurance for use of the applicant or recipient;

     (iii) Life insurance having a cash surrender value not exceeding one thousand five hundred dollars; and

     (iv) Cash, marketable securities, and any excess of values above one thousand five hundred dollars equity in a vehicle and above one thousand five hundred dollars in cash surrender value of life insurance, not exceeding one thousand five hundred dollars for a single person or two thousand two hundred fifty dollars for a family unit of two or more.  The one thousand dollar limit in subsection (10)(d) of this section does not apply to recipients of or applicants for general assistance.

     (f) If an applicant for or recipient of public assistance possesses property and belongings in excess of the ceiling value, such value shall be used in determining the need of the applicant or recipient, except that:  (i) The department may exempt resources or income when the income and resources are determined necessary to the applicant's or recipient's restoration to independence, to decrease the need for public assistance, or to aid in rehabilitating the applicant or recipient or a dependent of the applicant or recipient; and (ii) the department may provide grant assistance for a period not to exceed nine months from the date the agreement is signed pursuant to this section to persons who are otherwise ineligible because of excess real property owned by such persons when they are making a good faith effort to dispose of that property((, but the recipient must sign an agreement to dispose of the property and repay assistance payments made to the date of disposition of the property which would not have been made had the disposal occurred at the beginning of the period for which the payments of such assistance were made.  In no event shall such amount due the state exceed the net proceeds otherwise available to the recipient from the disposition, unless after nine months from the date of the agreement the property has not been sold, or if the recipient's eligibility for financial assistance ceases for any other reason.  In these two instances the entire amount of assistance paid during this period will be treated as an overpayment and a debt due the state, and may be recovered pursuant to RCW 43.20B.630)):  PROVIDED, That:

     (A) The applicant or recipient shall sign an agreement to repay the lesser of the amount of aid received or the net proceeds of such sale;

     (B) If the owner of the excess property ceases to make good faith efforts to sell the property, the entire amount of assistance may become an overpayment and a debt due the state, and may be recovered pursuant to RCW 43.20B.630;

     (C) Applicants and recipients shall be advised of their right to a fair hearing and afforded the opportunity to challenge a decision that good faith efforts to sell have ceased, prior to assessment of an overpayment under this section; and

     (D) At the time assistance is authorized, the department shall file a lien without a sum certain on the specific property.

     (11) "Income"--(a) All appreciable gains in real or personal property (cash or kind) or other assets, which are received by or become available for use and enjoyment by an applicant or recipient during the month of application or after applying for or receiving public assistance.  The department may by rule and regulation exempt income received by an applicant for or recipient of public assistance which can be used by him to decrease his need for public assistance or to aid in rehabilitating him or his dependents, but such exemption shall not, unless otherwise provided in this title, exceed the exemptions of resources granted under this chapter to an applicant for public assistance.  In determining the amount of assistance to which an applicant or recipient of aid to families with dependent children is entitled, the department is hereby authorized to disregard as a resource or income the earned income exemptions consistent with federal requirements.  The department may permit the above exemption of earnings of a child to be retained by such child to cover the cost of special future identifiable needs even though the total exceeds the exemptions or resources granted to applicants and recipients of public assistance, but consistent with federal requirements.  In formulating rules and regulations pursuant to this chapter, the department shall define income and resources and the availability thereof, consistent with federal requirements.  All resources and income not specifically exempted, and any income or other economic benefit derived from the use of, or appreciation in value of, exempt resources, shall be considered in determining the need of an applicant or recipient of public assistance.

     (b) If, under applicable federal requirements, the state has the option of considering property in the form of lump sum compensatory awards or related settlements received by an applicant or

recipient as income or as a resource, the department shall consider such property to be a resource.

     (12) "Need"--The difference between the applicant's or recipient's standards of assistance for himself and the dependent members of his family, as measured by the standards of the department, and value of all nonexempt resources and nonexempt income received by or available to the applicant or recipient and the dependent members of his family.

     (13) For purposes of determining eligibility for public assistance and participation levels in the cost of medical care, the department shall exempt restitution payments made to people of Japanese and Aleut ancestry pursuant to the Civil Liberties Act of 1988 and the Aleutian and Pribilof Island Restitution Act passed by congress, P.L. 100-383, including all income and resources derived therefrom.

     (14)  In the construction of words and phrases used in this title, the singular number shall include the plural, the masculine gender shall include both the feminine and neuter genders and the present tense shall include the past and future tenses, unless the context thereof shall clearly indicate to the contrary.

 

     Sec. 2.  RCW 74.04.055 and 1979 c 141 s 298 are each amended to read as follows:

     In furtherance of the policy of this state to cooperate with the federal government in the programs included in this title the secretary shall issue such rules and regulations as may become necessary to entitle this state to participate in federal grants-in-aid, goods, commodities and services unless the same be expressly prohibited by this title.  Any section or provision of this title which may be susceptible to more than one construction shall be interpreted in favor of the construction most likely to satisfy federal laws entitling this state to receive federal matching or other funds for the various programs of public assistance.  If any part of this chapter is found to be in conflict with federal requirements which are a prescribed condition to the receipts of federal funds to the state, the conflicting part of this chapter is hereby inoperative solely to the extent of the conflict with respect to the agencies directly affected, and such finding or determination shall not affect the operation of the remainder of this chapter.

 

     Sec. 3.  RCW 74.04.500 and 1979 c 141 s 322 are each amended to read as follows:

     The department of social and health services is authorized to establish a food stamp program under the federal food stamp act of ((1964)) 1977, as amended.

 

     Sec. 4.  RCW 74.04.515 and 1969 ex.s. c 172 s 7 are each amended to read as follows:

     In ((determining eligibility for purchase of)) administering the food stamp((s)) program, there shall be no discrimination against any ((household)) applicant or recipient by reason of age, sex, handicap, religious creed, political beliefs, race, color, or national origin.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Sec. 5.  The legislature hereby expresses its intention to comply with the requirements under the federal social security act, as amended, by creating a job opportunities and basic skills training program for applicants and recipients of aid to families with dependent children, which program shall be operated by the department of social and health services in conformance with federal law.

     (1) The legislature hereby establishes as state policy the goal of economic self-sufficiency for employable recipients of public assistance, through employment, training, and education.  The purpose of this program is to provide recipients of aid to families with dependent children the opportunity to obtain a full range of necessary education, training, skills, and supportive services, including child care, consistent with their needs, that will help them enter or reenter gainful employment, thereby avoiding long-term welfare dependence and achieving economic self-sufficiency.

     The legislature finds that the well-being of children depends not only on meeting their material needs, but also on the ability of parents to become economically self-sufficient.  The job opportunities and basic skills training program is specifically directed at increasing the household earnings of aid to families with dependent children recipients, through the removal of barriers preventing them from achieving self-sufficiency.  These barriers include, but are not limited to, the lack of supportive services such as affordable and reliable child care, adequate transportation, appropriate counseling, and necessary job-related tools, equipment, books, clothing and supplies, the absence of basic literacy skills, the lack of educational attainment sufficient to meet labor market demands for career employees, and the nonavailability of useful labor market assessments.

     The legislature also recognizes that aid to families with dependent children recipients must be acknowledged as active participants in self-sufficiency planning under the program.

     The legislature finds that the department of social and health services should communicate concepts of personal empowerment, self-motivation, and self-esteem to program participants.

     The legislature further recognizes that informed choice is consistent with individual responsibility, and that parents should be given a range of options for available child care while participating in the program.

     The legislature finds that education, including, but not limited to, literacy, high school equivalency, vocational, secondary, and postsecondary, is one of the most important tools an individual needs to achieve full independence, and that this should be an important component of the program.

     The legislature further finds that the objectives of this program are to assure that:  Aid to families with dependent children recipients achieve financial stability and an adequate standard of living at wages that will meet family needs.

     (2) The department of social and health services is authorized to contract with public and private employment and training agencies and other public service entities to provide services prescribed or allowed under the federal social security act, as amended, to carry out the purposes of this program.  The department of social and health services has sole authority and responsibility to carry out the job opportunities and basic skills training program.  No contracting entity shall have the authority to review, change, or disapprove any administrative decision, or otherwise substitute its judgment for that of the department of social and health services as to the application of policies and rules adopted by the department of social and health services.

     (3) The department of social and health services and all entities contracting with it shall give first priority of service in all respects to individuals volunteering for program participation, to the extent feasible under federal law.

     (4) The department of social and health services shall adopt rules pursuant to chapter 34.05 RCW establishing criteria constituting circumstances of good cause for an individual failing or refusing to participate in an assigned program component, or failing or refusing to accept or retain employment.  The criteria shall include, but not be limited to, the following circumstances:  (a) If the individual is a parent or other relative personally providing care for a child under age six and the employment would require the individual to work more than twenty hours per week; (b) if child care, or day care for an incapacitated individual living in the same home as a dependent child, is necessary for an individual to participate or continue participation in the program or accept employment, and such care is not available, and the department of social and health services fails to provide such care; (c) the employment would result in the family of the participant experiencing a net loss of cash income; or (d) circumstances that are beyond the control of the individual's household, either on a short-term or on an ongoing basis.

     (5) The department of social and health services shall adopt rules pursuant to chapter 34.05 RCW as necessary to effectuate the intent and purpose of this chapter.

     (6) Any section or provision of law dealing with the job opportunities and basic skills training program which may be susceptible to more than one construction shall be interpreted in favor of the construction most likely to comply with federal laws entitling the state to receive federal funds.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Sec. 6.  If any part of this chapter shall be found to be in conflict with federal requirements which are a prescribed condition to the allocation of federal funds to the state, such conflicting part of this chapter is hereby declared to be inoperative solely to the extent of such conflict and with respect to the agency directly affected, and such finding or determination shall not affect the operation of the remainder of this chapter and its application to the agency concerned.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Sec. 7.  If any provision of this chapter or its application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the remainder of the chapter or the application of the provision to other persons or circumstances is not affected.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Sec. 8.  Sections 5 through 7 of this act shall constitute a new chapter in Title 74 RCW.

 

     NEW SECTION.  Sec. 9.  The following acts or parts of acts are each repealed:

     (1) RCW 74.04.390 and 1979 c 141 s 315, 1963 c 228 s 6, & 1961 c 269 s 2;

     (2) RCW 74.04.400 and 1979 c 141 s 316, 1963 c 228 s 7, & 1961 c 269 s 3;

     (3) RCW 74.04.410 and 1979 c 141 s 317, 1963 c 228 s 8, & 1961 c 269 s 4;

     (4) RCW 74.04.420 and 1979 c 141 s 318, 1963 c 228 s 9, & 1961 c 269 s 5;

     (5) RCW 74.04.430 and 1987 c 185 s 39, 1979 c 141 s 319, 1963 c 228 s 10, & 1961 c 269 s 6;

     (6) RCW 74.04.440 and 1963 c 228 s 11 & 1961 c 269 s 7;

     (7) RCW 74.04.450 and 1963 c 228 s 12;

     (8) RCW 74.04.460 and 1963 c 228 s 13;

     (9) RCW 74.04.470 and 1979 c 141 s 320 & 1963 c 228 s 14;

     (10) RCW 74.04.473 and 1983 1st ex.s. c 41 s 41;

     (11) RCW 74.04.477 and 1983 1st ex.s. c 41 s 42;

     (12) RCW 74.04.505 and 1969 ex.s. c 172 s 5;

     (13) RCW 74.22.010 and 1969 c 14 s 1;

     (14) RCW 74.22.020 and 1979 c 141 s 372 & 1969 c 14 s 2;

     (15) RCW 74.22.030 and 1969 c 14 s 3;

     (16) RCW 74.22.040 and 1969 c 14 s 4;

     (17) RCW 74.22.050 and 1979 c 141 s 373 & 1969 c 14 s 5;

     (18) RCW 74.22.060 and 1969 c 14 s 6;

     (19) RCW 74.22.070 and 1979 c 141 s 374 & 1969 c 14 s 7;

     (20) RCW 74.22.080 and 1969 c 14 s 8;

     (21) RCW 74.22.090 and 1969 c 14 s 9;

     (22) RCW 74.22.100 and 1979 c 141 s 375 & 1969 c 14 s 10;

     (23) RCW 74.22.110 and 1979 c 141 s 376 & 1969 c 14 s 11;

     (24) RCW 74.22.120 and 1969 c 14 s 12;

     (25) RCW 74.23.005 and 1969 c 15 s 1;

     (26) RCW 74.23.010 and 1969 c 15 s 2;

     (27) RCW 74.23.020 and 1979 c 141 s 377 & 1969 c 15 s 3;

     (28) RCW 74.23.030 and 1969 c 15 s 4;

     (29) RCW 74.23.040 and 1979 c 141 s 378 & 1969 c 15 s 5;

     (30) RCW 74.23.050 and 1969 c 15 s 6;

     (31) RCW 74.23.060 and 1969 c 15 s 7;

     (32) RCW 74.23.070 and 1979 c 141 s 379 & 1969 c 15 s 8;

     (33) RCW 74.23.080 and 1969 c 15 s 9;

     (34) RCW 74.23.090 and 1969 c 15 s 10;

     (35) RCW 74.23.100 and 1969 c 15 s 11;

     (36) RCW 74.23.110 and 1979 c 141 s 380 & 1969 c 15 s 12;

     (37) RCW 74.23.120 and 1979 c 141 s 381 & 1969 c 15 s 13; and

     (38) RCW 74.23.900 and 1969 c 15 s 14.