SENATE BILL REPORT
ESB 5194
As Passed Senate, March 8, 2005
Title: An act relating to the United States longshore and harbor workers' compensation account in the Washington insurance guaranty association.
Brief Description: Including the longshore and harbor workers' compensation account within the Washington insurance guaranty association.
Sponsors: Senators Franklin, Benton and Keiser; by request of Insurance Commissioner.
Brief History:
Committee Activity: Labor, Commerce, Research & Development: 1/24/05, 1/31/05 [DP].
Passed Senate: 3/8/05, 49-0.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, COMMERCE, RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT
Majority Report: Do pass.Signed by Senators Kohl-Welles, Chair; Franklin, Vice Chair; Brown, Deccio, Hewitt, Honeyford, Keiser, Parlette and Prentice.
Staff: Alison Mendiola (786-7483)
Background: Insurance guaranty associations have been created in Washington to cover life and
disability insurance policies and some casualty insurance policies. Their purpose is to provide
a mechanism for payment of covered claims when an insurer becomes insolvent and to assess the
cost of such protection among insurers. The Washington Insurance Guaranty Association
(WIGA), a statutorily created nonprofit unincorporated legal entity, operates two accounts: (1)
the automobile insurance account and (2) an account for all other direct insurance (except life,
title, surety, disability, credit, mortgage guaranty, workers'compensation, and ocean marine).
Under federal law, businesses whose employees work in maritime employment on or near
navigable waters of the United States are required to purchase longshore and harbor workers'
compensation act insurance. This insurance is available through private insurers or through an
assigned risk plan created in Washington law. Insurers who provide longshore and harbor
workers compensation act insurance (USL&H) policies are not covered by a Washington
insurance guaranty association. Consequently, if an insurer becomes insolvent, there is no
mechanism for payment of covered claims by a pool to which all insurers in this type of plan
contribute. Employers who purchase longshore and harbor workers' compensation insurance from
private insurers remain responsible for an employee's job-related injury or death if the insurer
becomes insolvent.
The U.S. Department of Labor (US DOL) is promulgating rules which will require all insurers
writing USL&H in states without guaranty fund coverage to post full security for their USL&H
business in that state.
In 2004, ESB 6158 directed the Insurance Commissioner to create a committee to study the best
method by which to provide insurance guaranty protection for USL&H Workers' Compensation
Act insurance policyholders and employees, with a report due to the Legislature by December
1, 2004.
Summary of Bill: A new account in the Washington Insurance Guarantee Association (WIGA)
is created to cover USL&H insurance.
Key elements of this account are as follows:
An "unpaid claim" is one in which benefits are due and the insurer is insolvent and: (1) the
worksite from which the injury occurred is within this state or on the navigable waters within or
immediately offshore of this state; or (2) if the worksite from which the injury occurred is outside
this state, the injured worker is a permanent resident of this state, the injured worker is
temporarily working at the worksite from which the injury occurred, and the injured worker is not
covered by a policy of the longshore and harbor workers' compensation insurance issued in
another state.
In the event of insolvency of a member insurer who writes USL&H insurance, at least one
member of the WIGA Board of Directors must represent the interests of this class.
Loan amounts sought by the WIGA related to the USL&H account may be sought from the
USL&H assigned risk plan or other parties.
The collection of a pre-insolvency assessment continues post-insolvency:
1) beginning July 1, 2005, USL&H insurers are assessed an amount determined by the board, but not to exceed 3 percent of net direct written premiums;
2) following an insolvency, USL&H insurers are assessed an amount determined by the
board, but not to exceed 3 percent of net direct written premiums; and
3) insurer assessment prior to an insolvency continue until a net fund balance is established
that equals 4 percent of the aggregate net direct premium for the calendar year preceding
the assessment on all insurers authorized to write such policies.
If any insurer fails to provide its net direct written premium data as requested by the association,
the association may substitute that insurer's direct written premiums for worker's compensation
reported in its annual statement to the state.
The WIGA must not access any funds from the automobile or insurance account or the account
of all other insurance to cover the cost of claims or administration arising under this account.
Appropriation: None.
Fiscal Note: Available.
Committee/Commission/Task Force Created: No.
Effective Date: This bill contains an emergency clause and takes effect immediately.
Testimony For: The maritime industry is important and has a great effect on the WA economy.
Given the likelihood of Kemper (an insurer) becoming insolvent, this bill is needed. The US DOL
is in the process of finalizing rules that would require insurers to post full security without this
account. Without this account, if an insurer becomes insolvent, the employer is liable for the
claim and most policyholders are small and mid-size employers who would not be able to take
that kind of hit. Larger employers self-insure.
Concerns: Whether the funding of this new account would be adequate given the likelihood of
Kemper (largest writer of L&H insurance in WA) becoming insolvent in the near future. The bill
says WIGA can not go to the other accounts for funding, and reality of securing a loan is unlikely.
Testimony Against: None.
Who Testified: PRO: Dale Newell, Insurance Brokers and Agents of the West; Mary Clogston, OIC; Gordon Baxter, International Longshore & Warehouse Union and Shellfish Diver's Union; Randy Ray, Todd Shipyards. CONCERNS: Elizabeth Moceri, WIGA.