ESHB 1571 -
By Senator Rockefeller
PULLED 04/14/2009
On page 4, beginning on line 13 of the amendment, after "(6)" strike all material through "chapter." on line 16
On page 17, after line 7 of the amendment, insert the following:
"Sec. 19 RCW 4.12.040 and 1989 c 15 s 1 are each amended to read
as follows:
(1) No judge of a superior court of the state of Washington shall
sit to hear or try any action or proceeding when it shall be
established as hereinafter provided that said judge is prejudiced
against any party or attorney, or the interest of any party or attorney
appearing in such cause. In such case the presiding judge in judicial
districts where there is more than one judge shall forthwith transfer
the action to another department of the same court, or call in a judge
from some other court. In all judicial districts where there is only
one judge, a certified copy of the motion and affidavit filed in the
cause shall be transmitted by the clerk of the superior court to the
clerk of the superior court designated by the chief justice of the
supreme court. Upon receipt the clerk of said superior court shall
transmit the forwarded affidavit to the presiding judge who shall
direct a visiting judge to hear and try such action as soon as
convenient and practical.
(2) The presiding judge in judicial districts where there is more
than one judge, or the presiding judge of judicial districts where
there is only one judge, may send a case for trial to another court if
the convenience of witnesses or the ends of justice will not be
interfered with by such a course and the action is of such a character
that a change of venue may be ordered: PROVIDED, That in criminal
prosecutions the case shall not be sent for trial to any court outside
the county unless the accused shall waive his or her right to a trial
by a jury of the county in which the offense is alleged to have been
committed.
(3) This section does not apply to water right adjudications filed
under chapter 90.03 or 90.44 RCW. Disqualification of judges in water
right adjudications is governed by section 3 of this act.
Sec. 20 RCW 4.12.050 and 1941 c 148 s 1 are each amended to read
as follows:
(1) Any party to or any attorney appearing in any action or
proceeding in a superior court, may establish such prejudice by motion,
supported by affidavit that the judge before whom the action is pending
is prejudiced against such party or attorney, so that such party or
attorney cannot, or believes that he or she cannot, have a fair and
impartial trial before such judge: PROVIDED, That such motion and
affidavit is filed and called to the attention of the judge before he
or she shall have made any ruling whatsoever in the case, either on the
motion of the party making the affidavit, or on the motion of any other
party to the action, of the hearing of which the party making the
affidavit has been given notice, and before the judge presiding has
made any order or ruling involving discretion, but the arrangement of
the calendar, the setting of an action, motion or proceeding down for
hearing or trial, the arraignment of the accused in a criminal action
or the fixing of bail, shall not be construed as a ruling or order
involving discretion within the meaning of this proviso; and in any
event, in counties where there is but one resident judge, such motion
and affidavit shall be filed not later than the day on which the case
is called to be set for trial: AND PROVIDED FURTHER, That
notwithstanding the filing of such motion and affidavit, if the parties
shall, by stipulation in writing agree, such judge may hear argument
and rule upon any preliminary motions, demurrers, or other matter
thereafter presented: AND PROVIDED FURTHER, That no party or attorney
shall be permitted to make more than one such application in any action
or proceeding under this section and RCW 4.12.040.
(2) This section does not apply to water right adjudications filed
under chapter 90.03 or 90.44 RCW. Disqualification of judges in water
right adjudications is governed by section 3 of this act."
Renumber the remaining sections consecutively and correct any internal references accordingly.
ESHB 1571 -
By Senator Rockefeller
PULLED 04/14/2009
On page 17, line 21 of the title amendment, after "90.44.220," strike "and 43.21B.110" and insert "43.21B.110, 4.12.040, and 4.12.050"
EFFECT: Eliminates an "incorporation by reference" issue that currently exists in the striking amendment.