HB 2232 -
By Representative Anderson
FAILED 02/10/2012
Strike everything after the enacting clause and insert the following:
"NEW SECTION. Sec. 1 (1) Under federal law, Indian nations are
federally dependent domestic sovereigns that are distinct, independent
political entities legally separate from the state and owing no
allegiance to the state. Indian nations are uniquely empowered to
generate income for their communities through taxing and other revenue
mechanisms, such as operating casinos, that are not available to
constitutionally authorized political subdivisions of the state.
Indian nations do not pay property tax on land held in trust by the
federal government nor on nonreservation land used for essential
government services. Tribally owned businesses are not subject to
sales and excise taxes on transactions conducted by tribal members on
tribal land. The state of Washington, through the Centennial Accord,
has agreed to treat Indian nations on a sovereign-to-sovereign basis.
(2) The legislature finds that many statutory provisions treat
Indian nations not as independent sovereigns but as state-dependent
entities, which they are not, creating a clear conflict in the
application of state laws. Indian nations have numerous independent
sources of revenue. In 2011, the tribes generated nearly one billion
nine hundred fifty-four million dollars in net gambling receipts. The
Washington state office of financial management estimates that less
than two percent of the state's population is Native American.
(3) In this time when the state faces significant continuing budget
deficits and must make funding reductions to service programs it is
providing to all its citizens, the legislature has made policy changes
in many areas to require those that have independent sources of revenue
to pay for the state services they use. The legislature intends to
clarify the sovereign legal standing of Indian nations with respect to
the state of Washington and the eligibility of Indian nations to apply
for and receive state-provided program resources contingent upon
sovereign-to-sovereign revenue sharing agreements to help defray the
costs of such program services. The legislature intends the state to
eventually govern sovereign-to-sovereign relations with each tribe
through single compacts with individual tribes that address the
multitude of issues between each tribe and the state instead of the
multitude of compacts on select issues created today.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 2 (1) To be eligible to apply for and receive
money from programs identified in section 3 of this act, a tribal
government of a federally recognized Indian tribe located within the
state must have a sovereign-to-sovereign agreement with the state that
provides for the state to receive remuneration from the Indian nation
for the privileges provided by these state programs and services in an
amount sufficient so that the state receives a benefit for extending
the privilege of state programs and services to federally recognized
Indian nations.
(2) The requirements and conditions of this section apply unless
the application of a requirement or condition is prohibited by federal
law.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 3 (1) State-funded programs subject to the
conditions of section 2 of this act include but are not limited to:
(a) Public facilities loans and grants from the community economic
revitalization board;
(b) The local infrastructure financing tool program;
(c) Bond funding from the state and local improvements revolving
account for:
(i) Waste disposal facilities;
(ii) Water supply facilities;
(iii) Recreation areas and facilities; and
(iv) Health and social service facilities;
(d) Department of agriculture programs for:
(i) Funding and technical assistance under the department's pest
program;
(ii) Surface water monitoring; and
(iii) Food safety;
(e) The building communities fund program;
(f) The tourism competitive grant program;
(g) Programs funded under the recreation and conservation office;
(h) Lake Roosevelt Columbia partnership agreements;
(i) Toxic clean-up programs under the department of ecology;
(j) The centennial clean water program;
(k) Public health emergency preparedness and response under the
department of health;
(l) Grant programs under the emergency management division of the
military department;
(m) The competitive grant program for economic development activity
designed to further regional cluster growth administered by the
department of commerce;
(n) Grants and loans through the department of transportation for
planning, acquisition, construction, improvement, and maintenance or
operation of an airport;
(o) Funds received from counties using the county road
administration board ferry capital improvement program;
(p) State maintenance funds to eligible tribes under the temporary
assistance for needy families program;
(q) Housing-based supportive services for homeless families;
(r) Funds available through housing assistance programs and the
Washington housing trust fund;
(s) Affordable housing programs and tax exemptions for tribal and
intertribal housing authorities;
(t) Funds from the home visiting services account;
(u) Funds from the American Indian scholarship endowment fund;
(v) Grants made available for heritage capital projects;
(w) Funding from the forest and fish support account;
(x) State funds provided through the department of social and
health services as follows:
(i) Funds by the juvenile rehabilitation administration;
(ii) Funds provided for outpatient and prevention services and
administration of those programs;
(iii) Funds provided as part of the mental health block grant;
(iv) Programs through the children's administration that foster
independent living and life skills; and
(v) Funds provided for alcohol, drug, and problem-gambling
treatment unless the tribe has made contributions to the state through
provisions of Appendix X2 to the tribal-state gaming compacts;
(y) Services provided by the Washington state patrol in Indian
country or to Indian members on their property; and
(z) State programs or funding provided through the superintendent
of public instruction, including:
(i) The building bridges dropout prevention grants; and
(ii) Services provided by the office of native education.
(2) Nothing in this section or section 2 of this act prohibits
allowing access to federally recognized Indian tribes located within
the state and their members to federally provided funding for which
they are otherwise eligible.
(3) State agencies may require compliance with section 2 of this
act for Indian nations seeking access to state-funded programs not
listed in subsection (1) of this section that come into existence after
the effective date of this section unless prohibited by statute.
(4) Nothing in this chapter prevents tribal citizens as individuals
from applying for and receiving state services that they are eligible
to receive under the law.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 4 (1) The governor may enter an agreement with
an Indian tribe to receive payment for the privilege of participating
in state programs under section 2 of this act subject to the conditions
of this section.
(2) The agreement with each Indian tribe must be for an amount
sufficient to provide the state with a benefit for extending the
privilege of state programs and services to federally recognized Indian
tribes. The agreement must specify that payments are made to the state
treasurer on a quarterly basis.
(3) A sovereign-to-sovereign agreement entered into pursuant to
this chapter must include:
(a) Mechanisms to allow the state auditor and state agencies to
conduct audits of recipients of state services in the same manner as
they would for local governments or other program participants; and
(b) A provision that agreements are public records and must be
disclosed upon request and posted on an appropriate state web site.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 5 The Indian nation eligibility for state
services account is created in the state treasury. All receipts from
the agreements in section 4 of this act must be deposited into the
account. The state treasurer must track amounts received from
individual Indian tribes and report amounts received quarterly to the
department of revenue. The state treasurer must transfer on July 1st
of each year the entire fund balance of the account into the general
fund.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 6 The state may consent to the jurisdiction of
the federal courts in actions brought by an Indian tribe seeking
enforcement of an agreement under section 4 of this act, conditioned
upon the Indian tribe providing similar consent in the agreement and
waiver of claims of sovereign immunity that would prevent enforcement
of any provisions of this chapter or in relation to state government
services provided pursuant to an agreement under section 4 of this act.
Sec. 7 RCW 43.06.455 and 2001 c 235 s 2 are each amended to read
as follows:
(1) The governor may enter into cigarette tax contracts concerning
the sale of cigarettes. All cigarette tax contracts ((shall)) must
meet the requirements for cigarette tax contracts under this section.
Except for cigarette tax contracts under RCW 43.06.460, the rates,
revenue sharing, and exemption terms of a cigarette tax contract are
not effective unless authorized in a bill enacted by the legislature.
(2) Cigarette tax contracts ((shall be)) are in regard to retail
sales in which Indian retailers make delivery and physical transfer of
possession of the cigarettes from the seller to the buyer within Indian
country, and are not in regard to transactions by non-Indian retailers.
In addition, contracts ((shall)) must provide that retailers ((shall))
do not sell or give, or permit to be sold or given, cigarettes to any
person under the age of eighteen years.
(3) A cigarette tax contract with a tribe ((shall)) must provide
for a tribal cigarette tax in lieu of all state cigarette taxes and
state and local sales and use taxes on sales of cigarettes in Indian
country by Indian retailers. The tribe may allow an exemption for
sales to tribal members.
(4) Cigarette tax contracts ((shall)) must provide that all
cigarettes possessed or sold by a retailer ((shall)) bear a cigarette
stamp obtained by wholesalers from a bank or other suitable stamp
vendor and applied to the cigarettes. The procedures to be used by the
tribe in obtaining tax stamps must include a means to assure that the
tribal tax will be paid by the wholesaler obtaining such cigarettes.
Tribal stamps must have serial numbers or some other discrete
identification so that each stamp can be traced to its source.
(5) Cigarette tax contracts ((shall)) must provide that retailers
((shall)) purchase cigarettes only from:
(a) Wholesalers or manufacturers licensed to do business in the
state of Washington;
(b) Out-of-state wholesalers or manufacturers who, although not
licensed to do business in the state of Washington, agree to comply
with the terms of the cigarette tax contract, are certified to the
state as having so agreed, and who do in fact so comply. However, the
state may in its sole discretion exercise its administrative and
enforcement powers over such wholesalers or manufacturers to the extent
permitted by law;
(c) A tribal wholesaler that purchases only from a wholesaler or
manufacturer described in (a), (b), or (d) of this subsection; and
(d) A tribal manufacturer.
(6) Cigarette tax contracts ((shall)) must be for renewable periods
of no more than eight years. A renewal may not include a renewal of
the phase-in period. For renewals occurring after the effective date
of this section, any agreement must include a provision requiring the
tribe to provide for the state to receive remuneration from the Indian
nation for the privileges provided by these state programs and services
in an amount sufficient so that the state receives a benefit for
extending the privilege of state programs and services to federally
recognized Indian nations.
(7) Cigarette tax contracts ((shall)) must include provisions for
compliance, such as transport and notice requirements, inspection
procedures, stamping requirements, recordkeeping, and audit
requirements.
(8) Tax revenue retained by a tribe must be used for essential
government services. Use of tax revenue for subsidization of cigarette
and food retailers is prohibited.
(9) The cigarette tax contract may include provisions to resolve
disputes using a nonjudicial process, such as mediation.
(10) The governor may delegate the power to negotiate cigarette tax
contracts to the department of revenue. The department of revenue
((shall)) must consult with the liquor control board during the
negotiations.
(11) Information received by the state or open to state review
under the terms of a contract is subject to the provisions of RCW
82.32.330.
(12) It is the intent of the legislature that the liquor control
board and the department of revenue continue the division of duties and
shared authority under chapter 82.24 RCW and therefore the liquor
control board is responsible for enforcement activities that come under
the terms of chapter 82.24 RCW.
(13) Each cigarette tax contract ((shall)) must include a procedure
for notifying the other party that a violation has occurred, a
procedure for establishing whether a violation has in fact occurred, an
opportunity to correct such violation, and a provision providing for
termination of the contract should the violation fail to be resolved
through this process, such termination subject to mediation should the
terms of the contract so allow. A contract ((shall)) must provide for
termination of the contract if resolution of a dispute does not occur
within twenty-four months from the time notification of a violation has
occurred. Intervening violations do not extend this time period. In
addition, the contract ((shall)) must include provisions delineating
the respective roles and responsibilities of the tribe, the department
of revenue, and the liquor control board.
(14) For purposes of this section and RCW 43.06.460, 82.08.0316,
82.12.0316, and 82.24.295:
(a) "Essential government services" means services such as tribal
administration, public facilities, fire, police, public health,
education, job services, sewer, water, environmental and land use,
transportation, utility services, and economic development;
(b) "Indian retailer" or "retailer" means (i) a retailer wholly
owned and operated by an Indian tribe, (ii) a business wholly owned and
operated by a tribal member and licensed by the tribe, or (iii) a
business owned and operated by the Indian person or persons in whose
name the land is held in trust; and
(c) "Indian tribe" or "tribe" means a federally recognized Indian
tribe located within the geographical boundaries of the state of
Washington.
Sec. 8 RCW 84.36.010 and 2010 c 281 s 1 are each amended to read
as follows:
(1) All property belonging exclusively to the United States, the
state, or any county or municipal corporation subject to subsection (3)
of this section; all property belonging exclusively to any federally
recognized Indian tribe located in the state, if that property is used
exclusively for essential government services; all state route number
16 corridor transportation systems and facilities constructed under
chapter 47.46 RCW; all property under a financing contract pursuant to
chapter 39.94 RCW or recorded agreement granting immediate possession
and use to the public bodies listed in this section or under an order
of immediate possession and use pursuant to RCW 8.04.090; and, for a
period of forty years from acquisition, all property of a community
center; is exempt from taxation. All property belonging exclusively to
a foreign national government is exempt from taxation if that property
is used exclusively as an office or residence for a consul or other
official representative of the foreign national government, and if the
consul or other official representative is a citizen of that foreign
nation.
(2) For the purposes of this section the following definitions
apply unless the context clearly requires otherwise.
(a) "Community center" means property, including a building or
buildings, determined to be surplus to the needs of a district by a
local school board, and purchased or acquired by a nonprofit
organization for the purposes of converting them into community
facilities for the delivery of nonresidential coordinated services for
community members. The community center may make space available to
businesses, individuals, or other parties through the loan or rental of
space in or on the property.
(b) "Essential government services" means services such as tribal
administration, public facilities, fire, police, public health,
education, sewer, water, environmental and land use, transportation,
and utility services.
(3) The exemption for a federally recognized Indian tribe located
in the state is only allowed for those tribes with a valid sovereign-to-sovereign remuneration agreement under chapter 43.--- RCW (the new
chapter created in section 9 of this act).
NEW SECTION. Sec. 9 Sections 1 through 6 of this act constitute
a new chapter in Title
NEW SECTION. Sec. 10 If any provision of this act or its
application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the
remainder of the act or the application of the provision to other
persons or circumstances is not affected.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 11 This act is necessary for the immediate
preservation of the public peace, health, or safety, or support of the
state government and its existing public institutions, and takes effect
immediately."
Correct the title.
EFFECT: (1) Strikes all provisions of the original bill; (2) requires an Indian tribe to have a sovereign-to-sovereign agreement with the state requiring payment of remuneration to the state in order to receive the benefit of specified state programs and services; (3) requires that the remuneration be in an amount that provides the state with sufficient benefit; (4) authorizes the governor to enter into an agreement with a tribe to allow participation in specified state programs in return for the tribe's payment of the requisite remuneration; (5) creates the Indian nation eligibility for state services account in the state treasury for the receipt of payments made by tribes in return for the receipt of state services and participation in state programs; (6) requires the state and a tribe to mutually consent to the jurisdiction of the federal courts for enforcement of remuneration agreements and for a tribe to waive its sovereign immunity regarding such enforcement; (7) requires that new agreements between the state and a tribe regarding cigarette compacts to include remuneration to the state in order to receive the benefit of the state tax exemption; (8) makes the property tax exemption for tribal property used for essential government services contingent upon the tribe having a sovereign-to-sovereign remuneration agreement in place; (9) makes the tribal leasehold tax exemption contingent upon the tribe having a sovereign-to-sovereign remuneration agreement in place; and (10) adds an emergency clause.