SSB 5784 -
By Representative Short
FAILED 04/05/2011
On page 2, after line 29, insert the following:
"NEW SECTION. Sec. 3 A new section is added to chapter 43.372
RCW to read as follows:
(1) If the expenditure of money from the marine resources
stewardship trust account created in RCW 43.372.070 results in the
creation of a new state program or rule, then the agency or agencies
responsible for implementing the program or rule must identify any
peer-reviewed science, scientific literature, or other sources of
information reviewed by the agency or relied upon for the
implementation of the program or rule.
(2) As used in this section, "peer-reviewed science" means
information developed using the scientific method for which the
following factors are true:
(a) The scientific information is provided by a qualified,
scientific professional or professionals with issue-appropriate
expertise based on the professional's credentials, certifications,
earned advanced degrees, years of experience, recognized leadership in
an appropriate scholarly area, formal training, and recognized ability
to produce peer-reviewed professional literature;
(b) The scientific information has been subjected to independent
peer review by at least three reviewers who are qualified and are
independent with no conflict of interest. Independent peer review may
be performed by reputable scientific journals, scholarly organizations
such as the national academies, commissioned by the relevant agency, or
commissioned by qualified entities whose interests will be affected by
the action;
(c) The methods used to obtain the information are clearly stated,
standardized for the pertinent scientific discipline, and are able to
be replicated;
(d) The conclusions underlying the information are based on
reasonable and logical assumptions supported by other studies and
consistent with the data presented;
(e) The data underlying the information have been analyzed using
the appropriate statistical or quantitative methods;
(f) The information has been placed in a proper context and is
appropriately framed with respect to the prevailing body of pertinent
scientific knowledge; and
(g) The information is based on assumptions, analytical techniques,
and conclusions that are clearly stated and well-referenced with
citations to credible literature and other pertinent existing
information."
Correct the title.
EFFECT: Requires the agencies implementing any new programs or rules created as a result of expenditures from the marine resources stewardship trust account to identify any peer-reviewed science the agency relies upon; creates a definition for "peer-reviewed science."