Washington State

House of Representatives

Office of Program Research

BILL

ANALYSIS

Public Safety Committee

HB 1885

This analysis was prepared by non-partisan legislative staff for the use of legislative members in their deliberations. This analysis is not a part of the legislation nor does it constitute a statement of legislative intent.

Brief Description: Addressing and mitigating the impacts of property crimes in Washington state.

Sponsors: Representatives Klippert, Hudgins, Chandler, Hunter, MacEwen, Goodman, Ormsby, Tarleton, Fitzgibbon, Kagi, Ryu, Reykdal, Stanford and Walkinshaw.

Brief Summary of Bill

  • Creates a new felony property offense sentencing grid with reduced standard ranges.

  • Imposes 12 months of community custody for a felony property offense when the offender has an offender score of two or more.

  • Creates the Washington Justice Commission (WJC) to assume the duties of the Sentencing Guidelines Commission and administer grant programs.

  • Appropriates $2 million for law enforcement property crime reduction grants.

  • Appropriates $500,000 for county pretrial improvement grants.

  • Appropriates $400,000 for new victim compensation benefits for victims of property crimes.

  • Appropriates $100,000 for the victim notification programs in King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties.

  • Appropriates $9 million to the Department of Corrections to fund community supervision of property offenders, community violator bed impacts, and mental health and cognitive behavior treatment and services.

  • Requires the WJC to prepare racial and ethnic impact statements on legislation that describes the effects of proposed legislation on the racial and ethnic composition of the criminal offender population.

  • Provides a sunset review and termination of the WJC and the sentencing provisions for property crimes.

Hearing Date: 2/11/15

Staff: Cassie Jones (786-7303) and Yvonne Walker (786-7841).

Background:

Felony Sentencing.

The sentence imposed for a felony crime will depend on the severity, or seriousness level of the offense and the defendant's offender score. Felony crimes are separated into 16 different seriousness levels. The offender score may vary from zero to nine plus points depending on five factors: (1) the number of prior criminal convictions or juvenile dispositions; (2) the relationship between any prior offense(s) and the current offense of conviction; (3) the presence of other current convictions; (4) the offender's community custody status at the time the crime was committed; and (5) the length of the offender's crime-free behavior between offenses.

The standard sentence range for any offense that is not a drug offense is established by referring to the standard sentencing grid. For each current offense, the intersection of the column defined by the offender score and the row defined by the offense seriousness level determines the standard sentence range. Below is the current sentencing grid for seriousness levels one through four.

Serious

Level

Offender Score

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9 or more

4

3-9 months

6-12 months

12+-14 months

13-17

months

15-20 months

22-29 months

33-43 months

43-57 months

53-70 months

63-84 months

3

1-3 months

3-8 months

4-12 months

9-12

months

12+-16 months

17-22 months

22-29 months

33-43 months

43-57 months

51-68 months

2

0-90 days

2-6 months

3-9 months

4-12 months

12+-14 months

14-18 months

17-22 months

22-29 months

33-43 months

43-57 months

1

0-60 days

0-90 days

2-5 months

2-6 months

3-8 months

4-12 months

12+-14 months

14-18 months

17-22 months

22-29 months

Offenders convicted of the following categories of offenses also receive a term of community custody as part of their sentence:

Commission.

The Sentencing Guidelines Commission (SGC) was created by the Legislature in 1981 as part of the Sentencing Reform Act. The SGC served as an independent body statutorily required to evaluate and monitor adult and juvenile sentencing policies and practices and make recommendations to the Governor and the Legislature, served as a clearinghouse and information center on adult and juvenile sentencing, and conducted ongoing research on sentencing and related issues.

The SGC consists of 20 voting members, 16 of whom are appointed by the Governor. The members include four superior court judges, two defense attorneys, two prosecutors, four citizens, the chief of a local law enforcement agency, one county elected official, one city elected official, and one administrator of juvenile court services. There are four ex-officio voting members: the Secretary of the Department of Corrections (DOC), the Director of the Office of Financial Management (OFM), the chair of the Indeterminate Sentence Review Board, and the Director for the Juvenile Rehabilitation Administration. Four legislators are appointed by the leadership of the House of Representatives and the Senate and serve as nonvoting members. The SGC was authorized to appoint research staff to accomplish the duties of the SGC and a full-time executive director whose salary was fixed by the Governor.

In 2011 (pursuant to Engrossed Substitute Senate Bill 5891), the SGC was reorganized and became an advisory agency, located within the OFM. The position of the executive director was eliminated. The Caseload Forecast Council (CFC) became: (1) the clearinghouse and information center for adult and juvenile sentencing; (2) responsible for annually producing a statistical summary of adult felony sentencing and juvenile dispositions; and (3) responsible for publishing and maintaining the adult felony sentencing manual. The DOC assumed full responsibility for administering the interstate compact for adult offender supervision in the state.

Victims of Crime.

Assistance to Victims. The Washington's Crime Victims' Compensation Program (CVCP), within the Department of Labor and Industries (L&I) provides benefits to innocent victims of criminal acts.  Generally, persons injured by a criminal act in Washington, or their surviving spouses and dependents, are eligible to receive benefits (burial costs, medical treatment, and lost wages) under the CVCP.

Crime Victims Advocacy. The Office of Crime Victims Advocacy within the Department of Commerce (COM), administers grant funds for community programs working with crime victims and assists communities in planning and implementing services for crime victims.

Victim Notification. The Victim Information and Notification System, also known as VINE, automatically notifies a registered victim when various changes occur such as when an offender transfers to another facility, is discharged, changes custody or supervision levels, escapes, becomes noncompliant in certain instances, or has an upcoming court date.

Sunset Review.

The Sunset Act requires the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Committee to conduct a sunset review of a program or agency and provide a report with recommendations regarding whether the program should be retained, modified, or allowed to terminate.

Summary of Bill:

Felony Sentencing.

Most felony property offenses with a seriousness level of four and below are removed from the current seriousness level classifications and assigned a new seriousness level. A new sentencing grid is created with new, reduced standard ranges for those reclassified felony property offenses. Offenders convicted of a property offense, who have an offender score of two or more will also receive 12 months of community custody as part of their sentence.

Serious

Level

Offender Score

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9 or more

4

15-180 days

30-240 days

30-300 days

30-365 days

12+-16 months

14-18 months

16-24 months

24-30 months

30-36.5 months

36.5-42 months

3

10-90 days

15-180 days

20-180 days

30-240 days

30-300 days

60-365 days

12+-16 months

14-18 months

16-24 months

24-30 months

2

5-90 days

10-120 days

15-180 days

20-180 days

30-240 days

30-300 days

60-365 days

12+-16 months

14-18 months

16-20 months

1

5-60 days

5-90 days

10-120 days

20-180 days

30-240 days

30-300 days

30-300 days

30-365 days

12+-16 months

14-18 months

The following felony property offenses were omitted from the newly created sentencing grid: Residential Burglary, Theft of Ammonia, and Theft of a Firearm. Therefore, sentencing for these offenses remains the same. Sentencing remains the same for all other felony offenses.

Commission.

The SGC is renamed and becomes the Washington Justice Commission (WJC). The WJC assumes all responsibilities of the SGC. The voting members of the WJC consists of 19 members, as the result of the removal of two of the four superior court judges, and the addition of the chief justice of the supreme court or the chef justice's designee. The executive director of the CFC, or his or her designee, is appointed to the WJC as an ex-officio, nonvoting member. The WJC may also hire an executive director and staff to carry out its mission.

All duties and functions of the SGC are transferred to the WJC. The WJC must help improve the state justice system by providing a centralized forum for developing statewide policy recommendations relating to property crimes in Washington. Recommendations approved by the WJC must be forwarded to the Governor and the appropriate committees of the Legislature annually in December. The WJC must also periodically review property crime seriousness levels and the classification of the offenses and make recommendations for any changes to the Governor and the Legislature.

The WJC must develop a long-range strategic plan that promotes and coordinates a justice system that encompasses public safety, offender accountability, crime reduction and prevention, and offender treatment and rehabilitation. The plan must be submitted to the Governor and the appropriate committees of the Legislature by December 2016, and every two years thereafter.

The WJC may also conduct joint studies with other state entities; assist the CFC in providing analytical and statistical information; provide technical assistance and support to local law and justice committees; provide an annual state and juvenile sentencing manual; prepare racial and ethnic impact statements; apply for gifts and grants; and award grants as appropriated by the Legislature.

Grants.

Law Enforcement Grant. The WJC must establish a law enforcement grant program. A total of $2 million is appropriated, in each Fiscal Year (2016 and 2017), for law enforcement property crime reduction grants. Local law enforcement agencies must submit proposals to the WJC that address property crime. The WJC must use an advisory committee to evaluate grant applications and monitor the effectiveness of the grant projects. Preference must be given to grant applicants that can demonstrate a commitment to regional, multijurisdictional strategies, and that can clearly outline a comprehensive plan for municipalities to work with law enforcement, community-based organizations, and government agencies to address property crime.

Pretrial Grant. The WJC must establish a pretrial grant program. A total of $500,000 is appropriated, in each Fiscal Year, (2016 and 2017) for county pretrial improvement grants. The WJC must identify at least one county to receive a grant that will test the impact of providing defendants with earlier access to pretrial defense counsel on pretrial outcomes and county budgets.

Each of the grants listed above are one-time grants but may be renewed as determined by the WJC.

Victims of Crime.

Assistance to Victims. A total of $400,000 is appropriated, in each Fiscal Year (2016 and 2017), for new victim compensation benefits for victims of property crimes. The WJC must enter into an interagency agreement with either the COM or the L&I, or establish its own program, to provide assistance to victims of property crimes.

Victim Notification. A total of $100,000 is appropriated, in each Fiscal Year (2016 and 2017), for the victim notification programs in King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties.

Department of Corrections.

A total of $9 million is appropriated for the fiscal biennium 2016-17 to the DOC to fund mandatory supervision of property offenders, community violator bed impacts, and mental health and cognitive behavior treatment and services.

Racial and Ethnic Impact Statement.

If one member from each of the two largest caucuses in the House of Representatives or the Senate request a racial and ethnic impact statement regarding legislation that has been introduced, the WJC must prepare an analysis that describes the effects of the proposed legislation on the racial and ethnic composition of the criminal offender population; or recipients of human services. A racial and ethnic impact statement must be impartial and understandable, and must include, for racial and ethnic groups for which data are available, the following: (1) an estimate of how the proposed legislation would change the racial and ethnic composition of the criminal offender population or recipients of human services; (2) a statement of the methodologies and assumptions used in preparing the estimate; and (3) if the racial and ethnic impact statement addresses the effect of proposed legislation on the criminal offender population, an estimate of the racial and ethnic composition of the crime victims who may be affected by the proposed legislation.

Washington Justice Account.

A WJC Account (Account) is created in the State Treasurer. All gifts, donations, and grants must be deposited into the Account. Expenditures from the Account may only be used for implementing the mission and duties of the WJC.

Sunset Review.

A sunset review and termination of the WJC and the sentencing provisions for property crimes are scheduled for the years 2021 and 2022, respectively.

The act is null and void unless funded in the budget.

Appropriation: In each Fiscal Year (2016 and 2017) the following appropriations are provided: (1) a total of $2 million for law enforcement property crime reduction grants; (2) a total of $500,000 for county pretrial improvement grants; (3) a total of $400,000 for new victim compensation benefits for victims of property crimes; (4) a total of $100,000 for the victim notification programs in King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties; and (5) a total of $9 million to the DOC to fund the mandatory supervision of property offenders, community violator bed impacts, and mental health and cognitive behavior treatment and services.

Fiscal Note: Requested on February 4, 2015.

Effective Date: The bill takes effect 90 days after adjournment of the session in which the bill is passed. However, the bill is null and void unless funded in the budget.