SENATE BILL REPORT

ESSB 5987

This analysis was prepared by non-partisan legislative staff for the use of legislative members in their deliberations. This analysis is not a part of the legislation nor does it constitute a statement of legislative intent.

As Passed Senate, March 2, 2015

Title: An act relating to transportation revenue.

Brief Description: Concerning transportation revenue.

Sponsors: Senate Committee on Transportation (originally sponsored by Senators King, Hobbs, Fain, Liias and Litzow).

Brief History:

Committee Activity: Transportation: 2/18/15, 2/19/15 [DPS, DNP].

Passed Senate: 3/02/15, 27-22.

SENATE COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION

Majority Report: That Substitute Senate Bill No. 5987 be substituted therefor, and the substitute bill do pass.

Signed by Senators King, Chair; Fain, Vice Chair; Hobbs, Ranking Minority Member; Liias, Assistant Ranking Minority Member; Baumgartner, Litzow, Miloscia, Pedersen, Rivers and Sheldon.

Minority Report: Do not pass.

Signed by Senators Benton, Vice Chair; Cleveland, Habib and Jayapal.

Staff: Amanda Cecil (786-7429)

Background: 18th Amendment. The 18th Amendment to the Washington State Constitution requires that the state's motor vehicle fuel taxes, currently $0.375 per gallon; vehicle licensing fees; and all other state revenue intended to be used for highway purposes be deposited into the Motor Vehicle Fund. Monies in that fund may only be spent for highway purposes, which are defined to include expenditures on construction, preservation, maintenance, operation, and administration of highways and ferries.

Handling Loss Deduction. Licensed fuel suppliers, distributors, and importers are allowed a handling loss deduction on motor vehicle fuel as follows: for a motor vehicle fuel supplier acting as a distributor, 0.25 percent; and for all other licensees, 0.30 percent. Originally this was to account for losses the distributors sustained through evaporation and handling and was reduced in 1951 from 1 percent to the current rate. In 2008 the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Committee (JLARC) reviewed this exemption – JLARC Report 09-4: 2008 Expedited Tax Preference Performance Reviews – and recommended that the Legislature terminate the motor fuel handling loss deduction. Their recommendation was based on current Department of Ecology regulations concerning the methods and equipment used in the distribution of fuel, which allow for little or no handling losses.

Transfers to Non-Highway Accounts. Transfers are made from the Motor Vehicle Fund to the ORV and Non-highway Vehicle Account, the Marine Fuel Tax Refund Account, and the Snowmobile Account for motor vehicle fuel taxes paid by non-highway users. Each of these transfers is made based on a calculation that is based on a rate of fuel tax of $0.23 per gallon.

Weight Fees. Generally all motor vehicles used on public highways must be registered with the Department of Licensing (DOL) annually. Most vehicles, such as passenger cars, motorcycles, vans, and cabs, are subject to a $30 license tab fee; a weight fee of $10, $20, or $30 based on the scale weight of the vehicle; and other fees totaling $3.75. The proceeds from vehicle weight fees are deposited to the Multimodal Transportation Account. Funds in the Multimodal Transportation Account are used for transportation purposes, which is broader than highway purposes and can include public transportation and rail.

License Fee by Weight. In lieu of the vehicle license fee and weight fees, trucks, buses, and for-hire vehicles are subject to a license fee based on gross vehicle weight (GVW). The license fee by weight ranges from $38 for a 4000 pound vehicle to $3,400 for a 105,500 pound vehicle, in addition to a $3 filing fee. Proceeds from the license fee by weight are deposited into various accounts within the Motor Vehicle Fund.

Electric Vehicle Fee. In addition to any other fees due at annual vehicle registration, vehicles that are powered by electricity are subject to a licensing fee of $100 which is deposited into the Motor Vehicle Fund. If in any year proceeds from the electric vehicle fee are more than $1 million, 15 percent of the total funds must be deposited to the Transportation Improvement Account and 15 percent must be deposited to the Rural Arterial Trust Account.

Commercial Driver's Licenses. Any driver over 18 years of age with a valid driver's license can apply for a commercial driver instruction permit. To receive a commercial driver instruction permit, the person must pass a knowledge test. There is a $10 application fee. Prior to being issued a commercial driver's license (CDL) an applicant must have successfully completed a course of instruction in the operation of a commercial motor vehicle or have been certified by an employer as having the skills and training necessary to operate a commercial motor vehicle safely, and have passed a knowledge and skills test. An applicant must pay a fee of no more than $10 for each knowledge examination and a fee of no more than $100 for the skills examination; however, if the applicant's primary use of a CDL is for public benefit not-for-profit corporations that are federally supported head start programs, or public not-for-profit corporations that support early childhood education and assistance programs, then the applicant must a pay a fee of no more than $75 for the skills examination. A person who has been disqualified from operating a commercial motor vehicle may apply for a reinstatement of a CDL with a payment of $20 after the appropriate disqualification time period has expired.

Enhanced Driver's Licenses and Indenticards. The enhanced driver license (EDL) or enhanced ID card (EID) may be issued to a Washington resident that is also a United States citizen if they have confirmed their identity and citizenship. A person applying for an EDL must be at least 18 years old, and any age for a enhanced ID card and costs $15 in addition to any other fees due for a driver's license or ID card.

Studded Tires. Studded tires may only be used from November 1 until March 31 of each year or during other times of the year if the Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) deem it acceptable. The use of studded tires during any other time of the year is a traffic infraction.

Report of Sale/Transitional Ownership. The owner of a vehicle must notify DOL, the county, or a subagent when they sell or otherwise dispose of a vehicle. In order for a report of sale to be considered properly filed, it must include the date of the sale; the name and address of the seller and the buyer; the vehicle identification number and license plate number; the required fees, $3.75 if it is submitted to the county, or $5 if it is submitted to a subagent; and a date stamp by DOL showing that it was received on or before the fifth business day after the date of transfer.

Transportation Benefit District (TBD). A TBD is a quasi-municipal corporation and independent taxing authority that may be established by a county or city for the purpose of acquiring, constructing, improving, providing, and funding transportation improvements within the TBD. A TBD is governed by the legislative authority of the jurisdiction proposing to create it, or by a governance structure prescribed in an interlocal agreement among multiple jurisdictions. A TBD has independent taxing authority to implement the various revenue measures with voter approval. Additionally a TBD may impose a vehicle fee of up to $20 annually with a majority vote of the governing body if the TBD includes all the territory within the boundaries of the jurisdiction establishing the TBD.

Public Transportation Benefit Area (PTBA). A PTBA is a special-purpose district authorized to provide public transportation service within all or a portion of a county or counties. Cities must be wholly included or excluded. The PTBA is the most common type of district providing public transportation service in the state, with 21 currently in existence. A PTBA located on Puget Sound may also provide passenger-only ferry (POF) service after developing an investment plan. A PTBA may collect fares for service and, with approval of the majority of the voters within the area, impose up to a 0.9 percent sales and use tax within the area.

High Capacity Transportation (HCT) Systems. An HCT system is a system of public transportation services within an urbanized region operating principally on exclusive rights-of-way, and the supporting services and facilities necessary to implement the system, including interim express services and high occupancy vehicle lanes, which, taken as a whole, provides a substantially higher level of passenger capacity, speed, and service frequency than traditional public transportation systems operating principally in general purpose roadways. In the central Puget Sound region, HCT systems may be established and financed by a regional transit authority or a regional transportation investment district. There is currently one regional transit authority that has financed an HCT system, which is Sound Transit. Outside the central Puget Sound region, HCT systems may be established by transit agencies in counties containing an interstate highway that have a population greater than 175,000, which are Benton, Clark, Spokane, Thurston, Whatcom, and Yakima counties. Transit agencies authorized to provide HCT service may seek to finance the system and service with the following voter-approved revenue measures:

Sound Transit. A Regional Transit Authority (RTA) is authorized to use its tax revenues to develop and operate an HCT system. There is currently one RTA, Sound Transit, which operates light rail, commuter rail service, and express bus service in the central Puget Sound. After the approval of the most recent system expansion plan in 2008, Sound Transit imposes a sales and use tax of 0.9 percent, a motor vehicle excise tax of 0.3 percent, and a rental car sales and use tax of 0.8 percent within the boundaries of the Sound Transit district.

Motor Vehicle Excise Tax (MVET). An MVET is a tax paid on the value of a motor vehicle. For the purpose of determining any locally imposed MVET, the value of a vehicle other than a truck or trailer is 85 percent of the manufacturer's base suggested retail price of the vehicle when first offered for sale as a new vehicle, excluding any optional equipment, applicable federal excise taxes, state and local sales or use taxes, transportation or shipping costs, or preparatory or delivery costs, multiplied by the applicable percentage listed in the depreciation schedules. For the purpose of determining any locally imposed MVET, the value of a truck or trailer is the latest purchase price of the vehicle, excluding applicable federal excise taxes, state and local sales or use taxes, transportation or shipping costs, or preparatory or delivery costs, multiplied by the applicable percentage listed in the depreciation schedules based on the year of service of the vehicle since its last sale. The latest purchase year is considered the first year of service.

Property Tax Levy. The state Constitution limits regular property tax levies to a maximum of 1 percent of the property's value – $10 per $1,000 of assessed value. The Legislature established individual district rate maximums and aggregate rate maximums to keep the total tax rate for regular property taxes within the constitutional limit. For example, the state levy rate is limited to $3.60 per $1,000 of assessed value, county general levies are limited to $1.80 per $1,000 of assessed value, county road levies are limited to $2.25 per $1,000 of assessed value, and city levies are limited to $3.375 per $1,000 of assessed value. These districts are known as senior districts. Junior districts such as fire, library, hospital, and metropolitan park districts each have specific rate limits as well. The tax rates for most of these senior and junior districts must fit within an overall rate limit of $5.90 per $1,000 of assessed value. State statutes contain schedules specifying the preferential order in which the various junior taxing district levies will be prorated in the event that the $5.90 limit is exceeded. Under this prorating system, senior districts are given preference over junior districts.

Property Tax Gap. A few regular property tax levies are not placed into the $5.90 aggregate rate limit: emergency medical services, conservation futures, affordable housing, certain metropolitan park districts, county ferry districts, criminal justice, fire districts, and county transit. However, these districts are subject to reduction if the rates for these districts, the state property tax, and the districts subject to the $5.90 limit together exceed the constitutional limit of $10 per $1,000 of assessed value. These districts are in what has been called the gap, the $0.50 remaining after subtracting the $3.60 state levy and the $5.90 in local regular levies from the statutory $10 limit.

Summary of Engrossed Substitute Bill: Fuel Taxes and Transfers. The motor vehicle fuel tax is increased by $0.119 per gallon as follows:

Revenue from the $0.117 per gallon is distributed into the newly created Connecting Washington Account in the Motor Vehicle Fund.

The rate used to calculate transfers from the Motor Vehicle Fund to the ORV and Non-highway Vehicle Account, the Marine Fuel Tax Refund Account, and the Snowmobile Account for motor vehicle fuel taxes paid by non-highway users is increased with each increase in motor fuel taxes to a total of $0.347 per gallon.

The handling loss deduction from the motor vehicle fuel tax is repealed.

Weight Fees. Beginning July 1, 2016, weight fees are increased with a scale weigh of up to 14,000 pounds as shown in the table below. Beginning July 1, 2022, an additional $8 weight fee is added, which is deposited into the Multimodal Transportation Fund unless a carbon policy is adopted by rule, in which case it is deposited into the Connecting Washington Account.

Scale Weight

Current

Fee

FY 2017 Increase

FY 2017– FY 2021

Fee

FY 2022

Increase

FY 2022

Fee

4000

$10

$15

$25

$8

$33

6000

$20

$25

$45

$8

$53

8000

$30

$35

$65

$8

$73

10,000

$32

$33

$65

$8

$73

12,000

$49

$16

$65

$8

$73

14,000

$60

$5

$65

$8

$73

>16,000

$72+

$0–

$72

$8

$80

FY = Fiscal Year, July 1 through June 30 of each year.

Under the current law, weight fees increase commensurate with the license fee by weight but under this this act, the vehicles with a scale weight above fee is capped at $72 until 2022, and then $80. As a result the weight fee for vehicles 16,000 and above would decrease.

License Fee by Weight. Beginning July 1, 2016, the license fee by weight that is imposed on vehicles with a GVW of 10,000 and less is increased by $15 to $35. Beginning July 1, 2022, an additional $8 fee is added on vehicles with a GVW of less than or equal to 12,000, which is distributed to various accounts within the Motor Vehicle Fund, consistent with the distributing of other license fees by weight.

GVW

Current Fee

FY 2017

Increase

FY 2017– FY 2021

Fee

FY 2022

Increase

FY 2022

Fee

4000

$38

$15

$53

$8

$61

6000

$48

$25

$73

$8

$81

8000

$58

$35

$93

$8

$101

10,000

$60

$33

$93

$8

$101

Beginning July 1, 2016, a freight project fee of 15 percent of the license fee by weight is added on vehicles subject to a gross weight that have a GVW of more than 10,000 pounds. Proceeds from the fee are deposited in the Connecting Washington Account. Driver-related fees are deposited into the Highway Safety Fund unless a carbon policy is adopted by rule, in which case the additional revenue raised from the driver-related fee increases in this act is deposited into the Connecting Washington Account.

Driver-Related Fees. The following fee increases are effective July 1, 2016:

Document or Service

Current Fee

Proposed

Fee

CDL Requalification

$20

$35

CDL Instruction Permit

$10

$40

CDL Knowledge Exam

$10

$35

CDL Classified Skills Exam – reduced

$75

$225

CDL Classified Skills Exam

$100

$250

Enhanced Driver's Licenses and Identicards

$15

$54

The skills exam increases do not impact applicants that intend to drive a school bus. Payment of the CDL knowledge exam fee and the CDL classified skills exam fee entitles the individual to take the test up to two times.

If an enhanced driver's license or identicard is issued for a period other than six years, the fee is $9 per year.

Report of Sale and Transitional Ownership. Beginning July 1, 2017, service fees, filing fees, license plate technology fees, and license service fees that are imposed on other titling and registration transactions are also applied to report of sale and transitional ownership transactions for a total cost of $8.75 as shown in the table below. The bolded numbers represent fees that are not currently imposed by location.

Subagent

Auditor 

DOL

License Plate Technology Fee

$0.25

$0.25

$0.25

License Service Fee

$0.50

$0.50

$0.50

Filing Fee

$3.00

$3.00

$3.00

Subagent Service Fee

$5.00

$5.00

$5.00

Current Total Administrative Fees

$5.00

$3.75

$0.00

New Total Administrative Fees

$8.75

$8.75

$8.75

A report of sale that is received by DOL, the county auditor or other agent, or subagent after 21 days becomes effective on the day it is received by DOL, the county auditor or other agent, or subagent.

Intermittent-Use Trailer Registration. The registered owner of a trailer that is used only for intermittent personal use may apply for a permanent license plate and registration. Intermittent personal use is not general or daily, but seasonal or sporadic, and not more than once per week on average. There is a one-time fee for a permanent license plate and registration on an intermittent-use trailer of $187.50 which is distributed as follows: $20.35 must be deposited in the State Patrol Highway Account, $2.02 is deposited in the Puget Sound Ferry Operations Account, and the remainder is deposited to the Motor Vehicle Fund. Trailers registered as intermittent-use trailers are not subject to annual registration renewal. The owner of an intermittent-use trailer that is at least 30 years old may apply to DOL to display a license plate that was issued in the year that the trailer was manufactured to be displayed in lieu of a new license plate. The permanent license plate and registration on an intermittent-use trailer expires when ownership of the vehicle changes, when the vehicle is permanently removed from the state, or is otherwise disposed of. The permanent plate must be removed from the trailer prior to conveyance. A violation of the provisions related to intermittent-use trailers is subject to a traffic infraction of up to $150 including all applicable assessments and fees.

Studded Tire Fee. Beginning January 1, 2017, a fee of $5 is added to the sale of each new studded tire, of which the seller retains 10 percent and the remainder is deposited to the Motor Vehicle Fund.

Electric Vehicles. Beginning July 1, 2017, the electric vehicle fee is expanded to include plug-in electric hybrids vehicles. Proceeds from the fees are redirected to the Transportation Innovative Partnership Account until electric vehicles reach 0.5 percent of the vehicle fleet or until 2026, unless a carbon policy is adopted by rule, in which case it is directed back to the Motor Vehicle Fund. An electric vehicle infrastructure bank is created. The purpose of the bank is to provide financial assistance for the installation of publicly accessible electric vehicle charging stations in Washington. Electric vehicle infrastructure receiving financial assistance must include both DC fastcharging and Level 1 or Level 2 charging equipment. WSDOT must administer and disperse any funds deposited into the Transportation Innovative Partnership Account and prior to providing any financial assistance must submit a business plan to the transportation committees of the Legislature and to the Governor's Office.

Transportation Benefit Districts. A TBD may impose a vehicle fee of up to $40 upon a majority vote of the governing body if a $20 fee has been in effect for at least 24 months.

Community Transit Sales and Use Tax. A PTBA in a county with a population of 700,000 or more, that also contains a city with a population of 75,000 or more that operates a municipal transit system, may impose an additional sales and use tax of up to 0.3 percent with approval of the voters within the area. Based on the current population and existing public transportation governing structures, the act would only apply to Community Transit in Snohomish County.

Kitsap Transit POF District. The governing body of a PTBA only bordering western Puget Sound with a population of more than 200,000 – currently only Kitsap Transit, may establish one or more POF districts (Districts) within the boundaries of the PTBA. The boundaries of a District may include all or a portion of a city or town if the portion to be included is within the PTBA's boundaries. A District is considered an independent taxing authority, and is governed by the existing governing body of the PTBA that creates the District. A District is authorized to establish, finance, and provide POF service. The District also has specific authority to enter into contracts for POF service, public-private partnerships, design-build or general contractor/construction management, and other alternative procurement processes. A District may also issue certain general obligation and revenue bonds.

Prior to implementing POF service, a District must develop a POF investment plan that contains specific elements. In order to provide POF service, a majority of the voters in the District must approve the POF investment plan and the proposed taxes as part of a single vote.

A District may collect the following revenues for the purpose of implementing the POF investment plan:

Sound Transit. The following taxes may be imposed by and within the boundary of an RTA in a county with a population of 1.5 million or more if approved by a majority of the voters within the boundary of the RTA:

If an RTA imposes any of the taxes authorized above they are prohibited from receiving state funding.

Other Provisions. Garbage and refuse companies may consider the cost of any taxes or fees that are imposed or increased as part of this act normal operating expenses and are not required to apply to the Utilities and Transportation Commission for pass-through rates.

The sales tax deferral on the Tacoma Narrows Bridge project is extended from December 31, 2018, to December 31, 2031.

The definition of "low-income" that a transportation benefit district uses to determine eligibility for rebates of taxes, fees, and tolls is changed from at or below 45 percent of the median household income to 75 percent of the median household income.

The Aeronautics Account, which was inadvertently repealed in 2013, is reinstated.

In order for any substantive section of this act to take effect the following bills must be enacted by July 1, 2015:

Funds in the Connecting Washington Account and any other revenues that are generated as a result of this act may not be used for the state route 99 Alaskan Way viaduct replacement project.

The existing Complete Streets grant program at the Department of Transportation is expanded to included projects on county roads as well as city streets.

Appropriation: None.

Fiscal Note: Available.

[OFM requested ten-year cost projection pursuant to I-960.]

Committee/Commission/Task Force Created: No.

Effective Date: The bill contains several effective dates including emergency clauses. Please refer to the summary as well as the bill.

Staff Summary of Public Testimony on Proposed Substitute as Heard in Committee: PRO: This package is a great start to fixing the statewide transportation system. Fewer vehicles idling in traffic is a benefit to the state of Washington. The package makes progress toward taking care of what we have and investing in the state economy. This package is a balance of reforms and tax increases, and funds important projects across the state. A vast majority of people commute to work and as a result our highways are congested. Relieving congestion advances Washington's economy and makes Washington a better place to live and work. Nobody likes new taxes but this will allow for important investments infrastructure.

CON: The provision in the bill that hampers the ability for the Governor to enact a low-carbon fuel standard is a concern. Mobility funding is at a historic low and full authority should be provided to Sound Transit.

OTHER: Light rail is crucial and as such the full amount of the requested authorization should be granted to Sound Transit. Additional funds should be provided for safe routes to school and bicycle and pedestrian programs. Revenue should not be tied to carbon standards or reforms.

Persons Testifying: PRO: Larry Pursley, WA Trucking Assns.; Patty Lent, Mayor of Bremerton; Randy Netherlin, Mason County Commissioner; Jill Guernsey, Mayor of Gig Harbor; Claudia Balducci, Mayor of Bellevue; Kevin Wallace, Deputy Mayor of Bellevue; Don Anderson, Mayor of Lakewood; Tim Puryear, Lakewood Industrial Park; Michael Grayum, DuPont Mayor; Michael Courts, DuPont Councilmember; Katherine Campbell, SeaTac City Councilmember; Tony Anderson, SeaTac Deputy Mayor; Councilmember Francis Benjamin, Assn. of WA Cities, city of Pullman; John Marchione, Mayor, city of Redmond; Suzette Cooke, Mayor, city of Kent; Fred Butler, Mayor, city of Issaquah; John Lovick, Snohomish County Executive; Ray Stephanson, Mayor, city of Everett; Troy McClelland, CEO, Economic Alliance of Snohomish County; Crystal Donner, Vice President, Economic Alliance of Snohomish County; Vern Little, Mayor, city of Lake Stevens; Jon Nehring, Mayor, city of Marysville; Dave Earling, Mayor, city of Edmonds; Blake Trask, WA Bikes; Vic Colman, Childhood Obesity Prevention Coalition; Lindsay Hovind, American Heart Assn.; John Parrott, President, TOTE; Tom Pierson, President and CEO, Tacoma/Pierce County Chamber of Commerce; Tim Thompson, SR-167 Completion Coalition; Doug Richardson, Pierce County Councilman; Tim Curtis, Mayor, city of Fife; John Knutsen, Mayor, city of Puyallup; Catherine Rudolph, Government Affairs Director, Tacoma Pierce County Assn. of Realtors; Vince Santiago, Transportation Club of Tacoma; Don Meyer, Commissioner, Port of Tacoma; Stephanie Bowman, Commissioner, Port of Seattle; Eric Johnson, Executive Director, WA Public Ports Assn.; Kris Johnson, Assn. of WA Business; Steve Mullen, WA Roundtable; Lori Mattson, Tri Cities Chamber of Commerce; George Allen, Seattle Chamber of Commerce; Alisha Benson, Greater Spokane Inc; Lincoln Vanderveen, Bellevue Chamber of Commerce; Michael Shaw, WA State Transit Assn.; Brad Patterson, Mason Transit and Small and Mid-size Transit Alliance; Irene Plenefisch, Microsoft; David Condon, Mayor, city of Spokane; Kevin Bouchey, Yakima County Commissioner; Gary Rowe, WA State Assn. of Counties; Davor Gjurasic, Community Transit; Don Gerend, Sammamish City Councilmember; Dow Constantine, King County Executive; Larry Phillips, King County Council Chair; Brad Collins, Clallam Transit System, Vice Chair; Jordan Royer, Pacific Merchant Shipping Assn.; Walt Elliott, Executive Council of Ferry Advisory Committees; Sam Pace, South Sound Chambers of Commerce Legislative Coalition; Nancy Wyatt, Auburn Area Chamber of Commerce; Lora Butterfield, Fife Milton Edgewood Chamber of Commerce; Carolyn Logue, South Sound Chamber of Commerce Legislative Coalition; Charla Neuman, Neuman Navigations & Puyallup/Sumner Chamber of Commerce; Scott Robbert, Complete Distribution Services; John Filbert, Soniq Transportation and Warehouse; Vicky Baxter, Renton Chamber of Commerce; David Della, Community Director, Waste Management; Brent Camann, SECO Development; Jim Halstrom, WA State Tree Fruit Assn., Southern Wine & Spirits Co; Ron Arp, Identity Clark County; Steve Stuart, Ridgefield City Manager; Terry Kohl, WA State Snowmobile Assn.; Paul Roberts, Sound Transit, Everett City Councilman.

CON: Cliff Traisman, WA Conservation Voters, WA Environmental Council; Jessica Finn-Coven, Climate Solutions; Bruce Wishart, Sierra Club.

OTHER: Tom Trulove, Cheney; Andrew Austin, Transportation Choices Coalition; Bryce Yadon, Futurewise; Jeff Johnson, WA State Labor Council; Lee Newgent, WA Building and Constructions Trades; Ellicott Dandy, OneAmerica; Ed Murray, Mayor, city of Seattle; Lynn Peterson, WSDOT; Charles Knutson, Governor's Office.