SENATE BILL REPORT
SB 5604
BYSenators Vognild, Nelson, Bottiger, Rasmussen, Owen, Craswell, Bailey, Benitz, Hayner and Johnson; by request of Office of the Governor and Commissioner of Public Lands
Authorizing the conveyance of land for a United States Navy base in Everett.
Senate Committee on Natural Resources
Senate Hearing Date(s):February 18, 1987; February 25, 1987
Majority Report: That Substitute Senate Bill No. 5604 be substituted therefor, and the substitute bill do pass.
Signed by Senators Owen, Chairman; DeJarnatt, Vice Chairman; Barr, Craswell, McDonald, Patterson.
Senate Staff:Kaleen Cottingham (786-7415); Vic Moon (786-7469)
February 25, 1987
AS REPORTED BY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES, FEBRUARY 25, 1987
BACKGROUND:
The U.S. Navy proposes constructing berthing and support facilities at Everett's Norton Avenue Terminal site. The Navy's Homeport in Port Gardner will have space and support for up to 15 ships on the 117 acre site. In order to construct the Navy's facility, over 3 million cubic yards of material will be dredged from the mouth of the Snohomish River, including nearly a million yards of material contaminated with cadmium, mercury, lead, copper, PCBs and poly-aromatic hydrocarbons. The dredge spoils disposal site is proposed in deep water (330 to 410 feet deep) approximately 2 miles from the dredging site. The Navy proposes to dredge the material with a clam-shell-type dredge, load the material onto a barge and then dump the material at the designated disposal site. The Navy then proposes to cap the contaminated dredge material by dumping "clean" material through a pipe so that it will settle on top of the contaminated material to a depth of one meter.
Currently, the state owns some of the tidelands and all of the bedlands associated with the Navy Homeport project. In addition to the issues surrounding actual transfer of these tidelands and bedlands to the Navy, ownership also triggers an issue of whether the Navy must comply with the state's Shoreline Management Act.
The Navy is required under the federal Clean Water Act to obtain from the state a water quality certification and to obtain a section 10/404 dredge and fill permit from the Army Corps of Engineers. An issue has been raised whether the Navy is required to obtain from the state a shoreline substantial development permit under the Shoreline Management Act. The state argues that unless the Navy owns both the base construction and the dredge disposal sites, the Navy must obtain the substantial development permit. The state so argues because the federal Coastal Zone Management Act requires federal agencies undertaking an activity in the coastal zone to obtain a certification that the activity is consistent with the state's approved coastal zone management plan. Washington's approved coastal zone management plan consists of the entire Shoreline Management Act and implementing rules and plans. Congress, in its appropriation for this project, has also directed the Navy to obtain "all federal, state, and local permits required for the dredging activities" in the Everett project.
SUMMARY:
The intent of this legislation is to acknowledge the economic development associated with the Navy's homeport project in Everett while at the same time stating that the state should not assume liability or risks resulting from the Navy's proposal to cap the contaminated dredge spoils resulting from the project. The Legislature also acknowledges the importance of improving water quality in Puget Sound.
At the request of the Navy, and after compliance with the intent of this act, the Commissioner of Public lands is authorized to convey or permit the use of the beds of navigable waters in Port Gardner Bay for the Navy dredge spoil site. The conveyance shall reserve to the state the use of the property and associated water not inconsistent with its use as a disposal site.
The conveyance shall also include covenants as follows:
(1)The Navy will be responsible for any damage or liability relating to the use of the property including paying damages and undertaking remedial actions relating to water quality, hazardous substances, and fish or other natural resources;
(2)Comply with all permits relating to dredging; and
(3)Allow the state to enforce provisions of the Clean Water Act and other federal and state laws.
The Commissioner of Public Lands is authorized to exchange tidelands to the Navy necessary to locate the Navy base. The Harbor Line Commission shall modify harbor lines to facilitate the exchanges.
EFFECT OF PROPOSED SUBSTITUTE:
The need for the emergency clause is recited. Existing authority of the DNR to lease bedlands is modified to accommodate the lease to the Navy.
The dredge spoil site contemplated by the Navy is to be done by a lease instead of by conveyance. The term of the lease shall be 30 years. The lease shall contain conditions which (1) require the Navy to agree to hold the state harmless for any damage or liability relating to or resulting from the use of the dredge spoil site; (2) require the Navy to comply with all terms and conditions of federal permits (Section 401 Water Quality Certification and Section 404 Dredge and Fill Permit) and to require the Navy to comply with all statutes, regulations and permits relating to water quality and aquatic life including the Shoreline Management Act and Shoreline Master programs.
The enforceability of terms and conditions imposed on the Navy arise from several sources: (1) the lease; (2) the Section 401 Water Quality Permit; (3) the federal Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act; (4) the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act; and (5) any other applicable federal or state laws.
The exchange of tidelands shall be by deed executed by the Governor.
Emergency and severability clauses are added.
Fiscal Note: requested
Senate Committee - Testified: Brian Boyle, Commissioner of Public Lands; Gene Nelson; Paul Isaki, Governor's office; Bob Dilger, Washington State Building Trades Council; Chris Platt, Puget Sound Alliance; Capt. James Roth, U.S. Navy; Judith Merchant, Department of Fisheries