H-2452              _______________________________________________

 

                                          SUBSTITUTE HOUSE BILL NO. 1128

                        _______________________________________________

 

State of Washington                              50th Legislature                              1987 Regular Session

 

By House Committee on Ways & Means/Appropriations (originally sponsored by Representatives H. Sommers, Niemi, Allen, Miller, Rust, Basich, Sayan, Bristow, Rayburn and Winsley)

 

 

Read first time 3/9/87 and passed to Committee on Rules.

 

 


AN ACT Relating to the calculation of retirement benefits for part-time teachers; amending RCW 41.32.010 and 41.32.498; adding a new section to chapter 41.32 RCW; and creating a new section.

 

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON:

 

        Sec. 1.  Section 6, chapter 13, Laws of 1985 and RCW 41.32.010 are each amended to read as follows:

          As used in this chapter, unless a different meaning is plainly required by the context:

          (1) (a) "Accumulated contributions" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977, means the sum of all regular annuity contributions with regular interest thereon.

          (b) "Accumulated contributions" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means the sum of all contributions standing to the credit of a member in the member's individual account together with the regular interest thereon.

          (2) "Actuarial equivalent" means a benefit of equal value when computed upon the basis of such mortality tables and regulations as shall be adopted by the director and regular interest.

          (3) "Annuity" means the moneys payable per year during life by reason of accumulated contributions of a member.

          (4) "Annuity fund" means the fund in which all of the accumulated contributions of members are held.

          (5) "Annuity reserve fund" means the fund to which all accumulated contributions are transferred upon retirement.

          (6) (a) "Beneficiary" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977, means any person in receipt of a retirement allowance or other benefit provided by this chapter.

          (b) "Beneficiary" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means any person in receipt of a retirement allowance or other benefit provided by this chapter resulting from service rendered to an employer by another person.

          (7) "Contract" means any agreement for service and compensation between a member and an employer.

          (8) "Creditable service" means membership service plus prior service for which credit is allowable.  This subsection shall apply only to persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (9) "Dependent" means receiving one-half or more of support from a member.

          (10) "Disability allowance" means monthly payments during disability.  This subsection shall apply only to persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (11) (a) (i) "Earnable compensation" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977, means all salaries and wages paid by an employer to an employee member of the retirement system for personal services rendered during a fiscal year.  In all cases where compensation includes maintenance the employer shall fix the value of that part of the compensation not paid in money:  PROVIDED, That retroactive payments to an individual by an employer on reinstatement of the employee in a position, or payments by an employer to an individual in lieu of reinstatement in a position which are awarded or granted as the equivalent of the salary or wages which the individual would have earned during a payroll period shall be considered earnable compensation and the individual shall receive the equivalent service credit:  PROVIDED FURTHER, That if a leave of absence, without pay, is taken by a member for the purpose of serving as a member of the state legislature, and such member has served in the legislature five or more years, the salary which would have been received for the position from which the leave of absence was taken shall be considered as compensation earnable if the employee's contribution thereon is paid by the employee.  In addition, where a member has been a member of the state legislature for five or more years, earnable compensation for the member's two highest compensated consecutive years of service shall include a sum not to exceed thirty-six hundred dollars for each of such two consecutive years, regardless of whether or not legislative service was rendered during those two years.

          (ii) For members employed less than full time under written contract with a school district, or community college district, in an instructional position, for which the member receives service credit of less than one year in ((both)) all of the years used to determine the earnable compensation used for computing benefits due under RCW 41.32.497, 41.32.498, and 41.32.520, the member may elect, subject to RCW 41.32.498, to have earnable compensation ((means the compensation the member would have received in the same position if employed on a regular full-time basis for the same contract period)) defined as provided in section 2 of this 1987 act.  For the purposes of this subsection, the term "instructional position" means a position in which more than seventy-five percent of the member's time is spent ((in preparation for and in classroom instruction)) as a classroom instructor (including office hours), a librarian, or a counselor.  Earnable compensation shall be so defined only for the purpose of the calculation of retirement benefits and only as necessary to insure that members who receive fractional service credit under RCW 41.32.270 receive benefits proportional to those received by members who have received full-time service credit.

          (b) "Earnable compensation" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means salaries or wages earned by a member during a payroll period for personal services, including overtime payments, and shall include wages and salaries deferred under provisions established pursuant to sections 403(b), 414(h), and 457 of the United States Internal Revenue Code, but shall exclude lump sum payments for deferred annual sick leave, unused accumulated vacation, unused accumulated annual leave, or any form of severance pay:  PROVIDED, That retroactive payments to an individual by an employer on reinstatement of the employee in a position or payments by an employer to an individual in lieu of reinstatement in a position which are awarded or granted as the equivalent of the salary or wages which the individual would have earned during a payroll period shall be considered earnable compensation, to the extent provided above, and the individual shall receive the equivalent service credit:  PROVIDED FURTHER, That in any year in which a member serves in the legislature the member shall have the option of having such member's earnable compensation be the greater of:

          (i) the earnable compensation the member would have received had such member not served in the legislature; or

          (ii) such member's actual earnable compensation received for teaching and legislative service combined.  Any additional contributions to the retirement system required because compensation earnable under subparagraph (i) of this subsection is greater than compensation earnable under subparagraph (ii) of this subsection shall be paid by the member for both member and employer contributions.

          (12) "Employer" means the state of Washington, the school district, or any agency of the state of Washington by which the member is paid.

          (13) "Fiscal year" means a year which begins July 1st and ends June 30th of the following year.

          (14) "Former state fund" means the state retirement fund in operation for teachers under chapter 187, Laws of 1923, as amended.

          (15) "Local fund" means any of the local retirement funds for teachers operated in any school district in accordance with the provisions of chapter 163, Laws of 1917 as amended.

          (16) "Member" means any teacher included in the membership of the retirement system.  Also, any other employee of the public schools who, on July 1, 1947, had not elected to be exempt from membership and who, prior to that date, had by an authorized payroll deduction, contributed to the annuity fund.

          (17) "Membership service" means service rendered subsequent to the first day of eligibility of a person to membership in the retirement system:  PROVIDED, That where a member is employed by two or more employers the individual shall only receive one month's service credit during any calendar month in which multiple service is rendered.  The provisions of this subsection shall apply only to persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (18) "Pension" means the moneys payable per year during life from the pension reserve fund.

          (19) "Pension reserve fund" is a fund in which shall be accumulated an actuarial reserve adequate to meet present and future pension liabilities of the system and from which all pension obligations are to be paid.

          (20) "Prior service" means service rendered prior to the first date of eligibility to membership in the retirement system for which credit is allowable.  The provisions of this subsection shall apply only to persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (21) "Prior service contributions" means contributions made by a member to secure credit for prior service.  The provisions of this subsection shall apply only to persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (22) "Public school" means any institution or activity operated by the state of Washington or any instrumentality or political subdivision thereof  employing teachers, except the University of Washington and Washington State University.

          (23) "Regular contributions" means the amounts required to be deducted from the compensation of a member and credited to the member's individual account in the annuity fund.  This subsection shall apply only to persons establishing membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (24) "Regular interest" means such rate as the director may determine.

          (25) (a) "Retirement allowance" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977, means the sum of annuity and pension or any optional benefits payable in lieu thereof.

          (b) "Retirement allowance" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means monthly payments to a retiree or beneficiary as provided in this chapter.

          (26) "Retirement system" means the Washington state teachers' retirement system.

          (27) (a) "Service" means the time during which a member has been employed by an employer for compensation:  PROVIDED, That where a member is employed by two or more employers the individual shall only receive one month's service credit during any calendar month in which multiple service is rendered.

          (b) "Service" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means periods of employment by a member for one or more employers for which earnable compensation is earned for ninety or more hours per calendar month.  Members shall receive twelve months of service for each contract year or school year of employment.

          Any person who is a member of the teachers' retirement system and who is elected or appointed to a state elective position may continue to be a member of the retirement system and continue to receive service credit for the time spent in a state elective position by making the required member contributions.

         

          When an individual is employed by two or more employers the individual shall only receive one month's service credit during any calendar month in which multiple service for ninety or more hours is rendered.

          Notwithstanding RCW 41.32.240, teachers covered by RCW 41.32.755 through 41.32.825, who render service need not serve for ninety days to obtain membership so long as the required contribution is submitted for such ninety-day period.  Where a member did not receive service credit under RCW 41.32.775 through 41.32.825 due to the ninety-day period in RCW 41.32.240 the member may receive service credit for that period so long as the required contribution is submitted for the period.  Anyone entering membership on or after October 1, 1977, and prior to July 1, 1979, shall have until June 30, 1980, to make the required contribution in one lump sum.

          (28) "Survivors' benefit fund" means the fund from which survivor benefits are paid to dependents of deceased members.  This subsection shall apply only to persons establishing membership in the retirement system on or before September 30, 1977.

          (29) "Teacher" means any person qualified to teach who is engaged by a public school in an instructional, administrative, or supervisory capacity.  The term includes state, educational service district, and school district superintendents and their assistants and all employees certificated by the superintendent of public instruction; and in addition thereto any full time school doctor who is employed by a public school and renders service of an instructional or educational nature.

          (30) "Average final compensation" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means the member's average earnable compensation of the highest consecutive sixty months of service prior to such member's retirement, termination, or death.  Periods constituting authorized leaves of absence may not be used in the calculation of average final compensation.

          (31) "Retiree" for persons who establish membership in the retirement system on or after October 1, 1977, means any member in receipt of a retirement allowance or other benefit provided by this chapter resulting from service rendered to an employer by such member.

          (32) "Department" means the department of retirement systems created in chapter 41.50 RCW.

          (33) "Director" means the director of the department.

          (34) "State elective position" means any position held by any person elected or appointed to state-wide office or elected or appointed as a member of the legislature.

          (35) "State actuary" or "actuary" means the person appointed pursuant to RCW 44.44.010(2).

          (36) "Retirement board" means the director of retirement systems.

 

          NEW SECTION.  Sec. 2.  A new section is added to chapter 41.32 RCW to read as follows:

          (1) Subject to the limitations contained in this section, for the purposes of RCW 41.32.010(11)(a)(ii), earnable compensation means the compensation the member would have received in the same position if employed on a regular full-time basis for the same contract period.

          (2) In order to ensure that the benefit provided by this section is not used to unfairly inflate a member's retirement allowance, the department shall adopt rules having the force of law to govern the application of this section.

          (3)(a) In adopting rules which apply to a member employed by a school district, the department may consult the district's salary schedule and related workload provisions, if any, adopted pursuant to RCW 28A.67.066.  The rules may require that, in order to be eligible for this benefit, a member's position must either be included on the district's schedule, or the position must have duties, responsibilities, and method of pay which are similar to those found on the district's schedule.

          (b) In adopting rules which apply to a member employed by a community college district, the department may consult the district's salary schedule and workload provisions contained in an agreement negotiated pursuant to chapter 28B.52 RCW, or similar documents.  The rules may require that, in order to be eligible for this benefit, a member's position must either be included on the district's agreement, or the position must have duties, responsibilities, and method of pay which are similar to those found on the district's agreement.  The maximum full-time work week used in calculating the benefit for community college employees paid on an hourly rate shall in no case exceed fifteen credit hours, twenty classroom contact hours, or thirty-five assigned hours.

          (4) If the legislature amends or revokes the benefit provided by this section, no affected employee who thereafter retires is entitled to receive the benefit as a matter of contractual right.

 

        Sec. 3.  Section 3, chapter 189, Laws of 1973 1st ex. sess. as amended by section 4, chapter 199, Laws of 1974 ex. sess. and RCW 41.32.498 are each amended to read as follows:

          Any person who becomes a member subsequent to April 25, 1973 or who has made the election, provided by RCW 41.32.497, to receive the benefit provided by this section, shall receive a retirement allowance consisting of:

          (1) An annuity which shall be the actuarial equivalent of his additional contributions on full salary as provided by chapter 274, Laws of 1955 and his lump sum payment in excess of the required contribution rate made at date of retirement, pursuant to RCW 41.32.350, if any; and

          (2) A combined pension and annuity service retirement allowance which shall be equal to two percent of his average earnable compensation for his two highest compensated consecutive years of service times the total years of creditable service established with the retirement system, to a maximum of sixty percent of such average earnable compensation:  PROVIDED, That any member who elects to have his or her benefit calculated using the definition of earnable compensation provided in section 2 of this 1987 act shall receive a pension based on his or her highest compensated sixty consecutive months of service.  Any member may irrevocably elect, at time of retirement, to withdraw all or a part of his accumulated contributions and to receive, in lieu of the full retirement allowance provided by this subsection, a reduction in the standard two percent allowance, of the actuarially determined amount of monthly annuity which would have been purchased by said contributions:  PROVIDED FURTHER, That no member may withdraw an amount of accumulated contributions which would lower his retirement allowance below the minimum allowance provided by RCW 41.32.497 as now or hereafter amended:  AND PROVIDED FURTHER, That said reduced amount may be reduced even further pursuant to the options provided in subsection (4) below;

          (3) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsections (1) and (2) of this section, the retirement allowance payable for service of a member who was state superintendent of public instruction on January 1, 1973 shall be equal to three percent of the average earnable compensation of his two highest consecutive years of service for each year of such service.

          (4) Upon an application for retirement approved by the board of trustees every member shall receive the maximum retirement allowance available to him throughout life unless prior to the time the first installment thereof becomes due he has elected to receive the reduced amount provided in subsection (2) and/or has elected by executing the proper application therefor, to receive the actuarial equivalent of his retirement allowance in reduced payments throughout his life, with the options listed below:

          Option 1.  If he dies before he has received the present value of his accumulated contributions at the time of his retirement by virtue of the annuity portion of his retirement allowance, the unpaid balance shall be paid to his estate or to such person as he shall have nominated by written designation executed and filed with the board of trustees.

          Option 2.  Upon his death his adjusted retirement allowance shall be continued throughout the life of and paid to such person as he shall have nominated by written designation duly executed and filed with the board of trustees at the time of his retirement.

          Option 3.  Upon his death one-half of his adjusted retirement allowance shall be continued throughout the life of and paid to such person as he shall have nominated by written designation executed and filed with the board of trustees at the time of his retirement.

 

          NEW SECTION.  Sec. 4.     This act shall not be construed as impairing any existing right acquired or any liability incurred by any member of the retirement system under the sections amended by this act.