H-4481              _______________________________________________

 

                                          SUBSTITUTE HOUSE BILL NO. 2365

                        _______________________________________________

 

State of Washington                               51st Legislature                              1990 Regular Session

 

By House Committee on Natural Resources & Parks (originally sponsored by Representatives Spanel, Ferguson, R. Fisher, Brumsickle, Sayan, K. Wilson, Sprenkle and Braddock)

 

 

Read first time 2/2/90.

 

 


AN ACT Relating to forest practices on lands likely to convert to other uses; amending RCW 76.09.050, 76.09.060, and 76.09.240.

 

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON:

 

        Sec. 1.  Section 5, chapter 137, Laws of 1974 ex. sess. as last amended by section 47, chapter 36, Laws of 1988 and RCW 76.09.050 are each amended to read as follows:

          (1) The board shall establish by rule which forest practices shall be included within each of the following classes:

          Class I:  Minimal or specific forest practices that have no direct potential for damaging a public resource that may be conducted without submitting an application or a notification;

          Class II:  Forest practices  which have a less than ordinary potential for damaging a public resource that may be conducted without submitting an application and may begin five calendar days, or such lesser time as the department may determine, after written notification by the operator, in the manner, content, and form as prescribed by the department, is received by the department.  Class II shall not include forest practices:

          (a) On lands platted after January 1, 1960, or being converted to another use;

          (b) Which require approvals under the provisions of the hydraulics act, RCW 75.20.100;

          (c) Within "shorelines of the state" as defined in RCW 90.58.030; or

          (d) Excluded from Class II by the board;

          Class III:  Forest practices  other than those contained in Class I, II, or IV.  A Class III application must be approved or disapproved by the department within  thirty calendar days from the date the department receives the application;

          Class IV:  Forest practices other than those contained in Class I or II:  (a) On lands platted after January 1, 1960, (b) on lands being converted to another use, (c) on lands which, pursuant to RCW 76.09.070 as now or hereafter amended, are not to be reforested because of the likelihood of future conversion to urban development, and/or (d) which have a potential for a substantial impact on the environment and therefore require an evaluation by the department as to whether or not a detailed statement must be prepared pursuant to the state environmental policy act, chapter 43.21C RCW.  Such evaluation shall be made within ten days from the date the department receives the application:  PROVIDED, That nothing herein shall be construed to prevent any local or regional governmental entity from determining that a detailed statement must be prepared for an action pursuant to a Class IV forest practice taken by that governmental entity concerning the land on which forest practices will be conducted.  A Class IV application must be approved or disapproved by the department within thirty calendar days from the date the department receives the application, unless the department determines that a detailed statement must be made, in which case the application must be approved or disapproved by the department within sixty calendar days from the date the department receives the application, unless the commissioner of public lands, through the promulgation of a formal order, determines that the process cannot be completed within such period.

          As guidance in determining the likelihood of future conversion to urban development the department shall consider all available information, including but not limited to:

          (i) Whether the land is assessed under the provisions of chapter 84.28, 84.33, or 84.34 RCW;

          (ii) Whether the land is excluded from any local improvement district;

          (iii) Whether the classification of the land in the local comprehensive plan or the local zoning ordinance permits or encourages long-term timber production;

          (iv) Whether the land lies outside the current or proposed boundary of a city or the urban growth boundary of a city or outside a water or sewer district;

          (v) Whether the land has received previous development permit approval; and

          (vi) The presence or absence of a forest management plan for the land.

          Forest practices under Classes I, II, and III are exempt from the requirements for preparation of a detailed statement under the state environmental policy act.

          In reviewing and determining the class of a forest practice application the department shall give substantial weight to the stated intention of the applicant or landowner.  Indicators of an intent of the landowner to maintain the land in commercial forestry include the demonstration of a forest management plan, the enrollment of the land under the provisions of chapter 84.28, 84.33, or 84.34 RCW, or previous application for a development permit.

          (2) No Class II, Class III, or Class IV forest practice shall be commenced ((or continued after January 1, 1975,)) unless the department has received a notification with regard to a Class II forest practice or approved an application with regard to a Class III or Class IV forest practice containing all information required by RCW 76.09.060 as now or hereafter amended((:  PROVIDED, That any person commencing a forest practice during 1974 may continue such forest practice until April 1, 1975, if such person has submitted an application to the department prior to January 1, 1975:  PROVIDED, FURTHER, That)).  In the event forest practices regulations necessary for the scheduled implementation of this chapter and RCW 90.48.420 have not been adopted in time to meet such schedules, the department shall have the authority to regulate forest practices and approve applications on such terms and conditions consistent with this chapter and RCW 90.48.420 and the purposes and policies of RCW 76.09.010 until applicable forest practices regulations are in effect.

          (3) If a notification or application is delivered in person to the department by the operator or his agent, the department shall immediately provide a dated receipt thereof.  In all other cases, the department shall immediately mail a dated receipt to the operator.

          (4) Forest practices shall be conducted in accordance with the forest practices regulations, orders and directives as authorized by this chapter or the forest practices regulations, and the terms and conditions of any approved applications.

          (5) The department of natural resources shall notify the applicant in writing of either its approval of the application or its disapproval of the application and the specific manner in which the application fails to comply with the provisions of this section or with the forest practices regulations.  Except as provided otherwise in this section, if the department fails to either approve or disapprove an application or any portion thereof within the applicable time limit, the application shall be deemed approved and the operation may be commenced:  PROVIDED, That this provision shall not apply to applications which are neither approved nor disapproved pursuant to the provisions of subsection (7) of this section:  PROVIDED, FURTHER, That if seasonal field conditions prevent the department from being able to properly evaluate the application, the department may issue an approval conditional upon further review within sixty days((:  PROVIDED, FURTHER, That the department shall have until April 1, 1975, to approve or disapprove an application involving forest practices allowed to continue to April 1, 1975, under the provisions of subsection (2) of this section)).  Upon receipt of any notification or any satisfactorily completed application the department shall in any event no later than two business days after such receipt transmit a copy to the departments of ecology, wildlife, and fisheries, and to the county ((in which)), city, or town in whose jurisdiction the forest practice is to be commenced.   Any comments by such agencies shall be directed to the department of natural resources.

          (6) If the county, city, or town believes that an application is inconsistent with this chapter, the forest practices regulations, or any local authority consistent with RCW 76.09.240 as now or hereafter amended, it may so notify the department and the applicant, specifying its objections.

          (7) The department shall not approve portions of applications to which a county, city, or town objects if:

          (a) The department receives written notice from the county, city, or town of such objections within fourteen business days from the time of  transmittal of the application to the county, city, or town, or one day before the department acts on the application, whichever is later; and

          (b) The objections relate to lands ((either)):

          (i) Platted after January 1, 1960; ((or))

          (ii) Being converted to another use; or

          (iii) Which the department has determined are not to be reforested due to the likelihood of future conversion to urban development.

          The department shall either disapprove those portions of such application or appeal the county, city, or town objections to the appeals board.  If the objections related to subparagraphs (b) (i) and (ii) of this subsection are based on local authority consistent with RCW 76.09.240 as now or hereafter amended, the department shall disapprove the application until such time as the county, city, or town consents to its approval or such disapproval is reversed on appeal.  The applicant shall be a party to all department appeals of county, city, or town objections.  Unless the county, city, or town either consents or has waived its rights under this subsection, the department shall not approve portions of an application affecting such lands until the minimum time for county, city, or town objections has expired.

          (8) In addition to any rights under the above paragraph, the county, city, or town may appeal any department approval of an application with respect to any lands within its jurisdiction.  The appeals board may suspend the department's approval in whole or in part pending such appeal where there exists potential for immediate and material damage to a public resource.

          (9) Appeals under this section shall be made to the appeals board in the manner and time provided in RCW 76.09.220(8).  In such appeals there shall be no presumption of correctness of either the county, city, or town or the department position.

          (10) The department shall, within four business days notify the county, city, or town of all notifications, approvals, and disapprovals of an application affecting lands within the county, city, or town, except to the extent the county, city, or town has waived its right to such notice.

          (11) A county, city, or town may waive in whole or in part its rights under this section, and may withdraw or modify any such waiver, at any time by written notice to the department.

 

        Sec. 2.  Section 6, chapter 137, Laws of 1974 ex. sess. as amended by section 3, chapter 200, Laws of 1975 1st ex. sess. and RCW 76.09.060 are each amended to read as follows:

          (1) The department shall prescribe the form and contents of the notification and application.  The forest practices regulations shall specify by whom and under what conditions the notification and application shall be signed.  The application or notification shall be delivered in person or sent by certified mail to the department.  The information required may include, but shall not  be limited to:

          (a) Name and address of the forest land owner, timber owner, and operator;

          (b) Description of the proposed forest practice or practices to be conducted;

          (c) Legal description of the land on which the forest practices are to be conducted;

          (d) Planimetric and topographic maps showing location and size of all lakes and streams and other public waters in and immediately adjacent to the operating area and showing all existing and proposed roads and major tractor roads;

          (e) Description of the silvicultural, harvesting, or other forest practice methods to be used, including the type of equipment to be used and materials to be applied;

          (f) Proposed plan for reforestation and for any revegetation necessary to reduce erosion potential from roadsides and yarding roads, as required by the forest practices regulations;

          (g) Soil, geological, and hydrological data with respect to forest practices;

          (h) The expected dates of commencement and completion of all forest practices specified in the application;

          (i) Provisions for continuing maintenance of roads and other construction or other measures necessary to afford protection to public resources; and

          (j) An affirmation that the statements contained in the notification or application are true.

          (2) At the option of the applicant, the application or notification may be submitted to cover a single forest practice or any number of forest practices within reasonable geographic or political boundaries as specified by the department.  Long range plans may be submitted to the department for review and consultation.

          (3) The application or notification shall indicate whether any land covered by the application or notification will be converted or is intended to be converted to a use other than commercial timber production within ((three)) ten years after completion of the forest practices described in it.

          (a) If the application states that any such land will be or is intended to be so converted:

          (i) The reforestation requirements of this chapter and of the forest practices regulations shall not apply if the land is in fact so converted unless applicable alternatives or limitations are provided in forest practices regulations issued under RCW 76.09.070 as now or hereafter amended;

          (ii) Completion of such forest practice operations shall be deemed conversion of the lands to another use for purposes of chapters 84.28, 84.33, and 84.34 RCW unless the conversion is to a use permitted under a current use tax agreement permitted under chapter 84.34 RCW;

          (iii) The forest practices described in the application are subject to applicable county, city, town, and regional governmental authority permitted under RCW 76.09.240 as now or hereafter amended as well as the forest practices regulations.

          (b) If the application or notification does not state that any land covered by the application or notification will be or is intended to be so converted:

          (i) For ((six)) ten years after the date of the application the county ((or)), city, town, and regional governmental entities ((may)) shall refuse to accept or process and shall deny any or all applications for permits or approvals, including building permits and subdivision approvals, relating to nonforestry uses of land subject to the application;

          (ii) Failure to comply with the reforestation requirements contained in any final order or decision shall constitute a removal from classification under the provisions of RCW 84.28.065, a removal of designation under the provisions of RCW 84.33.140, and a change of use under the provisions of RCW 84.34.080, and, if applicable, shall subject such lands to the payments and/or penalties resulting from such removals or changes; and

          (iii) Conversion to a use other than commercial timber operations within ((three)) ten years after completion of the forest practices without the consent of the county ((or municipality)), city, or town shall constitute a violation of each of the county, ((municipal)) city, town, and regional authorities to which the forest practice operations would have been subject if the application had so stated.

          (c) For ten years after the date of an application for a conversion to an agricultural use, the county, city, or town, and regional governmental entities shall deny any or all applications for permits or approvals, including building permits and subdivision approvals, relating to nonagricultural uses of land subject to the application.

          (d) If a forest practice is conducted without an application or notification required by this chapter, for ten years after the date the forest practice is discovered, the county, city, or town, and regional governmental entities shall refuse to accept and process, and shall deny any or all applications for permits or approvals, including building permits and subdivision approvals, relating to nonforestry uses of land subject to the application.

          (e) The forest practices board may adopt rules exempting certain activities and circumstances from (b)(i), (c), and (d) of this subsection if necessary to accomplish the purposes and policies stated in RCW 76.09.010.

          (f) The application or notification shall be either signed by the  land owner or accompanied by a statement signed by the  land owner indicating his or her intent with respect to conversion and acknowledging that he or she is familiar with the effects of this subsection.

           (4) Whenever an approved application authorizes a forest practice which, because of soil condition, proximity to a water course or other unusual factor, has a  potential for causing material damage to a public resource, as determined by the department, the applicant shall, when requested on the approved application, notify the department  two days before the commencement of actual operations.

           (5) Before  the operator commences any forest practice in a manner or to an extent significantly different from that described in a previously approved application or notification, there shall be submitted to the department a new application or notification form in the manner set forth in this section.

           (6) The notification to or the approval given by the department to an application to conduct a forest practice shall be effective for a term of one year from the date of approval or notification and shall not be renewed unless a new application is filed and approved or a new notification has been filed.

           (7) Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, no prior application or notification shall be required for any emergency forest practice necessitated by fire, flood, windstorm, earthquake, or other emergency as defined by the board, but the operator shall submit an application or notification, whichever is applicable, to the department within forty-eight hours after commencement of such practice.

 

        Sec. 3.  Section 24, chapter 137, Laws of 1974 ex. sess. as amended by section 11, chapter 200, Laws of 1975 1st ex. sess. and RCW 76.09.240 are each amended to read as follows:

          No county, city, ((municipality)) town, or other local or regional governmental  entity shall adopt or enforce any law, ordinance, or regulation pertaining to forest practices, except that to the extent otherwise permitted by law, such entities may exercise any:

          (1) Land use planning or zoning authority:  PROVIDED, That exercise of such authority may regulate forest practices only:  (a) Where the application submitted under RCW 76.09.060 as now or hereafter amended indicates that the lands will be converted to a use other than commercial timber production or the lands which the department has determined are not to be reforested because of the likelihood of future conversion to urban development; or (b) on lands which have been platted after January 1, 1960:  PROVIDED, That no permit system solely for forest practices shall be allowed; that any additional or more stringent regulations shall not be inconsistent with the forest practices regulations enacted under this chapter; and such local regulations shall not unreasonably prevent management or timber harvesting;

          (2) Taxing powers;

          (3) Regulatory authority with respect to public health; and

          (4) Authority granted by chapter 90.58 RCW, the "Shoreline Management Act of 1971", except that in relation to "shorelines" as defined in RCW 90.58.030, the following shall apply:

          (a) The forest practice regulations adopted pursuant to this chapter shall be the sole rules applicable to the performance of forest practices, and enforcement thereof shall be solely as provided in chapter 76.09 RCW;

          (b) As to that road construction which constitutes a substantial development, no permit shall be required under chapter 90.58 RCW for the construction of up to five hundred feet of one and only one road or segment of a road provided such road does not enter the shoreline more than once.  Such exemption from said permit requirements shall be limited to a single road or road segment for each forest practice and such road construction shall be subject to the requirements of chapter 76.09 RCW and regulations adopted pursuant thereto and to the prohibitions or restrictions of any master program in effect under the provisions of chapter 90.58 RCW.  Nothing in this subsection shall add to or diminish the authority of the shoreline management act regarding road construction except as specifically provided herein.  The provisions of this subsection shall not relate to any road which crosses over or through a stream, lake, or other water body subject to chapter 90.58 RCW;

          (c) Nothing in this section shall create, add to, or diminish the authority  of local government to prohibit or restrict forest practices within the shorelines through master programs adopted and approved pursuant to chapter 90.58 RCW except as provided in (a) and (b) above.

          Any powers granted by chapter 90.58 RCW pertaining to forest practices, as amended herein, are expressly limited to lands located within "shorelines of the state" as defined in RCW 90.58.030.