WSR 17-06-079
PROPOSED RULES
RECREATION AND CONSERVATION
OFFICE
(Recreation and Conservation Funding Board)
[Filed March 1, 2017, 10:23 a.m.]
Original Notice.
Preproposal statement of inquiry was filed as WSR 17-02-075.
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: Amending chapter 286-04 WAC, General and chapter 286-13 WAC, General grant assistance.
Repealing chapter 286-26 WAC, Nonhighway road and off-road vehicle funds; chapter 286-27 WAC, Washington wildlife and recreation program; chapter 286-35 WAC, Boating facilities program; chapter 286-40 WAC, Land and water conservation fund; and chapter 286-42 WAC, Aquatic lands enhancement account program.
Hearing Location(s): South Puget Sound Community College, Campus Room 194, 4220 6th Avenue S.E., Lacey, WA 98503, on May 10, 2017, at 4:00 p.m.
Date of Intended Adoption: May 10, 2017.
Submit Written Comments to: Leslie Connelly, 1111 Washington Avenue [Street] South, P.O. Box 40917, Olympia, WA 98504-0917, email leslie.connelly@rco.wa.gov, fax (360) 902-3026, by April 15, 2017.
Assistance for Persons with Disabilities: Contact Leslie Frank by May 9, 2017, TTY (360) 902-0220 or (360) 902-3013.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: The purpose of the proposal is to amend and clarify grant requirements and apply them to all grants for the recreation and conservation funding board. While specific program related rules would be repealed, the requirements within those programs are consolidated and incorporated into new sections in chapter 286-13 WAC, General grant assistance. The anticipated effects are:
(1) Consistent application of rules across grant programs for applicant eligibility, planning eligibility, matching share, grant request limits, public access, compliance with applicable laws, and long-term obligations;
(2) Clarification of the long-term obligations of receiving grant funds, including a new definition for project area and requirements to provide a project area map; and
(3) Allowing for modified grant program requirements for federal agencies, regardless of the grant program, when approved by the board.
Reasons Supporting Proposal: There are two reasons for this proposal. First, the recreation and conservation funding board administers different grant programs but applies many of the same rules and policies to grant awards, regardless of which grant program the funds come from. In addition, there are grant programs administered by the recreation and conservation funding board that do not have administrative rules, but follow the same grant requirements as a matter of policy. Consolidating the grant requirements will ensure consistency in their application and allow them to be applied to any project. Second, adding a definition and a map requirement for project area will provide sponsors a clear understanding of the long-term obligations of receiving grant funds and document where those long-term obligations apply on the ground.
Statutory Authority for Adoption: RCW 34.05.220, 42.56.040, 46.09.530, 79A.15.060, 79A.15.070, 79A.15.120, 79A.15.130, 79A.25.210.
Statute Being Implemented: Chapters 79A.15 and 79A.25 RCW, RCW 46.09.530.
Rule is not necessitated by federal law, federal or state court decision.
Name of Proponent: Recreation and conservation office, governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting: Leslie Connelly, 1111 Washington Street S.E., Olympia, WA 98504, (360) 902-3080; Implementation and Enforcement: Kaleen Cottingham, 1111 Washington Street S.E., Olympia, WA 98504, (360) 902-3000.
No small business economic impact statement has been prepared under chapter 19.85 RCW. The proposed rule making does not meet the definition of a "minor cost" in RCW 19.85.020(2) nor would it affect "small businesses" as defined in RCW 19.85.020(3).
A cost-benefit analysis is not required under RCW 34.05.328. The recreation and conservation office is not listed as an agency required to complete a cost-benefit analysis under RCW 34.05.328 (5)(a)(i).
March 1, 2017
Leslie Connelly
Rules Coordinator
Natural Resources
Policy Specialist
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 15-15-072, filed 7/13/15, effective 8/13/15)
WAC 286-04-010 Definitions.
For purposes of Title 286 WAC, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise the following definitions apply:
(1) "Acquisition" means the purchase or donation of fee or less than fee interests in real property. These interests include, but are not limited to, conservation easements, access or trail easements, covenants, water rights, leases, and mineral rights.
(2) "Agreement" or "project agreement" means the accord accepted by the office and the sponsor for the project and includes any supplemental agreements, any amendments to the agreement and any intergovernmental agreements.
(3) "Applicant" means any party that meets qualifying standards, including deadlines, for submission of an application soliciting a grant of funds from the board.
(4) "Application" means the documents and other materials that an applicant submits to the office to support the applicant's request for grant funds.
(5) "Board" means the recreation and conservation funding board as described in RCW 79A.25.110.
(6) "Chair" means the chair of the board as described in RCW 79A.25.110.
(7) "Development project" means a project that results in the construction of or work resulting in new elements including, but not limited to, structures, facilities and materials to enhance outdoor recreation resources.
(8) "Director" means the director of the office or that person's designee as described in RCW 79A.25.150.
(9) "Education and enforcement project" means a project that provides information, education, and outreach programs; encourages responsible recreational behaviors; and may provide law enforcement for the benefit of outdoor recreationists.
(10) "Education project" means a project that provides information, education, and outreach programs for the benefit of outdoor recreationists.
(11) "Maintenance project" means a project that maintains existing areas and facilities through repairs and upkeep for the benefit of outdoor recreationists.
(12) "Maintenance and operation project" means a project that maintains existing areas and facilities through repairs, upkeep, and routine servicing for the benefit of outdoor recreationists.
(13) "Manual(s)" means a compilation of state and federal laws; board rules, policies, and procedures; and director procedures, forms, and instructions assembled in manual form for dissemination to parties that participate in the board's or office's grant program(s).
(14) "Match" or "matching share" means the portion of the total project cost in the project agreement provided by the project sponsor.
(15) "Office" means the recreation and conservation office as described in RCW 79A.25.010.
(16) "Planning project" means a project that results in one or more of the following: A study, a plan, construction plans and specifications, and permits to increase the availability of outdoor recreational resources.
(17) "Preagreement cost" means a project cost incurred before the period of performance identified in an agreement.
(18) "Project" means the undertaking which is, or may be, funded in whole or in part with funds administered by the office on behalf of the board.
(19) "Project area" is a geographic area that delineates a grant assisted site which is subject to application and project agreement requirements.
(20) "Reimbursement" means the payment of funds from the office to the sponsor for eligible and allowable project costs that have already been paid by the sponsor per the terms of an agreement.
(((20))) (21) "Renovation project" means a project that improves an existing site or structure in order to increase its service life or functions.
(((21))) (22) "Restoration project" means a project that brings a site back to its historic function as part of a natural ecosystem or improving the ecological functionality of the site.
(((22))) (23) "Sponsor" means an eligible applicant who has been awarded a grant of funds and is bound by an executed agreement; includes its officers, employees, agents, and successors.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 16-16-001, filed 7/20/16, effective 8/20/16)
WAC 286-13-010 Scope of chapter.
(1) This chapter contains general rules for grant program eligibility, applications, and projects funded with money from or through the board.
(2) Further rules are in ((chapter 286-26 WAC (Nonhighway and off-road vehicle activities program), chapter 286-27 WAC (Washington wildlife and recreation program),)) chapter 286-30 WAC (Firearms ((and archery)) range ((recreation program), chapter 286-35 WAC (Initiative 215 boating facilities program), chapter 286-40 WAC (Land and water conservation fund program) and chapter 286-42 WAC (Aquatic lands enhancement account program))).
(3) The director may apply the rules in this chapter to programs administered by the office that are not subject to the board's approval.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-015 Eligible applicants.
(1) Eligibility to apply for grant funding is determined by a grant program's statutory requirements unless authority is granted to the board.
(2) Eligible applicants in the aquatic lands enhancement account grant program are any division of local or state government and Native American tribes that are legally authorized to acquire and develop public open space, habitat, recreation lands or natural resources.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-035 Planning requirement.
(1) An applicant must submit a plan in accordance with WAC 286-13-040 in order to apply for a grant from any of the following programs:
(a) Boating facilities program pursuant to the Marine Recreation Land Act, chapter 79A.25 RCW;
(b) Land and water conservation fund pursuant to the Land and Water Conservation Fund Act of 1965;
(c) Nonhighway and off-road vehicle activities account pursuant to chapter 46.09 RCW, except when applying for a grant for an education and enforcement project or a maintenance and operation project; or
(d) Washington wildlife and recreation program funded under chapter 79A.15 RCW, except when applying for a grant for a project funded from the farm and forest account.
(2) At a minimum, the plan must include:
(a) A statement of the applicant's long-range goals and objectives;
(b) An inventory;
(c) An analysis of demand and need, that is, why action is required;
(d) A description of how the planning process gave the public ample opportunity to be involved in development of the plan;
(e) A current capital improvement program of at least six years; and
(f) Evidence that this plan has been approved by the applicant's governing entity most appropriate to the plan's scope. For example, a city or county-wide plan must be approved at the council or commission level. Plans with a different scope may be approved by department heads, district rangers, regional managers or supervisors, etc.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 14-09-074, filed 4/18/14, effective 5/19/14)
WAC 286-13-045 ((What rules govern matching resources?)) Matching resources and request limits.
(1) The board shall establish sponsor matching share requirements and fund request limits as allowed by law. Any changes will normally be done at a board meeting six months before program funding consideration.
(2) When the board gives preference to an applicant that provides a matching resource, it is the intent of the board to do so to foster and demonstrate local commitment to the proposed project, to make funds from a given grant program and revenue source available to a greater number of projects, and to fund projects that are ready to implement without delay.
(((2))) (3) Applicant resources used to match board funds must be eligible in the grant program. Sources of matching resources include, but are not limited to, any one or more of the following:
(a) Appropriations and cash;
(b) Value of the applicant's expenses for labor, materials, and equipment;
(c) Value of donated real property, labor, services, materials, and equipment use; and
(d) Grant funds, except those from the same grant program administered by the board.
(((3))) (4) The board may require the applicant to provide a portion of its matching resources in local resources.
(((4))) (5) State agency projects may be assisted by one hundred percent funding from board funds except where prohibited by law or the board.
(((5))) (6) Grants from state funds are intended to supplement the existing capacity of a sponsor. They are not intended to supplant existing programs or fund projects that would have been undertaken without grant funding.
(((6))) (7) Except for grant applications submitted within the same biennium, matching resources or board grant funds committed in one board funded project must not be used as match in another board funded project.
(((7))) (8) If a matching resource is required or provided in the grant application, it must also conform to the deadlines in WAC 286-13-040.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 14-09-074, filed 4/18/14, effective 5/19/14)
WAC 286-13-060 Project agreement.
For every funded project, an agreement must be executed as provided in this section.
(1) The project agreement shall be prepared by the office subsequent to approval of the project by the board at a public meeting. The project agreement is executed upon the signature of the office and the applicant and the parties are bound by the agreement's terms. The applicant shall not proceed until the project agreement has been executed, unless specific authorization pursuant to WAC 286-13-085 has been given by the director.
(2) If the project is approved by the board to receive a grant from federal funds, the director shall not execute an agreement or amendment with the applicant until federal funding has been authorized through an agreement with the applicable federal agency.
(3) Execution of the project agreement must conform to the deadlines in WAC 286-13-040.
(4) A board-federal agency agreement signed by the parties shall control the provision of funds granted by the board to federal agency sponsored projects. Absent this agreement, the standard terms and conditions of board's project agreement shall control.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 14-09-074, filed 4/18/14, effective 5/19/14)
WAC 286-13-115 ((Discrimination,)) Nondiscrimination, access to the public, and preferences.
(1) Sponsors shall not discriminate against users of projects assisted with board funds on the basis of race, creed, color, sex or gender, religion, national origin, disability, marital status, or sexual orientation.
(2) Properties, structures, and facilities intended for public use within the project area shall meet state and federal accessibility guidelines and nondiscrimination laws, regulations, and policies; be maintained to a standard that encourages use; and be open and available to the public at reasonable hours and times of the year.
(3) Sponsors shall not express a preference for users within the project area of board grant assisted projects on the basis of residence (including preferential reservation, membership, and/or permit systems). However, reasonable differences in admission and other fees may be maintained on the basis of residence. The board does not encourage the imposition of such differential fees. Fees for nonresidents must not exceed twice the fee imposed on residents. Where there is no fee for residents but a fee is charged to nonresidents, the nonresident fee shall not exceed the amount that would be imposed on residents at comparable state or local public facilities.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-130 Compliance with applicable laws.
Properties, structures, and facilities developed with the assistance of money granted by the board and within the project area shall be built, operated, and maintained according to applicable regulations, laws, building codes, and health standards to assure a reasonably safe condition and to prevent premature deterioration.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-140 Project area map.
(1) A project area map is required for each acquisition, development, renovation, and restoration project.
(2) At a minimum, the project area must include the property acquired, developed, renovated or restored with grant assistance and the route for the public to access the property. The project area must also include sufficient property that is functionally dependent to a grant assisted site and owned or controlled by the sponsor. Any additional property included in the project area must be necessary to complete the programmatic function described in the application and meet the need for the project.
(3) The sponsor must record a notice of grant as provided by the office on the title of the properties in the project area.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-150 Conveyance to the state for acquisition project.
(1) Acquisition of perpetual interests. When a sponsor acquires real property in perpetuity, the sponsor must record on the title of the property a binding instrument as required by the office that contains:
(a) A legal description of the real property acquired with grant assistance;
(b) A conveyance to the state of Washington of the right to use the described real property for the purposes funded by the grant in perpetuity; and
(c) A restriction on the conversion of use of the real property.
(2) Acquisition of nonperpetual interests. When a sponsor acquires real property for less than perpetuity, the interest may not be revocable at will. The sponsor must record on the title of the property a binding instrument as required by the office that contains:
(a) A legal description of the real property acquired with grant assistance;
(b) A conveyance to the state of Washington of the right to use the described real property for the purposes funded by the grant for the duration of the nonperpetual interest acquired; and
(c) A restriction on the conversion of use of the real property based on the minimum period in the grant program as follows:
(i) At least twenty years for projects funded from the youth athletic facilities program;
(ii) At least twenty-five years for projects funded from the aquatic lands enhancement account program;
(iii) At least twenty-five years for projects funded from the nonhighway and off-road vehicle activities account;
(iv) At least fifty years for projects funded from the boating facilities program; or
(v) At least fifty years for projects funded from the Washington wildlife and recreation program, except for:
(A) Farmland category projects must be for at least twenty-five years;
(B) Riparian protection category projects for conservation reserve enhancement program leases must be for at least twenty-five years; and
(C) Forestland category projects because only perpetual acquisitions are eligible.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-160 Long-term obligations for acquisition projects.
(1) The project area may not, without prior approval of the board or director, be converted to a use other than that for which funds were originally approved.
(2) Projects impacted by a reversion order by the Interstate Commerce Commission under section 8(d) of the National Trails System Act, 16 United States Code 1247(d), are not considered a conversion by the board. Substitution or replacement with interest in real property, facilities or moneys which are of at least equal market value at the time of replacement may be required.
(3) The board may only approve a conversion when the sponsor:
(a) Demonstrates the need to convert the project area including all efforts to consider practical alternatives, how they were evaluated, and the reasons they were not pursued;
(b) Provides an opportunity for the public to participate in the identification, development and evaluation of the alternatives, including a minimum public comment period of at least thirty days; and
(c) Commits to provide another interest in real property to serve as a replacement. The replacement must:
(i) Be of reasonably equivalent usefulness and location;
(ii) Be administered by the same sponsor unless otherwise approved by the board;
(iii) Satisfy need(s) identified in the sponsor's current plan as described in WAC 286-13-035 or other relevant local or statewide plan;
(iv) Be eligible in the same grant program account or category from which funds were originally allocated, unless otherwise approved by the board;
(v) Be interest in real property of at least equal current market value to the converted property; and
(vi) Satisfies the conversion without grant assistance from the board.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-170 Long-term obligations for development and renovation projects.
(1) The project area may not, without prior approval of the board or director, be converted to a use other than that for which funds were originally approved.
(2) Projects impacted by a reversion order by the Interstate Commerce Commission under section 8(d) of the National Trails System Act, 16 United States Code 1247(d), are not considered a conversion by the board. Substitution or replacement with interest in real property, facilities or moneys which are of at least equal market value at the time of replacement may be required.
(3) The board may only approve a conversion when the sponsor:
(a) Demonstrates the need to convert the project area including all efforts to consider practical alternatives, how they were evaluated, and the reasons they were not pursued;
(b) Provides an opportunity for the public to participate in the identification, development and evaluation of the alternatives, including a minimum public comment period of at least thirty days; and
(c) Provides another project area to serve as a replacement. The replacement must:
(i) Be of reasonably equivalent usefulness and location;
(ii) Be administered by the same sponsor unless otherwise approved by the board;
(iii) Be a new project area with facilities that satisfy need(s) identified in the sponsor's current plan as described in WAC 286-13-035 or the other relevant local or statewide plan;
(iv) Be eligible in the same grant program account or category from which funds were originally allocated, unless otherwise approved by the board; and
(v) Satisfies the conversion without grant assistance from the board.
NEW SECTION
WAC 286-13-180 Long-term obligations for restoration projects.
(1) The project area may not, without prior approval of the board or director, be converted to a use other than that for which funds were originally approved.
(2) The board may only approve a conversion when the sponsor:
(a) Demonstrates the need to convert the project area including all efforts to consider practical alternatives, how they were evaluated, and the reasons they were not pursued;
(b) Provides an opportunity for the public to participate in the identification, development and evaluation of the alternatives, including a minimum public comment period of at least thirty days; and
(c) Provides another project area to serve as a replacement for the restoration project. The replacement must:
(i) Be of reasonably equivalent habitat utility and location;
(ii) Be administered by the same sponsor unless otherwise approved by the board;
(iii) Be a new project area that satisfies need(s) identified in the sponsor's current plan as described in WAC 286-13-035 or the other relevant local or statewide plan;
(iv) Be administered under similar stewardship methods as the converted project area;
(v) Be eligible in the same grant program or category from which funds were originally allocated, unless otherwise approved by the board; and
(vi) Satisfies the conversion without grant assistance from the board.
REPEALER
The following chapter of the Washington Administrative Code is repealed:
WAC 286-26-010
Scope of chapter.
WAC 286-26-020
What definitions apply to this chapter?
WAC 286-26-080
Does this program have planning eligibility requirements?
WAC 286-26-083
What long term rules apply?
WAC 286-26-085
When considering approval of a conversion, what rules apply?
WAC 286-26-090
For land acquisition projects, are there long term obligations?
WAC 286-26-100
For development projects, are there long term obligations?
WAC 286-26-105
What provisions apply to federal agencies?
WAC 286-26-110
Matching amounts and caps determined.
REPEALER
The following chapter of the Washington Administrative Code is repealed:
WAC 286-27-010
What is the purpose of this chapter?
WAC 286-27-040
Does the program have planning eligibility requirements?
WAC 286-27-045
What is a conversion of use?
WAC 286-27-055
Are there long-term obligations for acquiring interest in real property?
WAC 286-27-061
Are there long-term obligations for restoration projects?
WAC 286-27-065
Are there long-term obligations for development projects?
WAC 286-27-066
What additional rules apply to conversions of use?
WAC 286-27-071
What rules apply to the sale of farmland?
WAC 286-27-075
Are matching resources required—Are there caps?
REPEALER
The following chapter of the Washington Administrative Code is repealed:
WAC 286-35-010
Scope.
WAC 286-35-030
Planning requirements.
WAC 286-35-060
Matching requirements and caps determined.
WAC 286-35-080
Acquisition projects—Deed of right, conversions, leases and easements.
WAC 286-35-090
Development projects—Conversion to other uses.
REPEALER
The following chapter of the Washington Administrative Code is repealed:
WAC 286-40-010
Scope.
WAC 286-40-020
Funding and candidate selection.
WAC 286-40-030
Matching requirements.
WAC 286-40-040
Projects eligible for funding.
WAC 286-40-050
Acquisition projects—Deed of right, conversions, leases and easements.
WAC 286-40-060
Development projects—Conversion to other uses.
REPEALER
The following chapter of the Washington Administrative Code is repealed:
WAC 286-42-010
What is the purpose of this chapter?
WAC 286-42-020
What organizations may receive grants?
WAC 286-42-030
Do these rules apply to projects funded on or before April 1, 2004?
WAC 286-42-040
What long term rules apply?
WAC 286-42-050
When considering approval of a conversion, what rules apply?
WAC 286-42-060
For land acquisition projects, are there long term obligations?
WAC 286-42-080
For development projects, are there long term obligations?
WAC 286-42-090
Must a grant recipient provide matching funds for the project—Are grant amounts limited?