WSR 17-23-181
PROPOSED RULES
ARTS COMMISSION
[Filed November 21, 2017, 4:10 p.m.]
Original Notice.
Preproposal statement of inquiry was filed as WSR 17-17-125.
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: Amendments to existing rules, WAC 30-01-040 Commission's purpose, 30-02-010 Definitions, 30-04-060 Copying, 30-08-030 Board meetings, 30-12-015 Grants, 30-12-016 Rosters, 30-12-017 Applications, 30-40-050 Funding, 30-40-060 Collections management, 30-40-100 Art acquisition committees, 30-40-110 Acquisition of works of art, and 30-44-030 Eligibility.
Hearing Location(s): On January 2, 2018, at 10:30 a.m., at the Evergreen Plaza Building, 711 Capitol Way South, Suite 600, Olympia, WA 98504.
Date of Intended Adoption: January 2, 2018.
Submit Written Comments to: Terry J. West, Deputy Director, 711 Capitol Way South, Suite 600, Olympia, WA 98504, email terry.west@arts.wa.gov, fax 360-586-5351, by December 31, 2017.
Assistance for Persons with Disabilities: Contact Terry J. West, phone 360-586-5350, fax 360-586-5351, TTY 800-883-6384 or 866-377-8895, email terry.west@arts.wa.gov, by December 31, 2017.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: Amendments to twelve existing rules including updates on definitions, clarifying language and recent changes. The amendments will ensure the rules are easy to understand.
Statutory Authority for Adoption: RCW 43.46.040.
Statute Being Implemented: RCW 43.46.040.
Rule is not necessitated by federal law, federal or state court decision.
Agency Comments or Recommendations, if any, as to Statutory Language, Implementation, Enforcement, and Fiscal Matters: Minor amendments imposing no additional cost to businesses and clarifying language making these rules easier to understand.
Name of Proponent: Washington state arts commission, governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting, Implementation, and Enforcement: Terry J. West, 711 Capitol Way South, Suite 600, Olympia, 360-586-5350.
A school district fiscal impact statement is not required under RCW 28A.305.135.
A cost-benefit analysis is not required under RCW 34.05.328. The Washington state arts commission is not listed under this statute as required to prepare a cost-benefit analysis. The rules being amended are not considered significant rule changes.
This rule proposal, or portions of the proposal, is exempt from requirements of the Regulatory Fairness Act because the proposal:
Is exempt under RCW 19.85.030.
Explanation of exemptions: A small business economic impact statement is not required under RCW 19.85.030 because there are not more than minor costs to businesses in order to comply with these minor amendments.
November 22, 2017
Karen Hanan
Executive Director
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-01-040 Commission's purpose.
The Washington state arts commission is charged with the conservation and development of the state's artistic resources as described in RCW 43.46.005. It is authorized by RCW 43.46.050 to study, plan, and advise the governor, state departments, and the legislature regarding cultural development. Through the authority granted by RCW 43.46.055, the commission may administer any activity, and assist any person or agency in programs or projects related to the growth and development of the arts ((and)), humanities, and the creative economy. The conservation and development of the state's artistic resources is essential to the social, educational, and economic growth of the state of Washington.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-02-010 Definitions.
The following definitions shall apply throughout Title 30 WAC:
"Accession" means to formally acquire a work of art for the state art collection, including the action of assigning an accession or control number to the work of art.
"Appeal procedure" means the procedure as established in WAC 30-12-036 (Request for review of denied applications) whereby an applicant may request a review of a denied application.
"Application form" means the printed ((or)), electronic, or web-based forms created and published by staff to be used in commission program applications.
"Application guidelines" means the published document that provides the public with information on how to apply for commission programs, including eligibility requirements, review criteria, deadlines, timelines, and appeal procedure. Application guidelines may be published in a printed format and/or in electronic format accessible through the commission's web site.
"Art advisory committee" means a committee formed by staff and a partner agency to develop plans and overall project specifications, and to make funding allocation decisions related to the state art collection.
"Art in public places program" means the visual art program of the commission established by the legislature in RCW 43.46.090 to acquire works of art and to develop, administer, and ((operate)) manage the state art collection.
"Art selection committee" means a committee formed by a partner agency, and approved by staff, to review and select artists to create works of art for the state art collection, or to review and select works of art for or from the state art collection, through a process facilitated by staff.
"Artistic disciplines" means dance, design, folk and traditional arts, media arts, music, literature, theater, visual arts, and interdisciplinary arts.
"Artistic excellence" means evidence of some or all of the following: Mastery of skills and techniques, communication of unique vision or perspective, professional approaches to process and presentation((, and/or communication of unique vision or perspective)). Additionally, for groups and organizations, includes the contribution the artistic work(s) make to the development of the artists involved, the art form and the arts generally; or for services delivered, the contribution the services make to the development of a vibrant arts and cultural community in the state.
(("Artistic merit" means evidence of some or all of the following: Potential impact on the artistic and/or cultural development of a community or individuals; and/or potential to broaden access to, expand and diversify the audiences for, and/or strengthen communities through the arts.))
"Arts professional" means an individual who has professional work experience in the arts or an arts-related field.
"Board" means the board of commissioners, consisting of nineteen members appointed by the governor and four members of the legislature appointed to the Washington state arts commission pursuant to RCW 43.46.015.
"Chair" means the chair of the board, elected pursuant to WAC 30-08-050 and fulfilling duties as established in Title 30 WAC.
"Collections management" means the ongoing care, preservation, and maintenance of the state art collection, including activities such as the management of conservation, restoration, deaccession, documentation, inventory, labeling, loans, and ((re-siting)) resiting of works of art.
"Commission" means the collective entity of the Washington state arts commission, including the board, executive director, and staff.
"Commissioner" means an individual appointed to the board of the Washington state arts commission.
"Conservation" means treatment of malfunctioning or damaged works of art for the purpose of bringing them to a stable condition so that future routine and special maintenance can be effective. Conservation-related activities may also include examination and documentation.
"Curator" means a qualified visual arts professional with past curatorial experience selected to recommend works of art for acquisition to the state art collection.
"Deaccession" means board action to remove an accessioned work of art from the state art collection.
"Disability" is defined in RCW 49.60.040(7).
"Eligibility requirements" means published standards by which applications are reviewed to determine if they meet the minimum required qualifications to apply for a commission program.
"Executive director" means that person employed pursuant to RCW 43.46.045 to carry out the functions of that chapter and Title 30 WAC.
"Grant" means a contract for arts or cultural services between the commission and an organization or individual, awarded through a competitive application process and approved or ratified by the board.
"Inventory" means a periodic survey of the physical state and current location of works of art in the state art collection.
"Nonprofit" means incorporation under the nonprofit laws of the state of Washington or another state, and determination by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) that the incorporated entity is exempt from taxation under Section 501 (c)(3) of the IRS code.
"Panel" means a group of individuals convened by staff to review applications, nominations, or staff recommendations based on published review criteria, in order to make recommendations to the board or executive director.
"Partner agency" means a state agency, K-12 public school, university, college, community college, or other public entity working with the art in public places program.
"Professional artist" means an individual who has a history of paid work as an artist.
"Public artist roster" means the board approved list of professional artists eligible to create visual works of art for the state art collection.
"Public benefit" means evidence of some or all of the following: Potential impact on the artistic, cultural, professional, or economic development of a community or individuals; and/or potential to broaden access to, expand and diversify the audiences for, and/or strengthen communities through the arts.
"Resiting" means the relocation of a work of art in the state art collection within the jurisdiction of a partner agency or between partner agencies.
"Restoration" means treatment that returns a malfunctioning or damaged work of art to a known or assumed state, often through the addition of nonoriginal material.
"Review criteria" means the standards used by panels to evaluate applications, nominations, or staff recommendations.
"Roster" means a list of approved arts professionals who have the skills and experience to address the needs of a specific commission program.
"Routine maintenance" means a regular procedure to preserve a work of art in the state art collection in proper condition: Clean, presentable, and in working order.
"Site responsive" means created, planned, or intended for a particular site. A site responsive work of art addresses both the physical characteristics of its location (((size, environment, lighting, public use, etc., of the site))) and the context of the community in which it is situated (((neighborhood, users of site, historical population, etc.))).
"Special maintenance" means anticipated but infrequent activities required to maintain aesthetic and/or structural aspects of the works of art in the state art collection, including integrity of the overall surface and/or individual elements.
"Staff" means employees of the Washington state arts commission, under the direction of the executive director, pursuant to RCW 43.46.045, employed to carry out the functions of that chapter, and Title 30 WAC.
"State art collection" means all works of art and select design models commissioned or purchased under RCW 43.17.200, 28A.58.055, 28A.335.210, 43.46.090, and 43.19.455.
"Teaching artist" means a professional artist who is dedicated to arts education as an integral part of his/her professional practice, and who has cultivated skills as an educator in concert with skills as an artist.
"Underserved" means populations whose opportunities to experience the arts are limited by geography, historical exclusion and marginalization due to race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, gender identity, economics, ((or)) disability, or other social or institutionally imposed barriers.
"Under-resourced" means a lack of access to specialized, professional, financial, or institutional expertise and communal knowledge, and/or working with neglected or dated infrastructures and limited or absent assets and resources resulting in lack of recognition, competitiveness, and cyclical absent or diminished funding.
"Washington state arts commission" means the collective entity of the Washington state arts commission, including the board and staff.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-04-060 Copying.
(1) Pursuant to RCW 42.56.120(2), as amended by section 3, chapter 304, Laws of 2017, the Washington state arts commission declares for the following reasons that it would be unduly burdensome for it to calculate the actual costs it charges for providing copies of public records: Funds were not allocated for performing a study to calculate such actual costs and the agency lacks the necessary funds to perform a study and calculations; staff resources are insufficient to perform a study and to calculate such actual costs; and a study would interfere with and disrupt other essential agency functions.
(2) The Washington state arts commission may charge fees for production of copies of public records consistent with the fee schedule established in RCW 42.56.120, as amended by section 3, chapter 304, Laws of 2017.
(3) No fee shall be charged for the inspection of public records. ((The commission shall charge ten cents per black and white copy. Specialized records, including color copy, will be duplicated at the amount necessary to reimburse the commission for its actual cost. If the public records officer deems it more efficient to have copying and/or duplicating done outside the commission, the charges will be based on the actual cost of such outside copying and/or duplicating service.))
For all copying and/or duplicating service charges incurred, an invoice will be sent to the requestor. Reimbursement is payable within fifteen days of receipt of invoice payable to the Washington state arts commission. The commission may require that all charges be paid in advance of release of the copies of the records.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-08-030 Board meetings.
(1) General schedule. The board meets at least four times each fiscal year and at such other times as determined to be necessary. All meetings of the board are "regular" or "special" meetings as those designations are applied in chapter 42.30 RCW. Meetings may be called, subject to the notice requirements of chapter 42.30 RCW, at any time and place by the chair or by a majority of the commissioners.
(2) Notice. Twenty calendar days' notice of all meetings shall be given by posting on the commission's web site notification of the date, time and location of the meeting, and by mailing or emailing the same to each commissioner and to any person who has made a written request to the commission to receive meeting notices.
(3) Special meetings. The twenty-day notice may be waived for special meetings upon consent of the chair. In such cases, the provisions of RCW 42.30.080 govern due notification of the time, place, and business to be transacted.
(4) Executive session. An executive session may be called by the chair or a majority of the board. Executive sessions shall deal only with matters authorized by chapter 42.30 RCW.
(5) Meeting formats. Meetings may be convened in-person and/or by conference call, online, or other alternative format as determined by the chair and the executive director, subject to the requirements of the Open Public Meetings Act, chapter 42.30 RCW.
(6) Rules of order. The board generally follows Roberts Rules of Order, newly revised, in conducting its business meetings.
(7) Quorum. A simple majority of the regularly appointed board members constitute a quorum. If all twenty-three positions are filled, the quorum is twelve.
(8) Voting rights. All officers of the board have the right to vote on all matters before the board, just as any other commissioner.
(9) Meeting materials. Staff makes meeting materials available to the public at the time of the meeting, and following the meeting upon request.
(10) Minutes of the proceedings of all board meetings are kept and published on the commission web site.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-12-015 Grants.
(1) The commission provides grants through a competitive process to organizations or individuals for the purpose of developing, sponsoring, and promoting the growth and development of the arts and arts education in the state of Washington.
(2) Application cycles, forms, guidelines, eligibility requirements, and review criteria are established and published by staff.
(3) The application process is managed pursuant to WAC 30-12-017 (Applications) and applications are reviewed by a panel pursuant to WAC 30-12-030 (Panels).
(4) The board reviews panel recommendations and approves grants, except as noted below.
(a) The executive director may approve grants which do not exceed three thousand dollars. Such actions are reviewed and ratified at the next meeting of the board.
(b) The board may delegate to the executive director approval of grants which exceed three thousand dollars. Such actions are reviewed and ratified at the next meeting of the board.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-12-016 Rosters.
(1) Staff may establish and manage a roster to address program needs.
(2) Application cycles, forms, guidelines, eligibility requirements, and review criteria are established and published by staff.
(3) The application process is managed pursuant to WAC 30-12-017 (Applications) and applications are reviewed by a panel pursuant to WAC 30-12-030 (Panels).
(4) Staff may eliminate a roster due to changes in priorities, program needs, or resources, subject to the review and approval of the board.
(5) Removal from a roster.
(a) Staff have the authority to remove individuals from a roster for the following reasons:
(i) Individual on the roster fails to inform staff of new contact information;
(ii) Individual on the roster requests to be removed;
(iii) Individual on the roster is deceased;
(iv) Expiration of roster term limit, as published in application guidelines;
(v) Violation of the terms of a commission-related contract;
(vi) If artists are accepted onto a roster as a team and subsequently dissolve the team, all individuals on the team are removed from the roster;
(vii) Any other reason specified in published application guidelines.
(b) Removed individuals may apply ((to)) for inclusion in the next roster ((competition)) application cycle, except if removed for violation of the terms of a commission-related contract or for other reasons as specified in application guidelines.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-12-017 Applications.
(1) Application cycles, forms, guidelines, eligibility requirements, and review criteria are established and published by staff.
(2) Application forms and guidelines are published on the commission web site no fewer than twenty calendar days prior to the deadline for submitting applications, pursuant to RCW 34.05.413.
(3) Applications ((that arrive or are postmarked)) submitted by the published deadline as specified in application guidelines are reviewed by staff to determine if the application meets published eligibility requirements.
(4) Staff convene a panel to review eligible applications pursuant to WAC 30-12-030 (Panels).
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-40-050 Funding.
(1) Calculation of funds.
(a) Pursuant to RCW 43.46.090 through 43.46.095, one-half of one percent of the state's capital appropriation for the original construction of specific public buildings is set aside for the administration, acquisition, and conservation of works of art for the state art collection.
(b) The formula is applied to escalated maximum allowable construction cost, and may be applied to architecture and engineering fees and equipment cost.
(c) Funding is generated by construction of any new building and/or additions to an existing building or structure except for highway construction sheds, warehouses, or other temporary buildings. In addition, funding is generated by any renovation and remodel work exceeding two hundred thousand dollars at universities, colleges, and community colleges. Renovation and remodel work does not include repair, maintenance, or replacement of building systems, such as HVAC, plumbing, wiring, fire sprinklers, roofs, insulation, lighting, or other system that keeps the building functional and safe.
(2) Partner agency eligibility and site requirements of funds.
(a) All state agencies including all state departments, boards, councils, commissions, and quasi-public corporations; all universities, colleges, community colleges, and technical colleges; and the office of the superintendent of public instruction who appropriates state funding to school districts for the original construction of school plant facilities, shall apply the formula.
(b) Works of art must be placed in public buildings or on public lands. In siting works of art, priority is given to state properties and K-12 public schools.
(c) Works of art may be sited in a location other than the construction site generating the funding.
(3) Use of funds.
(a) Staff is responsible for negotiating contracts and expending funds.
(b) Funds may be used for works of art in the state art collection that are:
(i) Integral to or attached to a public building or structure;
(ii) Detached inside or outside a public building or structure;
(iii) On or part of the landscape;
(iv) Permanent or temporary;
(v) Part of a portable exhibition or collection.
(c) Funds may be used for expenses incurred in the design, fabrication, and installation of works of art, artists' fees and expenses, staff administrative expenses, and conservation.
(d) Funds shall not be used for the partner agency's administrative expenses, architectural or professional design services, site preparation, public event expenses, insurance, fees for art selection committee participation, or maintenance of the work of art.
(e) Funds shall not be used for clock towers, electrically powered water features, memorials, logos, signage, or the depiction of school mascots.
(4) Determination of funds. Staff shall determine the funds that are available for projects and sites, in consultation with the partner agency; director of general administration; directors of state agencies; the superintendent of public instruction and school district boards of directors; or the boards of regents or trustees of universities, colleges, and community colleges. (RCW 43.17.210, 43.19.455, 28A.335.210, and 28B.10.025.)
(5) Supplemental funds. The one-half of one percent formula is a required minimum for works of art. Partner agencies may designate additional funds from other sources. Works of art acquired using supplemental funding become part of the state art collection.
(6) Transfer of funds. After project funds for works of art are determined, staff may request transfer of the funds from the partner agency.
(7) Pooling of funds.
(a) Staff may determine that funds from multiple construction projects may be combined as part of a pooling program or to fund larger works of art within a partner agency.
(b) Only K-12 school districts with applicable state assisted construction project funds may apply for K-12 pooled funds.
(c) Eligible K-12 school districts may apply for pooled funds pursuant to WAC 30-12-017 (Applications), WAC 30-12-030 (Panels), and in accordance with published application guidelines.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-40-060 Collections management.
(1) Staff manage the state art collection as funded, including conservation, restoration, deaccession, inventory, loans, ((and)) resiting, recordkeeping and documentation.
(2)(a) The commission enters into interagency agreements with partner agencies hosting sites for works of art in the state art collection. The interagency agreement is in effect throughout the partner agency's possession of the work(s) of art.
(b) Partner agencies are responsible for all routine and special maintenance for works of art in the state art collection, which they hold as stated in the interagency agreement.
(i) Routine maintenance includes activities such as surface dusting, replacement of lights, cleaning of glass or Plexiglas, removal of debris, or oiling of moving parts.
(ii) Special maintenance typically involves nonart specific skills including, but not limited to, the application of paint and/or sealant to certain works of art, mortar replacement, or landscape maintenance.
(3) Collections management policy includes:
(a) Conservation/restoration. The commission is responsible for the conservation and restoration of the state art collection. Staff determine conservation and restoration priorities and actions.
(b) Deaccession. The board has authority to formally remove works of art from the state art collection when those works of art meet the review criteria in the collections management policy. Removal of works of art follows the procedures outlined in the collections management policy.
(c) Gifts and transfers. The commission does not accept gifts and transfers of works of art to the state art collection.
(d) Insurance. The state art collection is self-insured.
(e) Inventory. Staff inventory the state art collection in accordance with the state administrative and accounting manual.
(f) Loans of works of art. Works of art may be loaned for temporary exhibition in accordance with the collections management policy. The executive director approves, and staff coordinate outgoing loans.
(g) Resiting. Staff manage the resiting of works of art from the state art collection. Resiting is intended to provide a long-term, secure, and visible home for a work of art. Priority for resiting is given to the original partner agency when possible.
(i) If resiting within the original partner agency jurisdiction is not feasible, then the work of art becomes available for resiting to other partner agencies, in accordance with the collections management policy. Priority may be given to partner agencies that have generated funding pursuant to WAC 30-40-050 (Funding) but have not received a public art project.
(ii) Resiting may not be feasible for physically integrated or site-responsive works of art.
(h) Collections management policies are approved by the board and published on the commission's web site.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-40-100 Art acquisition committees.
(1) Art advisory committees. Staff may recommend that a partner agency form an art advisory committee. Staff may appoint members of the committee. The committee may include, but is not limited to, members of an established art selection committee. The art advisory committee does not select artists or make decisions regarding artist proposals.
(2) Art selection committees. At staff request, an art selection committee shall be formed by the partner agency receiving the project. The committee is convened and facilitated by staff according to published program guidelines.
(a) Committee members may include partner agency administration, visual artists or visual art professionals, community members, board members and trustees, and building/location users. ((A balanced representation, reflecting the partner agency and the site's constituencies, should be appointed to the committee.)) The makeup of the committee should be gender-balanced and culturally diverse. Staff may recommend appointees to the committee.
(b) A preferred committee size is from three to seven members, depending on the method of acquisition of works of art.
(i) For commissioning works of art, the minimum committee size is five members. The committee shall select the artist and approve the artist's concept.
(ii) For direct purchase of curated existing works of art, the minimum committee size is five members. The committee will approve the curator, selection of artists, and work(s) of art.
(iii) For resiting works from the state art collection, the minimum committee size is three members. The committee shall select the work(s) of art to be permanently resited.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-40-110 Acquisition of works of art.
(1) The commission enters into an interagency agreement with any partner agency generating one-half of one percent funds and/or hosting a site for a work of art in the state art collection.
(2) Methods of selecting artists and works of art.
(a) Commissioning new works of art. The primary method of acquisition is by commissioning new works of art through an art selection committee. The public artist roster (WAC 30-40-120) is the tool for selecting artists for commissioning except as specified in (d) of this subsection.
(b) Curated purchase. Staff facilitates a process whereby a curator recommends work(s) of art for art selection committee approval. The curator roster (WAC 30-40-130) is the tool for selecting curators for recommendations except as specified in (d) of this subsection.
(c) Resiting. Works of art may be resited with any partner agency pursuant to WAC 30-40-060 (3)(g) and in accordance with the collection care policy.
(d) ((Open competition.)) An open call. In consultation with the director of a partner agency, staff may elect to manage an open ((competition)) call for artists to be considered for the commissioning of a new work(s) of art or for curators to recommend existing works of art through a curated purchase. The open ((competition)) call process is managed pursuant to WAC 30-12-017 (Applications) and WAC 30-12-030 (Panels) unless otherwise noted in this subsection.
(i) A partner agency art selection committee may act as the panel for the application review process.
(ii) In addition to artists who apply to the open ((competition)) call, the art selection committee ((will)) may review and consider all eligible artists from the public artist roster.
(iii) Artwork selection committee decisions regarding acquisitions are final and do not need board approval.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 10-23-102, filed 11/16/10, effective 12/17/10)
WAC 30-44-030 Eligibility.
(1) In order for the commission to consider an individual or organization for a governor's arts or heritage award, the nominee must:
(a) Be a current resident of the state of Washington, or have been a resident of the state of Washington during the time the contributions were made and/or achievements accomplished;
(b) Not have been a previous individual recipient with the exception of the young arts leader award;
(c) Not have been a previous organizational recipient within the last twenty years.
(2) The commission may establish additional eligibility requirements to be published in nomination guidelines.