H-4568.3  _______________________________________________

 

                 SECOND SUBSTITUTE HOUSE BILL 1113

          _______________________________________________

 

State of Washington      55th Legislature     1998 Regular Session

 

By House Committee on Agriculture & Ecology (originally sponsored by Representatives Chandler, Mastin, McMorris, Koster, Delvin, Mulliken, Johnson, Schoesler and Honeyford)

 

Read first time 02/05/98.  Referred to Committee on .

Authorizing a change in the use of water made surplus by certain activities and modifying transfer provisions.


    AN ACT Relating to water transfers and changes; amending RCW 90.03.380, 90.44.100, 90.03.290, and 90.44.445; and adding a new section to chapter 90.03 RCW.

 

BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON:

 

    Sec. 1.  RCW 90.03.380 and 1997 c 442 s 801 are each amended to read as follows:

    (1) The right to the use of water which has been applied to a beneficial use in the state shall be and remain appurtenant to the land or place upon which the same is used:  PROVIDED, HOWEVER, That the right may be transferred to another or to others and become appurtenant to any other land or place of use without loss of priority of right theretofore established if such change can be made without detriment or injury to existing rights.  The point of diversion of water for beneficial use or the purpose of use may be changed, if such change can be made without detriment or injury to existing rights.  A change in the place of use, point of diversion, and/or purpose of use of a water right to enable irrigation of additional acreage or the addition of new uses may be permitted if such change results in no increase in the annual consumptive quantity of water used under the water right.  For purposes of this section, "annual consumptive quantity" means the estimated or actual annual amount of water diverted pursuant to the water right, reduced by the estimated annual amount of return flows, averaged over the most recent five-year period of continuous beneficial use of the water right.  Before any transfer of such right to use water or change of the point of diversion of water or change of purpose of use can be made, any person having an interest in the transfer or change, shall file a written application therefor with the department, and the application shall not be granted until notice of the application is published as provided in RCW 90.03.280.  If it shall appear that such transfer or such change may be made without injury or detriment to existing rights, the department shall issue to the applicant a certificate in duplicate granting the right for such transfer or for such change of point of diversion or of use.  The certificate so issued shall be filed and be made a record with the department and the duplicate certificate issued to the applicant may be filed with the county auditor in like manner and with the same effect as provided in the original certificate or permit to divert water.

    (2) If an application for change proposes to transfer water rights from one irrigation district to another, the department shall, before publication of notice, receive concurrence from each of the irrigation districts that such transfer or change will not adversely affect the ability to deliver water to other landowners or impair the financial or operational integrity of either of the districts.

    (3) A change in place of use by an individual water user or users of water provided by an irrigation district need only receive approval for the change from the board of directors of the district if the use of water continues within the irrigation district, and when water is provided by an irrigation entity that is a member of a board of joint control created under chapter 87.80 RCW, approval need only be received from the board of joint control if the use of water continues within the area of jurisdiction of the joint board and the change can be made without detriment or injury to existing rights.  The board of directors of an irrigation district may approve such a change if the board determines that the change:  Will not adversely affect the district's ability to deliver water to other landowners; will not require the construction by the district of diversion or drainage facilities unless the board finds that the construction by the district is in the interest of the district; will not impair the financial or operational integrity of the district; and is consistent with the contractual obligations of the district.

    (4) Subsections (1), (2), and (3) of this section do not apply to a transfer or change governed by section 2 of this act.

    (5) This section shall not apply to trust water rights acquired by the state through the funding of water conservation projects under chapter 90.38 RCW or RCW 90.42.010 through 90.42.070.

    (6) Any right represented by an application for a water right for which a permit for water use has not been issued by the time a transfer or change is approved under this section may not be construed as being injured or detrimentally affected by the transfer or change.

    (7) The department may not initiate relinquishment proceedings under chapter 90.14 RCW regarding a water right for which an application for a transfer or change is filed under this section during the period beginning on the date the department receives the application and ending two years after the date the department approves or denies the application.

 

    NEW SECTION.  Sec. 2.  A new section is added to chapter 90.03 RCW to read as follows:

    (1)(a) If a portion of the water governed by a water right is made surplus to the beneficial uses exercised under the right through the implementation of practices or technologies, including but not limited to conveyance practices or technologies, which are more efficient or more water-use efficient than those under which the right was perfected, the right to use the surplus water may be changed as provided by subsection (2), (3), (4), or (5) of this section.

    (b) If a portion of the water governed by a water right is made surplus to the beneficial uses exercised under the right through a change in the crops grown under the water right, the right to use the surplus water may be changed as provided by subsection (3) of this section.  This subsection (1)(b) does not apply to water supplied by an irrigation district.

    (c) This section applies only to a change of an agricultural use or portion of an agricultural use of water to an agricultural use of water.

    (2) The use within an irrigation district of water supplied by the district and made surplus as provided in subsection (1)(a) of this section shall be regulated solely as provided by the board of directors of the irrigation district.  Such a use requires the approval of the board of directors of the irrigation district or must otherwise be authorized by the board.  The board may approve or authorize such a use only if the use does not impair the financial or operational integrity of the district.  Water supplied by an irrigation district and made surplus as provided in subsection (1)(a) of this section through actions taken by an individual water user served by the district is not available for use as a matter of right by that individual water user, but may be used by the board for the benefit of the district generally.  The district's board of directors may approve or otherwise authorize under this subsection uses of such surplus water that result in the total irrigated acreage within the district exceeding the irrigated acreage recorded with the department for the district's water right if the board notifies the department of the change in the irrigated acreage within the district.  Except as provided in subsection (5) of this section, such a notification provides a change in the district's water right and, upon receiving the notification, the department shall revise its records for the district's right to reflect the change.

    If an irrigation district is within a federal reclamation project and the district's board of directors approves or otherwise authorizes under this subsection uses of such surplus water that result in the total irrigated acreage within the federal project exceeding the irrigated acreage recorded with the department for the federal project's water right, the board shall notify the department of the change in the irrigated acreage within the federal project.  Except as provided by this subsection and subsection (5) of this section, such a notification provides a change in the federal reclamation project's water right and, upon receiving the notification, the department shall revise its records for the federal project's right to reflect the change except that the total irrigable acreage for a water right for a federal reclamation project may not exceed the total irrigable acreage authorized for the project by the United States and related repayment contracts.

    (3) The right to use water made surplus as provided in subsection (1)(a) or (b) of this section but not supplied by an irrigation district may be changed to use on other parcels of land owned by the holder of the water right that are contiguous to the parcel or parcels of land upon which the use of the water was authorized by the right before such a change.  The holder of the water right shall notify the department of such a change.  Except as provided in subsection (5) of this section, the notification provides a change in the holder's water right and, upon receiving the notification, the department shall revise its records for the water right to reflect the change.

    (4) If a notification is provided to the department under subsection (2) or (3) of this section with regard to water made surplus and subsequently used before the effective date of this section, the change in the water right shall be made without loss of priority of the right.

    (5) If a notification is provided to the department under subsection (2) or (3) of this section with regard to water made surplus and subsequently used, and that use begins after the effective date of this section, the priority date for the use of the water made surplus under this section is the date the notification is filed with the department.  When the department is notified regarding such a use under this subsection (5), the notification does not automatically provide a change in the water right holder's, irrigation district's, or reclamation project's water right.  The department shall issue the holder, district, or project a temporary water use permit for the use.  The term of the permit shall be for fifteen years.  It is presumed that the use of water under the temporary water use permit does not impair or interfere with water rights that are senior to the water right represented by the permit.  However, if at any time within the fifteen-year term of the permit the department determines that the change would impair or interfere with the use of such a senior water right, the department shall notify the holder of the temporary permit and shall file a notice of its decision with the superior court of the county in which the withdrawal of water under the right takes place.  The notice provided by the department shall not stay the use of water under the temporary permit.  The superior court shall review the determination of the department de novo.  In such a review, the burden of proof in overcoming the presumption provided by this subsection is on the department.  The presumption can be overcome only through the application of scientific data supporting the department's determination.  At the conclusion of its review, the superior court shall enter a ruling canceling the temporary permit, modifying the conditions of water use under the permit, or affirming that the use of water under the permit does not interfere with water rights senior to the water rights represented by the permit.  The decision of the superior court may be appealed as provided for other decisions of the court.  If a court's decision modifies the conditions of water use under the permit or affirms that the use of water under the permit does not interfere with senior water rights or if the department does not provide a notice under this subsection within the fifteen-year term of the permit, the use of the water is changed as provided by the temporary permit or the court's decision and the department shall revise its records regarding the right.

    The presumption provided by this subsection does not apply with regard to a claim made by any person with a water right in superior court or on appeal of a decision of the superior court that a temporary permit or change in a water right made under this subsection impairs or interferes with the use of the person's senior water right.

    (6) If a notification is filed with the department regarding the use of water made surplus under subsection (2) or (3) of this section and that use begins after the effective date of this section, the notification shall identify the date that the use of the water made surplus begins.

    (7) The authority provided by this section to change a water right shall not be construed as authorizing the use of a junior water right in a manner that impairs or interferes with the use of a senior water right.

    (8) If a water right changed under this section is a right represented by a statement of claim in the water rights claims registry, the department's obligation to revise its records to reflect the change shall be accomplished by providing an amendment to the statement of claim to reflect the change.

    (9) This section does not apply in an area with an acreage expansion program in effect on the effective date of this section that is an element of a ground water area or subarea management program as provided in RCW 90.44.445.

    (10) Nothing in this section authorizes a change in a water right or a portion of a water right that has not been perfected through beneficial use before the change.

 

    Sec. 3.  RCW 90.44.100 and 1997 c 316 s 2 are each amended to read as follows:

    (1) After an application to, and upon the issuance by the department of an amendment to the appropriate permit or certificate of ground water right, the holder of a valid right to withdraw public ground waters may, without losing the holder's priority of right, construct wells or other means of withdrawal at a new location in substitution for or in addition to those at the original location, or the holder may change the manner or the place of use of the water.

    (2) An amendment to construct replacement or a new additional well or wells at a location outside of the location of the original well or wells or to change the manner or place of use of the water shall be issued only after publication of notice of the application and findings as prescribed in the case of an original application.  Such amendment shall be issued by the department only on the conditions that:  (a) The additional or replacement well or wells shall tap the same body of public ground water as the original well or wells; (b) where a replacement well or wells is approved, the use of the original well or wells shall be discontinued and the original well or wells shall be properly decommissioned as required under chapter 18.104 RCW; (c) where an additional well or wells is constructed, the original well or wells may continue to be used, but the combined total withdrawal from the original and additional well or wells shall not enlarge the right conveyed by the original permit or certificate; and (d) other existing rights shall not be impaired.  The department may specify an approved manner of construction and shall require a showing of compliance with the terms of the amendment, as provided in RCW 90.44.080 in the case of an original permit.

    (3) The construction of a replacement or new additional well or wells at the location of the original well or wells shall be allowed without application to the department for an amendment.  However, the following apply to such a replacement or new additional well:  (a) The well shall tap the same body of public ground water as the original well or wells; (b) if a replacement well is constructed, the use of the original well or wells shall be discontinued and the original well or wells shall be properly decommissioned as required under chapter 18.104 RCW; (c) if a new additional well is constructed, the original well or wells may continue to be used, but the combined total withdrawal from the original and additional well or wells shall not enlarge the right conveyed by the original water use permit or certificate; (d) the construction and use of the well shall not interfere with or impair water rights with an earlier date of priority than the water right or rights for the original well or wells; (e) the replacement or additional well shall be located no closer than the original well to a well it might interfere with; (f) the department may specify an approved manner of construction of the well; and (g) the department shall require a showing of compliance with the conditions of this subsection (3).

    (4) This section does not apply to a transfer or change governed by section 2 of this act.

    (5) Any right represented by an application for a water right for which a permit for water use has not been issued by the time an amendment is approved under this section may not be construed as being impaired by the amendment.

    (6) The department may not initiate relinquishment proceedings under chapter 90.14 RCW regarding a water right for which an application for an amendment is filed under this section during the period beginning on the date the department receives the application and ending two years after the date the department makes a decision on the application.

    (7) As used in this section, the "location of the original well or wells" is the area described as the point of withdrawal in the original public notice published for the application for the water right for the well.

 

    Sec. 4.  RCW 90.03.290 and 1994 c 264 s 84 are each amended to read as follows:

    When an application complying with the provisions of this chapter and with the rules and regulations of the department has been filed, the same shall be placed on record with the department, and it shall be its duty to investigate the application, and determine what water, if any, is available for appropriation, and find and determine to what beneficial use or uses it can be applied.  If it is proposed to appropriate water for irrigation purposes, the department shall investigate, determine and find what lands are capable of irrigation by means of water found available for appropriation.  If it is proposed to appropriate water for the purpose of power development, the department shall investigate, determine and find whether the proposed development is likely to prove detrimental to the public interest, having in mind the highest feasible use of the waters belonging to the public.  If the application does not contain, and the applicant does not promptly furnish sufficient information on which to base such findings, the department may issue a preliminary permit, for a period of not to exceed three years, requiring the applicant to make such surveys, investigations, studies, and progress reports, as in the opinion of the department may be necessary.  If the applicant fails to comply with the conditions of the preliminary permit, it and the application or applications on which it is based shall be automatically canceled and the applicant so notified.  If the holder of a preliminary permit shall, before its expiration, file with the department a verified report of expenditures made and work done under the preliminary permit, which, in the opinion of the department, establishes the good faith, intent and ability of the applicant to carry on the proposed development, the preliminary permit may, with the approval of the governor, be extended, but not to exceed a maximum period of five years from the date of the issuance of the preliminary permit.  The department shall make and file as part of the record in the matter, written findings of fact concerning all things investigated, and if it shall find that there is water available for appropriation for a beneficial use, and the appropriation thereof as proposed in the application will not impair existing rights or be detrimental to the public welfare, it shall issue a permit stating the amount of water to which the applicant shall be entitled and the beneficial use or uses to which it may be applied:  PROVIDED, That where the water applied for is to be used for irrigation purposes, it shall become appurtenant only to such land as may be reclaimed thereby to the full extent of the soil for agricultural purposes.  But where there is no unappropriated water in the proposed source of supply, or where the proposed use conflicts with existing rights, or threatens to prove detrimental to the public interest, having due regard to the highest feasible development of the use of the waters belonging to the public, it shall be duty of the department to reject such application and to refuse to issue the permit asked for.  If the permit is refused because of conflict with existing rights and such applicant shall acquire same by purchase or condemnation under RCW 90.03.040, the department may thereupon grant such permit.  Any application may be approved for a less amount of water than that applied for, if there exists substantial reason therefor, and in any event shall not be approved for more water than can be applied to beneficial use for the purposes named in the application.  In determining whether or not a permit shall issue upon any application, it shall be the duty of the department to investigate all facts relevant and material to the application.  After the department approves said application in whole or in part and before any permit shall be issued thereon to the applicant, such applicant shall pay the fee provided in RCW 90.03.470:  PROVIDED FURTHER, That in the event a permit is issued by the department upon any application, it shall be its duty to notify the director of fish and wildlife of such issuance.

    This section does not apply to transfers or changes made under section 2 of this act or to applications for transfers or changes made under RCW 90.03.380 or 90.44.100.

 

    Sec. 5.  RCW 90.44.445 and 1993 c 99 s 1 are each amended to read as follows:

    In any acreage expansion program adopted by the department as an element of a ground water management program, the authorization for a water right certificate holder to participate in the program shall be on an annual basis for the first two years.  After the two-year period, the department may authorize participation for ten-year periods.  The department may authorize participation for ten-year periods for certificate holders who have already participated in an acreage expansion program for two years.  The department may require annual certification that the certificate holder has complied with all requirements of the program.  The department may terminate the authority of a certificate holder to participate in the program for one calendar year if the certificate holder fails to comply with the requirements of the program.

    This section applies only in an area with an acreage expansion program in effect on the effective date of this amendatory section that has been adopted by the department as an element of a ground water area or subarea management program.  The provisions of section 2 of this act, RCW 90.03.380, and 90.44.100 apply to transfers, changes, and amendments to permits or rights for the beneficial use of ground water in any other area.

 


                            --- END ---