ESSB 6001 -
By Committee on Technology, Energy & Communications
NOT CONSIDERED 04/12/2007
Strike everything after the enacting clause and insert the following:
NEW SECTION. Sec. 1 (1) The legislature finds that:
(a) Washington is especially vulnerable to climate change because
of the state's dependence on snow pack for summer stream flows and
because the expected rise in sea levels threatens our coastal
communities. Extreme weather, a warming Pacific Northwest, reduced
snow pack, and sea level rise are four major ways that climate change
is disrupting Washington's economy, environment, and communities;
(b) Washington's greenhouse gases emissions are continuing to
increase, despite international scientific consensus that worldwide
emissions must be reduced significantly below current levels to avert
catastrophic climate change;
(c) Washington state greenhouse gases are substantially caused by
the transportation sector of the economy;
(d) Washington has been a leader in actions to reduce the increase
of greenhouse gases emissions, such as being the first state in the
nation to adopt a carbon dioxide mitigation program for new thermal
electric plants, mandating integrated resource planning for electric
utilities to include life-cycle costs of carbon dioxide emissions,
including the adoption of clean car standards, stronger appliance
energy efficiency standards, increased production and use of renewable
liquid fuels, and increased renewable energy sources by electrical
utilities;
(e) A greenhouse gases emissions performance standard will work in
unison with the state's carbon dioxide mitigation policy for
fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities located in the
state under chapter 80.70 RCW and its related rules;
(f) While these actions are significant, there is a need to assess
the trend of greenhouse gases emissions statewide over the next several
decades, and to take sufficient actions so that Washington meets its
responsibility to contribute to the global actions needed to reduce the
impacts and the pace of global warming;
(g) Actions to reduce greenhouse gases emissions will spur
technology development and increase efficiency, thus resulting in
benefits to Washington's economy and businesses; and
(h) The state of Washington has an obligation to provide clear
guidance for the procurement of baseload electric generation to
alleviate regulatory uncertainty while addressing risks that can affect
the ability of electric utilities to make necessary and timely
investments to ensure an adequate, reliable, and cost-effective supply
of electricity.
(2) The legislature finds that companies that generate greenhouse
gases emissions or manufacture products that generate such emissions
are purchasing carbon credits from landowners and from other companies
that provide carbon credits. Companies that are purchasing carbon
credits would benefit from a program to trade and to bank carbon
credits. Washington forests are one of the most effective resources
that can absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Forests, and other
planted lands and waters, provide carbon storage and mitigate
greenhouse gases emissions. Washington contains the most productive
forests in the world and both public and private landowners could
benefit from a carbon storage trading and banking program.
(3) The legislature intends by this act to establish statutory
goals for the statewide reduction in greenhouse gases emissions and to
adopt the recommendations provided by the Washington climate change
challenge stakeholder group, which is charged with designing and
recommending a comprehensive set of policies to the legislature and the
governor on how to achieve the goals. The legislature further intends
by this act to authorize immediate actions in the electric power
generation sector for the reduction of greenhouse gases emissions and
to accelerate efficiency in the transportation sector.
(4) The legislature finds that:
(a) To the extent energy efficiency and renewable resources are
unable to satisfy increasing energy and capacity needs, the state will
rely on clean and efficient fossil fuel-fired generation and will
encourage the development of cost-effective, highly efficient, and
environmentally sound supply resources to provide reliability and
consistency with the state's energy priorities;
(b) It is vital to ensure all electric utilities internalize the
significant and underrecognized cost of emissions and to reduce
Washington's exposure to costs associated with future regulation of
these emissions, which is consistent with the objectives of integrated
resource planning by electric utilities under chapter 19.280 RCW; and
(c) The state of California recently enacted a law establishing a
greenhouse gases emissions performance standard for electric utility
procurement of baseload electric generation that is based on the
emissions of a combined-cycle thermal electric generation facility
fueled by natural gas.
(5) The legislature finds that the climate change challenge
stakeholder group provides a process for identifying the policies
necessary to achieve the economic and emissions reduction goals in
sections 3 and 4 of this act. The climate change challenge stakeholder
group should seek emission reduction policies and strategies, to the
maximum extent possible, that minimize economic disruptions and protect
jobs for Washington state workers, citizens, and businesses, while
avoiding policies and strategies that would result in the transfer or
outsourcing of economic advantages or jobs to other states, regions, or
nations.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 2 The definitions in this section apply
throughout this chapter unless the context clearly requires otherwise.
(1) "Attorney general" means the Washington state office of the
attorney general.
(2) "Auditor" means: (a) The Washington state auditor's office or
its designee for consumer-owned utilities under its jurisdiction; or
(b) an independent auditor selected by a consumer-owned utility that is
not under the jurisdiction of the state auditor.
(3) "Average available greenhouse gases emissions output" means the
average greenhouse gases emissions from combined-cycle natural gas
thermal electric generation turbines available for sale in the United
States as surveyed and reported by the energy policy division of the
department of community, trade, and economic development under section
7 of this act.
(4) "Baseload electric generation" means electric generation from
a power plant that is designed and intended to provide electricity at
an annualized plant capacity factor of at least sixty percent.
(5) "Climate change challenge stakeholder group" means the
consultation group established by Executive Order 07-02 to consider and
recommend policies for the state to adopt to achieve greenhouse gases
emissions goals.
(6) "Cogeneration facility" means a power plant in which the heat
or steam is also used for industrial or commercial heating or cooling
purposes and that meets federal energy regulatory commission standards
for qualifying facilities under the public utility regulatory policies
act of 1978 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 824a-3), as amended.
(7) "Combined-cycle natural gas thermal electric generation
facility" means a power plant that employs a combination of one or more
gas turbines and steam turbines in which electricity is produced in the
steam turbine from otherwise lost waste heat exiting from one or more
of the gas turbines.
(8) "Commission" means the Washington utilities and transportation
commission.
(9) "Consumer-owned utility" means a municipal utility formed under
Title 35 RCW, a public utility district formed under Title 54 RCW, an
irrigation district formed under chapter 87.03 RCW, a cooperative
formed under chapter 23.86 RCW, a mutual corporation or association
formed under chapter 24.06 RCW, or port district within which an
industrial district has been established as authorized by Title 53 RCW,
that is engaged in the business of distributing electricity to more
than one retail electric customer in the state.
(10) "Department" means the department of ecology.
(11) "Distributed generation" means electric generation connected
to the distribution level of the transmission and distribution grid,
which is usually located at or near the intended place of use.
(12) "Electrical company" means a company owned by investors that
meets the definition of RCW 80.04.010.
(13) "Electric utility" means an electrical company or a
consumer-owned utility.
(14) "Governing board" means the board of directors or legislative
authority of a consumer-owned utility.
(15) "Greenhouse gases" includes carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous
oxide, hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons, and sulfur hexafluoride.
(16) "Long-term financial commitment" means:
(a) Either a new ownership interest in baseload electric generation
or an upgrade to a baseload electric generation facility; or
(b) A new or renewed contract for baseload electric generation with
a term of five or more years for the provision of retail power or
wholesale power to end-use customers in this state.
(17) "Net emissions" means the formula for calculating total carbon
dioxide emissions as determined according to chapter 173-407 WAC as it
existed on July 1, 2007.
(18) "Plant capacity factor" means the ratio of the electricity
produced during a given time period, measured in kilowatt-hours, to the
electricity the unit could have produced if it had been operated at its
rated capacity during that period, expressed in kilowatt-hours.
(19) "Power plant" means a facility for the generation of
electricity that is permitted as a single plant by the energy facility
site evaluation council or a local jurisdiction.
(20) "Upgrade" means any modification made for the primary purpose
of increasing the electric generation capacity of a baseload electric
generation facility. "Upgrade" does not include routine or necessary
maintenance, installation of emission control equipment, installation,
replacement, or modification of equipment that improves the heat rate
of the facility, or installation, replacement, or modification of
equipment for the primary purpose of maintaining reliable generation
output capability that does not increase the heat input or fuel usage
as specified in existing generation air quality permits as of the
effective date of this section, but may result in incidental increases
in generation capacity.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 3 (1) The following greenhouse gases emissions
reduction and clean energy economy goals are established for Washington
state:
(a) By 2020, reduce overall greenhouse gases emissions in the state
to 1990 levels, which equals seventy-eight million five hundred
thousand metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions;
(b) By 2035, reduce overall greenhouse gases emissions in the state
to twenty-five percent below 1990 levels, which equals fifty-eight
million eight hundred eighty thousand metric tons of carbon dioxide
equivalent emissions;
(c) By 2050, the state will do its part to reach global climate
stabilization levels by reducing overall emissions to fifty percent
below 1990 levels, which equals thirty-nine million two hundred fifty
thousand million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions, or
seventy percent below the state's expected emissions that year; and
(d) By 2020, increase the number of clean energy sector jobs to
twenty-five thousand from the eight thousand four hundred jobs the
state had in 2004.
(2) By December 31st of each even-numbered year beginning in 2010,
the departments of ecology and community, trade, and economic
development shall report to the governor and the appropriate committees
of the senate and house of representatives the total greenhouse gases
emissions for the preceding two years, and totals in each major source
sector.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 4 (1) The following greenhouse gases emissions
reduction goals with respect to electricity generation are established
for the electricity sector in Washington state:
(a) By 2020, reduce greenhouse gases emissions in the state to 1990
levels, which equals seven million four hundred thirty thousand metric
tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions;
(b) By 2035, reduce greenhouse gases emissions in the state to
twenty-five percent below 1990 levels, which equals five million five
hundred seventy thousand metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent
emissions; and
(c) By 2050, the state will do its part to reach global climate
stabilization levels by reducing emissions to fifty percent below 1990
levels, which equals three million seven hundred twenty thousand metric
tons of carbon dioxide equivalent emissions, or seventy percent below
the state's expected emissions that year.
(2) By December 31st of each even-numbered year beginning in 2010,
the departments of ecology and community, trade, and economic
development shall report to the governor and the appropriate committees
of the senate and house of representatives the total greenhouse gas
emissions for the preceding two years, and totals in each major source
sector.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 5 The climate change challenge stakeholder
group shall develop policy recommendations to the governor and the
legislature as to what policies must be put in place in order for the
state to meet the greenhouse gases emissions reduction standards
established in sections 3 and 4 of this act. These recommendations
must be submitted to the legislature and the governor by December 1,
2007.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 6 (1) Beginning July 1, 2008, the greenhouse
gases emissions performance standard for all baseload electric
generation for which electric utilities enter into long-term financial
commitments on or after such date is the lower of:
(a) One thousand one hundred pounds of greenhouse gases per
megawatt-hour; or
(b) The average available greenhouse gases emissions output as
determined by the department of community, trade, and economic
development under section 7 of this act.
(2) Even if their actual emissions are higher than the greenhouse
gases emissions performance standard, all baseload electric generation
facilities in operation as of June 30, 2008, are deemed to be in
compliance with the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard
established under this section until the facilities are the subject of
long-term financial commitments.
(3) All electric generating facilities or power plants powered by
renewable resources, as defined in RCW 19.280.020, are deemed to be in
compliance with the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard
established under this section. For the purposes of this section,
"renewable resources" include, but are not limited to, hydroelectric
generation.
(4) Even if their actual emissions are higher than the greenhouse
gases emissions performance standard, all baseload electric generation
facilities that begin operation after June 30, 2008, are deemed to be
in compliance with the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard
established under this section provided that the baseload electric
generation facility mitigates its total carbon dioxide emissions under
RCW 80.70.020.
(5) In determining the rate of emissions of greenhouse gases for
baseload electric generation, the net emissions resulting from the
production of electricity by the baseload electric generation must be
included.
(6) Carbon dioxide that is sequestered so as to prevent releases
into the atmosphere, which is in compliance with applicable laws and
regulations, may not be counted as net emissions of the power plant in
determining compliance with the greenhouse gases emissions performance
standard.
(7) In adopting and implementing the greenhouse gases emissions
performance standard, the department, in consultation with the
commission, the Bonneville power administration, the western
electricity coordination council, the energy facility site evaluation
council, the department of community, trade, and economic development
energy policy division, electric utilities, public interest
representatives, and consumer representatives shall consider the
effects of the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard on
system reliability and overall costs to electricity customers.
(8) In developing and implementing the greenhouse gases emissions
performance standard, the department shall to the extent practicable,
with assistance of the commission, the department of community, trade,
and economic development energy policy division, and electric
utilities, address electricity from unspecified sources in a manner
consistent with this chapter.
(9) By December 1, 2007, the climate change challenge stakeholder
group shall develop policy recommendations to the governor and the
legislature on implementation of the greenhouse gases emissions
performance standards established in this section. These
recommendations must include, but not be limited to:
(a) Procedures regarding verification and enforcement of the
greenhouse gases emissions performance standard;
(b) Whether existing mechanisms for carbon sequestration under
chapter 80.70 RCW and its related rules are sufficient;
(c) A transition plan for phasing out carbon dioxide mitigation
under chapter 80.70 RCW as a means of achieving the goals of this act;
(d) A process for replacing the highest emitting thermal electric
plants that have exceeded their expected useful life with newer
technologies that have lower greenhouse gases emission levels; and
(e) Methods to utilize indigenous resources, such as landfill gas,
geothermal resources, and other assets that might reduce greenhouse
gases emissions consistent with the purposes of this act.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 7 The energy policy division of the department
of community, trade, and economic development shall survey
combined-cycle natural gas thermal electric generation facilities
available for sale in the United States and determine an average rate
of emission of greenhouse gases for these facilities. The department
of community, trade, and economic development shall report the results
of its survey to the legislature on a biennial basis, starting June 30,
2008.
Sec. 8 RCW 80.70.020 and 2004 c 224 s 2 are each amended to read
as follows:
(1) The provisions of this chapter apply to:
(a) New fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities with
station-generating capability of three hundred fifty thousand kilowatts
or more and fossil-fueled floating thermal electric generation
facilities of one hundred thousand kilowatts or more under RCW
80.50.020(14)(a), for which an application for site certification is
made to the council after July 1, 2004;
(b) New fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities with
station-generating capability of more than twenty-five thousand
kilowatts, but less than three hundred fifty thousand kilowatts, except
for fossil-fueled floating thermal electric generation facilities under
the council's jurisdiction, for which an application for an order of
approval has been submitted after July 1, 2004;
(c) Fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities with
station-generating capability of three hundred fifty thousand kilowatts
or more that have an existing site certification agreement and, after
July 1, 2004, apply to the council to increase the output of carbon
dioxide emissions by fifteen percent or more through permanent changes
in facility operations or modification or equipment; and
(d) Fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities with
station-generating capability of more than twenty-five thousand
kilowatts, but less than three hundred fifty thousand kilowatts, except
for fossil-fueled floating thermal electric generation facilities under
the council's jurisdiction, that have an existing order of approval
and, after July 1, 2004, apply to the department or authority, as
appropriate, to permanently modify the facility so as to increase its
station-generating capability by at least twenty-five thousand
kilowatts or to increase the output of carbon dioxide emissions by
fifteen percent or more, whichever measure is greater.
(2)(a) A proposed site certification agreement submitted to the
governor under RCW 80.50.100 and a final site certification agreement
issued under RCW 80.50.100 shall include an approved carbon dioxide
mitigation plan.
(b) For fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities not
under jurisdiction of the council, the order of approval shall require
an approved carbon dioxide mitigation plan.
(c) Site certification agreement holders or order of approval
holders may request, at any time, a change in conditions of an approved
carbon dioxide mitigation plan if the council, department, or
authority, as appropriate, finds that the change meets all requirements
and conditions for approval of such plans.
(3) An applicant for a fossil-fueled thermal electric generation
facility shall include one or a combination of the following carbon
dioxide mitigation options as part of its mitigation plan:
(a) Payment to a third party to provide mitigation;
(b) Direct purchase of permanent carbon credits; or
(c) Investment in applicant-controlled carbon dioxide mitigation
projects, including combined heat and power (cogeneration).
(4) Fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities that
receive site certification approval or an order of approval shall
provide mitigation ((for twenty percent of)) to reduce the total carbon
dioxide emissions produced by the facility to one thousand one hundred
pounds of greenhouse gases per megawatt-hour or the average available
greenhouse gases emissions output as determined under section 7 of this
act, whichever is lower.
(5) If the certificate holder or order of approval holder chooses
to pay a third party to provide the mitigation, the mitigation rate
shall be one dollar and sixty cents per metric ton of carbon dioxide to
be mitigated. For a cogeneration plant, the monetary amount is based
on ((the difference between twenty percent of)) the total carbon
dioxide emissions ((and)) minus one thousand one hundred pounds of
greenhouse gases per megawatt-hour or the average available greenhouse
gases emissions output as determined under section 7 of this act,
whichever is lower, minus the cogeneration credit.
(a) Through rule making, the council may adjust the rate per ton
biennially as long as any increase or decrease does not exceed fifty
percent of the current rate. The department or authority shall use the
adjusted rate established by the council pursuant to this subsection
for fossil-fueled thermal electric generation facilities subject to the
provisions of this chapter.
(b) In adjusting the mitigation rate the council shall consider,
but is not limited to, the current market price of a ton of carbon
dioxide. The council's adjusted mitigation rate shall be consistent
with RCW 80.50.010(3).
(6) The applicant may choose to make to the third party a lump sum
payment or partial payment over a period of five years.
(a) Under the lump sum payment option, the payment amount is
determined by ((multiplying the total carbon dioxide emissions by the
twenty percent mitigation requirement under subsection (4) of this
section and)) calculating the difference between the total carbon
dioxide emissions and one thousand one hundred pounds of greenhouse
gases per megawatt-hour or the average available greenhouse gases
emissions output as determined under section 7 of this act, whichever
is lower, multiplied by the per ton mitigation rate established under
subsection (5) of this section.
(b) No later than one hundred twenty days after the start of
commercial operation, the certificate holder or order of approval
holder shall make a one-time payment to the independent qualified
organization for the amount determined under subsection (5) of this
section.
(c) As an alternative to a one-time payment, the certificate holder
or order of approval holder may make a partial payment of twenty
percent of the amount determined under subsection (5) of this section
no later than one hundred twenty days after commercial operation and a
payment in the same amount or as adjusted according to subsection
(5)(a) of this section, on the anniversary date of the initial payment
in each of the following four years. With the initial payment, the
certificate holder or order of approval holder shall provide a letter
of credit or other comparable security acceptable to the council or the
department for the remaining eighty percent mitigation payment amount
including possible changes to the rate per metric ton from rule making
under subsection (5)(a) of this section.
(7)(a) All electric utilities that enter into long-term financial
commitments for baseload generation located outside the state shall
meet the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard under chapter
80.-- RCW (sections 1 through 7 and 9 through 11 of this act).
Electric utilities shall provide mitigation for greenhouse gases
emissions in excess of the greenhouse gases emissions standard
established in section 6 of this act.
(b) The electric utility shall choose one or a combination of the
following carbon dioxide mitigation options to mitigate for carbon
dioxide emissions:
(i) Payment to a third party to provide mitigation;
(ii) Direct purchase of permanent carbon credits as specified under
RCW 80.70.030; or
(iii) Investment in load-serving utility-controlled carbon dioxide
mitigation projects, including combined heat and power (cogeneration).
NEW SECTION. Sec. 9 (1) No electrical company may enter into a
long-term financial commitment unless the baseload electric generation
supplied under such a long-term financial commitment complies with the
greenhouse gases emissions performance standard established under
section 6 of this act.
(2) In order to enforce the requirements of this chapter, the
commission shall review in a general rate case or as provided in
subsection (5) of this section any long-term financial commitment
entered into by an electrical company after June 30, 2008, to determine
whether the baseload electric generation to be supplied under that
long-term financial commitment complies with the greenhouse gases
emissions performance standard established under section 6 of this act.
(3) In determining whether a long-term financial commitment is for
baseload electric generation, the commission shall consider:
(a) The design of the power plant and its intended use, based upon
the electricity purchase contract, if any;
(b) Permits necessary for the operation of the power plant; and
(c) Any other matter the commission determines is relevant under
the circumstances.
(4) Upon application by an electric company, the commission may
provide a case-by-case exemption from the greenhouse gases emissions
performance standard to address: (a) Unanticipated electric system
reliability needs; or (b) catastrophic events or threat of significant
financial harm that may arise from unforeseen circumstances.
(5) Upon application by an electrical company, the commission shall
make a determination regarding the company's proposed decision to
acquire electric generation or enter into a power purchase agreement
for electricity that complies with the greenhouse gases emissions
performance standard established under section 6 of this act, as to the
need for the resource, and the appropriateness of the specific resource
selected. The commission shall take into consideration each electric
company's most recent integrated resource plan. In addition, the
commission shall provide for recovery of the prudently incurred capital
and operating cost of these resources and may impose such conditions as
it finds necessary to ensure that rates are fair, just, reasonable, and
sufficient, coincident with the in-service date of the project or the
effective date of the power purchase agreement.
(6) An electrical company may account for and defer for later
consideration by the commission costs incurred in connection with the
long-term financial commitment, including operating and maintenance
costs, depreciation, taxes, and cost of invested capital. The deferral
begins with the date on which the power plant begins commercial
operation or the effective date of the power purchase agreement and
ends on the effective date of the final decision by the commission
regarding recovery in rates of these deferred costs. Creation of such
a deferral account does not by itself determine whether recovery of any
or all of these costs is appropriate.
(7) The commission shall adopt procedures to verify net emissions
of greenhouse gases from baseload electric generation under section 6
of this act.
(8) The commission shall adopt rules for the enforcement of this
section with respect to electrical companies and adopt procedural rules
for approving costs incurred by an electrical company under subsection
(4) of this section.
(9) The commission shall adopt the rules necessary to implement
this section by December 31, 2008.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 10 (1) No consumer-owned utility may enter
into a long-term financial commitment unless the baseload electric
generation supplied under such a long-term financial commitment
complies with the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard
established under section 6 of this act.
(2) The governing board of a consumer-owned utility shall review
and make a determination on any long-term financial commitment by the
utility, pursuant to this chapter, to determine whether the baseload
electric generation to be supplied under that long-term financial
commitment complies with the greenhouse gases emissions performance
standard established under section 6 of this act. No consumer-owned
utility may enter into a long-term financial commitment unless the
baseload electric generation to be supplied under that long-term
financial commitment complies with the greenhouse gases emissions
performance standard established under section 6 of this act.
(3) In confirming that a long-term financial commitment is for
baseload electric generation, the governing board shall consider: (a)
The design of the power plant and the intended use of the power plant
based upon the electricity purchase contract, if any; (b) permits
necessary for the operation of the power plant; and (c) any other
matter the governing board determines is relevant under the
circumstances.
(4) The governing board may provide a case-by-case exemption from
the greenhouse gases emissions performance standard to address: (a)
Unanticipated electric system reliability needs; or (b) catastrophic
events or threat of significant financial harm that may arise from
unforeseen circumstances.
(5) The governing board shall adopt procedures to verify net
emissions of greenhouse gases from baseload electric generation under
section 6 of this act, and may request assistance from the department
in doing so.
(6) For consumer-owned utilities, the auditor is responsible for
auditing compliance under this chapter and rules adopted under this
chapter that apply to those utilities and the attorney general is
responsible for enforcing that compliance.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 11 For the purposes of sections 6, 7, 9, and
10 of this act and RCW 80.70.020, the department, in consultation with
the commission and the governing boards of consumer-owned utilities,
shall review the greenhouse gases emission performance standard
established in this chapter to determine need, applicability, and
effectiveness no less than every five years following the effective
date of this section, or upon implementation of a federal or state law
or rule regulating carbon dioxide emissions of electrical utilities,
and report to the legislature.
NEW SECTION. Sec. 12 Sections 1 through 7 and 9 through 11 of
this act constitute a new chapter in Title
Correct the title.