"Stealthing" generally refers to the intentional removal or destruction of a condom or another sexually protective device during sexual intercourse by one partner without the other partner's consent. Stealthing may result in unintended pregnancy and the transmission of sexually transmitted infections.
Stealthing is not explicitly prohibited under state law. Depending on the specific circumstances, the underlying conduct may qualify as a criminal offense or an actionable civil tort.
At least two states, California and Maine, have recently enacted legislation authorizing civil remedies for nonconsensual removal of or tampering with a condom, and several other states, including Iowa, New York, and Texas, have recently introduced legislation explicitly prohibiting stealthing and providing for civil and criminal penalties.
A person who engaged in sexual contact or sexual penetration with another person may bring a civil action against that other person if the other person engaged in sexual contact or penetration after:
A person who engaged in sexual contact or sexual penetration with another person may also bring a civil action against that other person if the other person:
Evidence that the plaintiff consented to previous sexual contact or penetration without a sexually protective device does not by itself establish consent to any subsequent sexual contact or penetration without a sexually protective device.
Subject to applicable state law and procedural rules, a plaintiff may use a pseudonym in place of the plaintiff's true name in an action for nonconsensual removal of or tampering with a sexually protective device or for misleading another person regarding the use of a sexually protective device.
A prevailing plaintiff may recover compensatory and punitive damages, statutory damages of $5,000 per violation, injunctive relief, and any other relief the court deems appropriate. In determining punitive damages, the court may take into consideration any previous findings of liability against the defendant for nonconsensual removal of, tampering with, or misleading about the use of a sexually protective device. The court must award costs and reasonable attorneys' fees to a prevailing plaintiff.
PRO: Nonconsensual condom removal, also known as stealthing, is a violation of trust and personal autonomy. Stealthing is a serious issue of sexual and reproductive violence, coercion, and intimate partner violence. Stealthing can result in STIs, unwanted pregnancies, and serious mental and physical harm. There are very few practical resources or legal remedies for people in Washington who are victims of stealthing. This legislation will create civil remedies for victims, make clear to perpetrators that their actions will not be tolerated and that there are consequences to their actions, and ensure that victims have a path to justice when a victim's consent is violated.
PRO: Natalie Beetham; Mina Hashemi; Emma Schwartz, The Adjacent Project; Georgilee Flynn; Jennifer Friedman; Elizabeth Hendren, Sexual Violence Law Center; Skylar Johnson, Planned Parenthood Generation Action UW Chapter.