H-2A Temporary Agricultural Worker Visa Program. The federal H-2A Program allows agricultural employers to hire foreign workers on temporary guest worker visas when there are insufficient qualified domestic farmworkers available and the use of H-2A workers would not have a negative effect on the wages or working conditions of domestic farmworkers. Although the United States Department of Labor (US DOL) establishes the rules for the federal program, the Employment Security Department (ESD) is charged with administering certain aspects of the program.
Employers seeking to use the H-2A Program must first submit a job order to the ESD. The job order includes the number of workers requested and other information, such as the wages the employer will pay. ESD confirms that the job order meets federal requirements and notifies US DOL. ESD also engages in recruitment efforts to find domestic farmworkers, using the state's WorkSource offices. ESD refers domestic applicants to the employer, and the employer is required to hire all qualified, able, willing, and available domestic farmworkers. Employers also engage in direct recruitment of domestic farmworkers as well.
The employer then submits an application to the US DOL for certification to use temporary guest workers. The application may be submitted by a single employer or a group of employers that will jointly employ the workers. US DOL must determine that there are not enough domestic farmworkers to fill the employer's positions. US DOL then certifies the employment of H-2A workers. Employers using H-2A workers must pay specified rates of pay, provide the workers housing and transportation, and meet other requirements. US DOL establishes what the prevailing wage rate for H-2A workers should be. ESD conducts wage surveys of employers and some farmworkers, subject to federal H-2A regulations. Participation in the surveys are voluntary.
ESD also conducts field visits, which are scheduled in advance, to help employers and H-2A farmworkers understand their rights and responsibilities and to observe working and living conditions. ESD also conducts field checks, which are random and unannounced, to ensure compliance with H-2A requirements.
Office of Agricultural and Seasonal Workforce Services. The Office of Agricultural and Seasonal Workforce Services (ASWS) was created within ESD to, among other things, process and adjudicate foreign labor certification applications from employers, conduct field checks and field visits and conduct training and outreach activities to employers using the H-2A program. ESD Commissioner appointed an advisory committee (Advisory Committee) within ASWS to review issues related to the H-2A program. The Advisory Committee consists of members representing agricultural workers and employers.
Data on H-2A Workers. Whenever the ESD conducts field checks or field visits of an employer, the ESD must collect:
ESD must compile the information and compare the number of workers sought by an employer on the employer's H-2A application with the number of H-2A workers actually working for the employer. ASWS must make the information available to the Advisory Committee on a quarterly basis.
Surveys of Hand Harvesters. ASWS must conduct a comprehensive annual wage survey of workers hand harvesting apples, cherries, pears, and blueberries. At a minimum, the survey must:
ASWS must use a phone survey designed to receive responses from a minimum of 850 total fruit harvesters. Beginning fiscal year 2024, the ASWS Office must include field surveys designed to receive responses from a minimum of:
Beginning fiscal year 2025, ASWS must include a field survey of cherry harvesters designed to receive responses from a minimum of 350 cherry harvesters.
ASWS must provide $25 incentive payments for survey respondents eligible to respond to the survey.
ASWS must submit a report to the appropriate committees of the Legislature every year by May 1st. The report must include information about the number of responses and individual responses, without names, by age, gender, United States birth or number of years in the United States; and whether the respondent filed an unemployment insurance claim.
PRO: We are looking for ways to minimize the hurdles to gather the information needed related to H-2A workers. When the program was established, Congress was worried that it would bring down wages. The surveys were supposed to provide a prevailing wage but the recent results are not doing their job. ESD only takes employer information. ESD uses phone surveys and it is too small a survey. Workers are not listened to when they complain. We want ESD to talk to us and not get the information through technology and phone calls.
The ASWS relies on an advisory committee, who need accurate information to advise ASWS. The fiscal note is modest in comparison to the agriculture revenue.
CON: Section 1 is not necessary; the information is available publicly already. Section 2 is not needed; ESD already does surveys. ASWS does field checks that collect data already and they are allowed to collect information. This raises the question of why and at what cost. The data collected cannot be used under US DOL rules. If changes need to be made, this should be discussed at an ASWS meeting. The problem should be addressed at ESD and not overburden ASWS.
OTHER: We would like some technical change. The requirements of ASWS should be with the Labor and Markets staff. We would like to extend the start date and have a severability clause.