HOUSE BILL REPORT
ESHB 1296
As Amended by the Senate
Title: An act relating to promoting a safe and supportive public education system through student rights, parental and guardian rights, employee protections, and requirements for state and local education entities.
Brief Description: Promoting a safe and supportive public education system.
Sponsors: House Committee on Education (originally sponsored by Representatives Stonier, Macri, Lekanoff, Doglio, Berry, Salahuddin, Davis, Ramel, Obras, Reed, Ormsby, Scott, Nance, Bergquist, Fitzgibbon, Parshley, Alvarado, Kloba, Pollet, Peterson, Fey, Simmons, Hill and Fosse).
Brief History:
Committee Activity:
Education: 1/23/25, 1/30/25 [DPS].
Floor Activity:
Passed House: 3/12/25, 56-37.
Senate Amended.
Passed Senate: 4/11/25, 30-19.
Brief Summary of Engrossed Substitute Bill
  • Requires policies and procedures of school districts, charter schools, and state-tribal education compact schools (STECs) to prioritize the protection of every student's safety, access to a free public education, and privacy.
  • Makes changes to delineated rights of parents and legal guardians of public school children.
  • Establishes a statement of student rights and associated duties for school districts, charter schools, and STECs.
  • Establishes antiretaliation protections for public school employees supporting students in the exercise of their legal rights and performing work in accordance with certain requirements.
HOUSE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Majority Report: The substitute bill be substituted therefor and the substitute bill do pass.Signed by 10 members:Representatives Santos, Chair; Shavers, Vice Chair; Bergquist, Callan, Donaghy, Ortiz-Self, Pollet, Reeves, Scott and Stonier.
Minority Report: Do not pass.Signed by 8 members:Representatives Rude, Ranking Minority Member; Keaton, Assistant Ranking Minority Member; Chase, Couture, Eslick, Marshall, McEntire and Steele.
Staff: Ethan Moreno (786-7386).
Background:

Declaration of Parental and Guardian Rights.
Legislation enacted in 2024 (Initiative Measure No. 2081) declared parents and guardians of public school children younger than 18 years old to have 15 specified rights.  The delineated rights related to:  receiving or being notified of academic, medical, safety, and law enforcement matters; accessing and inspecting certain materials and records; and opting their children out of certain activities.

 

Transgender Student Policy and Procedure Requirements.

The Washington State School Directors' Association is required to collaborate with the Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction (OSPI) to develop and update a model transgender student policy and procedure.  The model policy and procedure must, at a minimum:

  • incorporate the OSPI's rules and guidelines to eliminate discrimination in public schools on the basis of gender identity and expression;
  • address the unique challenges and needs faced by transgender students in public schools; and
  • describe the application of the model policy and procedure prohibiting harassment, intimidation, and bullying to transgender students.

 

Each school district and charter school must adopt or amend policies and procedures that incorporate all the elements of the model transgender student policy and procedure.  School districts and charter schools also must designate a primary contact regarding these policies and procedures who must, among other things, receive copies of related complaints.

 

Student Records:  Nondisclosure in Certain Child Abuse and Neglect Investigations.

Notwithstanding anything to the contrary, unless the parent has obtained a court order, a public school may not be required to release any records or information regarding a student's medical or health records or mental health counseling to a parent during the pendency of an investigation of child abuse or neglect.  This nonrelease requirement applies if the investigation is of the parent and is being conducted by a law enforcement agency or the Department of Children, Youth, and Families.

 

Alleged Sexual Misconduct by School Employee:  Notification Requirements.
School districts must, at the first opportunity but in all cases within 48 hours of receiving a report alleging sexual misconduct by a school employee, notify the parents of a student alleged to be the victim, target, or recipient of the misconduct.  School districts must also provide parents with information regarding their rights under Washington's Public Records Act to request the public records regarding school employee discipline.

 

Physical Abuse or Sexual Misconduct by School Employees:  Reporting Requirements.
School employees who have knowledge or reasonable cause to believe that a student has been a victim of physical abuse or sexual misconduct by another school employee, must report the abuse or misconduct to the appropriate school administrator.  The school administrator, as required by statutory provisions governing mandatory reporting obligations, must cause a report to be made to the proper law enforcement agency if the administrator has reasonable cause to believe that the misconduct or abuse has occurred.

 

Professional school personnel are also required to report all suspected child abuse and neglect, which includes sexual abuse and assault, to law enforcement or the Department of Children, Youth, and Families.

 

Public School Employees:  Employment Protections.
The Washington Law Against Discrimination (WLAD) prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation in places of public accommodation, including public schools.  Under the WLAD, it is unlawful for any employer to discharge, expel, or otherwise discriminate against any person because the person has opposed any practice forbidden by the WLAD.

 

The Washington Supreme Court recognizes the common law tort of wrongful termination in violation of public policy.  As a result, it is unlawful to terminate an employee for refusing to commit an unlawful act, for performing a public duty, for exercising a legal right or privilege, or in retaliation for reporting employer misconduct.  

 

Additionally, most public school employees in Washington are subject to collective bargaining agreements.  Collective bargaining agreements typically limit school districts to “just cause” termination and discipline, and afford covered employees with certain rights and protections.

 

Private Right of Action.
A private right of action is the right of a person to bring a civil legal claim in court to obtain a remedy for a specific harm to that person.  Private rights of action can be created and recognized by the courts or through legislation.  Examples of statutory private rights of action include the right to obtain legal relief for violations of the Washington Consumer Protection Act and Washington Law Against Discrimination.

Summary of Engrossed Substitute Bill:

I.  State Policy:  Prioritizing the Protection of Students' Safety, Access to Public Education, and Privacy.

Policies and procedures adopted by school districts, charter schools, and state-tribal education compact schools (STECs) must prioritize the protection of every student's safety, access to a free public education, and privacy to the fullest extent possible, except as required by state or federal law.  This policy is supplemental to existing and future policies and procedures and must be considered an integral part of those policies and procedures. 

 

The Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction (OSPI) must develop technical assistance and related materials, adopt rules, and enforce and obtain compliance with the policy, subject to specified notification requirements.  Examples of sanctions the OSPI may issue include:

  • terminating or withholding all or part of state apportionment or categorical moneys to the offending school district, charter school, or STEC;
  • terminating specified programs in which violations may be flagrant within the offending school district, charter school, or STEC; and
  • placing the offending school district, charter school, or STEC on probation with appropriate sanctions until compliance is achieved.

 

II.  Parental and Guardian Rights:  Modifications and No Private Right of Action.

Additions, modifications, and deletions are made to the list of declared rights for parents or legal guardians of children enrolled in public schools.  These rights do not create a private right of action.

 

Additional Rights.  Examples of additionally declared rights include the right to:

  • have their child receive a public education in a setting in which discrimination on the basis of protected class is prohibited;
  • file a complaint on behalf of their child relating to harassment, intimidation, and bullying;
  • have their child qualify for enrollment in a school district if they are transferred to, or pending transfer to, a military installation within the state in accordance with specified requirements;
  • have their child qualify without a legal residence for enrollment in a school district;
  • request enrollment for their child in a charter school;
  • receive annual notice of the public school's language access policies and services, the parents' rights to free language access services under federal law, and the contact information for any language access services; and
  • request information about special education programs and assistance for their child if their child is eligible for, but not receiving, special education services, including due to illness.

 

Modified Rights.  Examples of modified rights include the right to:

  • access their child's classroom and school sponsored activities to observe class procedure, teaching materials, and class conduct, and to examine curriculum, textbooks, instructional materials, and supplemental instructional materials in accordance with policies and procedures (rather than examining textbooks, curriculum, and supplemental materials used in their child's classroom);
  • inspect and review the education records of their child within a reasonable period of time, but not more than 45 days of submitting a request under the federal Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act as in effect on January 1, 2025, and as provided in requirements governing student education records (rather than to inspect their child's public school records and receive a copy within 10 days); 
  • not have their child removed from school grounds or buildings during school hours without authorization of a parent or legal guardian and according to statutory provisions governing permitted school campus removals (rather than receive immediate notification if their child is taken or removed from the public school campus without parental permission, including to stay at a youth shelter or host home);
  • receive immediate notification that a criminal action has been committed against their child on school property during the school day, including immediate notification if there has been a shooting or a threat of a shooting on school property, or that their child has been detained based on probable cause of involvement in a criminal activity on school property during the school day (rather than receiving immediate notification if a criminal action is deemed to have been committed against or by their child);
  • receive immediate notification if a criminal action is alleged to have been committed against their child, including immediate notification if their child is alleged to be the victim, target, or recipient of an allegation of sexual misconduct by a school employee (rather than receiving immediate notification if a criminal action is deemed to have been committed against or by their child);
  • receive immediate notification that their child is the alleged victim, target, or recipient of physical abuse, sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, or assault occurring on school property during the school day by another student, a school employee or contractor, or any other individual (rather than receiving immediate notification if a criminal action is deemed to have been committed against or by their child); and
  • in accordance with the federal Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment (PPRA), receive written notice and opt their child out of any survey, analysis, or evaluation that reveals information concerning certain personal or family information (rather than to receive written notice and the option to opt their child out of any surveys, assignments, questionnaires, role-playing activities, recordings of their child, or other student engagements that include questions about specified personal or family information, and surveys, analyses, and evaluations subject to areas covered by the PPRA).

 

"Education records" is defined as those official records, files, and data directly related to a student and maintained by the public school including, but not limited to, records encompassing all the material kept in the child's cumulative folder, such as general identifying data, records of attendance and of academic work completed, records of achievement and results of evaluative tests, disciplinary status, test protocols, and individualized education programs (rather than any student-specific files, documents, or other materials that are maintained by the public school).  "Education records" do not include records that are kept in the sole possession of the maker, are used only as a personal memory aid, and are not accessible or revealed to any other person except a temporary substitute for the maker of the record.

 

Eliminated Rights.  Examples of eliminated rights include the right to:

  • receive prior notification when medical services are being offered to their child, except where emergency medical treatment is required;
  • receive notification when any medical service or medications have been provided to their child that could result in any financial impact to the parent's or legal guardian's health insurance payments or copays; and
  • receive notification when the school has arranged directly or indirectly for medical treatment that results in follow-up care beyond normal school hours.

 

Nothing in the list of declared rights for parents and legal guardians changes access and disclosure provisions established in specified state laws related to health care information, or affects specified provisions in state law related to host homes, youth shelters, and children being taken into custody in relation to abuse or neglect allegations.

 

III.  Student Records:  Nondisclosure in Certain Child Abuse, Neglect, and Criminal Investigations.

School student record disclosure limitations for parents that are related to certain child abuse and neglect investigations of law enforcement or the Department of Children, Youth, and Families are extended to health care, social work, counseling, and disciplinary records (rather than records and information regarding medical or health records or mental health counseling).  The disclosure limitations are also extended to apply in criminal proceedings of parents and legal guardians where the student is the named victim.

 

IV.  Statement of Student Rights.
The Statement of Student Rights (Statement) is established for public school students.  The Statement provides 24 examples of student rights derived from the federal and state constitutions, and federal and state statutes.  Examples of the privileges and protections specified include:

  • the free exercise of religion;
  • the freedom of speech;
  • the right of students with disabilities to receive special education and related services that address their individual needs;
  • the right of students with disabilities to be free from discrimination with regard to accessing education programs and facilities;
  • the right to access, without tuition, a school district's kindergarten through twelfth grade basic education program for students of qualifying age; and
  • the right to access a learning environment with historically and scientifically accurate information.

 
Each school district, charter school, and STEC must develop student-focused materials that incorporate the Statement, share them via websites and other communication channels, and include them in a required civics course.
 

V.  Requirements Related to Transgender Students and Gender-Expansive Students.

By January 31, 2026, school districts and charter schools must adopt or amend policies and procedures related to transgender students to address the unique challenges faced by gender-expansive students and describe the application of the model policy and procedure prohibiting harassment, intimidation, and bullying to gender-expansive students. 

 

Online training materials of the OSPI based on a model policy and procedure of the Washington State School Directors' Association must be periodically revised by the OSPI and available to all school staff.  Additionally, the OSPI must adopt rules by December 31, 2025, to ensure compliance with requirements related to gender inclusive schools.

 

VI.  Alleged Sexual Misconduct by School Employees:  Notification Requirements.
School districts must immediately notify the parents or legal guardians of a student alleged to be the victim, target, or recipient of an allegation of sexual misconduct by a school employee, rather than at the first opportunity but in all cases within 48 hours of receiving such a report.  Additionally, requirements of school districts to notify parents about their public records rights regarding school employee discipline records are explicitly made applicable to legal guardians.

 

Notification requirements regarding alleged sexual misconduct by school employees are further modified to require school districts, charter schools, and state-tribal education compact schools to immediately notify the parents or legal guardians of a student if an employee or contractor of the school district, charter school, or state-tribal education compact school has knowledge or reasonable cause to believe that a student has been a victim, target, or recipient of physical abuse, sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, or assault occurring on school property during the school day.

 

VII.  Abuse, Sexual Misconduct, or Assault by School Employees or Contractors:  Reporting Requirements.
School employees or contractors who have knowledge or reasonable cause to believe that a student has been a victim of physical or sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, or assault by another school employee or contractor, must report the abuse, misconduct, or assault to the appropriate school administrator.  The school administrator, in accordance with statutory provisions governing mandator reporting obligations, must cause a report to be made to the proper law enforcement agency if the administrator has reasonable cause to believe that the abuse, misconduct, or assault has occurred.

 

VIII.  Public School Employees:  Antiretaliation Protections.

Employees and directors of school districts, charter schools, and STECs may not take an adverse employment action against an employee for supporting students in the exercise of their legal rights, including their right to a learning environment with historically and scientifically accurate information, or performing work in a manner consistent with the bill's provisions.

 

In addition, employees and directors of school districts, charter schools, and STECs may not take an adverse employment action against a teacher for instructing students in a manner consistent with state learning standards or using approved instructional materials that are culturally and experientially representative.

EFFECT OF SENATE AMENDMENT(S):

In comparison to the engrossed substitute bill, and by category, the Senate amendments make the following changes.

 

Local Policy and Procedure Requirements and Prioritization.  Regarding local policy and procedure requirements and prioritization, the Senate amendments:

  • require policies and procedures of school districts, charter schools, and state-tribal education compact schools to prioritize the protection of every student's safety, access to an academic environment free of discrimination, access to the state's statutory program of basic education, and privacy, rather than to prioritize the protection of every student's safety, access to a free public education, and privacy;
  • remove a directive requiring the Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction (OSPI) to adopt rules to implement the policy and procedure requirements related to the protection of every student's safety, access to a free public education, and privacy;
  • remove provisions directing school districts and charter schools to adopt or amend policies and procedures relating to eliminating discrimination on the basis of gender expression and gender identity, including requirements pertaining to gender-expansive students; and
  • remove provisions directing the OSPI to adopt rules by December 31, 2025, to ensure compliance with specified nondiscrimination provisions that include obligations for school districts, charter schools, the Washington State School Directors' Association and the OSPI.

 

Statement of Student Rights.  Regarding the statement of student rights, the Senate amendments:

  • establish a modified statement of student rights that is non-exhaustive but includes nine delineated rights and various statutory cross references, with examples including:
    • the right to access an amply funded program of basic education, established pursuant to Article IX of the Washington Constitution, that provides an opportunity to develop the knowledge and skills necessary to meet state-established graduation requirements, which are intended to provide students with the opportunity to graduate with a meaningful diploma that prepares them for postsecondary education, gainful employment, and citizenship as established in state law, rather than the right to a basic education that provides students with opportunities to develop the knowledge and skills necessary to meet state-established graduation requirements, which are intended to provide students with the opportunity to graduate with a meaningful diploma that prepares them for postsecondary education, gainful employment, and citizenship; and
    • the right to exercise constitutionally protected freedoms as established in the United States and Washington Constitutions and as further interpreted in applicable case law including, but not limited to, the freedoms of speech, assembly, and exercise of religion, rather than specifying that public school students are beneficiaries of the Declaration of Independence and the United States Constitution and the associated privileges and protections, including the free exercise of religion, the freedom of speech, and the right to peaceably assemble;
  • specify that the statement of student rights does not create a private right of action; and
  • add the statement of student rights and associated materials to the list of contents that must be included in mandatory, one-half credit stand-alone high school civics courses.

 

Delineated Rights of Parents and Legal Guardians and Certain Notification Requirements.  Regarding certain notification requirements, the Senate amendments:

  • modify the delineated list of parent and guardian rights to receive immediate notification:
    • upon receipt of a report that a criminal action is alleged to have been committed against their child on school property during the school day or during a school sponsored activity, rather than if a criminal action is alleged to have been committed against their child on school property during the school day, during a school sponsored activity, or by a school employee, contractor, or volunteer; and
    • upon receipt of a report that their child is alleged to be the victim, target, or recipient of physical or sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, or assault by a school employee or school contractor as required by state law, rather than notification if a criminal action is alleged to have been committed against their child, including immediate notification if their child is alleged to be the victim, target, or recipient of an allegation of sexual misconduct by a school employee as required by state law;
  • modify provisions related alleged misconduct of school employees to provide that the school district must immediately notify the parents or guardians of a student after receiving a report of an allegation that a student is a victim, target, or recipient of physical or sexual abuse, sexual misconduct, or assault by a school employee or school contractor; and
  • modify reporting requirements related to physical abuse or sexual misconduct against a student by school employees to:
    • apply also to sexual abuse and assault and actions by contractors; and
    • require immediate notification to parents and guardians.

 

Complaint Process to Address Willful Noncompliance with Certain Education Laws.  Regarding the complaint process to address willful noncompliance with certain education laws, the Senate amendments:

  • establish a complaint process allowing students, parents, guardians, and school district residents to file complaints with the OSPI alleging willful noncompliance by school district superintendents, boards of directors, or individual directors with state laws concerning civil rights, harassment, intimidation, bullying, certain curriculum and instructional materials requirements, use of student restraint and isolation, or student discipline;
  • direct the OSPI to develop a process to investigate and secure equitable resolutions for qualifying complaints and includes consultation, rulemaking, and other requirements for the OSPI;
  • require the OSPI to provide notice to school districts that are noncompliant with the specified state laws and to identify corrective actions;
  • require school districts to adopt compliance action plans (for approval by the OSPI) and satisfy related public meeting requirements if the OSPI finds noncompliance with the specified state laws;
  • permit the OSPI to impose certain consequences, including withholding and redirecting certain basic education funds, for willful noncompliance with the specified state laws;
  • include a process for administrative appeals of noncompliance complaints;
  • amend the Office of the Education Ombud's complaint receipt process and the charter schools' complaint process to also apply to the OSPI's new complaint process;
  • require the OSPI's model student handbook to include information about the OSPI's new complaint process;
  • make the OSPI's new complaint process generally applicable to charter schools and state-tribal education compact schools;
  • direct the Professional Educator Standards Board to adopt rules making a school district superintendent's willful noncompliance with state law an act of unprofessional conduct;
  • amend the school directors' oath to include support for the laws of Washington; and
  • specify that willful or negligent noncompliance with state law constitutes a violation of the oath of office and that school directors may be subject to recall and discharge.

 

Modifications to Protected Classes.  Regarding the modification to protected classes, the Senate amendments:

  • add the following protected classes to the nondiscrimination provisions that apply to public schools:  ethnicity, homelessness, immigration or citizenship status, and neurodivergence;
  • separate sexual orientation, gender expression, and gender identity into three separate protected classes; and
  • provide new or modified definitions for these protected classes that apply to public schools.

 

Emergency Clause.  The Senate amendments exclude provisions related to the model student handbook from the emergency clause.

Appropriation: None.
Fiscal Note: Available.  New fiscal note requested on April 14, 2025.
Effective Date: The bill contains an emergency clause and takes effect immediately.
Staff Summary of Public Testimony:

(In support) For years, we have heard statistics about the challenges that students have when their basic needs are not met.  This bill is centered on promoting a safe and supportive learning environment.  This bill establishes rights and supports for students and the trusted adults who support them.  The success of students is a responsibility for all of us.

 

This bill is vitally important.  Some students share information at school that could be detrimental if shared in a nonsupportive household.  Education is important and educators should not be required to "out" students.  In some cases, school is the only safe place that students have.

 

The novel 1984 warned us about limiting our ability to define ourselves, but that is happening now.  The protections for educators in the bill are important, as they are being targeted.  Those protections should be strengthened.

 

We have asked students to come to school as their full selves.  Most people want kids to have the freedom to learn and be themselves.  Some people have exploited the confusion resulting from Initiative 2081, but this bill aligns the initiative with current law.

 

(Opposed) Parents are the first teachers and overseers of their children.  Parental support is essential to student success.  This bill undermines trust that was rebuilt after the pandemic through Initiative 2081.  This bill should be rejected to preserve vital parent/student trust.

 

This bill overrides parents and is contrary to new federal regulations.  Passing this bill may jeopardize federal funding.

 

Thousands of people volunteered time and effort to pass Initiative 2081.  Amending the initiative after it was passed is taking a sledgehammer to democracy.  This bill violates natural law.

 

(Other) LGBTQIA persons have higher rates of suicide, and the rates are higher still among transgender students.  Students who feel safe and supported at school have better education outcomes.  Inclusive policies are about creating a sense of belonging.

 

There are concerns about the process requirements and penalty authorizations in the bill for the OSPI.  This bill runs the risk of inadvertently impacting schools based on the actions of school district decision-makers.  Placing the OSPI in an adversarial position with schools is not good policy.

Persons Testifying:

(In support) Representative Monica Jurado Stonier, prime sponsor; Samantha Fogg, Seattle Council PTSA Co-President; Tracy Dr. Castro-Gill, Washington Ethnic Studies Now; Howl Hall; Albert Johnson; Courtney Normand, Planned Parenthood Alliance Advocates; and Brier Moreno.

(Opposed) Ronda Litzenberger, Eatonville School Board; Dawn Land, Reject 5599; and Sarah Garriott.
(Other) Jill Oldson, Washington State School Directors' Association; and Lisa Keating, Executive Director, Washington State LGBTQ Commission.
Persons Signed In To Testify But Not Testifying:

More than 20 persons signed in. Please see committee staff for information.