Determines that certain types of distributed energy projects and activities are distributed energy priorities.
Provides statutory exemptions from the State Environmental Policy Act for solar energy generation in certain locations.
Specifies the addition of an agrivoltaic facility to land classified as farm and agricultural open space land does not constitute a reclassification, withdrawal, or removal from open space classification and is not subject to additional tax.
State Environmental Policy Act. The State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA) establishes a review process for state and local governments to identify environmental impacts that may result from governmental decisions, such as the issuance of permits or the adoption of land use plans. The SEPA environmental review process involves a project proponent or the lead agency completing an environmental checklist to identify and evaluate probable environmental impacts.
If an initial review of the checklist and supporting documents results in a determination that the government decision has a probable significant adverse environmental impact, known as a threshold determination, the proposal must undergo a more comprehensive environmental analysis in the form of an environmental impact statement. If the SEPA review process identifies significant adverse environmental impacts, the lead agency may deny a government decision or may require mitigation for identified environmental impacts.
SEPA laws and SEPA rules, adopted by the Department of Ecology, provide categorical exemptions to remove certain proposals or agency actions from review.
Open Space and Land Use Taxation Act. All property is subject to a property tax each year based on the property's highest and best use, unless a specific exemption is provided by law. The Washington Constitution authorizes agricultural, timber, and open space lands to be valued on the basis of their current use rather than fair market value. Two programs of current use valuation have been established: one program for forest lands, and a second program that includes open space lands, farm and agricultural lands, and timber lands (Open Space Program).
To qualify for the Open Space Program, farm and agricultural lands must be 20 or more acres and devoted primarily to commercial agricultural purposes or enrolled in the federal Conservation Reserve Program. Parcels of land less than 20 acres devoted primarily to agriculture may qualify for the Current Use Valuation Program if certain income tests are met. Farm and agricultural land also includes certain incidental uses compatible with agricultural purposes, including wetland preservation, provided such use does not exceed 20 percent of the classified land.
If the property no longer satisfies the criteria for classification, the county assessor notifies the owner in writing that the property will be removed from the Open Space Program. When the property is removed from its current use classification, back taxes plus interest must be paid, plus an additional 20 percent penalty.
Energy Independence Act. Approved by voters in 2006, the Energy Independence Act (EIA), also known as Initiative 937, requires electric utilities with 25,000 or more customers to meet targets for energy conservation and using eligible renewable resources. Utilities that must comply with the EIA are called qualifying utilities. Currently, 18 utilities are qualifying utilities.
Each qualifying electric utility must pursue all available conservation that is cost effective, reliable, and feasible. Cost-effectiveness is determined by using methodologies consistent with those developed by the Pacific Northwest Electric Power and Conservation Planning Council.
Each qualifying utility must use eligible renewable resources, or acquire equivalent renewable energy credits, or a combination of both, to meet the following annual targets:
A utility is not required to meet a renewable energy target if it spends at least 4 percent of its retail revenue requirement on the incremental cost of renewable energy and renewable energy credits. The cost cap for a utility that has no load growth is 1 percent.
Distributed Energy Priorities. Categories of clean energy facilities and nonproject activities are determined to be distributed energy priorities (DEPs), including:
Agrivoltaics facilities must meet certain criteria in order to qualify as a DEP, including that the facility is a ground-mounted photovoltaic solar energy system that must:
State Environmental Policy Act. The following actions are categorically exempt from SEPA, except when undertaken wholly or partly on lands covered by water:
Open Space and Land Use Taxation Act. Land on which an agrivoltaics facility is located may be considered agricultural or open space land for purposes of the Open Space and Land Use Taxation Act. The addition of an agrivoltaics facility does not constitute a reclassification, withdrawal, or removal of lands under the Open Space and Land Use Taxation Act, and thus does not require the payment of seven years of back taxes plus interest and a 20 percent penalty.
Energy Independent Act. A qualifying utility may use any combination of eligible renewable resources and DEP projects to be in compliance with EIA renewable energy targets.
A DEP project is any combination of projects in the utility’s service territory that include accelerated conservation, demand response, distributed energy storage, distributed soler energy generation, and distributed wind energy generation.
Accelerated conservation is defined as conservation included in a qualifying utility's most recent cost-effective conservation potential under the EIA and in excess of the biennial acquisition target under the EIA. The definition incudes a formula for measuring the annual energy savings and that any accelerated conservation savings may not be included as excess conservation savings under the EIA. Demand response is defined as changes in electric usage by demand-side resources from their normal consumption patterns in response to changes in the price of electricity, or to incentive payments designed to induce lower electricity use, at times of high wholesale market prices or when system reliability is jeopardized. A formula is provided for converting demand response to a megawatt-hour for the purpose of quantifying the amount of eligible demand response.
The committee recommended a different version of the bill than what was heard. PRO: This is an opportunity to look at these pragmatic solutions where we face the increase in electricity demand from data centers, manufacturing, and electrification on our transportation systems. We can incentivize projects in local areas with utility funds to build out renewable generation, conservation, and also resilience on the grid. Originally the renewable portfolio standard was created to provide incentives to invest in new projects. Many utilities purchase renewable energy credits to meet their CETA and EIA requirements, and often these credits are purchased from out of state projects that are already on the grid. We'd like to keep the funds for in-state project that benefit our gird and local economy. We'd like to include hydrogen storage. We are facing rapidly increasing electricity demand and utilities need to be able to make some critical investments in their local distribution systems and new carbon-free resources, demand response, and conservation. Utilities are still spending about 2 percent of their revenue requirement to comply with the renewable requirement under the EIA. This bill provides an alternative compliance option that allows utilities to shift some investment to fund local clean energy projects and grid resiliency. The approach strengthens our local utility distribution system and keeps investments within our communities with direct clean energy related projects.
CON: I-937 encourages the investment in both clean energy as well as conservation. The intent was for all utilities with more than 25,000 customers to invest in the clean energy transition with nonhydro renewables, which remains an important goal today as utilities are making unprecedented investments to meet load growth and replace retiring coal. The bill would allow utilities to forego purchasing nonhydro renewables if they spend money instead on resilience projects, which are investments the utilities must pursue anyway. We might be willing to support broad reforms to I-937 if those reforms committed utilities to doing more on conservation. It is sensible that utilities need to decarbonize; however, utilities and hence rate payers are being burdened by the impacts of tech and data center development on regional resources. Legislation must not name utilities as responsible for bearing the brunt of this development. The bill unfortunately changes the cost effective standard that's established in the EIA and would have a direct negative impact for ratepayers because by definition, you would be investing in projects that are no longer cost-effective resources. Additionally, smaller local resources are likely to be more expensive than utility scale resources without geographic considerations.
OTHER: We are concerned about how we would implement the bill given some of the vague terms and provisions in the bill. We are not sure how to measure investment levels provided in the bill, or whether existing projects would count or if the list of eligible projects actually further the resilience of the grid. Some may be valid as local projects, even if they are more expensive than the other renewable resources that the utilities might pursue.
PRO: Senator Matt Boehnke, Prime Sponsor; Dave Warren, WA Green Hydrogen Alliance; Liz Anderson, Washington Public Utility Districts Association; Samantha Louderback, Washington Rural Electric Cooperative Association; Sheila Corson, Mason PUD #3.