According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, an assignment of benefits (AOB) is an agreement signed by a policyholder that allows a third party, such as a repair company, to act on behalf of the insured and seek payment from the insurer. An AOB allows the third party to deal directly with the insurer in negotiating repairs and issuing payment directly to the third party without the policyholder's involvement. An AOB also assigns the policyholder's rights and benefits in resolving a claim to the third party, including the right to sue after a denial and mediate the claim.
Current state law does not specifically address the assignment of benefits under property insurance policies.
The bill prohibits a person from soliciting, coercing, requiring, or contracting with any insured to enter into an assignment agreement, in whole or in part, whereby any post-loss insurance benefit under any property insurance coverage is assigned or transferred from the insured to the person. Such assignment agreement is void and unenforceable.
This restriction does not apply to any of the following:
The restriction also does not prohibit an insured from authorizing or directing payment to, or paying, a person for services, materials, or any other thing which may be, or is, covered under an insurance policy.
If the Office of the Insurance Commissioner (OIC) has cause to believe that any person has violated the restriction, the OIC may issue a cease-and-desist order, bring an action for injunctive relief, and impose a fine of $50,000 per violation. Any fine collected by the OIC for such violation must be paid to the state treasurer for the account of the general fund.
The following terms are defined:
PRO: My district was affected by the bomb cyclone last year, increased wildfire risk, and flooding from the recent atmospheric river. The bill addresses damage from fire or major water events. Under current law, a contractor that comes in to provide repair services can have a part of the contract that would assign the insurance benefits over to the contractor. This can happen at a moment when the homeowner is in a very vulnerable position and may not be in a time when they are reading the repair company's legal contract line-by-line. This can block the homeowner from participating in the implementation of the insurance claim. This bill protects the consumer from potential financial disaster. There was a consumer who had a water loss and signed an assignment agreement. The insurance company asked for photos but the contractor did not provide them, leading to a denial of the claim. The OIC got involved but ultimately the contractor stopped communicating with the OIC.
The OIC finds aggressive vendors can pressure consumers to sign documents before contacting their insurance company, misrepresent facts, or perform unauthorized work. Contractors have expertise in repair procedures and how to efficiently do the work, but they are not licensed to discuss how insurance coverage works or how the loss settlement procedures in a policy guide the claim. That is the role of licensed public adjusters and attorneys. An assignment of benefits (AOB) transfers key rights to the contractor and are often presented as a convenience. Multiple Gulf states have seen rampant AOB misuse and have prohibited AOBs. We are starting to see similar patterns in Washington, particularly with water damage claims, and are trying to get ahead of the problem. We understand that the Washington State Association for Justice has some clarifying changes on the intent section relating to covenant judgments and we'll work with them on it.
The Washington State Association for Justice supports the bill. I've seen repair contractors ask customers to assign their property insurance rights and it cause big problems. An AOB gives the contractor extra leverage over the insurance company, but the homeowner loses their rights for other coverages such as for temporary housing or for personal property.
PEMCO Insurance supports this bill to ensure the policyholder retains their rights throughout the entire claim process and beyond. By assigning their benefits, the policyholder loses their right to pursue dispute resolution under the policy.
The National Insurance Crime Bureau supports the bill. Post-loss AOBs create misaligned incentives and removes the policyholder from the claims process.
PRO: Senator Victoria Hunt, Prime Sponsor; Joel Hanson, Washington State Association for Justice; Patty Kuderer, Office of the Insurance Commissioner; David Forte, Office of the Insurance Commissioner; Janet McDaniel, PEMCO Insurance; Marian Smith, National Insurance Crime Bureau.