WSR 14-15-017 PROPOSED RULES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE [Filed July 7, 2014, 7:48 a.m.]
Original Notice.
Preproposal statement of inquiry was filed as WSR 14-11-086.
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: Chapter 16-06 WAC, Public records.
Hearing Location(s): Natural Resources Building, 1111 Washington Street S.E., Second Floor, Conference Room 259, Olympia, WA 98504, on August 27, 2014, at 9:00 a.m.
Date of Intended Adoption: September 12, 2014.
Submit Written Comments to: Teresa Norman, Washington State Department of Agriculture, P.O. Box 42560, Olympia, WA 98504-2560, e-mail WSDARulesComments@agr.wa.gov, fax (360) 902-2092, by 5:00 p.m. August 27, 2014.
Assistance for Persons with Disabilities: Contact WSDA receptionist by August 20, 2014, TTY (800) 833-6388 or 711.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: The department is proposing to amend chapter 16-06 WAC to:
This rule making does not propose to change, and is separate from, rule making proposed in the CR-101 filed on December 23, 2013, requesting comments on WAC 16-06-210(29), which relates to the release of information for animal numbers, acreage, nutrients generated and exported, and crop yields in numeric ranges in response to a request for public records.
Reasons Supporting Proposal: These changes are necessary to clarify the charges the department will bill for reproducing paper records into electronic format in response to public records requests. These changes are also a part of the department's ongoing commitment to regulatory improvement under executive orders 06-02, 05-03, and 97-02.
Statute Being Implemented: Chapter 42.56 RCW.
Name of Proponent: Washington state department of agriculture (WSDA), governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting, Implementation and Enforcement: Pam Potwin, Olympia, (360) 902-1935.
No small business economic impact statement has been prepared under chapter 19.85 RCW. RCW 19.85.030(1) requires that WSDA prepare a small business economic impact statement (SBEIS) if proposed rules will impose more than minor costs on affected businesses or industry. The department has analyzed the economic effects of the proposed revisions and has concluded that they do not impose more than minor costs on small businesses. In most cases the proposed amendments decrease potential charges for receiving copies of public records from the department. Therefore, an SBEIS is not required.
A cost-benefit analysis is not required under RCW 34.05.328. WSDA is not a listed agency under RCW 34.05.328 (5)(a)(i).
July 7, 2014
Julie D. Morgan
Chief of Staff
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 09-03-032, filed 1/12/09, effective 2/12/09)
WAC 16-06-160 Description of department ((organization)), address and telephone number of Olympia administrative offices.
((The administrative offices of the Washington state department of agriculture are)) Headquartered in Olympia and located in the Natural Resources Building, 1111 Washington Street S.E., P.O. Box 42560, Olympia, Washington 98504-2560, the department employs personnel in every county in Washington. The department serves the people of Washington state by supporting the agricultural community and promoting consumer and environmental protection since 1913. The information telephone number is (((360) 902-1800)) 360-902-1800. The department is organized into seven ((divisions)) functional areas:
(1) Director's office;
(2) Administrative services ((division));
(3) Animal services division;
(4) Commodity inspection division;
(5) Food safety and consumer services division;
(6) Pesticide management division; and
(7) Plant protection division.
The department maintains service locations or major field offices around the state. ((Several of these offices are headed by a supervisor or chief.)) The administrative offices located in Olympia can assist persons in locating office locations around the state. The department's organization chart is available upon request from the Public Records Officer ((and the Human Resources Office)), Washington State Department of Agriculture, P.O. Box 42560, Olympia, Washington 98504-2560, phone 360-902-1935, fax 360-902-2092 and also on the agency web site. The public is encouraged to view the organization chart on the web site.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 09-03-032, filed 1/12/09, effective 2/12/09)
WAC 16-06-180 Public records officer.
(1) Any person wishing to request access to the department's public records, or seeking assistance in making a public records request, should contact the public records officer.
(2) You may contact the public records officer ((by mail)) at the Washington State Department of Agriculture, 1111 Washington Street SE, P.O. Box 42560, Olympia, Washington 98504-2560, by telephone at ((360-902-1809)) 360-902-1935, by fax at 360-902-2092, or by e-mail at: publicdisclosure@agr.wa.gov.
(3) The name of the department's current public records officer is also on file with the office of the code reviser in accordance with RCW 42.56.580 and is published in the Washington State Register.
(4) The public records officer will oversee compliance with the Public Records Act, but a designee of the public records officer may process the request or otherwise fulfill the duties of the public records officer. The public records officer will provide the fullest assistance to requestors.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 09-03-032, filed 1/12/09, effective 2/12/09)
WAC 16-06-200 Costs of disclosure.
(1) No fee will be charged for the inspection of public records.
(2) The department charges a fee of fifteen cents per page of ((copy)) photocopy when copy charges exceed ((ten)) twenty dollars for providing copies of public records. The department may also charge actual costs of mailing, including the cost of the shipping container. This charge is the amount necessary to reimburse the department for copying costs incident to the disclosure request.
(3) The department may charge the actual cost involved for the duplication of tape recordings, video tapes, photographs, slides, postage, or delivery if these costs exceed ((ten)) twenty dollars.
(4) The public records officer may waive the fee when the expenses of processing payment exceeds the costs of providing copies.
(5) Electronic records: The department ((may charge the actual costs incurred for providing recordings in electronic format, such as the cost of scanning records or the cost of providing records on a CD-ROM)) charges a fee of five cents per page of scanned copy when the costs exceed twenty dollars and the records are converted from paper to electronic format, upon request. There will be no charge for e-mailing electronic records to a requestor unless another cost applies.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 09-03-032, filed 1/12/09, effective 2/12/09)
WAC 16-06-210 Exemptions.
The Public Records Act provides that a number of types of information or records are exempt from public inspection and copying. In addition, records are exempt from disclosure if any other statute exempts or prohibits disclosure. Requestors should be aware of the following exemptions to public disclosure specific to department records. This list is not exhaustive and other exemptions may apply:
(1) Personal information in any files maintained for employees, appointees, or elected officials of any public agency to the extent that disclosure would violate their right to privacy (reference RCW 42.56.230(((2))) (3)).
(2) Investigative records (reference RCW 42.56.240).
(3) Test questions, scoring keys, and other examination data used to administer a license (reference RCW 42.56.250(1)).
(4) Records that are relevant to a controversy to which an agency is a party but which records would not be available to another party under the rules of pretrial discovery for causes pending in the superior courts (reference RCW 42.56.290).
(5) Lists of individuals requested for commercial purposes (reference RCW 42.56.070(9)).
(6) ((Social Security numbers are confidential and not subject to disclosure except when expressly required by or governed by other law (reference RCW 41.56.250; for full text, see subsection (9) of this section).)) Records related to the entry of prohibited agricultural products imported into Washington state or that had Washington state as a final destination received from the United States Department of Homeland Security or the United States Department of Agriculture that are not disclosable by the federal agency under federal law including 5 U.S.C. Sec. 552 (reference RCW 42.56.380(12).
(7) Credit card numbers, debit card numbers, electronic check numbers, card expiration dates, or bank or other financial account numbers, except when disclosure is expressly required or governed by other law (reference RCW 42.56.230(((4))) (5)).
(8) Applications for public employment, including the names of applicants, resumes, and other related materials submitted with respect to the applicant (reference RCW 42.56.250(2)).
(9) Residential addresses, residential telephone numbers, personal wireless telephone numbers, personal electronic mail addresses, Social Security numbers and emergency contact information of employees or volunteers of a public agency, and the names, dates of birth, residential addresses, residential telephone numbers, personal wireless telephone numbers, personal electronic mail addresses, Social Security numbers, and emergency contact information of dependents of employees or volunteers of a public agency that are held by any agency in personnel records, public employment related records, or volunteer rosters, or are included in any mailing list of employees or volunteers of any public agency (reference RCW 42.56.250(3)).
(10) Information provided for the semi-annual report for fertilizers, minerals and limes that would reveal the business operation of the person making the report (reference RCW 15.54.362(5) and 42.56.380(2)).
(11) The semiannual report required in the Commercial Feed Act is not a public record, and any information given in such report which would reveal the business operation of the person making the report is exempt from disclosure, and information obtained by the department from other governmental agencies or other sources that is used to verify information received in the report is exempt from public disclosure (reference RCW 15.53.9018).
(12) The department has the authority to publish reports of official seed inspections, seed certifications, laboratory statistics, verified violations of this chapter, and other seed branch activities which do not reveal confidential information regarding individual company operations or production (reference RCW 15.49.370(8)).
(13) Business related information obtained under the Organic Food Products Act concerning an entity certified under that act or an applicant for certification under RCW 15.86.110, and records whose disclosure is prohibited by the federal Organic Certification Act, 7 U.S.C. Sec. 6515(g) and the rules adopted under that act (reference RCW 42.56.380(1)).
(14) Consignment information contained on phytosanitary certificates issued by the department under chapters 15.13, 15.17, and 15.49 RCW or federal phytosanitary certificates issued under 7 C.F.R. 353 through cooperative agreements with the animal and plant health inspection service, United States Department of Agriculture, or on applications for phytosanitary certification required by the department (reference RCW 42.56.380(4)).
(15) Financial and commercial information and records supplied by businesses or individuals during application for loans or program services provided by the former chapter 15.110 RCW or chapter 43.325 RCW (the energy freedom loan program) (reference RCW 42.56.270(4)).
(16) Information obtained under RCW 15.19.080 regarding the purchases, sales, or production of an individual American ginseng grower or dealer (reference RCW 42.56.380(6)).
(17) Financial statement information required to determine whether or not an applicant for a license to operate a warehouse under chapter 22.09 RCW, agriculture commodities, meets minimum net worth requirements (reference RCW 22.09.040(9)).
(18) All financial statement information to determine whether or not an applicant for a license to be a grain dealer under chapter 22.09 RCW meets the minimum net worth requirements (reference RCW 22.09.045(7)).
(19) Information submitted by an individual or business to the department of agriculture under the requirements of chapters 16.36, 16.57, and 43.23 RCW for the purpose of ((participating in a state or national animal identification system)) herd inventory management for animal disease traceability, is exempt from disclosure. This information includes animal ownership, numbers of animals, locations, contact information, movements of livestock, financial information, the purchase and sale of livestock, account numbers or unique identifiers issued by government to private entities, and information related to livestock disease or injury that would identify an animal, a person or location. Disclosure to local, state, and federal officials is not public disclosure. This exemption does not affect the disclosure of information used in reportable animal health investigations under chapter 16.36 RCW once they are complete (reference RCW 42.56.380(9)).
(20) Results of testing for animal diseases ((not required to be reported under chapter 16.36 RCW that is done at the request)) from samples submitted by or at the direction of the animal owner or the owner's designee and that can be identified to a particular business or individual is exempt from disclosure (reference RCW 42.56.380(10)).
(21) Information that can be identified to a particular business and that is collected under chapter 15.17 RCW, standards of grades and packs, and specifically RCW 15.17.140(2) and 15.17.143 for certificates of compliance (reference RCW 42.56.380(7)).
(22) Financial statement information provided under RCW 16.65.030 (1)(d), public livestock markets, is confidential information and not subject to public disclosure (reference RCW 16.65.030 (1)(d) and 42.56.380(8)).
(23) Privileged or confidential information or data that contains trade secrets, commercial, or financial information and is required and submitted under the Washington Pesticide Control Act (reference RCW 15.58.060 (1)(c) and 15.58.065).
(24) Except for release of statistical information not descriptive of any readily identifiable person or persons, all financial and commercial information and records supplied by persons to the department with respect to export market development projects (reference RCW 43.23.270 and 42.56.270(3)).
(25) Information submitted by an applicant under chapter 17.24 RCW that is privileged or confidential because it contains trade secrets or commercial or financial information (reference RCW 17.24.061).
(26) Production or sales records required to determine assessment levels and actual assessment payments to commodity boards and commissions formed under chapters 15.24, 15.26, 15.28, 15.44, 15.65, 15.66, 15.74, 15.88, 15.89, 15.100, and 16.67 RCW, or required by the department to administer these chapters or the department's programs (reference RCW 42.56.380(3)).
(27) Financial and commercial information and records supplied by persons:
(a) To the department for the purpose of conducting a referendum for the potential establishment of a commodity board or commission; or
(b) To the department or commodity boards or commissions formed under chapters 15.24, 15.28, 15.44, 15.65, 15.66, 15.74, 15.88, 15.89, 15.100, or 16.67 RCW, with respect to domestic or export marketing activities or individual producer's production information (reference RCW 42.56.380(5)).
(28) Farm plans developed by conservation districts, unless the farm plan is used for the application or issuance of a permit (reference RCW 42.56.270(17)).
(29) Under RCW 42.56.610 and 90.64.190, information identifying the number of animals; volume of livestock nutrients generated; number of acres covered by the plan or used for land application of livestock nutrients; livestock nutrients transferred to other persons; and crop yields in plans, records, and reports obtained by state and local agencies from dairies, animal feeding operations, and concentrated animal feeding operations not required to apply for a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit is disclosable in the following ranges:
(a) Number of animals: Beef cattle
1 to 19
20 to 159
160 to 299
300 to 999
1,000 to 5,999
6,000 to 10,999
11,000 to 15,999
16,000 to 20,999
21,000 to 25,999
26,000 to 31,199
31,200 to 37,439
37,440 to 44,999
45,000 and above
(b) Number of animals: Mature dairy cattle
1 to 37
38 to 199
200 to 699
700 to 1,699
1,700 to 2,699
2,700 to 3,699
3,700 to 4,699
4,700 to 5,699
5,700 to 6,839
6,840 and above
(c) Number of animals: Dairy heifers
1 to 49
50 to 149
150 to 299
300 to 999
1,000 to 1,999
2,000 to 2,999
3,000 to 3,999
4,000 and above
(d) Number of animals: Swine (fifty-five pounds or greater)
1 to 19
20 to 159
160 to 399
400 to 749
750 to 2,499
2,500 to 4,249
4,250 to 5,999
6,000 to 7,749
7,750 and above
(e) Number of animals: Swine (less than fifty-five pounds)
1 to 99
100 to 499
500 to 1,099
1,100 to 1,999
2,000 to 2,999
3,000 to 9,999
10,000 to 16,999
17,000 to 23,999
24,000 to 30,999
31,000 and above
(f) Number of animals: Layers (all ages)
1 to 199
200 to 999
1,000 to 10,999
11,000 to 24,999
25,000 to 81,999
82,000 to 138,999
139,000 to 195,999
196,000 to 252,999
253,000 to 309,999
310,000 to 371,999
372,000 to 446,399
446,400 to 535,679
535,680 to 642,815
642,816 to 771,379
771,380 to 925,655
925,656 to 1,110,787
1,110,788 to 1,332,945
1,332,946 and above
(g) Number of animals: Broilers (all ages)
1 to 199
200 to 999
1,000 to 17,999
18,000 to 37,499
37,500 to 124,999
125,000 to 212,499
212,500 to 299,999
300,000 and above
(h) Number of animals: Horses
1 to 19
20 to 79
80 to 149
150 to 499
500 to 849
850 to 1,199
1,200 to 1,549
1,550 and above
(i) Livestock nutrients generated or exported by volume (ft3/day)
1 to 74
75 to 134
135 to 299
300 to 449
450 to 749
750 to 1,499
1,500 to 2,499
2,500 to 4,999
5,000 to 8,499
8,500 to 11,999
12,000 to 15,999
16,000 and above
(j) Livestock nutrients generated or exported by weight (tons/year)
1 to 5,256
5,257 to 10,512
10,513 to 21,024
21,025 to 42,048
42,049 to 84,096
84,097 to 164,184
164,185 to 262,734
262,735 to 394,200
394,201 to 558,384
558,385 to 722,634
722,635 to 919,734
919,735 to 1,051,134
1,051,135 and above
(k) Number of acres covered by the plan or used for land application of livestock nutrients
0 to 25
26 to 65
66 to 120
121 to 300
301 to 550
551 to 900
901 to 1,300
1,301 to 1,800
1,801 to 2,500
2,501 to 3,200
3,201 to 4,000
4,001 to 6,000
6,001 to 9,000
9,001 to 11,500
11,501 to 14,000
14,001 and above
(l) Crop yields - tons/acre
0 to 1
1.1 to 2
2.1 to 3.5
3.6 to 5
5.1 to 7
7.1 to 9
9.1 to 12
12.1 to 14.5
14.6 to 17
17.1 to 19.5
19.6 to 22
22.1 to 26
26.1 and above
(30) Records of international livestock importation that can be identified to a particular animal, business, or individual received from the United States Department of Homeland Security or the United States Department of Agriculture that are not disclosable by the federal agency under federal law including 5 U.S.C. Sec. 552 (reference RCW 42.56.380(11)).
(31) A person aggrieved by a violation of chapter 17.21 RCW or the rules adopted under that chapter is entitled, on request, to have his or her name protected from disclosure in any communication with persons outside the department and in any record published, released, or made available to persons outside the department except as provided in RCW 17.21.340 (1)(a)(ii).
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 09-03-032, filed 1/12/09, effective 2/12/09)
WAC 16-06-220 Review of denial of request for inspection or copying of public records.
(1) Any person who objects to the initial denial of a records request may petition in writing to the ((public records officer)) administrative regulations program manager for a review of that decision. The petition shall include a copy of, or reasonably identify, the written statement by the department denying the request.
(2) The ((public records officer)) administrative regulations program manager will immediately consider the petition and either affirm or reverse the denial within two business days following the department's receipt of the petition, or within such other time as the department and the requestor mutually agree to.
(3) Under RCW 42.56.530, if the department denies a requestor access to public records because it claims the record is exempt in whole or in part from disclosure, the requestor may request the attorney general's office to review the matter. The attorney general has adopted rules on such requests in WAC 44-06-160.
(4) Any person may obtain court review of a denial of a public records request under RCW 42.56.550 at the conclusion of two business days after the initial denial, regardless of any internal administrative appeal.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 09-03-032, filed 1/12/09, effective 2/12/09)
WAC 16-06-250 Processing of public records requests—Electronic records.
(1) Requesting electronic records: The process for requesting electronic public records is the same as for requesting paper public records.
(2) Providing electronic records:
(a) The department has the discretion to determine whether to provide records electronically or in paper form.
(b) When a requestor requests records in an electronic format, the public records officer will endeavor to provide the nonexempt records or portions of such records that are reasonably locatable in an electronic format that is used by the department and is generally commercially available, or in a format that is reasonably translatable from the format in which the department keeps the record.
(c) When electronic records require redaction, or are contained in a proprietary data base, or otherwise cannot be reasonably provided in an electronic format, the department will provide paper copies of the records to the requestor.
(3) Customized access to data bases: With the consent of the requestor, the department may provide customized access under RCW ((43.105.280)) 43.41A.130 if the record is not reasonably locatable or not reasonably translatable into the format requested. The department may charge a fee consistent with RCW ((43.105.280)) 43.41A.130 for customized access.
REPEALER
The following section of the Washington Administrative Code is repealed:
| ||||||||||