WSR 16-07-023 PROPOSED RULES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE [Filed March 8, 2016, 9:37 a.m.]
Continuance of WSR 15-18-071.
Preproposal statement of inquiry was filed as WSR 15-06-051.
Title of Rule and Other Identifying Information: Chapter 16-470 WAC, Quarantine—Agricultural pests, the agency continues to consider amending the apple maggot quarantine as stated in the CR-102 filed August 28, 2015. However, the agency is revising the proposed "Date of intended adoption" for the reasons stated below.
Date of Intended Adoption: June 1, 2016.
Purpose of the Proposal and Its Anticipated Effects, Including Any Changes in Existing Rules: The agency is continuing the proposed date of intended adoption to address issues raised by its consultants and by persons from the apple industry and the composting industry during the public comment period and the hearings on October 8 and 9, 2015. The agency has retained the service of consultants to conduct a pest risk analysis of risks associated with composting operations in the pest-free area. Preliminary consultant reports suggest that there are additional potential risks that require further review and analysis. The agency has determined that this information will be necessary to consider for purposes of amending the apple maggot quarantine rules to add a new section allowing for the issuing of special permits for composting municipal green waste in the pest-free area. The pest risk analysis is expected to provide more definitive guidance on risk and mitigation conditions, which will assist the agency in identifying conditions in the proposed special permit rule and potentially preparing an amended small business economic impact statement if such conditions are to be identified in the amended special permit rule section. The agency may propose an additional hearing and comment period depending on the decisions it makes about the special permit rule section following receipt of the pest risk analysis.
Statute Being Implemented: Chapter 17.24 RCW.
Rule is not necessitated by federal law, federal or state court decision.
Name of Proponent: Department of agriculture, governmental.
Name of Agency Personnel Responsible for Drafting, Implementation, and Enforcement: James Marra, 1111 Washington Street S.E., Olympia, WA 98504-2560, (360) 902-2071.
March 8, 2016
Brad White
Assistant Director
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 06-14-004, filed 6/22/06, effective 8/1/06)
WAC 16-470-101 Establishing quarantine for apple maggot and plum curculio.
Apple maggot (Rhagoletis pomonella) and plum curculio (Conotrachelus nenuphar) are insects with a larval (worm) stage that develops within fruit. These insects are capable of attacking many fruit crops grown in Washington. Apple maggot is not established in significant portions of the major fruit production areas east of the Cascade Mountains, and plum curculio is not established anywhere in the state. An increased range for either insect would cause decreased environmental quality and economic loss to the agricultural industries of the state by increasing production inputs and jeopardizing foreign and domestic markets.
(1) The director of agriculture, pursuant to chapter 17.24 RCW, has determined that the regulation and/or exclusion of fresh fruits grown or originating from areas infested with apple maggot or plum curculio is necessary to protect the environmental quality and agricultural crops of the state.
(2) The director of agriculture, pursuant to chapter 17.24 RCW, has determined that municipal solid waste originating from areas infested with apple maggot is a host medium for apple maggot and is a "regulated commodity" as provided in WAC 16-470-111. The exclusion of such municipal solid waste from the pest free area is necessary to protect the environmental quality and agricultural crops of the state. The transport into and disposition of such municipal solid waste in the pest free area may be allowed by a special permit as provided in WAC 16-470-124(1).
(3) The director of agriculture, pursuant to chapter 17.24 RCW, has determined that yard debris, organic feedstocks, organic materials, and agricultural wastes as defined in WAC 173-350-100 originating from areas infested with apple maggot is a host medium for apple maggot and is a "regulated commodity" as provided in WAC 16-470-111. The exclusion of such waste from the pest free area is necessary to protect the environmental quality and agricultural crops of the state. The transport into and disposition of yard debris, organic feedstocks, organic materials, and agricultural wastes in the pest free area may be allowed by a special permit as provided in WAC 16-470-124(2).
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 01-14-075, filed 7/3/01, effective 8/3/01)
WAC 16-470-108 Distribution of infested or damaged fruit is prohibited.
Regulated commodities ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-111(1) and 16-470-125(2) that are known or found to be infested or damaged by apple maggot or plum curculio may not be distributed, sold, held for sale, or offered for sale, unless the fruit has undergone cold storage treatment, in compliance with WAC 16-470-113 (1)(a) and (b) or 16-470-127 (1)(a) and (b), and the necessary certificate has been issued by the appropriate plant protection organization.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 06-14-004, filed 6/22/06, effective 8/1/06)
WAC 16-470-111 ((What)) Commodities ((are)) regulated for apple maggot((?)).
(1) All fresh fruit of apple (including crab apple), cherry (except cherries that are commercial fruit), hawthorn (haw), pear (except pears that are commercial fruit from California, Idaho, Oregon, Utah, and Washington), plum, prune, and quince are regulated under quarantine for apple maggot.
(2) Municipal solid waste as defined in WAC 173-350-100 is regulated under quarantine for apple maggot. Municipal solid waste from the quarantine areas is a host medium for apple maggot containing or likely to contain those fruits listed under subsection (1) of this section.
(3) Yard debris, organic feedstocks, organic materials, and agricultural wastes as defined in WAC 173-350-100 are regulated under quarantine for apple maggot. Yard debris, organic feedstocks, organic materials, and agricultural wastes from quarantine areas are host mediums for apple maggot containing or likely to contain those fruits listed under subsection (1) of this section.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 01-14-075, filed 7/3/01, effective 8/3/01)
WAC 16-470-113 ((What do you need)) Requirements to ship commodities regulated for apple maggot from a state under quarantine into the pest free area for apple maggot((?)).
Shipment of ((regulated commodities)) fruit, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-111(1), from an area under quarantine, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-105(3), into the pest free area for apple maggot, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-105(1), is prohibited, unless at least one of the following conditions is met:
(1) The shipment is accompanied by an official certificate issued by the plant protection organization of the state of origin evidencing at least one of the following:
(a) The shipment is composed of apples, which ((have)) has undergone cold treatment for a continuous period of at least ninety days. During this ninety days, the temperature within the storage room must be maintained at thirty-seven and nine-tenths (37.9) degrees Fahrenheit or less.
(b) The shipment is composed of ((regulated commodities)) fresh fruit specified in WAC 16-470-111(1) other than apples, which ((have)) has undergone cold treatment for a continuous period of forty days or more. During this forty days, the temperature within the storage room must be maintained at thirty-two (32) degrees Fahrenheit or less.
(c) The shipment is composed of ((regulated commodities)) fresh fruit specified in WAC 16-470-111(1) from Oregon, Idaho, or Utah, certified by the state of origin in compliance with WAC 16-470-122.
(d) Each lot or shipment consists of repacked fruit, which was grown outside the area under quarantine and has been ((identity)) identified and maintained ((while)) separately from any fruit specified in WAC 16-470-111(1) grown within the area under quarantine. For repacked fruit, the certificate must show the following information:
(i) State in which the fruit was grown;
(ii) Point of repacking and reshipment;
(iii) Amount and kind of commodities comprising the lot or shipment; and
(iv) Names and addresses of the shipper and consignee.
(2) The fruit originated outside the area under quarantine for apple maggot and is a reshipment in original, unopened containers. The containers must each bear labels or other identifying marks evidencing origin outside the area under quarantine.
(3) The fruit is frozen solid.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 06-14-004, filed 6/22/06, effective 8/1/06)
WAC 16-470-115 ((Within Washington state, what is required to ship fruit)) Requirements for shipment of regulated commodities from the quarantine area for apple maggot into the pest free area ((for apple maggot from quarantined areas?)) within Washington state.
Shipment of regulated commodities, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-111, from an area under quarantine, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-105(2), into the pest free area for apple maggot, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-105(1), is prohibited, unless one of the following conditions is met:
(1) The shipment of fresh fruit is accompanied by a permit for movement of fruit issued by the department verifying one of the following:
(a) The fruit came from orchards and production sites that are not threatened with infestation; or
(b) The fruit has completed treatment as specified in WAC 16-470-118(3). If records of treatment verifying compliance with conditions specified in WAC 16-470-118(3) are made available to the department, no reinspection is required by the department.
(2) The shipment of fresh fruit is accompanied by a permit issued by the department in fulfillment of WAC 16-470-118 (2) and (3), which specifies conditions for shipment from orchards and production sites that are infested or threatened with infestation.
(3) The shipment of municipal solid waste from the quarantine area to the pest free area for purposes of disposal in a municipal solid waste landfill or appropriate disposal or treatment facility is accompanied by a special permit issued by the department as provided in WAC 16-470-124(1).
(4) The shipment of yard debris, organic feedstocks, organic materials, or agricultural wastes from the quarantine area to the pest free area for purposes of disposal in a municipal solid waste landfill or appropriate treatment or composting facility is accompanied by a special permit issued by the department as provided in WAC 16-470-124(2).
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 06-14-004, filed 6/22/06, effective 8/1/06)
WAC 16-470-118 Requirement within Washington state((, what is required)) to ship fruit into, within, or through the pest free area for apple maggot from an orchard or production site that is infested or threatened with infestation((?)).
All ((regulated commodities)) fresh fruit, as ((described)) specified in WAC 16-470-111(1), from an orchard or production site that is infested or threatened with infestation by apple maggot must be inspected (((except graded culls - See subsection (4) of this section))) by the department following accepted agency standards.
(1) If ((regulated commodities are)) the fruit is inspected and found free of apple maggot, the shipment must be accompanied by a permit for movement of fruit issued by the department.
(2) If ((regulated commodities are)) the fruit is found to be infested with apple maggot, a permit from the department, which specifies conditions for handling and shipment, is required to transport the fruit within or through the pest free area. No permit may be issued under this subsection for transportation of ((regulated commodities)) fresh fruit found to be infested with apple maggot into the pest free area for apple maggot.
(3) If ((regulated commodities are)) the fruit is found to be infested with apple maggot, one or more of the following treatments must be performed and verified by the department as specified in WAC 16-470-115 (1)(b) before the ((commodity)) fruit is moved from area(s) designated or quarantined by the department:
(a) Apples (including crab apples) cold treated as specified in WAC 16-470-113 (1)(a).
(b) ((Regulated commodities)) Fruit other than apples cold treated as specified in WAC 16-470-113 (1)(b).
(c) Other methods as prescribed in writing by the department.
(4) If the shipment contains graded culls, it must comply with the conditions specified in WAC 16-470-113 (1)(a) ((and)) or (b), dependent on the category of fruit.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 01-14-075, filed 7/3/01, effective 8/3/01)
WAC 16-470-122 ((What are the)) Requirements to ship regulated articles from Oregon, Idaho, or Utah into the pest free area for apple maggot((?)).
Commercially grown fresh fruit from Oregon, Idaho, or Utah may be shipped into the pest free area for apple maggot if both of the subsections of this section are complied with:
(1) A permit has been agreed to by the plant protection organization of the state of origin and the department. The permits must specify that the plant protection organization of the state of origin has conducted an adequate apple maggot detection program, which includes immediate written notification to the department of detections in counties where apple maggot has not previously been detected.
(2) The plant protection organization of the state of origin certifies that the fruit originated in areas in which apple maggot is not established, was grown in a commercial orchard, and has not been placed under quarantine.
NEW SECTION
WAC 16-470-124 Special permits for solid waste transport and disposition.
(1) The director may issue special permits admitting or allowing transportation and distribution of municipal solid waste for disposal at a solid waste landfill or appropriate disposal facility in the pest free area from the area under quarantine established in WAC 16-470-101, subject to conditions and provisions which the director may prescribe to prevent introduction, escape, or spread of the quarantined pests. For purposes of this section "solid waste" and "solid waste landfill" or "disposal facility" refer to solid waste and solid waste facilities regulated under chapters 70.95 RCW and 173-351 WAC by the Washington state department of ecology.
(2) The director may issue special permits admitting or allowing transportation and distribution of yard debris, organic feedstocks, organic materials, or agricultural wastes for treatment at a composting facility in the pest free area from the area under quarantine established in WAC 16-470-101, subject to conditions and provisions which the director may prescribe to prevent introduction, escape, or spread of the quarantined pests. For purposes of this section "yard debris," "organic feedstocks," "organic materials," and "agricultural wastes" or "composting facility" refer to waste and composting facilities regulated under chapters 70.95 RCW and 173-350 WAC by the Washington state department of ecology.
(3) When the owner of the waste identified in subsections (1) and (2) of this section transfers ownership of the waste to a different person receiving the waste for disposal or treatment in the pest free area, both owners must apply for and receive special permits under this section. A special permit to transport will not be issued to the transporting owner unless a special permit is concurrently issued to the receiving facility owner under conditions specified by the director.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 01-14-075, filed 7/3/01, effective 8/3/01)
WAC 16-470-127 ((What do you need)) Requirements to ship commodities regulated for plum curculio into Washington((?)).
Shipment into the state of Washington of regulated commodities described in WAC 16-470-125 from states under quarantine for plum curculio is prohibited, unless one of the following conditions is met:
(1) The shipment is accompanied by an official certificate issued by the plant protection organization of the state of origin evidencing at least one of the following:
(a) The shipment consists of apples, which have undergone cold treatment for a continuous period of at least ninety days. During this ninety days, the temperature within the storage room must be maintained at thirty-seven and nine-tenths (((37.9))) degrees Fahrenheit or less.
(b) The shipment consists of regulated commodities, which have undergone cold treatment for a continuous period of forty days or more. During this forty days, the temperature within the storage room must be maintained at thirty-two (((32))) degrees Fahrenheit or less.
(c) Each lot or shipment consists of repacked fruit, which was grown outside the area under quarantine and has been identity maintained while within the area under quarantine. For repacked fruit, the certificate must show the following information:
(i) State in which the fruit was grown;
(ii) Point of repacking and reshipment;
(iii) Amount and kind of commodities comprising the lot or shipment; and
(iv) Names and addresses of the shipper and consignee.
(2) The fruit originated outside the area under quarantine for plum curculio and is a reshipment in original, unopened containers. The containers must each bear labels or other identifying marks evidencing origin outside the area under quarantine.
(3) The shipment consists of fresh fruit from Utah counties where plum curculio is established and is made in compliance with terms of a permit agreed upon by both the Utah and Washington plant protection organizations.
(4) The shipment consists of fresh fruit from Utah counties where plum curculio is not established, and all of the following conditions are complied with:
(a) The Utah plant protection organization has conducted an adequate plum curculio detection program, which includes immediate written notification to the department of detections in counties where plum curculio has not previously been detected; and
(b) The Utah plant protection organization certifies that the fruit originated in areas in which plum curculio is not established, was grown in a commercial orchard, and has not been placed under quarantine.
AMENDATORY SECTION (Amending WSR 01-14-075, filed 7/3/01, effective 8/3/01)
WAC 16-470-130 Special permits for fresh fruit transport and distribution.
The director may issue special permits admitting, or allowing transportation and distribution of, regulated commodities described in WAC 16-470-111 and 16-470-125(2), which would not otherwise be eligible for entry from the area under quarantine, or for transportation or distribution, subject to conditions and provisions which the director may prescribe to prevent introduction, escape or spread of the quarantined pests.
|